Merged Hulsey presents research arguing WTC7 not brought down by fires/University of Alaska

The fact that all four corners of WTC 7 came down at the same time and that it went into free fall acceleration makes it very hard to show or believe fire caused the collapse.


It took about 17 seconds for WTC 7 to fully collapse and that is not free fall speed. The absence of CD detonations and seismic data have proven that no explosives were involved and the icing on the cake is that no CD evidence was ever found within the rubble of WTC 7.

It is no mystery to me how WTC 7 collapsed especially when concidering the size of that massive impact hole on the south wall of WTC 7 and the constant strucural load redisbution the steel structure of WTC 7 underwent during hours-long fire exposure.

By the time the Penthouse collapsed from east to west, it was evident that the rest of the steel structure of WTC 7 was far too weak to support the building, which was evident as observers reported that WTC 7 was buckling prior to its collapse and that was a major sign that fire, not CD explosives, was responsible for the collapse of WTC 7.

To sum it up, you have no case for CD explosives.
 
Tony Szamboti;11422854 if he thinks the shock load can be what he says to break the girder connections below due to leverage he hasn't even quantified. [/QUOTE said:
 
Wish they'd used principal stress vs von Mises. Can't tell direction. Are the arrows applied, reaction or just pointers to detail?
 
Multiple sections of the report are dedicated solely to rebutting Nordenson's errors, including most of Appendix C. I suspect you know this because I suspect your "discovery" of Nordenson's errors was actually cribbed from WAI.

I'm glad, in any event, that at the end of this long back-and-forth we've come to a place where you're admitting (1) you can't say that either ARUP or WAI got their respective collapse initiation mechanisms wrong, and (2) you can't say that WAI got its collapse propagation analysis wrong. Try to remember this the next time you are tempted to mislead your fellow travelers with bold proclamations re the impossibility of fire induced collapses.

Re Crazy--considering you haven't shared your detailed analysis/calculations, I'm just taking your word for it too. Difference is, I've now caught you being deliberately dishonest on several occasions and so I trust you far less.

How have I been deliberately dishonest if you make the claim show the evidence.

As I said I have to transcribe the data, from the program, into a set of simplified calculations.
There are several runs of the program each time varying the impact point.
 
How have I been deliberately dishonest if you make the claim show the evidence.

As I said I have to transcribe the data, from the program, into a set of simplified calculations.
There are several runs of the program each time varying the impact point.

I never said you were dishonest. Tony asked why I was essentially taking your word over his when you had not presented your calculations/analysis, and I was replying that I did so because neither of you have presented fulsome calculations and analysis but I know Tony has been deliberately deceptive several times, so I will take your assertions that Tony failed to consider certain scenarios at face value for now until everyone has a chance to compare notes.
 
I never said you were dishonest. Tony asked why I was essentially taking your word over his when you had not presented your calculations/analysis, and I was replying that I did so because neither of you have presented fulsome calculations and analysis but I know Tony has been deliberately deceptive several times, so I will take your assertions that Tony failed to consider certain scenarios at face value for now until everyone has a chance to compare notes.

OK that is fine thank you for clearing up the misunderstanding all I did was similar to what Oystein did on metha bunk, I looked at the situation in all it's complexity.
Not simply at the Idealized case Tony provided simply impacting the lower floor by a dirrect strike on top of the beam inline with the path of highest strength to resist collapse.
Simply bypassing the top of the beam, impacting the lower beam on the side reduces the energy by placing the impact loading on the bolts not on the seat.

The bolt strength against shear being 300,000. Not in the 600,000 range.
That reduces the energy by at least half then by moving the strike a foot farther down the beam, and using the maxwell equation, that reduced the energy another third.
So obviously the failure of the Beam was dependent on where and how it was struck, Tony only posts one hypothetical sinario, he is guilty of oversimplification of the problem.
 
OK that is fine thank you for clearing up the misunderstanding all I did was similar to what Oystein did on metha bunk, I looked at the situation in all it's complexity.
Not simply at the Idealized case Tony provided simply impacting the lower floor by a dirrect strike on top of the beam inline with the path of highest strength to resist collapse.
Simply bypassing the top of the beam, impacting the lower beam on the side reduces the energy by placing the impact loading on the bolts not on the seat.

The bolt strength against shear being 300,000. Not in the 600,000 range.
That reduces the energy by at least half then by moving the strike a foot farther down the beam, and using the maxwell equation, that reduced the energy another third.
So obviously the failure of the Beam was dependent on where and how it was struck, Tony only posts one hypothetical sinario, he is guilty of oversimplification of the problem.

No problem. And that's basically what I figured re your analysis. It seems apparent to me that Tony has not yet done all the work necessary to analyze the collapse propagation question in a terribly meaningful way, and I think Tony even acknowledges this in his own way around the edges of his comments. It'd be nice to actually see a constructive conversation about the sorts of factors that would need to be considered in a fulsome floor collapse propagation analysis. Hopefully the last two days have been conducive to getting us there.
 
Last edited:
No problem. And that's basically what I figured re your analysis. It seems apparent to me that Tony has not yet done all the work necessary to analyze the collapse propagation question in a terribly meaningful way, and I think Tony even acknowledges this in his own way around the edges of his comments. It'd be nice to actually see a constructive conversation about the sorts of factors that would need to be considered in a fulsome floor collapse propagation analysis. Hopefully the last two days have been conducive to getting us there.

Tony's argument against my analysis will be that the girders fall can only be represented as that of a counterlevered beam, however he can provide no proof of claim, and I also failed the beam below, by falling the girder as a bent not strait counter levered beam inducing side impact.

Tony's girder falls hot and undistorted by the energy acting upon it, onto the strongest possible resistance to collapse.

My Idea - analysis simply embraces reality and possible ways the girder might deform.
 
Wish they'd used principal stress vs von Mises. Can't tell direction. Are the arrows applied, reaction or just pointers to detail?


To point out details. Figure 5 shows that the column acted as a heat sink, but the connection was too far to have been affected and after two hours of fire exposure, span girder deflection was enough to tear the connecting bolts out of the webs. The results can be seen in the following photo


Internal Collapse Due To Fire

http://www.engineeringcivil.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/09/interanal-collapse-area-of-WTC1.jpg
 
To point out details. Figure 5 shows that the column acted as a heat sink, but the connection was too far to have been affected and after two hours of fire exposure, span girder deflection was enough to tear the connecting bolts out of the webs. The results can be seen in the following photo


Internal Collapse Due To Fire

http://www.engineeringcivil.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/09/interanal-collapse-area-of-WTC1.jpg
Kinda thought so.
With that kind of tear-out, there had to be some big-ass deflection capability at the other end. Either it was loose, or really undergoing some extreme plastic deformation. Stiffness would be near zero, meaning everything was cantilevered at the end in question.
 
I hope others notice that many people here are all talk and no action. They usually just makes claims and provide no calculations or basis for what they say.

Two sentences - and so many things so terribly wrong within them:

  1. You insinuate that our side has any need or motive to take action - this is not so: All the action has been done (among others: By FEMA, NIST, ARUP, WAI...), and the universal, worldwide consensus in all engineering firms and faculties is informed by them - not by your insignificant fringe "movement".
  2. You insinuate that calculations from our side, on top of all those already done by the published experts, are a necessary to prove our theory and/or rebut yours. This is not so: Again, the consensus within the engineering community worldwide is overwhelmingly on our side, while your side hasn't even provided a qualitative hint at a first draft for an alternative theory that could be approached quantitatively (e.g. with calculations). The simple fact of the matter is a trivial three-hop: I) Large, uncontrolled fires can and frequently do destroy steel-frame structure. II) WTC1/2/7 were steel-frame structures suffering from large, uncontrolled fires. III) It follows that, prima facie, it was those fires that destroyed all three.
  3. You, Tony, along with the entirety of "9/11 Truth", have, in fact, not provided any calculations or basis for what you say. There is, as of today, not even any evidence that anybody within "9/11 Truth" is working on such calculations. Specifically, the evidence at hand suggests that Professor Leroy Hulsey is not working on a WTC7 simulation - or else he and AE911Truth would have , as promised, informed the public about the progress off his work. Or else, they flagrantly broke a promise they made in order to skim gullibly donors of their money.
 
No, I did not reach any conclusion before doing the calculations.

When did you become convinced that WTC7 was intentionally, explosively demolished? That was like 2007, wasn't it?

Had you done all the calculations you are arguing with here by that time - YES or NO, Tony?
Where did you publish them such that we can scrutinize your models, assumptions and calculations? Oh - you have not at all, or have you, Tony?
 
...
I did share my analysis on Metabunk.
This isn't quite true - you shared the results of some black box manipulations, adorned with a pretty picture, and expected us to believe you did your model "right".
Where is the model, actually? You haven't shared it, AFAIK.

I can say that Nordenson is wrong hands down
Despite your not, in fact, sharing your analysis, I find it plausible that your result is good - I advance a measure of trust to you despite your oft-mentioned continued dishonesty.

and I suspect Weidlinger is overestimating the load amplification and the steel temperatures.
And there we have it - you suspect.
Of course you do - the result goes against your conclusions.
You ought to admit at this point that you came to your conclusions before making calculations.

You have too much faith in calculations anyway - no calculation you or anyone will ever do stands the slightest chance of provably representing the reality of the actual WTC7 event to the level of accuracy you yearn for (where a difference between 11.5 and 12 inches gets blown up by truthers to the deception of the century).
 
...
The fact that all four corners of WTC 7 came down at the same time and that it went into free fall acceleration makes it very hard to show or believe fire caused the collapse.
...

Fine.
After losing the debate about certain third-party analyses of the WTC7 collapse, you resort to the old old Twoofer mantras (yes, Twoofer, to point out my opinion that the entire "movement" believes in nothing but woo):
  • "Freefall" you ought to know that "freefall" is neither a sufficient nor a necessary condition to prove CD or disprove fire-induced collapse - it is an irrelevant, colateral circumstance.
  • None of you Twoofers have shown that the "symmetry" you allude to - the claimed simultaneousness of the descent of the various parts of the outer skin - actually exists, and is indicative of any particular collapse initiation mechanism. Now, you are one of the few Twoofers who have understood that the collapse, obviously, originated "somewhere" in the core (you must know, but can't make yourself admit that this can be, almost trivially, be localized to the neighborhood of column 79), and that any demolition devices on the periphery were not nexessary nor present nor even possible, and certainly without any evidence whatsoever. So with a collapse obviously, and agreed by you, originating in the core, why should the periphery collapse "symmetrically" in the first place - if not, in appearance, by pure and simple and meaningless chance?
 
This isn't quite true - you shared the results of some black box manipulations, adorned with a pretty picture, and expected us to believe you did your model "right".
Where is the model, actually? You haven't shared it, AFAIK.


Despite your not, in fact, sharing your analysis, I find it plausible that your result is good - I advance a measure of trust to you despite your oft-mentioned continued dishonesty.


And there we have it - you suspect.
Of course you do - the result goes against your conclusions.
You ought to admit at this point that you came to your conclusions before making calculations.

You have too much faith in calculations anyway - no calculation you or anyone will ever do stands the slightest chance of provably representing the reality of the actual WTC7 event to the level of accuracy you yearn for (where a difference between 11.5 and 12 inches gets blown up by truthers to the deception of the century).
Still waiting for even a free body of the beam in question.
I suspect that there is no model...
 
In the meantime, and without waiting for the publication and discussion of the Prof. Hulsey "WTC7 Evaluation", Tony Szamboti has contributed to yet another AE911Truth pamphlet - to be sold to gullible believers at US$ 25 apiece:

"World Trade Center Physics"

Look at the content:
  • 2 The Question of Why a Total Collapse Occurred
  • 4 The Missing Jolt: Why Did the North Tower Never Decelerate?
  • 6 Discussion of Why the Observed Motion History of the World Trade Center Towers Is Smooth
  • 10 Other Evidence Incompatible with Progressive Collapse
  • 12 The Free-Fall Collapse of World Trade Center Building 7

It seems that Tony doesn't need Hulsey's results - he already knows da Twoof. So why throw money at the project, Tony? Have you raised your voice to stop the wasting of money by Hulsey, if all the evidence you ever need is "Freefall, therefore D'uh"?
 
...to be sold to gullible believers at US$ 25 apiece...
That's not quite right - they're asking for donations in order to send the pamphlet to engineering professionals (apparently one dollar will pay for the pamphlet to be sent to one professional), but if you donate 25 dollars or more then you also receive a copy of the pamphlet yourself.

From the website:

Every dollar we raise for this campaign will allow us to reach one engineer. That includes the cost of printing, postage, and renting the mailing list we’ll be using.

Only one dollar per recipient! Compare that to a year ago, when it cost $50,000 to mail Beyond Misinformation to 20,000 architects and engineers. This year we’ll be reaching twice as many professionals for $15,000 less!

Donate $25 (or more) by August 20 (or $30 if you live outside the U.S.) and you will receive a souvenir copy of World Trade Center Physics in the mail — as well as reaching one engineer with every dollar you donate. What better way for you to inform 25 (or more) engineers on the 15th anniversary of 9/11?
 
and the universal, worldwide consensus in all engineering firms and faculties is informed by them
Silence is not consensus. Consensus is when people publicly agree on something.

There is NO universal, public consensus supporting the official story.

Again, silence is not consensus. Half-ass, incomplete, and fraudulent reports are not consensus.
 
Silence is not consensus. Consensus is when people publicly agree on something.

There is NO universal, public consensus supporting the official story.

Again, silence is not consensus. Half-ass, incomplete, and fraudulent reports are not consensus.
Did you know the sky is really orange? Proof is in the silence of the masses that support it's really blue. :rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom