DGM
Skeptic not Atheist
No, the walk-off to the west of the NIST WTC 7 report is refuted by ARUP. It wouldn't matter what the temperature got to, the girder could not get past the column side plate. The NIST WTC 7 report just ignored the side plate in their analysis and didn't mention it.
So ARUP used a diferant temperature and mechanism and came to the same result?
ARUP's analysis works until the Nordenson error using a point load with infinite stiffness for the load of the falling girder onto the girder below, where with the actual stiffness calculated it can be shown that a falling girder and floor assembly cannot shear the girder seat on the next floor down.
You know what this means? The structure the girder impacted was not in as-built strength. Maybe it was damaged by fire. I know how you like to take everything in isolation so I doubt you will consider this.
ARUP's analysis also shows the knife connections of the south and west girders don't break. Colaco's attempt to say the connections did not meet code doesn't say they would break nor does the fracture mechanics analysis in Nordenson, as there aren't any fatigue cycles to propagate the stress raiser into a crack that would matter.
Thus when their analysis is looked at critically one has to say that ARUP does not present a scenario where collapse would occur.
What did they say when you brought this to their attention?
Last edited:
