Merged Hulsey presents research arguing WTC7 not brought down by fires/University of Alaska

In regard to WTC 7, what does the following account indicate?




Crystal-clear structural signs that WTC 7 was in danger of collapsing, which it eventually did.

I might add that I have annealed steel at a temperature at only 900 degrees F. in order to formed steel into complex shapes. In other words, ordinary office fires can weaken steel structures to the point of collapse, which has occurred on many occasions and the collapse of WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7, are among the prime examples.

Furthermore, there was no way that WTC 7, which was a steel-frame building, could have been properly prepared for explosive demolition in secret.

Conspiracy theorist who've claimed that CD explosives took out the WTC buildings do not understand what it takes to bring down a steel frame building with explosives.


.

The bulge, oh the bulge. It caused it, it had to cause it, because it was......the bulge.

What a joke it is to even consider that something like a bulge on one wall (that wasn't even enough to have been recorded) could take down a 610 foot tall building with a football field sized floor plan. WTC 7 was over 300 feet long on one side and 250 feet long on the other and 144 foot wide and it is silly on its face to think it could have caused the complete collapse of the building.
 
Last edited:
The bulge, oh the bulge. It caused it, it had to cause it, because it was......the bulge.

What a joke it is to even consider that something like a bulge on one wall (that wasn't even enough to have been recorded) could take down a 610 foot tall building with a football field sized floor plan. WTC 7 was over 300 feet long on one side and 250 feet long on the other and 144 foot wide and it is silly on its face to think it could have caused the complete collapse of the building.


Wrong answer!!

You were set up and if you were a knowledgeable structural engineer, you would have known EXACTLY what I was getting at.

To sum it up, you've failed the test.
 
I don't think you are qualified to be giving tests.


As a retired aircraft structural supervisor, inspector, and technician, I know what I am talking about.

Just to let you know that I am knowledgeable on the process on what it takes to bring down a steel frame building with explosives. Anyone who claims that explosives brought down WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7, simply do not know what they are talking about because they do not understand the preparation process required to bring down a steel frame building with explosives. I might add that explosives make a lot of noise, which is not evident on audio in any WTC collapse video

Have you ever wondered why a massive bomb failed to bring down WTC 1 in 1993?
 
Last edited:
No, they did not come to the same result. ARUP's analysis showed the girder connections to column 79 don't break. So nothing is actually going to happen.



Wow, what a reach. Your problem is even if the temperature of the girder seat was 500 degrees C the factor of safety against it being broken is still about 2. The columns would have never gotten hotter than 300 degrees C, so 500 degrees is being generous. What you want to believe happened was impossible and simply could not have happened.

Nice magical girder, one question Tony in which direction does heat and soot travel up or down?

The hottest fires have no flames.

A chimney effect in the building would have burned as hot as an air curtain.
Air Curtain Burning: http://youtu.be/cHrWcwUyt2s

You don't know what your posting about Tony.
 
The NIST WTC 7 report has been shown to be untenable and the investigation needs to be redone.

The speculation that other fire damage could have somehow caused something the initial investigation did not consider is something a new investigation can pursue based on the evidence and transparent viable science.

I have shown that significant heating of the girder seat of the floor below would not have caused a failure.

The reports are demonstrably wrong and a new investigation is warranted. It is that straightforward and anybody who says otherwise is really flirting with being accused of having an agenda to prevent justice for some reason.

So why not consider such fire damage in your model? You are pointing the finger at everyone else and alleging they did an insufficient job, all while knowingly basing those allegations on your own insufficient model.
 
Be quiet everyone. Two, or is it three now, professional engineering groups have deduced that fire damage initiated a progressive collapse but they are all wrong. Tony Szamboti, one by one, has destroyed the credibility and reputation of these groups.
 
Last edited:
So why not consider such fire damage in your model? You are pointing the finger at everyone else and alleging they did an insufficient job, all while knowingly basing those allegations on your own insufficient model.

I already explained that I heated the girder seat on the floor below, but for some reason you seem to think there is more to be considered.

The onus is on you to be specific as to just what fire damage you think is pertinent and why.
 
Last edited:
I already explained that I heated the girder seat on the floor below, but for some reason you seem to think there is more to be considered.

The onus is on you to be specific as to just what fire damage you think is pertinent and why.

There is more to be considered how about dirrect heating of the girder too 1400C by combustion of gases and soot on the girder itself?

If you had done actual fire testing you would understand that is a dirrect possibility.
 
The NIST WTC 7 report has been shown to be untenable and the investigation needs to be redone.

The speculation that other fire damage could have somehow caused something the initial investigation did not consider is something a new investigation can pursue based on the evidence and transparent viable science.

I have shown that significant heating of the girder seat of the floor below would not have caused a failure. (lol, yea right)

The reports are demonstrably wrong and a new investigation is warranted. It is that straightforward and anybody who says otherwise is really flirting with being accused of having an agenda to prevent justice for some reason.


You can't even say who is going to do this investigation. Why don't you and your con man buddy go for it? One too many vacations on the dime of the mentally unstable? Can't afford it?

Do it. What's stopping you?
 
Apparently Tony hasn't read, the 2012 letter from RJ Lee, or the EPA reports that show why Johnathan Cole, and his nonsense are fallacy.
Do you want me to post them for you Tony, all this time and you have no understanding of fire chemistry.
Do you still believe that Plaster of Parish dust will smoother fires Tony, because I have proof it doesn't.
 
I already explained that I heated the girder seat on the floor below, but for some reason you seem to think there is more to be considered.

The onus is on you to be specific as to just what fire damage you think is pertinent and why.

Ok, then why don't you let us know at what temperature that girder on the lower floor will fail upon or after the impact of the upper floor according to your model?
 
Last edited:
The NIST WTC 7 report has been shown to be untenable and the investigation needs to be redone.

The speculation that other fire damage could have somehow caused something the initial investigation did not consider is something a new investigation can pursue based on the evidence and transparent viable science.

I have shown that significant heating of the girder seat of the floor below would not have caused a failure.

The reports are demonstrably wrong and a new investigation is warranted. It is that straightforward and anybody who says otherwise is really flirting with being accused of having an agenda to prevent justice for some reason.
Nuts




And now a word from our sponsors.
 
Ok, then why don't you let us know at what temperature that girder on the lower floor will fail upon or after the impact of the upper floor according to your model?

The girder seat at the floor below needs to be at a temperature of about 800 degrees C before the falling upper floor section could shear it.

I would hope you realize how impossible this is, as the seat is welded to the column, which in the fire simulations does not get beyond 300 degrees C.

I know many here are stunned, like piranhas hit with electric current in water, that the girder on the floor below cannot be broken loose by the falling upper floor section. Regardless of their desire not to believe this, it is the reality of the situation. It can easily be shown that there is far from enough force generated by the impact to cause it, at the temperatures shown in the fire simulations. Additionally, the extreme temperatures required by the seat below, to weaken it enough to allow it to happen, are far outside the realm of possibilities.

The floor cascades due to a falling girder alleged in the NIST and ARUP reports are simply not possible and these reports are both falsified by this situation.
 
Last edited:
The girder seat at the floor below needs to be at a temperature of about 800 degrees C before the falling upper floor section could shear it.

I would hope you realize how impossible this is, as the seat is welded to the column, which in the fire simulations does not get beyond 300 degrees C.

I know many here are stunned, like piranhas hit with electric current in water, that the girder on the floor below cannot be broken loose by the falling upper floor section. Regardless of their desire not to believe this, it is the reality of the situation. It can easily be shown that there is far from enough force generated by the impact to cause it, at the temperatures shown in the fire simulations. Additionally, the extreme temperatures required by the seat below, to weaken it enough to allow it to happen, are far outside the realm of possibilities.

The floor cascades due to a falling girder alleged in the NIST and ARUP reports are simply not possible and these reports are both falsified by this situation.

BS. If it is a welded seat, that makes it significantly weaker than the parent material, at room temperature and heating leads to reduced weld sheer and more deformation not less.
What's the sheer strength you are using for the weld, in foot per inch?
Can you back up your claim?
 
The girder seat at the floor below needs to be at a temperature of about 800 degrees C before the falling upper floor section could shear it.

I would hope you realize how impossible this is, as the seat is welded to the column, which in the fire simulations does not get beyond 300 degrees C.

I know many here are stunned, like piranhas hit with electric current in water, that the girder on the floor below cannot be broken loose by the falling upper floor section. Regardless of their desire not to believe this, it is the reality of the situation. It can easily be shown that there is far from enough force generated by the impact to cause it, at the temperatures shown in the fire simulations. Additionally, the extreme temperatures required by the seat below, to weaken it enough to allow it to happen, are far outside the realm of possibilities.

The floor cascades due to a falling girder alleged in the NIST and ARUP reports are simply not possible and these reports are both falsified by this situation.
Can you share with us the actual model that shows this? Also, are you not also heating the entire girder?

In any case, you've now gone from, "the multifloor collapse is impossible" to "my limited model, which omits many key structural elements and a realistic fire simulation shows, the collapse could occur under certain conditions". This is big progress towards being honest about the limits of your own conclusions.
 
Last edited:
BS. If it is a welded seat, that makes it significantly weaker than the parent material, at room temperature and heating leads to reduced weld sheer and more deformation not less.
What's the sheer strength you are using for the weld, in foot per inch?
Can you back up your claim?

The welds are 3/8" fillets on both sides of the 14 inch deep x 2 inch thick support plate (under the seat to the column) and the top of the seat to the outside of the column flange.

The weld material is E70.

See Frankel Steel drawing #9114.

The force required to shear the seat at room temperature, per Nordenson, is 632,000 lbs. and my calculation shows the same. If you disagree show your work.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom