Merged Hulsey presents research arguing WTC7 not brought down by fires/University of Alaska

OK. Let's also use the theoretical highest temperatures for office fires. I believe it's around 1400c.

It's funny how you use the NIST conservative fire estimate like bible truth but don't believe anything else they wrote.

Do you think you can eventually whittle away at the temperatures until the building was pristine?

Tony is nit picking between the UL tests and this.

The second fire rating is called the Fire Barrier Rating. This rating utilizes American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) Test E-119, and identifies the length of time an entire ceiling assembly will resist and prevent the spread of a fire. While a ceiling tile alone cannot truly be rated with its own Fire Barrier Rating, it is usually classified with the rating that it can achieve when used in a ceiling assembly that collectively has that same rating. For example, if a ceiling tile is given a Fire Barrier Rating of 2 hours, it is meant for use in a full ceiling assembly that also has a 2 hour Fire Barrier Rating.

http://www.ceilume.com/ceiling-tile-fire-ratings.cfm
 
There were three replies within the same minute (by me, BM and CC), and mine happened to land on the bottom of the previous page, so Tony may be escused for having missed it.

Tony, could you please consider giving us a short opinion on the Hulsey study (the topic of this thread, after all!) by replying to my post #1880, please?
Thanks.

Oystein,

The project was started last summer and there is an enormous amount of prep work (modeling all of the parts and assembling them, doing sub-assemblies and testing their reactions, fire simulation, etc.) that would be involved in an FEA the size of what the entire WTC 7 building would be. You can't get results before you do the prep work.

I have read that there will be some results discussed in NYC soon and I mentioned that here.

I don't know what one could report prior to doing that prep work and I am not surprised in the time it has taken.

Please don't continue to try to trap me in some type of argument/discussion on this. I have given you my opinion and would appreciate it if you can leave it at that.
 
OK. Let's also use the theoretical highest temperatures for office fires. I believe it's around 1400c.

It's funny how you use the NIST conservative fire estimate like bible truth but don't believe anything else they wrote.

Do you think you can eventually whittle away at the temperatures until the building was pristine?

Nobody is talking about air temperatures (and I doubt 1,400 C would be achieved there in fires like those in WTC 7).

The point I was making is that 859 C steel temperatures for beams in WTC 7 are extremely unlikely and Weidlinger provides no basis for using those kinds of temperatures. Benthamitemetric tried to use a study on trusses in WTC 1, as opposed to beams, to say those temperatures could be reached. He apparently doesn't want to/or didn't think to consider specific heat and mass. I am sure he knows a 30 lb. turkey will not cook nearly as fast as a 10 lb. turkey at the same oven temperature.
 
Last edited:
Nobody is talking about air temperatures (and I doubt 1,400 C would be achieved there in fires like those in WTC 7).

Why wouldn't you talk about air (gas) temperatures? They are typically higher then the flame or radiant. They also linger for greater amounts of time.
 
Last edited:
Why wouldn't you talk about air (gas) temperatures? They are typically higher then the flame or radiant. They also linger for greater amounts of time.

Air temperature by itself is far from indicative of steel temperature. Heat transfer needs to take place and other things such as fuel load, time at temperature, mass of the steel, fire protection, and exposure to radiation need to be considered.

If you are considering those things also, then by all means you can talk about air temperature and then show how you would arrive at the steel temperatures, which is ultimately what is germane to the issue of collapse.
 
Last edited:
Air temperature by itself is far from indicative of steel temperature. Heat transfer needs to take place and other things such as fuel load, time at temperature, mass of the steel, fire protection, and exposure to radiation need to be considered.

If you are considering those things also, then by all means you can talk about air temperature and then show how you would arrive at the steel temperatures, which is ultimately what is germane to the issue of collapse.
You seem to be ignoring a very significant source of heating. You must know what a convection oven is, it cooks food with no direct path from the heat source other then air.

Do you think the steel can't absorb heat from the air? Do you think gas temperature can't exceed flame temperatures?
 
Last edited:
Oystein,

The project was started last summer and there is an enormous amount of prep work (modeling all of the parts and assembling them, doing sub-assemblies and testing their reactions, fire simulation, etc.) that would be involved in an FEA the size of what the entire WTC 7 building would be. You can't get results before you do the prep work. ...

I am most deeply disappointed with this dodging, squirming, profoudly dishonest answer Tony. Why do you taint your reputation further this way? Why are you doing yourself this disservice?

You see, neither I, nor indeed the wtc7evaluation.org homepage, talk of "results". The word is "progress".

When AE911Truth launched the site and announced the project in November 2015, they quickly added a few videos that documented almost daily progress.
They publushed daily work diaries.
This most clearly raised an expectation that they would keep reporting progress that way, but stopped entirely after the early August videos and an early October diary.


I asked you, Tony:


Now, the truth of the matter is that the public can NOT follow its progress - at all! NO aspect of the scientific process is being posted there. True or untrue, Tony?

So AE911Truth, and Professor Hulsey, broke a promise they gave when they asked for money - True or untrue, Tony?


Simple "True/Untrue" question.
I can't understand why you dodge them.
 
I am most deeply disappointed with this dodging, squirming, profoudly dishonest answer Tony. Why do you taint your reputation further this way? Why are you doing yourself this disservice?

You see, neither I, nor indeed the wtc7evaluation.org homepage, talk of "results". The word is "progress".

When AE911Truth launched the site and announced the project in November 2015, they quickly added a few videos that documented almost daily progress.
They publushed daily work diaries.
This most clearly raised an expectation that they would keep reporting progress that way, but stopped entirely after the early August videos and an early October diary.


I asked you, Tony:


Now, the truth of the matter is that the public can NOT follow its progress - at all! NO aspect of the scientific process is being posted there. True or untrue, Tony?

So AE911Truth, and Professor Hulsey, broke a promise they gave when they asked for money - True or untrue, Tony?


Simple "True/Untrue" question.
I can't understand why you dodge them.

I don't have a problem with the amount of discussion from the WTC 7 Evaluation project. It takes time to do what they are doing and there aren't many lines of demarcation to give an update that has grist. You don't like it, but then you have never done an FEA, and apparently are whining without knowing what it takes.

I think you are whining because you have an agenda to smear the UA study. Judging from what you say, the last thing you want to see is the UA study show there are problems with a fire initiated cause.

I really don't need to listen to your insidious complaints.
 
Last edited:
You seem to be ignoring a very significant source of heating. You must know what a convection oven is, it cooks food with no direct path from the heat source other then air.

Do you think the steel can't absorb heat from the air? Do you think gas temperature can't exceed flame temperatures?

Sure, I know what a convection oven is, and it takes time to cook, and the more massive and denser the item the more time it takes.

Convection is a contributor, but radiation is by far the biggest contributor to heating of steel in building fires and it is significantly mitigated by ceiling tiles.

Here is a link to a paper on this for you to read and ponder http://usir.salford.ac.uk/14780/
 
Last edited:
Sure, I know what a convection oven is, and it takes time to cook, and the bigger the item the more time it takes.

Convection is a contributor, but radiation is by far the biggest contributor to heating of steel in building fires and it is significantly mitigated by ceiling tiles.

Please support your assertion that radiant is by far the biggest contributor.

I'll wait.
 
Read the paper I linked to in post #1895 above. See pages 24 and 55.

What part exactly supports your assertion. A quick read finds this:


Whilst a lot of researches have ignored the convective heat
transfer because the radiative heat flux is the dominant component of total heat
flux, it is not considered that this is a universally correct approach. For
engulfed conditions this may be a reasonable assumption. However, outside the fire, the level of radiation drops away and the assumption becomes less valid. The
assumption is also less valid for surfaces that are highly reflective. As the magnitude of the received radiation lowers, then the significance of convection increases and convection may make a considerable difference to the fire endurance of the element.

This seems to support the idea that in long duration fire convection heating is in fact on par.
 
Last edited:
I have read what NIST based their truss temperature on in the report and they do assume blown off SFRM.

The trusses do not have nearly the same mass as the steel beams in WTC 7. You are talking apples and oranges and want to say they are the same. It is your low level of understanding and nerve in arguing what you don't fully appreciate that I would say is the sad part here.

The Cardington tests do not show any steel temperatures like those claimed by Weidlinger.

You didn't answer about how the trusses could pull the exterior inward while the test you reference says they fell off their seats.

I did cite the BHP Collins street test for the ceiling tile issue. Where is your head?

The NIST computer simulation assumes blown off insulation. Read the actual paper I linked as to what real world experiments found re the temperature of the insulated trusses in a scale model. They hit temperatures in excess of 900 C.

Can you cite me to where in the NIST report NIST claimed its temperature scenario for WTC 7 represented an upper limit of the possible temperatures? How about in the ARUP report?

You are left with purely naked assertions that WAI used temperature profiles beyond some undefined theoretical limit, even though we know NIST's scale model experiments (published in a peer reviewed fire science journal) demonstrated that even higher temperatures were possible.

And let's put aside the fact that you still can't bring yourself to simply acknowledge that you agree with ARUP re beam walk off. And that you are quibbling about the maximum temperature in the WAI model without addressing why you think that maximum temperature was important to the multifloor collapse that occurred after the initiation event. You've provided no analysis that the subsequent multifloor failings were depending on the temperature of the initiating floor. As I've pointed out, WAI explicitly corrected the Nordenson impact energy calculation and still found there would be a run away collapse. You nitpick at other parts of their model (with naked assertions and false analogies/inferences), but you dont address at all how they correct the failings of your incredibly simplified model and show that the correction of those failings leads to collapse. I see why you have a reputation for being a dishonest and disingenuous debater, by the way.
 
Last edited:
I don't have a problem with the amount of discussion from the WTC 7 Evaluation project.
Tony,
was that the question I asked? Yes or No, Tony? <- Please answer this question either with a clear, unqualified "Yes", or a clear, unqualified "No"!

Hint: The answer is of course "No"!
I did NOT ask "Do you have a problem with the amount of discussion from the WTC 7 Evaluation project?"
I asked, in fact:
"NO aspect of the scientific process is being posted there [after some time in 2015]. True or untrue, Tony?"
Please answer THIS question, either with a clear, unqualified "True", or a clear, unqualified "Untrue"!

It takes time to do what they are doing and there aren't many lines of demarcation to give an update that has grist. You don't like it, but then you have never done an FEA, and apparently are whining without knowing what it takes.
So you are saying, or are you not, that it is very clearly TRUE that neither AE911Truth nor Hulsey are posting "Every aspect of the scientific process ... here and on the university's website so that the public can follow its progress" - right, Tony?
Please answer THIS question, either with a clear, unqualified "Right", or a clear, unqualified "Wrong"!

I think you are whining because you have an agenda to smear the UA study. Judging from what you say, the last thing you want to see is the UA study show there are problems with a fire initiated cause.
Don't dodge and squirm, Tony.

I really don't need to listen to your insidious complaints.
I am NOT complaining.
I am asking you questions.
You dodge them and lie by innuendo when you instead answer questions of your own making. What a poor show this is.



Remember, when AE911Truth and Hulsey asked for money, they promised that "Every aspect of the scientific process will be posted here and on the university's website so that the public can follow its progress."
That was a PROMISE, wasn't it? <- Answer YES or NO, please!
They backed it up by posting almost daily lab videos, and by posting daily work diaries. TRUE or UNTRUE, Tony?

Are you really trying to suggest that potential donors were NOT led to expect progress updates more frequently than ... uhm ... NEVER?
Why are you holding back with honest answers, Tony? Why are you, effectively, defending the broken promises? You cannot seriously feign to be contented with this total, 100% lack of promised progress reporting and not conducting the investigation "completely open and transparent"!
 
What part exactly supports your assertion. A quick read finds this:




This seems to support the idea that in long duration fire convection heating is in fact on par.

The key here is outside of the fire. The temperatures are much lower there and convection would play more of a role. It is not significant if a non-fire area 40 to 50 feet away sees some 500 degree F air temps due to convection and isn't affected by radiation.

It is the in the fire situation where the heating of the steel to high temperatures would occur, and that is where radiation is dominant.

Why didn't you show what it says on page 55? I provide it below.

As shown in Fig.4.4, it is assumed that the layer AB is detached from the main body of the laminate. Then an additional term should be included in the energy conservative equation for points B and B' to take account of the heat transmission by radiation and convection between B and B'. If these are assumed to be on two infinitely large flat surfaces, the equation for the magnitude of heat flow G is G = Er(sigma)[TB +273)4 - (TB'+273)4] + H (TB -TB')
where Er is the resultant emissivity;
H is the heat transfer coefficient.

On the right hand side of the equation, the first term represents the radiation and second term represents convection. Since both the theoretical prediction and the explicit experimental measurement of above two parameters are difficult, they are determined by finding a reasonable fit between the model and the observed results. In the final analyses, Er is set as 0.9 and H is given the value 20 W/deg-C. It is found that the radiation energy provides the major component of G.
 
Last edited:
Dear people -

You're arguing the fine detail of fire science, as if it matters, with a man who believes that 192 (minimum) high-explosive detonations happened in the course of ~1 second in WTC7 and went entirely unnoticed.

A man who has never explained how or why the explosives were installed and how the evidence of their presence was utterly absent from the debris.

A man who has claimed that fires *could not* have been set in WTC7 by hot debris impacting it from WTC1, and that the fires were set by an arson team.

A man who claimed that the E mechanical penthouse was dropped early so that 'it wouldn't topple off sideways' (paraphrasing slightly, but not much)

A man who refuses to accept excellent photographic evidence of the inward-bowing of the WTC1 walls well prior to collapse 'because it isn't video'.

Have fun :D
 
The key here is outside of the fire. The temperatures are much lower there and convection would play more of a role. It is not significant if a non-fire area 40 to 50 feet away sees some 500 degree F air temps due to convection and isn't affected by radiation.

It is the in the fire situation where the heating of the steel to high temperatures would occur, and that is where radiation is dominant.

Why don't you show what it says on page 55?

I'm watching racing and I have not read the whole paper.

How do you know what the actual fire condition were? You down play fire but fact is many fire professionals agree that the NIST was over conservative in their assessments. You keep claiming values as upper limits of office fires.

The paper you link list fires at 1000c as normal. Do you disagree?
 
I'm watching racing and I have not read the whole paper.

How do you know what the actual fire condition were? You down play fire but fact is many fire professionals agree that the NIST was over conservative in their assessments. You keep claiming values as upper limits of office fires.

The paper you link list fires at 1000c as normal. Do you disagree?

I told you to go to pages 24 and 55. I don't think you liked what you saw on page 55 and decided not to highlight it. Nice try. I did it for you. It is clear that radiation is dominant in the fire area and would be the major contributor to steel temperature increases. If the steel is shielded from view of the fire it will not heat up nearly as much even if convective heat currents circulate around it.

Air temps of 1000C are usually normal peak temps of short duration in office fires. I don't argue that. However, they are not the steel temps, which require significant time at temperature due to their mass and specific heat. The reason steel framed buildings don't come down due to fire is because the temperature isn't high enough for long enough due to a limited fuel load.

Talking about air temps alone, as you seem to do, is not descriptive or indicative of the steel temperatures which is what is needed for structural analysis of potential failure modes.

I don't think NIST was over conservative and I can name some professors who think they used too high a fuel load. Additionally, they certainly were ridiculous and extreme in having the fires last for four hours in one area. That is generally impossible in an office fire and the photos of WTC 7 prove it did not happen.
 
Last edited:
I told you to go to pages 24 and 55. I don't think you liked what you saw on page 55 and decided not to highlight it...............

Don't pretend to know what I'm thinking.

I know you need to down play temperature and you have never been able to produce a narrative that supports your belief.

I told you I'm watching racing and I will deal with this latest nit pick in due time.
 
Don't pretend to know what I'm thinking.

I know you need to down play temperature and you have never been able to produce a narrative that supports your belief.

I told you I'm watching racing and I will deal with this latest nit pick in due time.

Go watch your racing. I have made my point showing you that radiation is the dominant heat transfer mechanism in a fire and that ceiling tiles would have eliminated it for much of the steel in WTC 7.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom