Tony Szamboti
Illuminator
- Joined
- Jun 2, 2007
- Messages
- 4,976
Can you share with us the actual model that shows this? Also, are you not also heating the entire girder?
In any case, you've now gone from, "the multifloor collapse is impossible" to "my limited model, which omits many key structural elements and a realistic fire simulation shows, the collapse could occur under certain conditions". This is big progress towards being honest about the limits of your own conclusions.
In my model the girder at the floor below is also heated and that affects its stiffness and the shock load amplification. The softer the material the less stiff and the lower the shock amplification. You need to remember that the falling beam and girder assembly has a static force of just 46,000 lbs. and the room temperature force required to shear the seat is 632,000 lbs. At 800 degrees C the force required is about 10% of that, so a shock amplification still occurs.
Of course, the problem is you can't get the seat anywhere near that hot. The lower stiffness of the girder also only needs to occur at 12 inches from the seat which is where the impact occurs.
I haven't gone from anything other than what I have been saying since looking into Nordenson's calculation about six months ago. I am saying the multi-floor collapse is impossible. You are well aware of that from the Metabunk.org thread from six months ago. It really isn't a complicated configuration for shearing of the seat and the calculations are what they are. Have someone else do it if you don't believe what I am saying.
Last edited: