Merged Hulsey presents research arguing WTC7 not brought down by fires/University of Alaska

Can you share with us the actual model that shows this? Also, are you not also heating the entire girder?

In any case, you've now gone from, "the multifloor collapse is impossible" to "my limited model, which omits many key structural elements and a realistic fire simulation shows, the collapse could occur under certain conditions". This is big progress towards being honest about the limits of your own conclusions.

In my model the girder at the floor below is also heated and that affects its stiffness and the shock load amplification. The softer the material the less stiff and the lower the shock amplification. You need to remember that the falling beam and girder assembly has a static force of just 46,000 lbs. and the room temperature force required to shear the seat is 632,000 lbs. At 800 degrees C the force required is about 10% of that, so a shock amplification still occurs.

Of course, the problem is you can't get the seat anywhere near that hot. The lower stiffness of the girder also only needs to occur at 12 inches from the seat which is where the impact occurs.

I haven't gone from anything other than what I have been saying since looking into Nordenson's calculation about six months ago. I am saying the multi-floor collapse is impossible. You are well aware of that from the Metabunk.org thread from six months ago. It really isn't a complicated configuration for shearing of the seat and the calculations are what they are. Have someone else do it if you don't believe what I am saying.
 
Last edited:
In my model the girder at the floor below is also heated and that affects its stiffness and the shock load amplification. The softer the material the less stiff and the lower the shock amplification. You need to remember that the falling beam and girder assembly has a static force of just 46,000 lbs. and the room temperature force required to shear the seat is 632,000 lbs. At 800 degrees C the force required is about 10% of that, so a shock amplification still occurs.

Of course, the problem is you can't get the seat anywhere near that hot. The lower stiffness of the girder also only needs to occur at 12 inches from the seat which is where the impact occurs.

I haven't gone from anything other than what I have been saying since looking into Nordenson's calculation about six months ago. I am saying the multi-floor collapse is impossible. You are well aware of that from the Metabunk.org thread from six months ago. It really isn't a complicated configuration for shearing of the seat and the calculations are what they are. Have someone else do it if you don't believe what I am saying.

It seems to me like there is something missing from your model. If you accept ARUP's determination that heat alone can cause a floor section to fail, it seems there is likely a whole range of parameters under which heat + the impact or weight of another floor would cause a floor to fail, no?
 
It seems to me like there is something missing from your model. If you accept ARUP's determination that heat alone can cause a floor section to fail, it seems there is likely a whole range of parameters under which heat + the impact or weight of another floor would cause a floor to fail, no?

There is nothing missing. You are mixing apples and oranges in your vague notion.

Sagging of the beams to pull the girder off its seat is not the same thing or even related to the need to have a large impact force to shear the girder seat below.

There is actually an opposite action to commonality and possibility of failure in that heat and lowering of the modulus of elasticity causes the beam sagging but conversely drops the shock amplification of the beam and girder assembly load on the girder below by allowing greater deflection due to lowering the modulus.

If I remember correctly you are a lawyer and an educated person. However, most people who aren't mechanical or civil engineers don't have the technical training in this specific area to do the calculations themselves and lack the full understanding and nuances of structures and behavior under load that would come with that training. Even a large number of engineers don't fully appreciate dynamic loading if they don't work with it. It sounds like you just can't fully appreciate what I am saying. You should have another mechanical or civil engineer, who works with dynamic loads, do the calculations.
 
Last edited:
There is nothing missing. You are mixing apples and oranges in your vague notion.

Sagging of the beams to pull the girder off its seat is not the same thing or even related to the need to have a large impact force to shear the girder seat below.

There is actually an opposite action to commonality and possibility of failure in that heat and lowering of the modulus of elasticity causes the beam sagging but conversely drops the shock amplification of the beam and girder assembly load on the girder below by allowing greater deflection due to lowering the modulus.

If I remember correctly you are a lawyer and an educated person. However, most people who aren't mechanical or civil engineers don't have the technical training in this specific area to do the calculations themselves and lack the full understanding and nuances of structures and behavior under load that would come with that training. Even a large number of engineers don't fully appreciate dynamic loading if they don't work with it. It sounds like you just can't fully appreciate what I am saying. You should have another mechanical or civil engineer, who works with dynamic loads, do the calculations.

Does your model replicate ARUP's findings re the failure of the first beam as a result of heat?

I am a lawyer and I know the limits to my knowledge on engineering issues. I believe I acknowledge those limits fairly (as in the conversation on metabunk, which ended far too soon, in my opinion). But, even without getting into the engineering minutae, there is a lot simply thinking through the problem logically can do to inform us about the limitations of a given model (in this case, yours). The goal here is to understand whether there is any set of parameters under which a multistory collapse could occur as a result of fire in the WTC 7. You claim, based on your model, that there is not. My questions are going towards reconciling that claim with the ARUP findings to determine what the limits of your model are. I suspect you know that simply claiming such a collapse is "impossible" is a bridge too far based on the work you've done to date (and I'm not denigrating that work--just seeking to understand its limits).
 
Last edited:
Does your model replicate ARUP's findings re the failure of the first beam as a result of heat?

The whole point of my exercise with the Nordenson report, concerning whether the falling beam and girder assembly could shear the girder seat at the next floor down, came after Bailey's analysis, which showed the girder could have been pulled off its seat to the east, so I did not concern myself with that and simply started where Nordenson did.


I am a lawyer and I know the limits to my knowledge on engineering issues. I believe I acknowledge those limits fairly (as in the conversation on metabunk, which ended far too soon, in my opinion). But, even without getting into the engineering minutae, there is a lot simply thinking through the problem logically can do to inform us about the limitations of a given model (in this case, yours). The goal here is to understand whether there is any set of parameters under which a multistory collapse could occur as a result of fire in the WTC 7. You claim, based on your model, that there is not. My questions are going towards reconciling that claim with the ARUP findings to determine what the limits of your model are. I suspect you know that simply claiming such a collapse is "impossible" is a bridge too far based on the work you've done to date (and I'm not denigrating that work--just seeking to understand its limits).

I am saying that there is presently no analysis that shows that column 79 could have lost enough lateral support to buckle. I don't think that is a bridge too far if you understand that only one connection on one story could possibly have been broken. There are two major structural mistakes in the ARUP reports and they are both in Nordenson's report. The first of course is the use of an infinitely stiff point load for the falling beam and girder assembly and the second has to do with the attempt to apply Fracture Mechanics to the south and west girder connections that Bailey shows remain stable. Fracture Mechanics is not applicable as it requires load cycles, and there essentially were none.

I am not going to continue this conversation as I have things to do and I think I have explained the situation in more than sufficient detail. Both the NIST and ARUP reports have been falsified by the inability of the falling beam and girder assembly to cause a floor cascade.
 
Last edited:
Tony,

Wasn't it you who said this below?
The bottom line is we now know that the girder could have not come off that seat and it is clear from the discovery that there were serious omissions and a seat width distortion, which happened to match the maximum expansion of the beams to get the girder web past the edge of the seat, that there was some level of malfeasance on the part of someone at NIST to make it look like it could have.

With all that has come out, anyone who still says girder A2001 could have walked off its seat at column 79 is only fooling themselves or trying to fool others.

Serious omissions huh? Malfeasance? ARUP added those "omissions" into their study right Tony? ARUP came to the conclusion that the initial floor beam came off its seat just like the NIST said, just not the same way.

Are you now going to retract all your previous statements saying it was impossible for this to happen?
 
Tony,

Wasn't it you who said this below?


Serious omissions huh? Malfeasance? ARUP added those "omissions" into their study right Tony? ARUP came to the conclusion that the initial floor beam came off its seat just like the NIST said, just not the same way.

Are you now going to retract all your previous statements saying it was impossible for this to happen?

ARUP then had a fatal error which proved it and the NIST report are false in the inability to break through the next floor down.

I also have my doubts that the girder would have been pulled off its seat but that is made moot by the fact that even if it did it could not cause a floor cascade and loss of lateral support for column 79. Therefore, it never buckles.

You don't even have a point when things are put in context.
 
I am saying that there is presently no analysis that shows that column 79 could have lost enough lateral support to buckle. I don't think that is a bridge too far if you understand that only one connection on one story could possibly have been broken. There are two major structural mistakes in the ARUP reports and they are both in Nordenson's report. The first of course is the use of an infinitely stiff point load for the falling beam and girder assembly and the second has to do with the attempt to apply Fracture Mechanics to the south and west girder connections that Bailey shows remain stable. Fracture Mechanics is not applicable as it requires load cycles, and there essentially were none.
Are they in on it too now Tony? I love how you pass these off as "mistakes", but when it comes to the NIST, they did it on purpose to cover up controlled demolitions.

I am not going to continue this conversation as I have things to do and I think I have explained the situation in more than sufficient detail.
Of course you're not going to continue...

I'll ask anyways since you seem to want to continue to dance around giving a direct answer.

Do you now agree that the initial beam at column 79 could have come off its seat like ARUP states in their conclusion?

Yes or no?
 
ARUP then had a fatal error which proved it and the NIST report are false in the inability to break through the next floor down.
That's nice Tony.

My point being that you and gerrycan INITIALLY argued that it was IMPOSSIBLE for the initial beam to have come off its seat AT ALL!

You claimed the NIST intentionally left out structural elements that would have prevented this!

ARUP added those IMPORTANT STRUCTUTRAL ELEMENTS the YOU claim the NIST intentionally left out and they STILL concluded that the initial beam came off its seat.

Are you now going to retract all of your previous statements that it was impossible for the initial beam to come off its seat? Do you agree with ARUP that the initial beam was pulled off its seat?
 
Interesting...
Actually when ARUP (a competent engineering firm)

Yet...
I also have my doubts that the girder would have been pulled off its seat

I get it now. You support ARUP and pat them on the back when they agree with your beliefs, but doubt them when they don't.

What a joke!

I suppose you have the math to support WHY you doubt ARUP's conclusion regarding the initial beam coming off its seat right? OR is it just the fact that you believe more in your idiotic controlled demolitions theory?
 
ARUP then had a fatal error which proved it and the NIST report are false in the inability to break through the next floor down.

I also have my doubts that the girder would have been pulled off its seat but that is made moot by the fact that even if it did it could not cause a floor cascade and loss of lateral support for column 79. Therefore, it never buckles.

You don't even have a point when things are put in context.

I understand (though do not agree with) your contention re the conflict between the ARUP and NIST reports falsifying the NIST report, but I'm not sure if I've seen your contention re ARUP's model itself being in error. Care to elaborate or point me to where you have previously elaborated on that point?

I think you made a solid mechanical point as to the force it would take to collapse the lower floors via shearing, but I'm far less convinced that you have done the work necessary to understand all the ways in which the lower floors could have been weakened by the fires that could have altered the forces it would take to fail them.
 
Last edited:
ARUP then had a fatal error which proved it and the NIST report are false in the inability to break through the next floor down.

I also have my doubts that the girder would have been pulled off its seat but that is made moot by the fact that even if it did it could not cause a floor cascade and loss of lateral support for column 79. Therefore, it never buckles.

You don't even have a point when things are put in context.


At the point of interest, how long did fire rage out of control before WTC 7 collapsed?

During that time, were secondary explosions observed or heard from that location?

What happens when explosives are exposed to fire?

.
 
Last edited:
At the point of interest, how long did fire rage out of control before WTC 7 collapsed?

More important is what was the local damage to the structure.

Tony only use damage documented in the reports. This damage assessment has be criticized many times by fire professionals as being over conservative. In effect Tony takes the one element he wants to highlight and present it in it's best case for survival.

Realistically, there was likely local floor failure all day long. Why else would you think the FDNY wouldn't go in there. The saying "Don't trust the truss" isn't propaganda to debunk "truthers".
 
More important is what was the local damage to the structure.

Tony only use damage documented in the reports. This damage assessment has be criticized many times by fire professionals as being over conservative. In effect Tony takes the one element he wants to highlight and present it in it's best case for survival.

Realistically, there was likely local floor failure all day long. Why else would you think the FDNY wouldn't go in there. The saying "Don't trust the truss" isn't propaganda to debunk "truthers".


And after all of these years, there is not one shred of evidence that explosives were used during the 9/11 terrorist attack. Truthers don't seem to understand they were duped.
 
And after all of these years, there is not one shred of evidence that explosives were used during the 9/11 terrorist attack. Truthers don't seem to understand they were duped.
The sad part is they don't expect any factual proof. They expect perfection from the "official story" but , they don't care about any details that support their belief. They don't even care about promises made for investigations. The Basile study proves this.
 
That's nice Tony.

My point being that you and gerrycan INITIALLY argued that it was IMPOSSIBLE for the initial beam to have come off its seat AT ALL!

You claimed the NIST intentionally left out structural elements that would have prevented this!

ARUP added those IMPORTANT STRUCTUTRAL ELEMENTS the YOU claim the NIST intentionally left out and they STILL concluded that the initial beam came off its seat.

Are you now going to retract all of your previous statements that it was impossible for the initial beam to come off its seat? Do you agree with ARUP that the initial beam was pulled off its seat?

NIST said the girder flange failed when its web was pushed past its seat. That could not happen with the stiffeners on the girder, so it is pertinent to what NIST did. I do believe the stiffeners were left off intentionally to try and show the girder could fail by pushing it to the west. They could only push the girder about 5.5 inches due to beam expansion so they needed the flange to fail. That was probably why they initially claimed the girder seat was only 11" wide when the drawings said it was 12". They got away with that for over three years. The shop fabrication drawing for girder A2001 has never been released, but the girder to column assembly drawing was and it showed the seat width and stiffeners. They also ignored the girder being trapped behind the column 79 side plate after just 3" of lateral travel. I think that was intentional also. The NIST situation for single girder failure is impossible once all of the actual parameters are known and it is naïve to think the omissions, distortions, and ignoring of pertinent structural features wasn't intentional.

The ARUP situation was not constrained by beam expansion, as it pulls the girder back towards the beams due to their sagging and there is a slim possibility, with enough heat and load, that the girder could be pulled completely off its seat but not due to flange failure, which can't happen with the stiffeners. To pull it off the seat it would have to move the girder its entire 11.510 inch width plus the .245 inches on the side of the seat or 11.755 inches. This much shortening of the beams would require them to sag about 61 inches, which is extremely unlikely since it would require beam temperatures in excess of 800 degrees C.

I do not think the ARUP pull off happened either, but as I said, it is moot as the girder fall could not cause a floor collapse cascade which would be needed to cause column 79 to buckle.

Gamolon, it seems you are groping at straws to maintain some sort of desperate illusion that these reports actually describe what caused the collapse. What a shame.
 
Last edited:
NIST said the girder flange failed when its web was pushed past its seat. That could not happen with the stiffeners on the girder, so it is pertinent to what NIST did. I do believe the stiffeners were left off intentionally to try and show the girder could fail by pushing it to the west. They could only push the girder about 5.5 inches due to beam expansion so they needed the flange to fail. That was probably why they initially claimed the girder seat was only 11" wide when the drawings said it was 12". They got away with that for over three years. The shop fabrication drawing for girder A2001 has never been released, but the girder to column assembly drawing was and it showed the seat width and stiffeners. They also ignored the girder being trapped behind the column 79 side plate after just 3" of lateral travel. I think that was intentional also. The NIST situation for single girder failure is impossible once all of the actual parameters are known and it is naïve to think the omissions, distortions, and ignoring of pertinent structural features wasn't intentional.

The ARUP situation was not constrained by beam expansion, as it pulls the girder back towards the beams due to their sagging and there is a slim possibility, with enough heat and load, that the girder could be pulled completely off its seat but not due to flange failure, which can't happen with the stiffeners. To pull it off the seat it would have to move the girder its entire 11.510 inch width plus the .245 inches on the side of the seat or 11.755 inches. This much shortening of the beams would require them to sag about 61 inches, which is extremely unlikely since it would require beam temperatures in excess of 800 degrees C.

I do not think the ARUP pull off happened either, but as I said, it is moot as the girder fall could not cause a floor collapse cascade which would be needed to cause column 79 to buckle.

Gamolon, it seems you are groping at straws to maintain some sort of desperate illusion that these reports actually describe what caused the collapse. What a shame.

Even if you were right and NIST was wrong on some aspects of the collapse, you still have not falsified NIST base hypothesis that fires caused the collapse. Also the intensity of the fires on the girders are unknown and in knowable, because of the rapidly moving air currents in the building transporting fuel though the fire zones.
Temperatures of up to 1400c are a possibility.
 
NIST said the girder flange failed when its web was pushed past its seat. That could not happen with the stiffeners on the girder, so it is pertinent to what NIST did. I do believe the stiffeners were left off intentionally to try and show the girder could fail by pushing it to the west. They could only push the girder about 5.5 inches due to beam expansion so they needed the flange to fail. That was probably why they initially claimed the girder seat was only 11" wide when the drawings said it was 12". They got away with that for over three years. The shop fabrication drawing for girder A2001 has never been released, but the girder to column assembly drawing was and it showed the seat width and stiffeners. They also ignored the girder being trapped behind the column 79 side plate after just 3" of lateral travel. I think that was intentional also. The NIST situation for single girder failure is impossible once all of the actual parameters are known and it is naïve to think the omissions, distortions, and ignoring of pertinent structural features wasn't intentional.

The ARUP situation was not constrained by beam expansion, as it pulls the girder back towards the beams due to their sagging and there is a slim possibility, with enough heat and load, that the girder could be pulled completely off its seat but not due to flange failure, which can't happen with the stiffeners. To pull it off the seat it would have to move the girder its entire 11.510 inch width plus the .245 inches on the side of the seat or 11.755 inches. This much shortening of the beams would require them to sag about 61 inches, which is extremely unlikely since it would require beam temperatures in excess of 800 degrees C.

I do not think the ARUP pull off happened either, but as I said, it is moot as the girder fall could not cause a floor collapse cascade which would be needed to cause column 79 to buckle.
So frigging what? NIST elaborated a report to warn the engineering world of the deficiencies that led to the collapse. Their conclusion was that it was the result of unfought fires. Alternative explanations have been given by those who were not convinced by NIST's, enough of them as to satisfy all engineers except the politically motivated, which won't be satisfied unless the explanation matches their political prejudices.

NIST's report covers much more than just engineering, and even if the engineering parts of the report were wrong, there are still other reports that confirm that the collapse was caused by fire, enough to satisfy the non-politically motivated engineers that were not convinced by NIST's explanation.

The only engineers that remain dissatisfied are the ones with an agenda.
 
Last edited:
So frigging what? NIST elaborated a report to warn the engineering world of the deficiencies that led to the collapse. Their conclusion was that it was the result of unfought fires. Alternative explanations have been given by those who were not convinced by NIST's, enough of them as to satisfy all engineers except the politically motivated, which won't be satisfied unless the explanation matches their political prejudices.

NIST's report covers much more than just engineering, and even if the engineering parts of the report were wrong, there are still other reports that confirm that the collapse was caused by fire, enough to satisfy the non-politically motivated engineers that were not convinced by NIST's explanation.

The only engineers that remain dissatisfied are the ones with an agenda.

And/or profit motivation, Like Cole's membership in AE/911 stupid.

PS. Tony disqualified himself as an Engineering professional, when he publicly
Supported Cole's purposefully flawed experiments designed to deceave.
I suspect both Cole and Tony know why Cole's experiments are garbage science, but I will give Tony the benefit of the doubt, as a favor to a fellow forum member.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom