Merged Hulsey presents research arguing WTC7 not brought down by fires/University of Alaska

Maybe they didn't include it because it wasn't rated for fire. The tiles are only a small part of the system. Light and other fixtures make a huge difference in performance.

I know you need to down play the fires as much as possible but, without knowing the setup you can't claim any effect. In some cases fires have been trapped in suspended ceiling making the fires effect worse.

Sure you can make a rough order of magnitude estimate.

From what I read radiation is the biggest contributor to the heat transfer and it would seem ceiling tiles would play a big role in protecting the steel above from radiation, even if there were some missing tiles.

If 10% of the tiles are missing you still have 90% preventing radiation. Some analysts even ignore convection saying radiation is the largest contributor by far.

I am surprised I haven't seen the ceiling tile as a radiation barrier discussed here before. Was it? I could have missed it if it was.
 
Last edited:
Sure you can make a rough order of magnitude estimate.

From what I read radiation is the biggest contributor to the heat transfer and it would seem ceiling tiles would play a big role in protecting the steel above from radiation, even if there were some missing tiles.

If 10% of the tiles are missing you still have 90% preventing radiation. Some analysts even ignore convection saying radiation is the largest contributor by far.

I am surprised I haven't seen the ceiling tile as a radiation barrier discussed here before. Was it? I could have missed it if it was.

Why not 85% missing? At what point during the fire did the whole ceiling collapse? Did it collapse?

We could go on for days speculating about what ifs. What if the fires were much worse then the NIST estimated? They did only include the fires that could be seen.
 
The NIST and ARUP fire simulations, a general knowledge of radiation and convection, fuel energy in an office fire, and specific heat and mass of steel.

NIST allowed the fires to burn for four hours in one place, when they usually burn out in no more than an hour, and they did not have beam temperatures above 600 degrees C.

ARUP's analysis used relatively high air temperatures for a full hour of 700 to 800 degrees C and showed steel temperatures up to 700 degrees C, but only for upper flanges of the beams and only for a short peak period.

I have every confidence that the Weidlinger 859 degree C beam temperature claim would be knocked down significantly if it was contested.

Where do NIST and ARUP say that their chosen temperature profiles are definite and that they rule out an even hotter scenario?
 
Why not 85% missing? At what point during the fire did the whole ceiling collapse? Did it collapse?

We could go on for days speculating about what ifs. What if the fires were much worse then the NIST estimated? They did only include the fires that could be seen.

An elevator was dislodged in 7 world trade center, and much of the facade was damaded on the side facing the towers.

Do you think ceiling tiles would matter?
 
Where do NIST and ARUP say that their chosen temperature profiles are definite and that they rule out an even hotter scenario?

You need to look at the temperatures they show in their respective diagrams.

NIST has the fires active for four hours. Do you think that is legitimate?

NIST also did not include ceiling tiles in their fire simulation citing some that were dislodged. Do you think that is legitimate?

ARUP used 700 and 800 degree C fire temperatures for an hour. Do you think that is legitimate?

ARUP also did not include ceiling tiles in their fire simulation. Do you think that is legitimate?

I think both of these studies were looking to heat the steel as much as possible by disingenuously leaving out the ceiling tiles. I am not surprised that those here proposing that fire did it don't want to talk about the mitigating effect that ceiling tiles have on the heat transfer to the steel framing above them and below the floor, which also protects it.
 
Last edited:
An elevator was dislodged in 7 world trade center, and much of the facade was damaded on the side facing the towers.

Do you think ceiling tiles would matter?

Yes, certainly ceiling tiles would matter as they would still provide a radiation barrier. Radiation needs a view to transfer heat. It is also the largest contributor to heat transfer in a fire.

Why have those here proposing fire did it not discussed this effect in the past?
 
Why not 85% missing? At what point during the fire did the whole ceiling collapse? Did it collapse?

We could go on for days speculating about what ifs. What if the fires were much worse then the NIST estimated? They did only include the fires that could be seen.

There are photographs showing the ceiling tiles down in some places but not in others. Why not make an estimate rather than just ignoring their known mitigating effect?
 
How about the ceiling tiles eliminating the radiation component for heat transfer? You didn't address that question.

Yes I did, an engineering professional would have understood that my post negated that potential.

Would you like to witness an experiment for yourself, I have A36 steel I beams, can get 100 barrel oil tanks used junk ones, and I still have ceiling tiles from my 2006-7 tests.

I can fabricate the beam girder connection stiffiners ceiling tires, and match evens in the building experimentally and you can view the experiments themselves.

I have already done them, I know what the results will be, I am not an idiot like Cole Tony, I know the effect structure and fire dynamics has on chemical reactions.

Can you off set the cost for my time and materials if I choose to redo the experiments properly ?

A lot of work has to be done not as easy a building a brush pile and sticking a steel beam into it!
 
Yes I did, an engineering professional would have understood that my post negated that potential.

Would you like to witness an experiment for yourself, I have A36 steel I beams, can get 100 barrel oil tanks used junk ones, and I still have ceiling tiles from my 2006-7 tests.

I can fabricate the beam girder connection stiffiners ceiling tires, and match evens in the building experimentally and you can view the experiments themselves.

I have already done them, I know what the results will be, I am not an idiot like Cole Tony, I know the effect structure and fire dynamics has on chemical reactions.

Can you off set the cost for my time and materials if I choose to redo the experiments properly ?

A lot of work has to be done not as easy a building a brush pile and sticking a steel beam into it!

If you would actually do a test of a fire below a ceiling tile system with steel above it that would be interesting. Calculations show the ceiling tiles would significantly limit the temperature of the steel above it. BHP Collins tests show the calculations are right.

I think if you spent less time here, and actually did the test you would see for yourself, and it would be paid for with your time not spent here.
 
Last edited:
You need to look at the temperatures they show in their respective diagrams.

NIST has the fires active for four hours. Do you think that is legitimate?

NIST also did not include ceiling tiles in their fire simulation citing some that were dislodged. Do you think that is legitimate?

ARUP used 700 and 800 degree C fire temperatures for an hour. Do you think that is legitimate?

ARUP also did not include ceiling tiles in their fire simulation. Do you think that is legitimate?

I think both of these studies were looking to heat the steel as much as possible by disingenuously leaving out the ceiling tiles. I am not surprised that those here proposing that fire did it don't want to talk about the mitigating effect that ceiling tiles have on the heat transfer to the steel framing above them and below the floor, which also protects it.

The NIST model was built by a group of PhD fire scientists and was even based on extensive real world testing, including a full scale model test of of the fires in WTC 1. I don't find your mere assertions re it being flawed to be persuasive, especially given your own bias towards conclusions that would give deeper meaning to your work for the past 10 years.

Speaking of the scale model experiment re WTC 1, here are the conclusions they reached (emphasis added):

The fire and structures on the 96th floor of World Trade Center Tower 1 were reconstructed in a 1 / 20 scale. The choice of floor and wall materials and insulating material on structural system were based on the scaling rules to produce similarity between the scaled model and prototype. The testing of the scaled model shows a vivid example of using a scaled model to simulate a real-world disaster, and the results obtained help us to understand the failure mechanism involved in the disaster.

The testing of the scaled model provides the hot gas tempera-ture profile and the heat flux measurements at different locations. The total burning time of the fuels in the scaled model is about 25 min, which corresponds to the 120 min burning of the WTC1. Based on the structural analysis of WTC structural system at el-evated temperature conducted by NIST, the experimental results in the scaled model provide a timeline of structural response of WCT1 during the disaster. The results are summarized as follow-ing:

1. Fire was spread from the north to the south. The hot gas temperature reached a peak at 65 minutes in the north area and 110 min in the south area.
2. The peak hot gas temperature in the model reached 1,000 ° C.
3. The peak temperature of trusses reached 900 ° C and the peak temperature of exterior columns is about 600 ° C.
4. The time to reach the maximum steel temperature in the truss with 25.4 mm thick insulation is delayed about 10 min com-paring to the truss with 12.7 mm insulation. However, the peak steel temperature in both trusses is similar.
5. The scale experiment result reproduced a timeline of the pro-totype. Along with the numerical simulation results con-ducted by NIST2005[1], the scale experiment results indicate that the long-span floor trusses at the southwest corner would begin sagging significantly at 80 – 90 minprototype time[1]. This corresponds to the visual record which shows that the inward bowing of the south exterior wall was first observed at 96 min from the airplane impact. The scale experiment result indicates that the long-span floor trusses at the south-west corner would begin falling off the truss seats at around 85 – 95 min and the instability of the exterior columns could therefore occur at around 95 min. This matches the fact that WTC1 collapsed at 102 min.
6. A better understanding of the fire spreading and fire tempera-ture profiles at different locations of the 96th floor has been built based on the scale experiment results.
7. The results show that the testing of the scale model can rep-licate the prototype behavior in a satisfactory manner.

Have you ever taken it upon yourself to read about this experiment? It's been published for nearly ten years now. https://www.researchgate.net/public..._the_96th_Floor_of_World_Trade_Center_Tower_1
 
The NIST model was built by a group of PhD fire scientists and was even based on extensive real world testing, including a full scale model test of of the fires in WTC 1. I don't find your mere assertions re it being flawed to be persuasive, especially given your own bias towards conclusions that would give deeper meaning to your work for the past 10 years.

Speaking of the scale model experiment re WTC 1, here are the conclusions they reached (emphasis added):



Have you ever taken it upon yourself to read about this experiment? It's been published for nearly ten years now. https://www.researchgate.net/public..._the_96th_Floor_of_World_Trade_Center_Tower_1
You and I were talking about WTC 7. The 96th floor of WTC 1 had aircraft impact damage which is not applicable to WTC 7. I am also sure they did not have ceiling tiles in the tests.

However, since you brought it up I will introduce you to a contradiction it exposes in the NIST WTC report you so want to believe. They say the trusses would pull the exterior columns inward due to sagging, but in the fire simulation they say the trusses fell off their seats. Which one is it? Or do you want it both ways?
 
Last edited:
How did they account for the impact damage in the scale model experiment, Tony?

I am sure they did not have ceiling tiles and would excuse that by saying the aircraft fragments that blew off the fire insulation on the steel destroyed the ceiling tiles.

That is the damage they would have maintained occurred and the way they would have accounted for it in the test. Of course, most of the ceiling tiles would have remained intact across the south side and thus many of the trusses would not have been subject to radiation. The test was not accurate in any sense of the word.
 
Last edited:
...
Of course, Weidlinger, like NIST, did not provide an analysis to critique and simply asserted that the floors below broke loose. ...

Nor do YOU, Tony, actually provide an analysis to critique and simply asserted that the floors below could not break loose. And this despite you admitting that your (unshown, merely asserted) model was far less elaborate than any of the others, and thus almost certainly insufficient to "prove" impossibility.

Nor does Prof. Leroy Hulsey provide the public with any analysis and work progress to critique - as AE911Truth most clearly promised he would!

And that brings me to my previous post, which you (predictably) dodged entirely, even though it was on topic in this thread, while all this talk of NIST, ARUP, Weidlinger etc is offtopic:

I had asked in post #1831 - and implore you to please reply, and reply with honesty:
Tony, I understand you are not responsible for this ominous silence of the WTC7Evaluation project, but could you, please, share with us your honest opinion of their conduct?

You are aware, are you not, that the project's website, along with asking for money, promised that ...
"WTC 7 Evaluation is a completely open and transparent investigation into the cause of World Trade Center Building 7's collapse. Every aspect of the scientific process will be posted here and on the university's website so that the public can follow its progress."​

Now, the truth of the matter is that the public can NOT follow its progress - at all! NO aspect of the scientific process is being posted there. True or untrue, Tony?

So AE911Truth, and Professor Hulsey, broke a promise they gave when they asked for money - True or untrue, Tony?


Please do not dodge these clear questions, and give us your honest opinion!


My opinion is that AE911Truth blatantly and clearly broke a promise, that a show presentation in 6 weeks or so will not be able to heal.
I hope you have the courage and personal integrity to call that particular spade very clearly, and without squirming, dodging or excuses, a spade, and nothing but a spade.​
 
I am sure they did not have ceiling tiles and would excuse that by saying the aircraft fragments that blew off the fire insulation on the steel destroyed the ceiling tiles.

That is the damage they would have maintained occurred and the way they would have accounted for it in the test. Of course, most of the ceiling tiles would have remained intact across the south side and thus many of the trusses would not have been subject to radiation. The test was not accurate in any sense of the word.
Ok, so you've never even read the paper. You claim we need a new investigation, and yet for nine years have not even read a peer reviewed fire science paper that directly addresses the subject at hand? Duly noted.

The answer, by the way, is that they did not degrade the insulation of the trusses for purposes of the scale model experiment (mooting your quibble about impact damage). The trusses still reached 900°C, showing that it is plausible that a similar steel element in a similar fire (in this case, a fire that burned much longer) could reach a 850°C temperature. That you are now reduced to quibbling about ceiling tiles (based on no cited fire science reference) is just sad, Tony.
 
Last edited:
If you would actually do a test of a fire below a ceiling tile system with steel above it that would be interesting. Calculations show the ceiling tiles would significantly limit the temperature of the steel above it. BHP Collins tests show the calculations are right.

I think if you spent less time here, and actually did the test you would see for yourself, and it would be paid for with your time not spent here.

I have actually already done that test- experiment years ago.

The results vary with damage and type of ceiling tile The BHP Collins test did not use the same ceiling tile in the towers.
 
Ok, so you've never even read the paper. You claim we need a new investigation, and yet for nine years have not even read a peer reviewed fire science paper that directly addresses the subject at hand? Duly noted.

The answer, by the way, is that they did not degrade the insulation of the trusses for purposes of the scale model experiment. The trusses still reached 900°C, showing very clearly that it is plausible that a similar steel element in a similar fire (in this case, a fire that burned much longer) could reach a 850°C temperature. That you are now reduced to quibbling about ceiling tiles (based on no cited fire science reference) is just sad, Tony.

I have read what NIST based their truss temperature on in the report and they do assume blown off SFRM.

The trusses do not have nearly the same mass as the steel beams in WTC 7. You are talking apples and oranges and want to say they are the same. It is your low level of understanding and nerve in arguing what you don't fully appreciate that I would say is the sad part here.

The Cardington tests do not show any steel temperatures like those claimed by Weidlinger.

You didn't answer about how the trusses could pull the exterior inward while the test you reference says they fell off their seats.

I did cite the BHP Collins street test for the ceiling tile issue. Where is your head?
 
Last edited:
There were three replies within the same minute (by me, BM and CC), and mine happened to land on the bottom of the previous page, so Tony may be escused for having missed it.

Tony, could you please consider giving us a short opinion on the Hulsey study (the topic of this thread, after all!) by replying to my post #1880, please?
Thanks.
 
There are photographs showing the ceiling tiles down in some places but not in others. Why not make an estimate rather than just ignoring their known mitigating effect?
OK. Let's also use the theoretical highest temperatures for office fires. I believe it's around 1400c.

It's funny how you use the NIST conservative fire estimate like bible truth but don't believe anything else they wrote.

Do you think you can eventually whittle away at the temperatures until the building was pristine?
 
Nor do YOU, Tony, actually provide an analysis to critique and simply asserted that the floors below could not break loose. And this despite you admitting that your (unshown, merely asserted) model was far less elaborate than any of the others, and thus almost certainly insufficient to "prove" impossibility.

Nor does Prof. Leroy Hulsey provide the public with any analysis and work progress to critique - as AE911Truth most clearly promised he would!

And that brings me to my previous post, which you (predictably) dodged entirely, even though it was on topic in this thread, while all this talk of NIST, ARUP, Weidlinger etc is offtopic:

I had asked in post #1831 - and implore you to please reply, and reply with honesty:
Tony, I understand you are not responsible for this ominous silence of the WTC7Evaluation project, but could you, please, share with us your honest opinion of their conduct?

You are aware, are you not, that the project's website, along with asking for money, promised that ...
"WTC 7 Evaluation is a completely open and transparent investigation into the cause of World Trade Center Building 7's collapse. Every aspect of the scientific process will be posted here and on the university's website so that the public can follow its progress."​

Now, the truth of the matter is that the public can NOT follow its progress - at all! NO aspect of the scientific process is being posted there. True or untrue, Tony?

So AE911Truth, and Professor Hulsey, broke a promise they gave when they asked for money - True or untrue, Tony?


Please do not dodge these clear questions, and give us your honest opinion!


My opinion is that AE911Truth blatantly and clearly broke a promise, that a show presentation in 6 weeks or so will not be able to heal.
I hope you have the courage and personal integrity to call that particular spade very clearly, and without squirming, dodging or excuses, a spade, and nothing but a spade.​
For Tony:
Inquiring minds want to know if you agree with anybody. Please answer as truthfully as you can.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom