The other day, I had started to scan the video, by looking at short snippets and jumping ahead in steps of 1 minute. I was looking for something (forgot what), and stopped shortly before the 19 minutes mark when I was distracted by a bit of real life.
So today, I am starting to watch at just before 19:00 - and the "whoa" moments come flying fast:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_7IVCSpalbA&t=19m
1.) 19:01 min: Slide reads:
"NIST, 2004 - Outside the selected area, commcetion failure were not modeled (used as Fix or Pin). Connections were not modeled in the exterior moment frame"
He is somehow bemoaning the fact that the Chapter 11 model (ANSYS, 16 floors) only has the east floors in much detail, and considers the west part as rigid.
Why does he quote from the 2004 draft??? The final (2008) version of NCSTAR 1-9 provides reasons for that engineering choice (page 475):
"Outside the selected area, structural damage–such as buckling of the steel frame and crushing and cracking of the concrete slab–was modeled over the entire floor, but connection failures were not modeled. The extent of the area with detailed connection models was based on the results of single floor fire simulations, where connection damage west of Columns 73 through 76 were not found to contribute to an initial failure event on the east side of the structure. The area where break elements were modeled was selected to reduce the model size without biasing the results for simulating the initial failure event.
Framing connections outside of the selected area, or on other floors not subjected to fire, were modeled as either fixed or pinned, using typical modeling approaches. Connections were not modeled in the exterior moment frame, as no failures were observed there prior to the onset of global collapse. Column splices were also not modeled for interior columns, as the purpose of the ANSYS model was to accumulate local failures up to the point of buckling in a column. When column buckling appeared to be imminent, the analyses were continued in the LS-DYNA 47 story model."
He doesn't really explain why he brings up that issue.
We'll return to it in a minute!
2.) 19:16: Slide reads (bolding by Hulsey):
NIST NCSTAR 1-9 Page 525 [this is an error; actually page 527; Oy], 2008
"A girder was considered to have lost vertical support when its web was no longer supported by the bearing seat. The bearing seat at Column 79 was 11 in. wide. Thus, when the girder end at Column 79 had been pushed laterally at least 5.5 in., it was no longer supported by the bearing seat."
This very sentence, specifically the numbers "11 in." and "5.5 in.", have been identified as a mere typo by NIST in the Errata, January 2009. The actual model used the correct numbers (12 and 6.25, respectively)
It can be no coincidence that Hulsey quotes this of all passages, but not the correction. It has to be a deliberate misrepresentation?!
3.) 19:45: He now jumps to the dynamic collapse model (Chapter 12, 47-story LS-DYNA)
without saying so.
He shows next to each other a video of the collapsing building and a Chapter 12 animation by NIST of the same. The caption reads:
"There is no connection modeled in outside frame, and it will enhance the rigidity of outside frame. Which makes the comparison similar."
This is not a quote from NIST, it's bad English, and
it's FALSE: Of course the full 47-story LS-DYNA model included all connections, including outside frames (Chapter 12.2.3 has details).
4.) At 20:05, he runs the collapse video and the NIST animation alongside one another and points out, (fairly - if he uses the correct animation, which I haven't checked), that they don't look very much the same.
Then, after 20:23, he provides an explanation: The slide shows a snippet from a floor of the 16-floor ANSYS model (Chapter 11) next to an image of the full 47-story LS-DYNA model (Chapter 12), and a caption:
"Outside the selected area [east of col. 76 in ANSYS] connection failures were not modeled; separated progressive collapse into two part"
Oh my goodness!
They are conflating the properties and boundary conditions of two separate models! The Hulsey team failed at reading and understanding the NIST-report!!
Hulsey speaks (20:30):
"The left [east in the ANSYS model] side is where the springs are [i.e. non-pinned connections], the right side is where the springs are not, and if that building began to fail, the left side went down faster than the right side ... which means that their model was not accurate."
Moron. It means
Hulsey doesn't understand what NIST did.
With this, there is no need to watch any further.