Merged Hulsey presents research arguing WTC7 not brought down by fires/University of Alaska

That's not necessarily true. The conclusion does not follow from results as we know. ;)

No, per Oystein's post.

ETA: and Oz' follow up.
Thanks LSSBB - and a partial apology/explanation for DGM.

DGM I wasn't ignoring your comment which is correct at the level of debate you are addressing. Your point is moot at the more fundamental level of false argument I have been identifying.

In the metaphoric language of your (DGM's) sig:
1) It is "not necessarily true" because, at this stage, all the trees in the forest may not have been identified. There could well be more "trees" in that wrong forest. AKA in - plain English - there could be more "results" not yet known but they will be in Hulsey's wrong setting.
BUT
2) Pgimeno, Oystein and I in varying "styles" are saying "Hulsey is in the wrong forest" there is "no point discusing his description of one or more specific trees" which are in the wrong forest.
 
The other day, I had started to scan the video, by looking at short snippets and jumping ahead in steps of 1 minute. I was looking for something (forgot what), and stopped shortly before the 19 minutes mark when I was distracted by a bit of real life.

So today, I am starting to watch at just before 19:00 - and the "whoa" moments come flying fast:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_7IVCSpalbA&t=19m

1.) 19:01 min: Slide reads:
"NIST, 2004 - Outside the selected area, commcetion failure were not modeled (used as Fix or Pin). Connections were not modeled in the exterior moment frame"​
He is somehow bemoaning the fact that the Chapter 11 model (ANSYS, 16 floors) only has the east floors in much detail, and considers the west part as rigid.
Why does he quote from the 2004 draft??? The final (2008) version of NCSTAR 1-9 provides reasons for that engineering choice (page 475):
"Outside the selected area, structural damage–such as buckling of the steel frame and crushing and cracking of the concrete slab–was modeled over the entire floor, but connection failures were not modeled. The extent of the area with detailed connection models was based on the results of single floor fire simulations, where connection damage west of Columns 73 through 76 were not found to contribute to an initial failure event on the east side of the structure. The area where break elements were modeled was selected to reduce the model size without biasing the results for simulating the initial failure event.
Framing connections outside of the selected area, or on other floors not subjected to fire, were modeled as either fixed or pinned, using typical modeling approaches. Connections were not modeled in the exterior moment frame, as no failures were observed there prior to the onset of global collapse. Column splices were also not modeled for interior columns, as the purpose of the ANSYS model was to accumulate local failures up to the point of buckling in a column. When column buckling appeared to be imminent, the analyses were continued in the LS-DYNA 47 story model."​
He doesn't really explain why he brings up that issue.
We'll return to it in a minute!

2.) 19:16: Slide reads (bolding by Hulsey):
NIST NCSTAR 1-9 Page 525 [this is an error; actually page 527; Oy], 2008
"A girder was considered to have lost vertical support when its web was no longer supported by the bearing seat. The bearing seat at Column 79 was 11 in. wide. Thus, when the girder end at Column 79 had been pushed laterally at least 5.5 in., it was no longer supported by the bearing seat."​
This very sentence, specifically the numbers "11 in." and "5.5 in.", have been identified as a mere typo by NIST in the Errata, January 2009. The actual model used the correct numbers (12 and 6.25, respectively) It can be no coincidence that Hulsey quotes this of all passages, but not the correction. It has to be a deliberate misrepresentation?!


3.) 19:45: He now jumps to the dynamic collapse model (Chapter 12, 47-story LS-DYNA) without saying so.
He shows next to each other a video of the collapsing building and a Chapter 12 animation by NIST of the same. The caption reads:
"There is no connection modeled in outside frame, and it will enhance the rigidity of outside frame. Which makes the comparison similar."​
This is not a quote from NIST, it's bad English, and it's FALSE: Of course the full 47-story LS-DYNA model included all connections, including outside frames (Chapter 12.2.3 has details).


4.) At 20:05, he runs the collapse video and the NIST animation alongside one another and points out, (fairly - if he uses the correct animation, which I haven't checked), that they don't look very much the same.
Then, after 20:23, he provides an explanation: The slide shows a snippet from a floor of the 16-floor ANSYS model (Chapter 11) next to an image of the full 47-story LS-DYNA model (Chapter 12), and a caption:
"Outside the selected area [east of col. 76 in ANSYS] connection failures were not modeled; separated progressive collapse into two part"​
Oh my goodness! They are conflating the properties and boundary conditions of two separate models! The Hulsey team failed at reading and understanding the NIST-report!!
Hulsey speaks (20:30):
"The left [east in the ANSYS model] side is where the springs are [i.e. non-pinned connections], the right side is where the springs are not, and if that building began to fail, the left side went down faster than the right side ... which means that their model was not accurate."​
Moron. It means Hulsey doesn't understand what NIST did.


With this, there is no need to watch any further.
 
Last edited:
Hulsey is explicit on how they are seeking peer-review - at 10:37 min:
"Once the results are tested, the information will be evaluated by our peers, and we intend to put together a peer-evaluation committee prior to completion of this work, and once that has been reviewed and scrutinized, then we intend to put it out and publish it in the literature."​
I notice he doesn't say he wants to go to a peer-reviewed engineering journal of any prestige. He merely talks about peers he apparently plans to pick himself. Who will those peers be? Any critics? Anyone from NIST perhaps, or ARUP? Or from any of the many major university engineering departments that have not gone bonkers? I doubt it.
I am sure he'll ask Korol and Cole (both Coles perhaps, including the non-engineer David Cole), Szamboti and perhaps Coste. And Jones and Harrit for good measure :p
 
I notice he doesn't say he wants to go to a peer-reviewed engineering journal of any prestige. He merely talks about peers he apparently plans to pick himself. Who will those peers be? Any critics? Anyone from NIST perhaps, or ARUP? Or from any of the many major university engineering departments that have not gone bonkers? I doubt it.
I am sure he'll ask Korol and Cole (both Coles perhaps, including the non-engineer David Cole), Szamboti and perhaps Coste. And Jones and Harrit for good measure :p
More than likely. It seems it will be a "biased peer"-reviewed political pamphlet.

At this point I start to wonder why is Hulsey doing this to his reputation.
 
Oh ok, Hulsey somewhat dispells a couple of my concerns regarding peer review:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NlwjteSZiUk

At 3:40 explains that their "peers" shall be independent from AE911T, and that they then want to submit to a peer-reviewed journal.


At 4:53:
"We're in the process of writing our third quarterly report which will have in it the first quarterly report summary and the second quarterly report summary. That will then go for review by AE911Truth. We will then, once that's completed, they'll go on our website and also will probably go on AE911Truth's website, so people can read it and it will be available"​
Aha! Quarterly reports? Where are they? Why are they only writing a third quarterly report yet, the study ought to be in its sixth quarter, if I count correctly!
 
Oh ok, Hulsey somewhat dispells a couple of my concerns regarding peer review:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NlwjteSZiUk

At 3:40 explains that their "peers" shall be independent from AE911T, and that they then want to submit to a peer-reviewed journal.


At 4:53:
"We're in the process of writing our third quarterly report which will have in it the first quarterly report summary and the second quarterly report summary. That will then go for review by AE911Truth. We will then, once that's completed, they'll go on our website and also will probably go on AE911Truth's website, so people can read it and it will be available"​
Aha! Quarterly reports? Where are they? Why are they only writing a third quarterly report yet, the study ought to be in its sixth quarter, if I count correctly!

Do you really have such little interest in Dr. Hulsey's investiigation that you feel it necessary to constantly obsess on the minutiae?
 
We've now heard a series of people go on about the NIST bit about the girder at 79 floor 13. How many more of these will be done?

Now that he seems to have concluded that fire cannot lead to the collapse of a building because he could not confirm the NIST col 79 stuff... does this mean that something other than fire led to the collapse? And what did he find out? Or wasn't that what he was supposed to do... study the collapse?

Let's imagine...

What would a new investigation do?
 
Do you really have such little interest in Dr. Hulsey's investiigation that you feel it necessary to constantly obsess on the minutiae?

There really is no minutia. Need a certain level of results for that, I think.

Then again, it's interesting you blow right by the point of why the whole exercise is pointless as far as proving anything regarding controlled demolition.

Stick to that script!
 
There really is no minutia. Need a certain level of results for that, I think.

Then again, it's interesting you blow right by the point of why the whole exercise is pointless as far as proving anything regarding controlled demolition.

Stick to that script!

Typical trufers. Get caught, run like hell.
C'mon, guys. Just a little help. Show us a free body of Girder 79 with the loads you say were there...
 
If you have an issue about the fire conclusions, I suggest you focus on where you believe the study was flawed.

As is all to common in this forum, when dealing with a non-member, the man is attacked but not his argument.


So are we to conclude that no one here can pin point flaws in Dr. Hulsey's research and findings?

At 4:53:
"We're in the process of writing our third quarterly report which will have in it the first quarterly report summary and the second quarterly report summary. That will then go for review by AE911Truth. We will then, once that's completed, they'll go on our website and also will probably go on AE911Truth's website, so people can read it and it will be available"​
Aha! Quarterly reports? Where are they? Why are they only writing a third quarterly report yet, the study ought to be in its sixth quarter, if I count correctly!

Do you really have such little interest in Dr. Hulsey's investiigation that you feel it necessary to constantly obsess on the minutiae?

I'm confused as to what you woulf like debunkers to do, Criteria. You say we should look at the study to see if it has flaws but when we ask to see it you call that "minutia".
 
I'm confused as to what you woulf like debunkers to do, Criteria. You say we should look at the study to see if it has flaws but when we ask to see it you call that "minutia".

It's the classic bait-and-switch. If we criticize the conclusion, Criteria appeals to authority. If we address the authority by criticizing the methodology, Criteria accuses us of focusing on minutiae and says we've failed to address the conclusion. Rinse and repeat.

Dave
 
So are we to conclude that no one here can pin point flaws in Dr. Hulsey's research and findings?
From experience we know that you will "conclude" whatever suits your goal.

HOWEVER one fatal flaw in Hulsey's project is easy to identify.

He is playing the "false dichotomy" trick which is also T Szamboti's current strategy.

It goes this way - the Szamboti version:

"I claim there was CD, I have proved that [some expert] is wrong THEREFORE I am right."

And in recent months we have seen T Szamboti work through several experts - Nordenson, ARUP will serve as examples.

The Hulsey version is even sillier.

Now this is where both Szamboti and Hulsey seem to know how to play - jerk the chains of - "debunkers".

Just about every opponent seeks to prove that Szamboti or Hulsey are wrong in details.

Why bother? Why waste the effort? The fatal error lies in the false dichotomy "If I prove you wrong it means that I am right." His claim is dead BEFORE we even look at whether or not he has falsified some other party. Even if true the fact that some other person's hypothesis is wrong does NOT make Hulsey right.

In Hulsey's case - and depending which version of his moving goalpost claims we address (I'm picking one - but they are all false.)

He claims that he will show what did NOT happen.

And the implication Hulsey relies on is that something else did happen. BUT he wont say CD. Is there any other possibility than additional MHI?

At least Szamboti is honest - he says "CD". Hulsey plays "pea and thimble" tricks. He says he will be scientific and not speculate CD.

Utter bleeding nonsense.
1) He is in blatant and unprofessional opposition to the Scientific Method; PLUS
2) If it wasn't fire - what was it if not some form of additional MHI? AND
3) No matter how many other explanations he claims he has proved wrong HIS claim is NOT MADE OUT until he proves it RIGHT by an affirmative hypothesis.

Other members here can no doubt find errors in this technical details and his procedural dishonesties. I'll stay with my normal practice and identify the fatal errors of framing logic and false starting point assumptions.

There is no point arguing about the leaves on a tree if it is the wrong tree in the wrong forest.
 
Last edited:
There really is no minutia. Need a certain level of results for that, I think.
Maybe you need some special glasses to be able to see the minutia properly. They're probably quite expensive, and available exclusively from your usual 'truther' outlet.

If you do buy the special glasses, and still can't see the minutia properly, then clearly you don't reach the minimum IQ requirements to use them.

If you can find "thermitic compounds" in paint chips, and understand that this can only mean that thermite was used to create those paint chips (there is no other explanation possible -- ignore those lying chemists, everyone knows they work for the lizard people), then you're getting near the required IQ mark.

Try huffing some glue for a few months, and you might manage to get there.
 
...Then again, it's interesting you blow right by the point of why the whole exercise is pointless as far as proving anything regarding controlled demolition...
clap.gif
clap.gif

The exercise is also pointless as far as proving "it wasn't fire" which is (or was given the moving goalposts) Hulsey's goal.

AFAIK the ONLY way to "prove a negative" is to prove the converse. Someone correct me if I'm wrong.

And Hulsey has specifically taken CD out of "speculation".

The only way to "prove Controlled Demolition" is to prove controlled demolition.

No matter how many examples Hulsey claims he has proved "fire only" hypotheses wrong it will NOT prove any alternate hypothesis or claim correct.
 
Why bother? Why waste the effort? The fatal error lies in the false dichotomy "If I prove you wrong it means that I am right." His claim is dead BEFORE we even look at whether or not he has falsified some other party. Even if true the fact that some other person's hypothesis is wrong does NOT make Hulsey right.

And this is why Hulsey's claim of 100% certainty that WTC7 was a CD is complete nonsense. He has addressed a single specific collapse initiation scenario; his conclusion is a classic case of denying the antecedent.

P1: If NIST's conclusion is correct, then WTC7 collapsed due to fire.
Hulsey's P2: NIST's conclusion is incorrect.
Hulsey's fallacious C: WTC7 did not collapse due to fire.

To give an analogy, suppose a tree is found lying on its side in the forest. A conspiracy theorist happens to see it and asks a forest ranger for the details of how it fell. The forest ranger replies that, as far as he believes, it was cut down with a 1kg felling axe. The conspiracy theorist then argues that the tree was actually blown up with dynamite. He points to the axe marks on the tree and explains that they are 20% too large to have been made by a 1kg felling axe, that therefore the official explanation provided by the forest ranger is incorrect, and claims that he is 100% certain that the tree was blown up.

That's nonsense even if the tree is in the right forest.

Dave
 
Do you really have such little interest in Dr. Hulsey's investiigation that you feel it necessary to constantly obsess on the minutiae?
If NIST does it, it's an unforgivable lack of transparency.

If Hulsey does it, it's minutiae.

Got it. It's called double standards.
 
Last edited:
And this is why Hulsey's claim of 100% certainty that WTC7 was a CD is complete nonsense. He has addressed a single specific collapse initiation scenario; his conclusion is a classic case of denying the antecedent.

P1: If NIST's conclusion is correct, then WTC7 collapsed due to fire.
Hulsey's P2: NIST's conclusion is incorrect.
Hulsey's fallacious C: WTC7 did not collapse due to fire.

To give an analogy, suppose a tree is found lying on its side in the forest. A conspiracy theorist happens to see it and asks a forest ranger for the details of how it fell. The forest ranger replies that, as far as he believes, it was cut down with a 1kg felling axe. The conspiracy theorist then argues that the tree was actually blown up with dynamite. He points to the axe marks on the tree and explains that they are 20% too large to have been made by a 1kg felling axe, that therefore the official explanation provided by the forest ranger is incorrect, and claims that he is 100% certain that the tree was blown up.

That's nonsense even if the tree is in the right forest.

Dave
Which is why, despite Oz and oy bellyakin about us getting trapped talking about a tree when the forest is wrong, I keep harping on a free body.
If they have proved NIST wrong on an inconsequential detail, they ought to be able to show it, right?
They can't even make that case.
 
I'm confused as to what you woulf like debunkers to do, Criteria. You say we should look at the study to see if it has flaws but when we ask to see it you call that "minutia".

When Criteria returns, I really would like a response.

TSZ may also comment on this. After all AE911T did, and has, complained long and loud about the WTC 7 final report having taken several years to come out, and about NIST not making their full data set available. Yet Hulsey's report displays an even worse case of making the report available. At least NIST published interim reports and a final report. All we have so far is a verbal presentation. Imagine the hue and cry and gnashing of teeth if all that was released for a NIST interim or final report was a speech by Shyam Sunder.:eye-poppi
 
Last edited:
And this is why Hulsey's claim of 100% certainty that WTC7 was a CD is complete nonsense. He has addressed a single specific collapse initiation scenario; his conclusion is a classic case of denying the antecedent.

P1: If NIST's conclusion is correct, then WTC7 collapsed due to fire.
Hulsey's P2: NIST's conclusion is incorrect.
Hulsey's fallacious C: WTC7 did not collapse due to fire.

To give an analogy, suppose a tree is found lying on its side in the forest. A conspiracy theorist happens to see it and asks a forest ranger for the details of how it fell. The forest ranger replies that, as far as he believes, it was cut down with a 1kg felling axe. The conspiracy theorist then argues that the tree was actually blown up with dynamite. He points to the axe marks on the tree and explains that they are 20% too large to have been made by a 1kg felling axe, that therefore the official explanation provided by the forest ranger is incorrect, and claims that he is 100% certain that the tree was blown up.

That's nonsense even if the tree is in the right forest.

Dave

The forest is only right if the tree is blown up, and makes no sound.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom