Merged Hulsey presents research arguing WTC7 not brought down by fires/University of Alaska

I am here once in a while to let you know that many of us in the general public understand 911 was a heinous and disgraceful scam.


May I remind you that you don't speak for the general public. Your post also reminded me of Richard Gage and AE911Truth and how he and his organization scammed those who've allowed themselves to be scammed out of their hard-earned dollars.


There were other things which could have been done for our energy needs besides invading Afghanistan...


All the Taliban had to do was to turn over Osama bin Laden. Had they done so, there would not have been a war involving U.S. troops. The Taliban refused and the rest is history.


... and Iraq


Just to let you know that Osama bin Laden's 9/11 terrorist attack on America had nothing to do with Iraq and not the reason why the U.S. invaded Iraq.


... and upsetting Syria.


Now, the plot thickens. What is Russia doing in Syria?


I understand you need to survive and it is a shame you poor bastards who can't seem to find more honorable work.


Just to let you know that 9/11 conspiracy theorist have been doing a despicable and dishonorable job to the victims of Osama bin Laden's 9/11 terrorist attack on America.
 
If you have the drawings and a description of the failure I will look at it.


To give you a hint, stiffeners failed to halt the collapse of the overpass due to fire just as stiffeners failed to halt the collapse of WTC 7. Furthermore, the collapse of WTC 7 had nothing do so with explosives, which experts concluded years ago and remember, explosives make a lot of noise as in the following video.


Controlled Demolition

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8U4erFzhC-U



Now, compare the previous video with the following video depicting the collapse of WTC 7 and point out the time lines where demolition explosions are heard as WTC 7 collapses.



WTC 7 Collapse Video


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LD06SAf0p9A


To further add, no one in their right mind would have used explosives to drop WTC 7 in a false flag operation because explosives and demolition hardware leave behind evidence that can be traced.

.
 
Last edited:
Did I mischaracterize WA's conclusion re multiple floor collapses? Did they not directly address your concern re Nordenson's impact calculations and still find, via a model that is far more extensive than your own, that multiple floors could collapse and, in fact, such a collapse could lead to a progressive collapse of the whole building, all as a result of the fires?

And you keep dodging on ARUP. Do you disagree with them re the girder being pushed off its seat in the scenarios they examined?
 
Last edited:
Did I mischaracterize WA's conclusion re multiple floor collapses? Did they not directly address your concern re Nordenson's impact calculations and still find, via a model that is far more extensive than your own, that multiple floors collapsed and, in fact, led to a progressive collapse of the whole building, all as a result of the fires?

And you keep dodging on ARUP. Do you disagree with them re the girder being pushed off its seat in the scenarios they examined?

Yes, you mischaracterized Weidlinger Associates failure mode. They said fin connections on the beams framing into the girders on the east side at floor 10 broke due to heating and that the floors fell on those below causing a multi-floor cascade.

This is essentially the same as what NIST and Nordenson try to say and is exactly what my impact analysis shows cannot happen.

Of course, Weidlinger, like NIST, did not provide an analysis to critique and simply asserted that the floors below broke loose. Weidlinger has even more nerve than NIST, as far as heating of the steel is concerned, as they have the beams at 859 degrees C, with no basis for the thermal analysis other than the author's name. I actually have to laugh at their attempt to use these impossible temperatures and fully understand why they did not provide a basis for them. That would be because they couldn't.
 
Last edited:
You're right. That's why they didn't look for the evidence and then shipped the metal away as soon as they could.

Why check for something for which there was no evidence in the first place? For an example, if they heard and saw demolition explosions, then that would have been a very good reason to investigate. However, no such explosions were seen nor heard as the WTC buildings collapsed.

Here are a few examples of what demolition explosions sound like.


Demolition Implosion Video

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eem7d58gjno


Some WTC steel was used in the construction of the USS New York and passed out as samples and even shipped to China and I once posed with WTC steel in Rio Vista, CA. at the local airport.

Selected WTC steel was examined at the Fresh Kills landfill and there is no need to waste time examining every piece of steel. Now, let's go here.


NIST’s findings also do not support the “controlled demolition”

NIST’s findings also do not support the “controlled demolition” theory since there is conclusive evidence that:

* the collapse was initiated in the impact and fire floors of the WTC towers and nowhere else, and;

* the time it took for the collapse to initiate (56 minutes for WTC 2 and 102 minutes for WTC 1) was dictated by (1) the extent of damage caused by the aircraft impact, and (2) the time it took for the fires to reach critical locations and weaken the structure to the point that the towers could not resist the tremendous energy released by the downward movement of the massive top section of the building at and above the fire and impact floors.

Video evidence also showed unambiguously that the collapse progressed from the top to the bottom, and there was no evidence (collected by NIST or by the New York City Police Department, the Port Authority Police Department, or the Fire Department of New York) of any blast or explosions in the region below the impact and fire floors as the top building sections (including and above the 98th floor in WTC 1 and the 82nd floor in WTC 2) began their downward movement upon collapse initiation.

http://www.nist.gov/el/disasterstudies/wtc/faqs_wtctowers.cfm
 
Weidlinger has even more nerve than NIST, as far as heating of the steel is concerned, as they have the beams at 859 degrees C, with no basis for the thermal analysis other than the author's name. I actually have to laugh at their attempt to use these impossible temperatures and fully understand why they did not provide a basis for them. That would be because they couldn't.


What can you tell us about this structural steel?


Horseshoe WTC Steel

http://i662.photobucket.com/albums/uu347/911conspiracytv/horseshoe_steel.jpg
 
Yes, you mischaracterized Weidlinger Associates failure mode. They said fin connections on the beams framing into the girders on the east side at floor 10 broke due to heating and that the floors fell on those below causing a multi-floor cascade.

This is essentially the same as what NIST and Nordenson try to say and is exactly what my impact analysis shows cannot happen.

Of course, Weidlinger, like NIST, did not provide an analysis to critique and simply asserted that the floors below broke loose. Weidlinger has even more nerve than NIST, as far as heating of the steel is concerned, as they have the beams at 859 degrees C, with no basis for the thermal analysis other than the author's name. I actually have to laugh at their attempt to use these impossible temperatures and fully understand why they did not provide a basis for them. That would be because they couldn't.
What's the basis for your heat analysis?
 
What's the basis for your heat analysis?

The NIST and ARUP fire simulations, a general knowledge of radiation and convection, fuel energy in an office fire, and specific heat and mass of steel.

NIST allowed the fires to burn for four hours in one place, when they usually burn out in no more than an hour, and they did not have beam temperatures above 600 degrees C.

ARUP's analysis used relatively high air temperatures for a full hour of 700 to 800 degrees C and showed steel temperatures up to 700 degrees C, but only for upper flanges of the beams and only for a short peak period.

I have every confidence that the Weidlinger 859 degree C beam temperature claim would be knocked down significantly if it was contested.
 
Last edited:
NIST allowed the fires to burn for four hours in one place, when they usually burn out in no more than an hour, and they did not have beam temperatures above 600 degrees C.

ARUP's analysis used relatively high air temperatures for a full hour of 700 to 800 degrees C and showed steel temperatures up to 700 degrees C, but only for upper flanges of the beams and only for a short peak period. I have every confidence that the Weidlinger 859 degree C beam temperature claim would be knocked down significantly if it was contested.

Typical office fires generate more than enough heat to weaken structural steel. There are types of steel lose 10% of their strength at 450 C, and 40% at 550 C'. At temperatures above 800 C ( 1475 F), it has lost 90% of its strength.

The steel structures of WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7 were subject to high-stressed load effects due to differential heating of their steel structures and structural load redistribution.

WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7 suffered major impact damage that resulted in structural load redistribuition in locations where fires raged out of control, which further weakened their structures whereas structural loads continued to be redistributed as structural weakening progressed due to uncontrolled fires and differential heating. In other words, it was just a matter of time before the collapse sequence commenced for each of those buildings and structural buckling observed on the exterior of WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7 were clear indicatiors that their structures were slowly being compremised by the combined effects of fire, impact damage, differential heating and structural load redistribution.

To make my point, WTC 1 and WTC 2 began their collapse seqences at the impact points. Any explosive or thermite placed in those locations would have been detonated or rendered ineffective, yet no secondary explosions were observed nor heard from impact to collapse and no evidence of demolition hardware or explosives was ever found within the WTC rubble.

In the case of WTC 7, once again, WTC 7 tilted toward the south in the final seconds of its collapse due to major impact damage from WTC 1. Fires raged for almost 7 hours in WTC 7 after major impact danage was incurred, yet no secondary explosions were observed or heard nor detected by seismographs. Had explosives been placed and detonated on their steel structures, shock signals would have been generated and sent into the ground whereas the signals would have been detected, yet no such signals were received by seismographs.

Let's look at it this way, you place your ear on one end of a steel beam and someone slams a hammer at the opposite end of the beam. The sound you hear is an example of what seismographs would have detected had explosives been detonated and for explosives for be effective against steel structures, the steel structures must first be pre-weakened and cutter charges and explosives must firmly be placed on the steel structures, otherwiise, the blast waves will simply flow around the steel beams. When you imply that explosives were used to bring down WTC 7 without evidence, that is an example of someone banging on a steel beam with a hammer, but producing no sound.

To sum it up, the claim that CD explosives were used to bring down the WTC buildings is simiply absurd and unfounded. Now, what can you tell us about the steel in the following photo?


Distorted Steel


http://www.911memorial.org/sites/al...og/images/TwistedWTCSteel1-e1275663221221.jpg
.
 
Last edited:
The NIST and ARUP fire simulations, a general knowledge of radiation and convection, fuel energy in an office fire, and specific heat and mass of steel.

NIST allowed the fires to burn for four hours in one place, when they usually burn out in no more than an hour, and they did not have beam temperatures above 600 degrees C.

ARUP's analysis used relatively high air temperatures for a full hour of 700 to 800 degrees C and showed steel temperatures up to 700 degrees C, but only for upper flanges of the beams and only for a short peak period.

I have every confidence that the Weidlinger 859 degree C beam temperature claim would be knocked down significantly if it was contested.

Did the NIST fire simulations involve chimney effect hydrocarbon
fires, as occurs in the real buildings?

Did neither NIST or ARUP got the fire tests right so fricking what, still doesn't make stupid
Claims of stupid CD correct.
 
The NIST and ARUP fire simulations, a general knowledge of radiation and convection, fuel energy in an office fire, and specific heat and mass of steel.

NIST allowed the fires to burn for four hours in one place, when they usually burn out in no more than an hour, and they did not have beam temperatures above 600 degrees C.

ARUP's analysis used relatively high air temperatures for a full hour of 700 to 800 degrees C and showed steel temperatures up to 700 degrees C, but only for upper flanges of the beams and only for a short peak period.

I have every confidence that the Weidlinger 859 degree C beam temperature claim would be knocked down significantly if it was contested.

I have every confidence you know nothing about fires, and the dynamics of them.

Temperature depends on fuel quality and oxidation factors.

Fuels can be redistributed in a fire, a girder temperature of 800-1000C is possible simply though dirrect oxidation of a refined fuel with sufficient oxidation upon the surface of the girder.

A fuel that when oxidized in air reaches a temperature of upwards of 1400C in dirrect contact with the metals surface.
 
I have every confidence you know nothing about fires, and the dynamics of them.

Temperature depends on fuel quality and oxidation factors.

Fuels can be redistributed in a fire, a girder temperature of 800-1000C is possible simply though dirrect oxidation of a refined fuel with sufficient oxidation upon the surface of the girder.

A fuel that when oxidized in air reaches a temperature of upwards of 1400C in dirrect contact with the metals surface.

Since you say you are an expert on fire I am wondering what can you tell us about the mitigating effects of ceiling tiles concerning heating of the steel, as they are between the fire and the steel. How much does it reduce the radiation and convection that the steel is exposed to from the fire?

I have been reading that it has a significant effect and testing has shown this.
 
Since you say you are an expert on fire I am wondering what can you tell us about the mitigating effects of ceiling tiles concerning heating of the steel, as they are between the fire and the steel. How much does it reduce the radiation and convection that the steel is exposed to from the fire?

I have been reading that it has a significant effect and testing has shown this.

Could you supply a reference?

Most ceiling tile installations don't cover a one hour fire rating. The issue is not the tiles themselves but the whole installation. They perform well when combined with sprinklers in fast moving fires.

I do a fair amount of commercial work and have seen several fires. The first thing to drop in fires is the ceiling. In fact this could be seen in the towers.


http://www.armstrong.com/commceilingsna/fire-performance-faq.html
 
Could you supply a reference?

Most ceiling tile installations don't cover a one hour fire rating. The issue is not the tiles themselves but the whole installation. They perform well when combined with sprinklers in fast moving fires.

I do a fair amount of commercial work and have seen several fires. The first thing to drop in fires is the ceiling. In fact this could be seen in the towers.


http://www.armstrong.com/commceilingsna/fire-performance-faq.html

I am talking about building 7.

A firefighter from Great Britain told me the below.

In the ‘BHP Collins Street Fire Tests’, data from experimental fires in a typical office environment setup, with a fire load of between 44-49 kg/m3, gas temperatures of between 831-1163°C were achieved. It was found that the suspended office ceiling provided a highly protective radiated and convective heat shield to the structures above. Gas temperatures above these tiles in these tests were only 344-724°C, resulting in a maximum unprotected steel beam temperature of only 430°C.

I would say that even if a tile here or there is dislodged and convective heat transfer can then take place, the remaining tiles still have a significant effect on the radiation component of the heat transfer, as it needs a view factor which there won't be.
 
Since you say you are an expert on fire I am wondering what can you tell us about the mitigating effects of ceiling tiles concerning heating of the steel, as they are between the fire and the steel. How much does it reduce the radiation and convection that the steel is exposed to from the fire?

I have been reading that it has a significant effect and testing has shown this.

What ceiling tiles, the debris from the Towers would have dislodged and loosened many of them, and As DGM stated the fire retardants in them have a one hour rating.
The ceiling tiles actually though do lead to pockets where soot builds up, interestingly soot can be ignited at 30OC with Iron Fe2O3 the resulting ignition of the Soot, refined carbon black particulates can react on the surface of steel at 1400C heating the steel to between 800-1000C.

Oh yes I have tested assemblies wih Ceiling tiles Identical to those used in the World Trade towers, they make a good pocket for the buildup of soot, and explosive and corrosive gases in the early stages of the fires.
However the thin strips used to hold them up don't last long in a corrosive hydrocarbon fire and at temperatures over 600C the fire retardants in them are rendered practically useless.

In a normal fire with sprinklers the tiles absorb moisture from the steam into the tiles materials and help prevent fire spread.

Are you suggesting that World Trade 7 was a normal fire, and proving you know nothing about fire dynamics?
 
I would say that even if a tile here or there is dislodged and convective heat transfer can then take place, the remaining tiles still have a significant effect on the radiation component of the heat transfer, as it needs a view factor which there won't be.

What ceiling setup was he talking about and was it the same as WTC 7? Installations vary greatly and most carry almost no fire rating. This is especially true in buildings where fire rating is achieved through SFRM application.
 
What ceiling setup was he talking about and was it the same as WTC 7? Installations vary greatly and most carry almost no fire rating. This is especially true in buildings where fire rating is achieved through SFRM application.

It looks to me like they would have a mitigating effect, even if some are dislodged.

He also told me NIST did not include ceiling tiles in their fire simulation.

You should look at the BHP Collins Street tests if you can get them. I am just reporting what the firefighter told me.
 
Last edited:
What ceiling tiles, the debris from the Towers would have dislodged and loosened many of them, and As DGM stated the fire retardants in them have a one hour rating.
The ceiling tiles actually though do lead to pockets where soot builds up, interestingly soot can be ignited at 30OC with Iron Fe2O3 the resulting ignition of the Soot, refined carbon black particulates can react on the surface of steel at 1400C heating the steel to between 800-1000C.

Oh yes I have tested assemblies wih Ceiling tiles Identical to those used in the World Trade towers, they make a good pocket for the buildup of soot, and explosive and corrosive gases in the early stages of the fires.
However the thin strips used to hold them up don't last long in a corrosive hydrocarbon fire and at temperatures over 600C the fire retardants in them are rendered practically useless.

In a normal fire with sprinklers the tiles absorb moisture from the steam into the tiles materials and help prevent fire spread.

Are you suggesting that World Trade 7 was a normal fire, and proving you know nothing about fire dynamics?

How about the ceiling tiles eliminating the radiation component for heat transfer? You didn't address that question.
 
Last edited:
He also told me NIST did not include ceiling tiles in their fire simulation.

Maybe they didn't include it because it wasn't rated for fire. The tiles are only a small part of the system. Light and other fixtures make a huge difference in performance.

I know you need to down play the fires as much as possible but, without knowing the setup you can't claim any effect. In some cases fires have been trapped in suspended ceiling making the fires effect worse.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom