Merged Hulsey presents research arguing WTC7 not brought down by fires/University of Alaska

No, the walk-off to the west of the NIST WTC 7 report is refuted by ARUP. It wouldn't matter what the temperature got to, the girder could not get past the column side plate. The NIST WTC 7 report just ignored the side plate in their analysis and didn't mention it.

So ARUP used a diferant temperature and mechanism and came to the same result?

ARUP's analysis works until the Nordenson error using a point load with infinite stiffness for the load of the falling girder onto the girder below, where with the actual stiffness calculated it can be shown that a falling girder and floor assembly cannot shear the girder seat on the next floor down.

You know what this means? The structure the girder impacted was not in as-built strength. Maybe it was damaged by fire. I know how you like to take everything in isolation so I doubt you will consider this.

ARUP's analysis also shows the knife connections of the south and west girders don't break. Colaco's attempt to say the connections did not meet code doesn't say they would break nor does the fracture mechanics analysis in Nordenson, as there aren't any fatigue cycles to propagate the stress raiser into a crack that would matter.

Thus when their analysis is looked at critically one has to say that ARUP does not present a scenario where collapse would occur.

What did they say when you brought this to their attention?
 
Last edited:
So ARUP used a diferant temperature and mechanism and came to the same result?

No, they did not come to the same result. ARUP's analysis showed the girder connections to column 79 don't break. So nothing is actually going to happen.

You know what this means? The structure the girder impacted was not in as-built strength. Maybe it was damaged by fire. I know how you like to take everything in isolation so I doubt you will consider this.

Wow, what a reach. Your problem is even if the temperature of the girder seat was 500 degrees C the factor of safety against it being broken is still about 2. The columns would have never gotten hotter than 300 degrees C, so 500 degrees is being generous. What you want to believe happened was impossible and simply could not have happened.
 
Last edited:
Where then Tony did Arup find the data on the damage to the building including column and stiffeners induced by the debris wave from the tower impacting 7?
Or did they use an undamaged building model?

How would the northeast corner of WTC 7, where NIST and ARUP allege the initiating failure occurred, have been affected by twin tower debris?

Do you realize it was the south side of WTC 7 that faced the Twin Towers?
 
Last edited:
Let me get this straight Tony.

The NIST states that the beam walked off it's seat due to thermal expansion, where the beam was PUSHED off said seat. You and gerrycan claim that NIST purposely left out certain structural elements and fudged numbers to get this favorable scenario which would support a government concocted fantasy collapse due to fires, all to cover up a government conspiracy that involved controlled demolitions.

Now you're saying that you AGREE with ARUP that it's feasible that the beam DID come ff it's seat, just not the way NIST says it did.

So in essence, NIST and ARUP agree that the beam came off it's seat and you agree with both of them regarding this conclusion, but what you DON'T agree with is HOW the NIST says it happened. Do I understand this correctly Tony?

What are the odds that NIST got the conclusion right, that the beam walked off it's seat, even when they fudged numbers and deliberately left out structural elements to support a conspiracy? Astonishing isn't it?

What about all your and gerrycan's blustering regarding key structural elements being deliberately left out and that if those elements would have been properly included, the beam would NOT have walked off its seat? ARUP included these in THEIR analysis right Tony? They concluded that the beam still came off its seat right?

So where does your witch hunt stand now? Have you moved away from the beam not coming off its seat and are focused on the beam stiffness and impact with the floor below error? Are you going after ARUP and Nordenson and accusing them of fudging their numbers like you have done with the NIST? Are they part of the conspiracy too Tony?

Do you give NIST a pass?

I think whoever did the NIST analysis was being deceptive because what they were trying to say happened was impossible.

At the end of ARUP's analysis they run into an impossibility also. That is that the falling girder cannot break the girder seat on the next floor down.

Bottom line is that there is no analysis that can show that column 79 could have lost enough lateral support to buckle and initiate the collapse.
 
No, they did not come to the same result. ARUP's analysis showed the girder connections to column 79 don't break. So nothing is actually going to happen.

Did they not show it failed?

Wow, what a reach. Your problem is even if the temperature of the girder seat was 500 degrees C the factor of safety against it being broken is still about 2. The columns would have never gotten hotter than 300 degrees C, so 500 degrees is being generous. What you want to believe happened was impossible and simply could not have happened.

Show your analysis.
 
Did they not show it failed?



Show your analysis.

You know Nordenson had a serious error using an infinite stiffness point load for the falling girder.

The girder seat required a shear load of 632,000 lbs. and at 500 degrees C steel retains about 70% of its strength which would put the failure load at 442,400 lbs.

My analysis (which you have seen on metabunk.org and at the 911 free forum recently) shows the impact load wouldn't be more than 215,000 lbs. from the 46,000 lb. static load.

Both of the above are being very conservative and the factor of safety is more than 2.

There is no chance for the falling girder to break the girder seat on the next floor down.
 
Last edited:
You know Nordenson had a serious error using an infinite stiffness point load for the falling girder.

The girder seat required a shear load of 632,000 lbs. and at 500 degrees C steel retains about 70% of its strength which would put the failure load at 442,400 lbs.

My analysis (which you have seen on metabunk.org and at the 911 free forum recently) shows the impact load wouldn't be more than 215,000 lbs. from the 46,000 lb. static load.

Both of the above are being very conservative and the factor of safety is more than 2.

There is no chance for the falling girder to break the girder seat on the next floor down.
Where is your temperature analysis?


You need to produce a full report so all of your assumptions can be reviewed. How else can we judge your opinion on the same level as the NIST or ARUP?

Agree?
 
Where is your temperature analysis?


You need to produce a full report so all of your assumptions can be reviewed. How else can we judge your opinion on the same level as the NIST or ARUP?

Agree?

You can't counter me, so you want to filibuster by saying I can't say anything without producing a fire simulation and a 1,000 page report.

I used the steel temperatures which were in the NIST and ARUP reports and I did an FEA to determine the stiffness of the beam and girder assembly and then did the hand calculations showing the girder deflection and the force it would apply in an impact with the potential energy all transformed to kinetic energy. It is valid and you can't argue against it.

I would think you would be embarrassed to say what you are here as it is obvious that this kind of desperate talk just shows you can't argue against what I am saying.
 
Last edited:
You can't counter me, so you want to filibuster .......................


Counter you on what? You have not produced a report supporting your theory.

You pick at everyone elses hoping your belief somehow sticks. Are you hoping someone will pick it up and actually do something?
 
Tony:

There's a bottom line here. Every "official story" has produced a detailed report so you can find some detail to pick at. Why do you think your "theory" should not be subject to the same scrutiny?
 
”You need to produce a full report so all of your assumptions can be reviewed.

How else can we judge your opinion on the same level as the NIST or ARUP? “

The NIST had WTC7 under engineering analysis for a lot of years before they submitted their final engineering hypothesis.

If the ARUP finding shows that the foundation of the NIST’s hypothesis (column 79’s failure mechanism) is insupportable, they are in serious disagreement.
 
The NIST had WTC7 under engineering analysis for a lot of years before they submitted their final engineering hypothesis.

If the ARUP finding shows that the foundation of the NIST’s hypothesis (column 79’s failure mechanism) is insupportable, they are in serious disagreement.
So? Two respected engineering groups came up with the same result but with different methods.

Is there an alternative that represents the same rigor?
 
Do you give NIST a pass?

I think whoever did the NIST analysis was being deceptive because what they were trying to say happened was impossible.

At the end of ARUP's analysis they run into an impossibility also. That is that the falling girder cannot break the girder seat on the next floor down.

Bottom line is that there is no analysis that can show that column 79 could have lost enough lateral support to buckle and initiate the collapse.
Tony,

I'll make this simple for you. Gerrycan had the same issue and played the same games.

Did ARUP arrive at the same conclusion that the beam at column 79 came off its seat?

Yes or no.

I find it quite funny that both you and gerrycan try like hell to run circles around the question I am asking. I'm not asking you about the cascading floors failures AFTER the initial beam coming off the seat at column 79. I am asking you about the initial beam coming of its seat at column 79.

Here is ARUP's conclusion:


According to that screenshot, does ARUP conclude that the beam comes of its seat at column 79 for cases 1 and 3?

YES or NO?

I look forward to more of your dodging the actual question.
 
You know Nordenson had a serious error using an infinite stiffness point load for the falling girder.

So ARUP and Nordensen made "errors", but the NIST was "deliberately fudging things to cover up a conspiracy involving controlled demolitions"?

:rolleyes:
 
No, they did not come to the same result. ARUP's analysis showed the girder connections to column 79 don't break.

They did? Can you explain ARUP's conclusion in the screenshot below? What exactly does the sentence "girder 79-44 being pulled off its seat at column 79" mean Tony? Are you saying this actually means that the connection at 79 held?!

:rolleyes:

 
You can't counter me, so you want to filibuster by saying I can't say anything without producing a fire simulation and a 1,000 page report.

I used the steel temperatures which were in the NIST and ARUP reports and I did an FEA to determine the stiffness of the beam and girder assembly and then did the hand calculations showing the girder deflection and the force it would apply in an impact with the potential energy all transformed to kinetic energy. It is valid and you can't argue against it.

I would think you would be embarrassed to say what you are here as it is obvious that this kind of desperate talk just shows you can't argue against what I am saying.

Do you believe it is possible that a multistory fire hot enough to cause the collapse of one floor could also have damaged the floor immediately below the collapsing floor? Did you factor this possibility into this mysterious "model" you purport to have created?
 
Last edited:
Bottom line is that there is no analysis that can show that column 79 could have lost enough lateral support to buckle and initiate the collapse.


In regard to WTC 7, what does the following account indicate?

The WTC 7 Bulge

During the afternoon, fire was also seen on floors 6–10, 13–14, 19–22, and 29–30.[38] In particular, the fires on floors 7 through 9 and 11 through 13 continued to burn out of control during the afternoon.

At approximately 2:00 pm, firefighters noticed a bulge in the southwest corner of 7 World Trade Center between the 10th and 13th floors, a sign that the building was unstable and might collapse.

http://www.firehouse.com/article/10567885/deputy-chief-peter-hayden


During the afternoon, firefighters also heard creaking sounds coming from the building.

http://www.firehouse.com/article/10568001/captain-chris-boyle


Crystal-clear structural signs that WTC 7 was in danger of collapsing, which it eventually did.

I might add that I have annealed steel at a temperature at only 900 degrees F. in order to formed steel into complex shapes. In other words, ordinary office fires can weaken steel structures to the point of collapse, which has occurred on many occasions and the collapse of WTC 1, WTC 2, and WTC 7, are among the prime examples.

Furthermore, there was no way that WTC 7, which was a steel-frame building, could have been properly prepared for explosive demolition in secret.

Conspiracy theorist who've claimed that CD explosives took out the WTC buildings do not understand what it takes to bring down a steel frame building with explosives.


.
 
Last edited:
Considering the lower floor column 79 location in question, it would seem impossible that any WTC1 debris could have gouged that deep without immediately toppling the building.

To suggest that any arriving dust could inflict major structural steel damage would be absurd.

What would have been the airspeed, against the facade?
You don't know do you?
 
The NIST had WTC7 under engineering analysis for a lot of years before they submitted their final engineering hypothesis.

If the ARUP finding shows that the foundation of the NIST’s hypothesis (column 79’s failure mechanism) is insupportable, they are in serious disagreement over a detail.

Fixed that for you.
 
Do you believe it is possible that a multistory fire hot enough to cause the collapse of one floor could also have damaged the floor immediately below the collapsing floor? Did you factor this possibility into this mysterious "model" you purport to have created?

The NIST WTC 7 report has been shown to be untenable and the investigation needs to be redone.

The speculation that other fire damage could have somehow caused something the initial investigation did not consider is something a new investigation can pursue based on the evidence and transparent viable science.

I have shown that significant heating of the girder seat of the floor below would not have caused a failure.

The reports are demonstrably wrong and a new investigation is warranted. It is that straightforward and anybody who says otherwise is really flirting with being accused of having an agenda to prevent justice for some reason.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom