Merged Hulsey presents research arguing WTC7 not brought down by fires/University of Alaska

The driving doubt for truth guys is that the heat from fires was insufficient to destroy the integrity of the frame... office fires can destroy steel buildings. This is the huge barrier that is faced because these guys can't see any energy capable of triggering a progrssive collapse. Heck even with the collapse of the top mass these guys refuse to accept that this could mechanically destroy the structure... so they see the twins turning to dust in mid air obviously by some explosive devices... They completely MISS the fact that the twins collapse phase was a result of tens of thousands of tons of fall debris from the floors below overwhelming the floors they impacted on their way down to the ground. How stupid can they be? What do they expect a 4" light weight concrete slab to be able to support? Wouldn't that be its design load/ultimate yield strength???? YESSSSSSSSS and it was far exceeded.

The heat destruction took place in the pre collapse period... no fire suppression... which is there to prevent exactly what happened... frame distortion and connection failures... no connections... no support for floor mass. Easy peasy.
 
The driving doubt for truth guys is that the heat from fires was insufficient to destroy the integrity of the frame... office fires can destroy steel buildings. This is the huge barrier that is faced because these guys can't see any energy capable of triggering a progrssive collapse. Heck even with the collapse of the top mass these guys refuse to accept that this could mechanically destroy the structure... so they see the twins turning to dust in mid air obviously by some explosive devices... They completely MISS the fact that the twins collapse phase was a result of tens of thousands of tons of fall debris from the floors below overwhelming the floors they impacted on their way down to the ground. How stupid can they be? What do they expect a 4" light weight concrete slab to be able to support? Wouldn't that be its design load/ultimate yield strength???? YESSSSSSSSS and it was far exceeded.

The heat destruction took place in the pre collapse period... no fire suppression... which is there to prevent exactly what happened... frame distortion and connection failures... no connections... no support for floor mass. Easy peasy.

JSO, they miss a lot of things, I just looked at the drawings of the stiffeners in question, and then did a little calculation on my computer, based on uneven heating of the girder in Question. The fact is the stiffeners is heated unevenly, will expand unevenly and actually cause bolt failure, seat failure and girder failure.
Tony's FEA is based on even heating that would most likely not occur in a real fire, Cole proves this point in his video where he holds a rod that he heated in his Hand, as he hammers it.

Uneven thermal expansion cases the expansion of only one stiffener the other restrains the girder, leading to a bending and warping of the girder and seat.

This can easily be demonstrated experimentally by building a mock up of the connection, and subjecting it to one sided uneven heating.

Tony's FEA as are Cole's experiments are way over simplified.
 
What a riot, just found several pages on stiffeners acting as heat sinks causing beam and girder deformation during heat straitening of bridges.
The same physical properties apply to structural steel in buildings, in other words experiments have proven for years Stiffiners act as heat sinks and can induce failure in fire not prevent it.
Please someone please I need laughing dogs for this thread.

Chapter 2: Heat Straightening Basics - Guide for Heat-Straightening of Damaged Steel Bridge Members - Steel - Structures - Bridges ...
https://www.fhwa.dot.gov › bridge › steel
May 28, 2015 - Heat straightening is a repair procedure in which ... Rather, the thermal expansion/contraction is an .... Schematic of strip heat on the flange of a rolled beam. ..... Attachments such as stiffeners may serve as a heat sink ...
 
Last edited:
Oh no it gets better remember when Tony says, that the fall of the girder can not fail the floor below, at 300C?
Well Tony is one hundred percent correct the highest potential for sheer is at 800C or at room temperature.

Fracture sheer is more likely in cold steel than warm ductile steel and ductility increases with temperature.

Hey Tony in which store did you buy the box of Crackerjacks, that had your engineering degree in it?

Maybe I can get mine, all this information readily avaliable, for so long and you still cling to the Twoof.
 
So frigging what? NIST elaborated a report to warn the engineering world of the deficiencies that led to the collapse. Their conclusion was that it was the result of unfought fires. Alternative explanations have been given by those who were not convinced by NIST's, enough of them as to satisfy all engineers except the politically motivated, which won't be satisfied unless the explanation matches their political prejudices.

NIST's report covers much more than just engineering, and even if the engineering parts of the report were wrong, there are still other reports that confirm that the collapse was caused by fire, enough to satisfy the non-politically motivated engineers that were not convinced by NIST's explanation.

The only engineers that remain dissatisfied are the ones with an agenda.
The report is not wrong. Get that straight. The report is correct.
The NIST report concludes that the beam failed at its connections, due to unfought fires and massive overload due to fires and other, previous, damage.
There was no design error. The joint was designed for, and withstood, 3 (or whatever ultimate safety factor was used) times the X pounds of load it was designed for at the temperature used for design.
Let's assume it was a FS of 3. It doesn't matter if the load was 3.01X or 20X, or even 2.7X at T=2*TD. Failure of the joint is assumed.
The report did not, and needed not, get into the details of the failure at the level fanatics want. See my previous posts on that. That was not its purpose
The other reports and papers get deeper into the details, certainly, but they are unimportant, except as scholarly musings and design guides to more efficient joints (as in lighter, cheaper, and easier to manufacture)
 
Since the subject of this thread is in fact WTC7Evaluation.org and Dr. J. Leroy Hulsey I thought we might move back on topic.

I am wondering if by chance Tony had any updates or progress reports for how it is all coming along. Things seem strangely silent of late at the AE911T site and the WTC7evaluation.org site has not been updated in a full year as of next Friday. We were told as I recall this was going to be an open and transparent 2 year study but I don't see anything happening.

Am I missing something?
 
Since the subject of this thread is in fact WTC7Evaluation.org and Dr. J. Leroy Hulsey I thought we might move back on topic.

I am wondering if by chance Tony had any updates or progress reports for how it is all coming along. Things seem strangely silent of late at the AE911T site and the WTC7evaluation.org site has not been updated in a full year as of next Friday. We were told as I recall this was going to be an open and transparent 2 year study but I don't see anything happening.

Am I missing something?

I have read where there will be results of the study to date made public soon in NYC. I don't know what those results entail at the moment.
 
Last edited:
The report is not wrong. Get that straight. The report is correct.
The NIST report concludes that the beam failed at its connections, due to unfought fires and massive overload due to fires and other, previous, damage.
There was no design error. The joint was designed for, and withstood, 3 (or whatever ultimate safety factor was used) times the X pounds of load it was designed for at the temperature used for design.
Let's assume it was a FS of 3. It doesn't matter if the load was 3.01X or 20X, or even 2.7X at T=2*TD. Failure of the joint is assumed.
The report did not, and needed not, get into the details of the failure at the level fanatics want. See my previous posts on that. That was not its purpose
The other reports and papers get deeper into the details, certainly, but they are unimportant, except as scholarly musings and design guides to more efficient joints (as in lighter, cheaper, and easier to manufacture)

Omitting the partial height web stiffeners on the girder, shortening the girder seat width to 11" when the drawings showed 12" and they could only get 5.5" of beam expansion, and ignoring the girder trapping on the column side plate after 3" of lateral travel, are more than just not getting into the details and they are found nowhere else. In addition, it is now apparent that the falling beam and girder assembly from the northeast corner cannot shear the girder seat below and thus there would be no floor failure cascade. Finally, it is clear that no analysis exists that shows column 79 could lose enough lateral support to cause it to buckle.

When these things are corrected the NIST WTC 7 report has no answer for how WTC 7 came down. It is completely non-explanatory and it is wrong to just give those responsible a pass. They need to come up with a new hypothesis that actually explains the evidence, redo the analysis, and amend the report.
 
Last edited:
Omitting the partial height web stiffeners on the girder, shortening the girder seat width to 11" when the drawings showed 12" and they could only get 5.5" of beam expansion, and ignoring the girder trapping on the column side plate after 3" of lateral travel, are more than just not getting into the details and they are found nowhere else.

When these things are corrected the NIST WTC 7 report has no answer for how WTC 7 came down. It is completely non-explanatory and it is wrong to just give them a pass.

See my previous posts on the subject.
It. Does. Not. Matter.
you are bitching and moaning about an error on the scale of 1 inch in several hundreds of thousands. You can't see the forest because that pine tree sapling is in the way...
 
See my previous posts on the subject.
It. Does. Not. Matter.
you are bitching and moaning about an error on the scale of 1 inch in several hundreds of thousands. You can't see the forest because that pine tree sapling is in the way...

I am not bitching about a 1 inch error on a scale of hundreds of thousands.

You are giving a pass to a report that has been shown to be completely non-explanatory by a large margin.

You say you are an engineer and I believe you. Maybe you can take tfk's place on the 911 free forum (he bowed out) and we can talk one-on-one.
 
Last edited:
Since the subject of this thread is in fact WTC7Evaluation.org and Dr. J. Leroy Hulsey I thought we might move back on topic.

I am wondering if by chance Tony had any updates or progress reports for how it is all coming along. Things seem strangely silent of late at the AE911T site and the WTC7evaluation.org site has not been updated in a full year as of next Friday. We were told as I recall this was going to be an open and transparent 2 year study but I don't see anything happening.

Am I missing something?
Thanks, Mark.

I have read where there will be results of the study to date made public soon in NYC. I don't know what those results entail at the moment.
Tony, I understand you are not responsible for this ominous silence of the WTC7Evaluation project, but could you, please, share with us your honest opinion of their conduct?

You are aware, are you not, that the project's website, along with asking for money, promised that ...
"WTC 7 Evaluation is a completely open and transparent investigation into the cause of World Trade Center Building 7's collapse. Every aspect of the scientific process will be posted here and on the university's website so that the public can follow its progress."​

Now, the truth of the matter is that the public can NOT follow its progress - at all! NO aspect of the scientific process is being posted there. True or untrue, Tony?

So AE911Truth, and Professor Hulsey, broke a promise they gave when they asked for money - True or untrue, Tony?


Please do not dodge these clear questions, and give us your honest opinion!


My opinion is that AE911Truth blatantly and clearly broke a promise, that a show presentation in 6 weeks or so will not be able to heal.
I hope you have the courage and personal integrity to call that particular spade very clearly, and without squirming, dodging or excuses, a spade, and nothing but a spade.
 
.............. Maybe you can take tfk's place on the 911 free forum (he bowed out) and we can talk one-on-one.

Would you be willing to talk about details of your hypothesis so they can be scrutinized to the same level you expect of the "official story"?

I don't personally know rwguinn but I can't imagine he would want a debate strictly on if the NIST got a detail wrong. You need to state an affirmative for CD that you are willing to support. I think rwguinn stated very clearly his opinion on the consequence of any error in the NIST reports.


rwguinn, please forgive me if I overstepped my bounds in my opinion above.
 
NIST said the girder flange failed when its web was pushed past its seat. That could not happen with the stiffeners on the girder, so it is pertinent to what NIST did. I do believe the stiffeners were left off intentionally to try and show the girder could fail by pushing it to the west. They could only push the girder about 5.5 inches due to beam expansion so they needed the flange to fail. That was probably why they initially claimed the girder seat was only 11" wide when the drawings said it was 12". They got away with that for over three years. The shop fabrication drawing for girder A2001 has never been released, but the girder to column assembly drawing was and it showed the seat width and stiffeners. They also ignored the girder being trapped behind the column 79 side plate after just 3" of lateral travel. I think that was intentional also. The NIST situation for single girder failure is impossible once all of the actual parameters are known and it is naïve to think the omissions, distortions, and ignoring of pertinent structural features wasn't intentional.

The ARUP situation was not constrained by beam expansion, as it pulls the girder back towards the beams due to their sagging and there is a slim possibility, with enough heat and load, that the girder could be pulled completely off its seat but not due to flange failure, which can't happen with the stiffeners. To pull it off the seat it would have to move the girder its entire 11.510 inch width plus the .245 inches on the side of the seat or 11.755 inches. This much shortening of the beams would require them to sag about 61 inches, which is extremely unlikely since it would require beam temperatures in excess of 800 degrees C.

I do not think the ARUP pull off happened either, but as I said, it is moot as the girder fall could not cause a floor collapse cascade which would be needed to cause column 79 to buckle.

Gamolon, it seems you are groping at straws to maintain some sort of desperate illusion that these reports actually describe what caused the collapse. What a shame.

What exactly is your basis for believing that neither of the two beam pull off scenarios identified by ARUP could happen?

You should remember that the ARUP report was prepared in support of a litigation and, specifically, in support of plaintiffs' theory that the building would not have collapsed were it not negligently designed. It was not conducted with an eye to identifying every single possible collapse mode across an infinite range of heating scenarios. It was conducted narrowly to test whether the unfilled flutes could likely have contributed to the collapse mode. In at least two plausible scenarios, ARUP determined that the flutes would have contributed to the collapse. That is the significance of their report and also why it can't be read to falsify NIST's. Both NIST and ARUP simply approached the heating of elements a different way, which lead to the beams behaving differently. We do not need to know which way was more accurate because we cannot travel back in time to see exsactly how the fires burned in the building; however, so long as either way is reasonably plausible, they both independently demonstrate that there are possible fire induced failure modes (and, together, they demonstrate there were a variety of such possible failure modes).

EDIT: Let's not forget that Weidlinger Associates has also extensively modeled WTC 7 and concluded there were fire-induced failure modes and that the collapse on Sept 11 was likely fire-induced: http://www.thorntontomasetti.com/projects/world_trade_center_7_collapse_investigation/. Notably, the WA model was prepared on the opposite side of the Aegis insurance as the Colaco/Nordenson/Bailey/etc. reports and thus purports to show alternative collapse modes that were not the result of negligent design. The reality is that there were many plausible collapse modes and, without actually knowing for certain how the fires burned through the floors, we can't do much more than identify such modes.

EDIT 2: You should take special note of the fact that WA makes a point of criticizing Nordenson's impact energy calculations in the same way you did. They also, however, criticize Nordenson's pristine floor assumptions, in the same way I criticized yours. See the section starting at page 72 of their report.
 
Last edited:
Would you be willing to talk about details of your hypothesis so they can be scrutinized to the same level you expect of the "official story"?

I don't personally know rwguinn but I can't imagine he would want a debate strictly on if the NIST got a detail wrong. You need to state an affirmative for CD that you are willing to support. I think rwguinn stated very clearly his opinion on the consequence of any error in the NIST reports.


rwguinn, please forgive me if I overstepped my bounds in my opinion above.

Pretty close.
Every engineer worth a damn will want to turn an interesting problem into a "Science Project". I have that tendency myself on some things, and have to fight it off on the real world. At some point, you have to decide that good enough is just that. You move on. The only times we won't move on is when there is an obvious, significant, and potentially dangerous flaw. I've quit jobs over that, and been transferred because of it, as have some of my peers.
But, there is a reason we design to margins--some material may be at minimum requirements, somebody drills a "snowman" instead of a round hole, or whatever.
I have no desire to debate a closed mind.

Now, back to our regularly scheduled denial and procrastination...
 
What exactly is your basis for believing that neither of the two beam pull off scenarios identified by ARUP could happen?

You should remember that the ARUP report was prepared in support of a litigation and, specifically, in support of plaintiffs' theory that the building would not have collapsed were it not negligently designed. It was not conducted with an eye to identifying every single possible collapse mode across an infinite range of heating scenarios. It was conducted narrowly to test whether the unfilled flutes could likely have contributed to the collapse mode. In at least two plausible scenarios, ARUP determined that the flutes would have contributed to the collapse. That is the significance of their report and also why it can't be read to falsify NIST's. Both NIST and ARUP simply approached the heating of elements a different way, which lead to the beams behaving differently. We do not need to know which way was more accurate because we cannot travel back in time to see exsactly how the fires burned in the building; however, so long as either way is reasonably plausible, they both independently demonstrate that there are possible fire induced failure modes (and, together, they demonstrate there were a variety of such possible failure modes).

EDIT: Let's not forget that Weidlinger Associates has also extensively modeled WTC 7 and concluded there were fire-induced failure modes and that the collapse on Sept 11 was likely fire-induced: http://www.thorntontomasetti.com/projects/world_trade_center_7_collapse_investigation/. Notably, the WA model was prepared on the opposite side of the Aegis insurance as the Colaco/Nordenson/Bailey/etc. reports and thus purports to show alternative collapse modes that were not the result of negligent design. The reality is that there were many plausible collapse modes and, without actually knowing for certain how the fires burned through the floors, we can't do much more than identify such modes.

EDIT 2: You should take special note of the fact that WA makes a point of criticizing Nordenson's impact energy calculations in the same way you did. They also, however, criticize Nordenson's pristine floor assumptions, in the same way I criticized yours. See the section starting at page 72 of their report.

I would hardly call what you are saying a criticism. It is more like fingers in ears.

I showed you that heating of the girder seat could not possibly allow the falling upper floor to shear the girder seat. The required temperature would have been impossible to achieve.

As for your attempt to soft pedal NIST's approach, that is ridiculous and you obviously aren't paying attention to the fact that the girder could not possibly be pushed off to the west for several reasons. In addition to the beams not being able to expand enough with the actual 12" seat width and really being far from enough with the stiffeners on the girder, the girder gets trapped behind the side plate after just three inches of lateral travel.

The NIST report should be dismissed as non-explanatory at a minimum and in reality it is deceptive and fraudulent.

The ARUP report is falsified due to the falling beam and girder assembly not being able to break through the next floor down even at maximum fire temperatures, because the seat can never get hot enough.
 
I would hardly call what you are saying a criticism. It is more like fingers in ears.

I showed you that heating of the girder seat could not possibly allow the falling upper floor to shear the girder seat. The required temperature would have been impossible to achieve.

As for your attempt to soft pedal NIST's approach, that is ridiculous and you obviously aren't paying attention to the fact that the girder could not possibly be pushed off to the west for several reasons. In addition to the beams not being able to expand enough with the actual 12" seat width and really being far from enough with the stiffeners on the girder, the girder gets trapped behind the side plate after just three inches of lateral travel.

The NIST report should be dismissed as non-explanatory at a minimum and in reality it is deceptive and fraudulent.

The ARUP report is falsified due to the falling beam and girder assembly not being able to break through the next floor down even at maximum fire temperatures, because the seat can never get hot enough.

To be clear--you didn't show me or anyone anything. You merely asserted something. And it's very clear that your assertions are based on incomplete information as you admit you have not adequately modeled a multifloor fire to the extent that would allow you draw inferences about the performance of multiple floors therein.

WA shows my point about the importance of damage across multiple floors very clearly. They corrected the error in Nordenson's calculation that you pointed out. They state this very explicitly. And then they ran a full fire and collapse simulation--something you have not done. And guess what? Multiple floors collapsed due to damage.

And just to be clear on another point, you are conflating ARUP's report re the failure of one floor with Nordenson's calculations as to how that could lead to a multifloor collapse. Are you doing this on purpose? Do you have any basis to believe ARUP's model was incorrect in showing the two scenarios in which the beam could fall off the seat?
 
Last edited:
As for your attempt to soft pedal NIST's approach, that is ridiculous and you obviously aren't paying attention to the fact that the girder could not possibly be pushed off to the west for several reasons. In addition to the beams not being able to expand enough with the actual 12" seat width and really being far from enough with the stiffeners on the girder, the girder gets trapped behind the side plate after just three inches of lateral travel.


Speaking of stiffeners, what can you tell us about stiffener performance regarding the MacArthur Maze overpass fire that weakened its steel structure to the point of collapse?
 
...
The ARUP report is falsified due to the falling beam and girder assembly not being able to break through the next floor down even at maximum fire temperatures, because the seat can never get hot enough.
Do you know what falsified means? No.

How is the silent explosives going when you told the FBI about the inside job and the nest of shills here at the 9/11 conspiracy theory sub-forum?

lol, 15 years arriving soon. You/Gage/911t remain, forever evidence free -
 
Last edited:
Speaking of stiffeners, what can you tell us about stiffener performance regarding the MacArthur Maze overpass fire that weakened its steel structure to the point of collapse?

If you have the drawings and a description of the failure I will look at it.
 
To be clear--you didn't show me or anyone anything. You merely asserted something. And it's very clear that your assertions are based on incomplete information as you admit you have not adequately modeled a multifloor fire to the extent that would allow you draw inferences about the performance of multiple floors therein.

WA shows my point about the importance of damage across multiple floors very clearly. They corrected the error in Nordenson's calculation that you pointed out. They state this very explicitly. And then they ran a full fire and collapse simulation--something you have not done. And guess what? Multiple floors collapsed due to damage.

And just to be clear on another point, you are conflating ARUP's report re the failure of one floor with Nordenson's calculations as to how that could lead to a multifloor collapse. Are you doing this on purpose? Do you have any basis to believe ARUP's model was incorrect in showing the two scenarios in which the beam could fall off the seat?

You clearly are not being sincere and genuine here. I performed analyses based on actual drawing dimensions and material properties at temperature. You are the one who is simply making assertions about some type of magical damage that might help your preferred outcome with no basis for doing so.

You seem like one of those who, when a decision is about to go against their interests, try to stop it by muddying things up and saying "we can never know", no matter how clear the circumstances actually are.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom