Merged Hulsey presents research arguing WTC7 not brought down by fires/University of Alaska

It's almost like he's never heard of flash over. Firefighter ventilate a building so the fire can burn and not fester into a concentration of super heated gas.

I always rolled my eyes well "truther" talked about "oxygen starved" fires. Most of the times that's the worst thing you can do for a fire.

I used a leaf blower to keep the heat away wile I filmed the fire.
Cordless and silent.

Tony must think we are all ignorant like the truthers he panders too, to make such easily refutable claims.
 
I used a leaf blower to keep the heat away wile I filmed the fire.
Cordless and silent.

Tony must think we are all ignorant like the truthers he panders too, to make such easily refutable claims.
The article he uses has a valid point. In fast moving controlled fires radiant heat transfer is the dominant force. His problem is the application in regards to WTC 7. This is why I quoted the paragraph I did.

The paper has nothing to do with what he wants to claim.
 
The article he uses has a valid point. In fast moving controlled fires radiant heat transfer is the dominant force. His problem is the application in regards to WTC 7. This is why I quoted the paragraph I did.

The paper has nothing to do with what he wants to claim.

I know just wanted to do a real world demonstration, that showed he was full of BS.
 
Oystein,
The project was started last summer and there is an enormous amount of prep work (modeling all of the parts and assembling them, doing sub-assemblies and testing their reactions, fire simulation, etc.) that would be involved in an FEA the size of what the entire WTC 7 building would be. You can't get results before you do the prep work.
<snip>
Of course you have done this enormous amount of prep work (modeling all of the parts and assembling them, doing sub-assemblies and testing their reactions, fire simulation, etc.) that would be involved in an FEA the size of what the entire WTC 7 building would be. And since you can't get results before you do the prep work, you can provide the enormous prep work and results you performed to reluctantly arrive at your explosive conclusion.

In order to seem convincing to reviewing specialist engineers, the prep work and results you completed should have mimicked the appearance of the studies as performed by NIST, Arup, Bailey.

Please provide a link to your enormous prep work and results.
 
Last edited:
Of course you have done this enormous amount of prep work (modeling all of the parts and assembling them, doing sub-assemblies and testing their reactions, fire simulation, etc.) that would be involved in an FEA the size of what the entire WTC 7 building would be. And since you can't get results before you do the prep work, you can provide the enormous prep work and results you performed to reluctantly arrive at your explosive conclusion.

In order to seem convincing to reviewing specialist engineers, the prep work and results you completed should have mimicked the appearance of the studies as performed by NIST, Arup, Bailey.

Please provide a link to your enormous prep work and results.

Please tell me your not holding your breath waiting for the prep work?:D
 
Of course you have done this enormous amount of prep work (modeling all of the parts and assembling them, doing sub-assemblies and testing their reactions, fire simulation, etc.) that would be involved in an FEA the size of what the entire WTC 7 building would be. And since you can't get results before you do the prep work, you can provide the enormous prep work and results you performed to reluctantly arrive at your explosive conclusion.

In order to seem convincing to reviewing specialist engineers, the prep work and results you completed should have mimicked the appearance of the studies as performed by NIST, Arup, Bailey.

Please provide a link to your enormous prep work and results.

It's on the back of an envelope, in his desk drawer under that old stack of installation DVDs
 
The NIST with all their resources spent over 7 years on the problem, and they still couldn't wouldn't get it right.

An assertion of which you have no valid proof, Tony's Ideas, have been proven fallacious, your Ideas are similarly regarded.

Tony didn't realize the by simply changing impact point the energy to fracture a connection changes.

Without knowledge of how and where the girder and floor it supported were loaded, his assertion that the failure of one girder not causing the other to fail is invalid.

His fire science knowledge is non existent, and his conclusions are nonsensical.
 
So frigging what? NIST elaborated a report to warn the engineering world of the deficiencies that led to the collapse. Their conclusion was that it was the result of unfought fires. Alternative explanations have been given by those who were not convinced by NIST's, enough of them as to satisfy all engineers except the politically motivated, which won't be satisfied unless the explanation matches their political prejudices.

NIST's report covers much more than just engineering, and even if the engineering parts of the report were wrong, there are still other reports that confirm that the collapse was caused by fire, enough to satisfy the non-politically motivated engineers that were not convinced by NIST's explanation.

The only engineers that remain dissatisfied are the ones with an agenda.
The report is not wrong. Get that straight. The report is correct.
I haven't suggested the report is wrong. There are opinions different to those of NIST on how the collapse initiated, that is a fact. Pointing that out does not equate asserting that the report is wrong.
 
I haven't suggested the report is wrong. There are opinions different to those of NIST on how the collapse initiated, that is a fact. Pointing that out does not equate asserting that the report is wrong.
I was addressing the "...even if the engineering...report is wrong..." statement, and emphasizing that it is not wrong, but incompatible with the level of detail demanded by those with an agenda...
 
WAI does not provide their analysis showing the amplification, just like NIST didn't. I also don't see where they corrected Nordenson's use of a point load for the falling beam and girder assembly.

I can say that none of the three: NIST, Nordenson (ARUP), or WAI can break through the next floor down with floor sections falling through one story onto the next floor down, especially with hot beams, and regardless of heated beams below.

There is simply not enough load amplification in a fall through one floor with the amount of deflection the beams would have.

If I hadn't already, let me make it clear that it doesn't matter if WAI had the beams at 859 Degrees C to get them to fall, their falling floor section can't break through the next one down. There is no chance that all of the steel involved on both floors of WAI's analysis would be above 800 degrees C.

This is critical to the collapse hypothesis of all three, as they need the floor cascade to remove lateral support from columns. Without it they have no collapse.

I think all three analyses are bovine skedaddle.

You can keep trying to salvage Weidlinger, but you will need to show me their amplification analysis and where they correct Nordenson's use of a point load. I can't find either.

Simple fact: You don't know how much force was required to destroy the lower floors because you have not done the analysis required to determine how damaged those floors could be. Your assertions are just bovine skedaddle, to borrow a phrase, and you know it.

Unlike you, WAI modeled the whole collapse. You can't point to any error they committed in doing so, so you fall back "well, they didn't show me all their math and they didn't come to the conclusion I wanted [note how your biased mind only objects when both conditions are met], so their report must have been an elaborate attempt to lie under oath."
 
Last edited:
Tony, please explain how it is that NIST, ARUP, and Nordenson groups manage to all be wrong and you be correct in determining that fire damage did not initiate a progressive collapse sequence.

IOW how is it that three professional forensic structural engineering groups can be outdone by you?
 
I was addressing the "...even if the engineering...report is wrong..." statement, and emphasizing that it is not wrong, but incompatible with the level of detail demanded by those with an agenda...
Agreed, but my actual wording was "...even if the engineering...report were wrong", to make it clear it's an hypothetical.

http://english.stackexchange.com/qu...ere-which-is-more-common-and-which-is-correct

Maybe the confusion has been caused by the ambiguity between plural simple past "were" and subjunctive mood "were". I used the latter.
 
Last edited:
............they've (AE) also spent a couple million dollars with really nothing to show for it. ;)

Yeah, did I say "equal"? I meant that AE911T has produced much less than has been produced to illustrate that fire damage initiated a progressive collapse of WTC7. In fact AE911T has produced nothing in the way of a collapse/destructive sequence, with the level of detail provided by at least three professional engineering groups that have. At least not beyond bald assertions and weak implications of one.
 
Yeah, did I say "equal"? I meant that AE911T has produced much less than has been produced to illustrate that fire damage initiated a progressive collapse of WTC7. In fact AE911T has produced nothing in the way of a collapse/destructive sequence, with the level of detail provided by at least three professional engineering groups that have. At least not beyond bald assertions and weak implications of one.

I produced more scientific information, for less than $500 dollars, in one day, Than AE/911 Truth has done in 15 years.
They are smarter than I am though they don't spend their own money they spend the money of truther fools.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom