Merged Hulsey presents research arguing WTC7 not brought down by fires/University of Alaska

Go watch your racing. I have made my point showing you that radiation is the dominant heat transfer mechanism in a fire and that ceiling tiles would have eliminated it for much of the steel in WTC 7.
But.......you have not shown it to be significant or made an argument for your own belief.

I'm in no rush. You are gaining no ground. In fact you can't even get any engineering organisation to listen to you. You can't deny this, it's why you're still here.
 
I am talking about building 7.

In the ‘BHP Collins Street Fire Tests’, data from experimental fires in a typical office environment setup, with a fire load of between 44-49 kg/m3, gas temperatures of between 831-1163°C were achieved. It was found that the suspended office ceiling provided a highly protective radiated and convective heat shield to the structures above. Gas temperatures above these tiles in these tests were only 344-724°C, resulting in a maximum unprotected steel beam temperature of only 430°C.d


Apparently, temperatures from uncontrolled fires were high enough to cause the collapse of WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7 and for the internal collapse of WTC 5.
 
But.......you have not shown it to be significant or made an argument for your own belief.

I'm in no rush. You are gaining no ground. In fact you can't even get any engineering organisation to listen to you. You can't deny this, it's why you're still here.

I am here just to remind you that many of us in the general citizenry think the stories we have been given for the building collapses in NYC on Sept. 11, 2001 stink, because they do not match the evidence, are full of nonsense, and the arguments of those here trying to prop them up aren't doing much to eliminate the smell.
 

Attachments

  • man-holding-his-nose.jpg
    man-holding-his-nose.jpg
    13.1 KB · Views: 42
Last edited:
I am here just to remind you that many of us in the general citizenry think the stories we have been given for the building collapses in NYC on Sept. 11, 2001 stink, because they do not match the evidence, are full of nonsense, and the arguments of those here trying to prop them up aren't doing much to eliminate the smell.
Wouldn't it be nice if the engineering world would take you seriously.

Care to speculate on why they don't?

I know why, you just can't step up and produce what would be needed to support your belief.
 
Last edited:
Additionally, they certainly were ridiculous and extreme in having the fires last for four hours in one area. That is generally impossible in an office fire...

Let's take a look.


Windsor Building Fire

Around midnight, on Saturday, February 12, 2005, a fire was detected on the 21st floor. The fire spread quickly throughout the entire building, leading to the collapse of the outermost, steel parts of the upper floors; firefighters needed almost 24 hours to extinguish it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windsor_Tower_(Madrid)


...and the photos of WTC 7 prove it did not happen.


Now, let's take a look at WTC 7, a building that burned for almost 7 hours before it collapsed.


WTC 7 Photo

http://www.debunking911.com/WTC7_Smoke.jpg









 
Wouldn't it be nice if the engineering world would take you seriously.

Care to speculate on why they don't?

I know why, you just can't step up and produce what would be needed to support your belief.

The oxymoron with you and others here is that when pinned down, like you have been with Nordenson's error, you admit the reports are wrong but then don't support a new investigation. Very strange.
 
Last edited:
The oxymoron with you and others here is that when pinned down, like you have been with Nordenson's error, you admit the reports are wrong but then don't support a new investigation. Very strange.
You really don't see that your lack of coherent theory hurts you as you are not arguing from a affirmative position?
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by skyeagle409
explosives and demolition hardware leave behind evidence that can be traced.

You're right. That's why they didn't look for the evidence and then shipped the metal away as soon as they could.

So the tens of thousands of clean-up personnel, the transporters, and the Chinese and Indian scrap firms were too stupid to recognize obvious evidence of demolition? Or have they all been bribed or intimidated into silence? Tell us what you think!
 
You really don't see that your lack of coherent theory hurts you as you are not arguing from a affirmative position?

I just know the story we have been given thus far stinks, and something needs to be done about the smell. What is hard to understand about you is that you admit it isn't correct and don't want to do anything about it.
 
Last edited:
I just know the story we have been given thus far stinks, and something needs to be done about the smell. What is hard to understand about you is that you admit it isn't correct and don't want to do anything about it.


Apparently, Mr. Reality and many experts do not agree with you and it is almost 15 years and counting and still no evidence of explosives.

Have you ever wondered how investigators uncovered as to who was responsible for the downing of Pan AM 103? American and British investigators found fragments of a circuit board and a timer, and ruled that a bomb, not mechanical failure, caused the explosion. As I've said before, the use of explosives leave behind evidence that can be traced.
 
Last edited:
I just know the story we have been given thus far stinks, and something needs to be done about the smell. What is hard to understand about you is that you admit it isn't correct and don't want to do anything about it.
But the story is essentially the same from all respected sources. There is no alternative presented that can be judged to the same degree (in detail).

Do you disagree with this statement?
 
Last edited:
But the story is essentially the same from all respected sources. There is no alternative presented that can be judged to the same degree.

Do you disagree with this statement?

There are alternative theories that do explain the evidence, you just act like there isn't and want to claim that nobody else believes them. You are committing a fallacy.

How can you admit Nordenson's error of using infinite stiffness and say the story is the same and go along with it?

Essentially your behavior is unethical. If you and I were the only two who saw a man stab another man and nobody else wanted to believe it because the perpetrator was a pillar of the community would you remain quiet about it and say nobody else agrees?
 
There are alternative theories that do explain the evidence, you just act like there isn't and want to claim that nobody else believes them.

To keep it simple, fire, in conjunction with impact damage, was responsible for the collapse of WTC 7, not explosives.
 
Where? You certainly have not done this.

You know the reports aren't right and you don't want a new investigation by authorities. You say average citizens should provide a complete explanation. That is unethical. Why are you being unethical?
 
Last edited:
You know the reports aren't right and you don't want a new investigation by authorities.


A new investigation would be a waste of time because the conclusion would remain the same.

Now, let's hear from a real demolition expert.


Brent Blanchard: Demolition Expert

Brent Blanchard: If I wanted to have the least amount of detection and of physical evidence I would have used a radio wireless frequency detonator, but there's still no way to wire all those columns together without using any wire. Even with a wireless detonator you would still have to tie these columns together. And the biggest point is still that you need access to those columns. There are only two ways you can blast such a thick steel H-beam. One is to bulk load it, which means you take a big load of explosives and you just duct tape it or attach it to the beams and you just let it rip and obliterate the beam. The second way, which is what happens with true controlled demolitions, is that you cut through the flanges and you attached the charges to a point where the flanges are pre-cut and then you finish the job with the explosives.

Those are really the only two ways to cause a beam of that size to fail. Now you have to magnify that times dozens, if not hundreds, of beams. Because if you shoot ten of those nothing is going to happen, the building won't fail. You have to shoot many more than that, because the weight is distributed around that structure at the core and around the perimeter. Both methods would be extremely noticeable to the naked eye.

Furthermore, if you were going to bulk load the columns, you would have not only seen the fireball where the plane hit but also huge fireballs everywhere these explosives detonate, and nothing of the sort was seen.

http://undicisettembre.blogspot.com/2014/10/an-interview-with-explosive-expert.html
 
You know the reports aren't right and you don't want a new investigation. That is unethical. Why are you being unethical?

Tony, Tony, Tony...Richard Gage and AE 9/11 Truth don't want a new investigation. That something you need to understand, before you waste the rest of your life supporting his organization.

If you notice, everything Richard Gage does is about making money, increasing donations. Gage doesn't give a damn about the truth, he never has...
 
Why check for something for which there was no evidence in the first place?

Should we all stop getting routine physicals because we are not sick?

When we take our car in for an oil change, should we ask them to skip checking the other fluid levels because the warning lights are not on?

If there is a traffic accident, should we avoid investigating the mechanical condition of the cars, the condition of the road, and the physical condition of the drivers? Should we rely solely on witness statements, even though there is other evidence we can use?

I didn't think so.

Your argument is so weak, it's laughable. The fact that you stick by it so steadfastly undermines every other post you make.
 
Tony, Tony, Tony...Richard Gage and AE 9/11 Truth don't want a new investigation. That something you need to understand, before you waste the rest of your life supporting his organization.

If you notice, everything Richard Gage does is about making money, increasing donations. Gage doesn't give a damn about the truth, he never has...

Other than AE911Truth asking for donations, what, if any, other basis do you have for saying these things?

Do you think we have been told the whole truth about 911 and if not do you support a new investigation?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom