Merged Hulsey presents research arguing WTC7 not brought down by fires/University of Alaska

1) No model or any other calculating tool can prove the negative "...that Building 7 couldn't be brought down by fires alone...".

Disclaimer: I am not an expert. I have no credibility. What I think does not matter.

That being said, here is something to think about.

What is the WTC7 project's purpose? Are they trying to prove that fire can't bring down a building, or are they trying to prove that the NIST report can't possibly be accurate? Is there a difference between the two? If so, what is it? Do you need to have any level of expertise to see this?

I would share my opinion, but it doesn't matter. What matters is that you stop listening to what other people tell you to think, and then start asking relevant questions.
 
This has got to be my favorite red herring "truthers" use to try to "prove" the NIST is hiding something.

Fact is, any competent engineering firm could use the information contained in the NIST reports to duplicate the results to within reasonable accuracy.

"Truthers" showed no reasonable reason for wanting the data inputs. Has there be any complaint about this from any engineering school or respected engineering firm? This is another example where "truthers" reputation bit them in the arse.

Actually when ARUP (a competent engineering firm) used the WTC 7 drawings and air temperatures of 700 and 800 degrees C for an hour they refuted the NIST WTC 7 analysis in the sense that a girder walk-off to the west was impossible due to the thermally expanded girder getting trapped behind the column 79 side plate after just 3 inches of lateral travel.

Their model also had the girder stiffeners included, which you could not get from the NIST report as they were left out of the analysis without it being admitted.
 
Last edited:
Actually when ARUP (a competent engineering firm) used the WTC 7 drawings and air temperatures of 700 and 800 degrees C for an hour they refuted the NIST WTC 7 analysis in the sense that a girder walk-off to the west was impossible due to the thermally expanded girder getting trapped behind the column 79 side plate after just 3 inches of lateral travel.

Their model also had the girder stiffeners included, which you could not get from the NIST report as they were left out of the analysis without it being admitted.
They also concluded that with a little more temperature the result would be duplicated. True?

Do you deny ARUP also presents a scenario where collapse would occur?
 
Last edited:
They also concluded that with a little more temperature the result would be duplicated. True?

No, the walk-off to the west of the NIST WTC 7 report is refuted by ARUP. It wouldn't matter what the temperature got to, the girder could not get past the column side plate. The NIST WTC 7 report just ignored the side plate in their analysis and didn't mention it.

Do you deny ARUP also presents a scenario where collapse would occur?


ARUP's analysis works until the Nordenson error using a point load with infinite stiffness for the load of the falling girder onto the girder below, where with the actual stiffness calculated it can be shown that a falling girder and floor assembly cannot shear the girder seat on the next floor down.

ARUP's analysis also shows the knife connections of the south and west girders don't break. Colaco's attempt to say the connections did not meet code doesn't say they would break nor does the fracture mechanics analysis in Nordenson, as there aren't any fatigue cycles to propagate the stress raiser into a crack that would matter.

Thus when their analysis is looked at critically one has to say that ARUP does not present a scenario where collapse would occur.
 
Last edited:
No, the walk-off to the west of the NIST
ARUP's analysis works until the Nordenson error using a point load with infinite stiffness for the load of the falling girder onto the girder below, where with the actual stiffness calculated it can be shown that a falling girder and floor assembly cannot shear the girder seat on the next floor down.

ARUP's analysis also shows the knife connections of the south and west girders don't break. Colaco's attempt to say the connections did not meet code doesn't say they would break nor does the fracture mechanics analysis in Nordenson, as there aren't any fatigue cycles to propagate the stress raiser into a crack that would matter.


What can you tell us about the internal structural failure of WTC 5 due to fire?


WTC 5 Structural Failure

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/34/WTC5-column-trees.jpg


Thus when their analysis is looked at critically one has to say that ARUP does not present a scenario where collapse would occur.


Then it is evident that ARUP is not doing it's homework properly.
 
Last edited:
What can you tell us about the internal structural failure of WTC 5 due to fire?
I can't answer your question, but I can certainly ask a few more.

Can skyeagle409 please show us where all of the pulverized concrete is? Can skyeagle409 please show us failures across the entire floor, and not just localized sections? I have lots more questions, but try to answer those two first.
 
I can't answer your question, but I can certainly ask a few more.

Can skyeagle409 please show us where all of the pulverized concrete is?


Right there in the general location where the WTC Towers collapsed, which is evident in the following photo, and note that debris and dust plumes are outpacing the collapse of the WTC Tower, which effectively debunks the 9/11 conspiracy claim that the WTC Towers collapsed at free fall or near-free fall speed.


WTC Tower Collapse Photo

http://www.911myths.com/assets/images/Collapse.jpg


Can skyeagle409 please show us failures across the entire floor, and not just localized sections?


Yes!

Notice the compressed air squib in the following photo as the WTC Tower collapses, which is an indication that the floors are falling upon one another, or should I say, it's a clear indication of a pancake collapse.


Squib of Compressed Air

http://911research.wtc7.net/wtc/evidence/photos/docs/tower2_exp1.jpg
 
Last edited:
No, the walk-off to the west of the NIST WTC 7 report is refuted by ARUP. It wouldn't matter what the temperature got to, the girder could not get past the column side plate. The NIST WTC 7 report just ignored the side plate in their analysis and didn't mention it.




ARUP's analysis works until the Nordenson error using a point load with infinite stiffness for the load of the falling girder onto the girder below, where with the actual stiffness calculated it can be shown that a falling girder and floor assembly cannot shear the girder seat on the next floor down.

ARUP's analysis also shows the knife connections of the south and west girders don't break. Colaco's attempt to say the connections did not meet code doesn't say they would break nor does the fracture mechanics analysis in Nordenson, as there aren't any fatigue cycles to propagate the stress raiser into a crack that would matter.

Thus when their analysis is looked at critically one has to say that ARUP does not present a scenario where collapse would occur.

Where then Tony did Arup find the data on the damage to the building including column and stiffeners induced by the debris wave from the tower impacting 7?
Or did they use an undamaged building model?
 
No; because Gage and Hulsey announced that's what the results would be at the same time that they announced the study. :rolleyes:

Proof?
Page 1:
AE911Truth said:
This Is a Turning Point
We at AE911Truth believe the UAF study will be a turning point in how the destruction of WTC 7 is viewed — both within the engineering community and by the general public.
Not only will the UAF study add credible, cutting-edge research to the existing body of evidence and analysis regarding the destruction of WTC 7, it will also generate an unprecedented level of awareness and willingness to look seriously at how this building was destroyed.
 
ARUP's analysis works until the Nordenson error using a point load with infinite stiffness for the load of the falling girder onto the girder below,

Let me get this straight Tony.

The NIST states that the beam walked off it's seat due to thermal expansion, where the beam was PUSHED off said seat. You and gerrycan claim that NIST purposely left out certain structural elements and fudged numbers to get this favorable scenario which would support a government concocted fantasy collapse due to fires, all to cover up a government conspiracy that involved controlled demolitions.

Now you're saying that you AGREE with ARUP that it's feasible that the beam DID come ff it's seat, just not the way NIST says it did.

So in essence, NIST and ARUP agree that the beam came off it's seat and you agree with both of them regarding this conclusion, but what you DON'T agree with is HOW the NIST says it happened. Do I understand this correctly Tony?

What are the odds that NIST got the conclusion right, that the beam walked off it's seat, even when they fudged numbers and deliberately left out structural elements to support a conspiracy? Astonishing isn't it?

What about all your and gerrycan's blustering regarding key structural elements being deliberately left out and that if those elements would have been properly included, the beam would NOT have walked off its seat? ARUP included these in THEIR analysis right Tony? They concluded that the beam still came off its seat right?

So where does your witch hunt stand now? Have you moved away from the beam not coming off its seat and are focused on the beam stiffness and impact with the floor below error? Are you going after ARUP and Nordenson and accusing them of fudging their numbers like you have done with the NIST? Are they part of the conspiracy too Tony?
 
Last edited:
Assuming the beam could come off its seat... the issue then becomes how does this lead to the "failure" of column 79.... the collapse of the EPH and the undoing of the rest of the interior structure. Would a single girder removed from column 79 begin the process of progressive total collapse? Perhaps yes... but let's see how this would happen!
 
Assuming the beam could come off its seat...
Will Tony go after ARUP and Nordensen now and accuse them of fudging numbers and being part of the conspiracy just like he has done with NIST?

I mean ARUP and NIST both agree on the conclusion that the beam came off its seat due to the results of office fires.

the issue then becomes how does this lead to the "failure" of column 79.... the collapse of the EPH and the undoing of the rest of the interior structure. Would a single girder removed from column 79 begin the process of progressive total collapse? Perhaps yes... but let's see how this would happen!
Agreed.

So Tony and gerrycan have moved away from claiming that it's impossible for the beam to have come off its seat due to fire and now are focused on the beam falling and impacting the floor below? That's my impression anyways.
 
”Where then Tony did ARUP find the data on the damage to the building, including column and stiffeners, induced by the debris wave from the tower impacting WTC7?”

Considering the lower floor column 79 location in question, it would seem impossible that any WTC1 debris could have gouged that deep without immediately toppling the building.

To suggest that any arriving dust could inflict major structural steel damage would be absurd.
 
Last edited:
Considering the lower floor column 79 location in question, it would seem impossible that any WTC1 debris could have gouged that deep without immediately toppling the building.


That doesn't make any sense considering that WTC 1 and WTC 2 did not topple over when they were struck by B-767's.
 
Where then Tony did Arup find the data on the damage to the building including column and stiffeners induced by the debris wave from the tower impacting 7?
Or did they use an undamaged building model?

Considering the lower floor column 79 location in question, it would seem impossible that any WTC1 debris could have gouged that deep without immediately toppling the building.

To suggest that any arriving dust could inflict major structural steel damage would be absurd.

Are you suggesting that the entire SW corner did not get gouged out by "arriving dust" from WTC1? Perhaps you just consider that to be minor damage.

BTW, I am curious, where has ANYONE ever stated that the "arriving dust" caused structural damage as deeply as to reach column 79?
 
Last edited:
Considering the lower floor column 79 location in question, it would seem impossible that any WTC1 debris could have gouged that deep without immediately toppling the building.

To suggest that any arriving dust could inflict major structural steel damage would be absurd.

That's illogical... two jets slammed into the twins and they stood... and had serious structural damage... But it was the heat and its effects which led to the progressive collapse... and once the tops' mass was falling the collapse then was completely gravity driven and the mass mechanically destroyed the framed integrity.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom