Merged Hulsey presents research arguing WTC7 not brought down by fires/University of Alaska

Well lets imagine.... NIST decided ... for whatever reason... to model the region around col 79 flr 3... and so they added heat inputs to their assumed steel columns, seat, beams, slabs, reinforcing, studs whatever... and did an FEA of sorts... Doesn't sound terribly complex to me... But I don't do these sorts of things.

They didn't seem to do much with any other node as far as I can tell and supposedly once 79 on 13 lost the girder it somehow buckled (loss of capacity from loss of bracing??) and somehow that became their global collapse kick off.

Sounds a bit fishy but maybe. But it would dumb to assume that was the SOLE PLACE WHERE THE UNCHECKED FIRES WERE MESSING UP THE FRAME. A safer assumption would be that multiple places of the frame over several floors and over the course of several hrs were getting toasted by fire... and becoming non performing nodes.
 
I get asked this by a particularly annoying troll on a different message board a lot. What is the reason that NIST doesn't release their data set for their FEAs? I've tried searching for this, but it's difficult. As long as you brought it up, I thought I'd throw the question in.

NIST didn't even get to make the determination on withholding the data. The inspector general for the department of transportation made that determination. The FOIA process is a strict statutory process and when departmental legal counsel responds, it is responding in that strict statutory framework. Does the government always get it right? No, of course not. The government's default position is to underdisclose. But that's why the FOIA process makes all such departmental determinations directly appealable to federal court. In the case of the NIST FOIA, however, no one ever appealed the decision, so it remains an open question whether the government had a sound reason for claiming the models themselves were exempt from statutory disclosure to the general public. (I'm guessing their theory was that, owing to NIST's conclusion that WTC7 would. have collapse entirely without fires of column 79 were removed between floors 11 and 13, that their model could be used to pinpoint other buildings with similar catastrophic vulnerabilities, but that's just my guess.)

Note, however, that an FOIA denial does not mean that NIST is not allowed to discuss and share its research. Again, FOIA requests fall into a very strict statutory regime. If you read the affidavits of the Aegis Insurance experts, they state plainly that they coordinated with NIST when building their models. Did those experts see the whole NIST model? Unclear. But real researchers would do what they did and coordinate directly with NIST on their research.
 
Last edited:
Do you really have such little interest in Dr. Hulsey's investiigation that you feel it necessary to constantly obsess on the minutiae?

Minutiae?
Do you consider broken promises "minutiae"?
I primarily "obsess" about getting informed at all. Hulsey gives us near to no information. Don't blame me for taking the little bit he says serious. You seem to be the one who is satisfied with nothing at all :)
 
Interesting point but why the innuendo?

I have said that:
1) Hulsey claims to be showing one or multiple explanations wrong (his story has changed over time)
2) No matter how many other explantions he shows wrong will not make his claim right; AND
3) The only valid way to "prove the negative" is to prove the "opposite" hypothesis is true. AKA to prove it "wasn't fire" he has to "prove" what it actually was.
...

Hulsey is quite outspoken not to have a positive claim.
He is 100% sure he has proven a negative, but refuses absolutely to even speculate on a positive claim.
This proves that he is a true Truther.
 
Whatever he is, he appears like a Danny Jewenko, used and going along with it by AE to get some media attention. he fact that they paraded this out on the 15 anniversary is very telling... and expected.

No, that's unfair to Jowenko. Jowenko never had a contract with truther nuts, never got money from truthers, never went to a truther nuts meeting to speak truthy things.
He was contacted by TV journalists for an interview, to provide some expert opinion, which he was nice enough to do. He explained well why WTC1+2 could not possibly have been CDed - several reasons given. He was unprepared for WTC7 which he had never heard of, and provided with only very limited information. Yes, without sound, some of the videos look like CD. That is the extent of Jowenko's involvement.

Hulsey, on the other hand, is a whore for da Twoof, cashing in $200,000 for wasting his reputation on a lying cause.

He must know how stupidly wrong he is to be 100% certain about a negative claim just because partial analysis seems to indicate one particular mechanism is unlikely. This seems to indicate to me that he is willfully dishonest - he seeks to please his source of money to be eligible for the entire dough.
 
...
I actually think this is why we have not seen a complete model and why Hulsey seems to have scaled back his study. I don't believe he has the resources to do what he promised. I think he thought AE 9/11 would come through with large amounts of money to secure the lab time needed to do this. This is why I asked about how much has been raised. ...

What is your source for the highlighted? I didn't hear that in the video linked to in the OP, nor the other video refered to by the first.
 
IIRC, they were worried about possible national security issues.

No matter what the reason, or whether or not NIST is justified in it, there ARE several other studies now that DID produce FEAs for WTC 7 without that NIST data. Quite obviously having such input data is not required in order to produce a report, and of the non-NIST reports done, each one ETA: ,aside from the unpublished Hulsey study,has concluded that the building's demise was due to fire damage.

In addition we have the hypocrisy of the very group most vocal about NIST not releasing that data has in turn sanctioned a report which is, so far, at least equally as tight with information as was NIST.

Fixed that for me.
 
What is your source for the highlighted? I didn't hear that in the video linked to in the OP, nor the other video refered to by the first.
It's more of an assumption made from comments he made. He comments on not drawing conclusions based on his own model but based on examining the NISTs. He talks about simplifications he makes to his own analysis to make the computing easier in working with the NISTs.

Originally it was said he would complete his model and then examine the NIST theory. Yes he has done modeling but I've see no evidence it is on the scale he original promises.
 
I've just stumbled upon this post by jaydeehess while I was searching for something else:

My prediction:
Hulsey is going to do nothing more than model the col 79/girder 44 and adjacent beams. That's it!

He will show movement less than total walk off of the girder and declare it 'impossible' , thus he will declare the entire NIST hypothysis impossible and declare ipso facto, that explosives would therefore be required.

The same asre about logic (do I get my Aussie pin now?) that AE911T uses.
I think you've earned that pin!

ETA: This is what I was looking for. Gerrycan replies:
I understand he is modelling the whole building.
Do you agree with the decision to release all the data to do with the study so that people can check it for themselves?
That's probably where I got the idea that it was going to be a full scale model.

Note also that even gerrycan gives outstanding importance to the release of all the data.

Also, in a post full of sarcasm, he highlights this:
Also, it's a mistake to release the input data. This will allow people to check the model and can only lead to trouble. Much better to stick with the NIST convention and keep the inputs to yourself.
Seems that that's indeed what Hulsey has done. :boggled:
 
Last edited:
It's more of an assumption made from comments he made. He comments on not drawing conclusions based on his own model but based on examining the NISTs. He talks about simplifications he makes to his own analysis to make the computing easier in working with the NISTs.

Originally it was said he would complete his model and then examine the NIST theory. Yes he has done modeling but I've see no evidence it is on the scale he original promises.

Ah. Assumption.

There of course have to be simplifications - it's both unreasonable and impossible to run stable dynamic simulations with a full and fully detailed model down to every hook and nail. This pretty much ought to go without even saying*.

I haven't seen his modelling yet, so I can't assess whether it is, or will be, in keeping with his promises.
I don't remember anyway that these promises were detailed. They said they would "fully" model the building, and didn't he say they did floors 3 to 47 fully? So floors 1+2 are missing, but perhaps they really are not that relevant; perhaps they lacked data to model them.



*Although Hulsey is hypocrite enough to roast NIST on their engineering judgement on where and what to simplify; Hulsey fails to give a proper engineering reason to criticize NIST's choices)
 
Ah. Assumption.

There of course have to be simplifications - it's both unreasonable and impossible to run stable dynamic simulations with a full and fully detailed model down to every hook and nail. This pretty much ought to go without even saying*.

I will gladly concede the point. I do believe they have constructed a full model but, I seriously doubt they have the resources to do anything meaningful on that full scale.

I suppose time will tell...........;)
 
Ah. Assumption.

There of course have to be simplifications - it's both unreasonable and impossible to run stable dynamic simulations with a full and fully detailed model down to every hook and nail. This pretty much ought to go without even saying*.

Which is also why an FEA cannot be said to "prove" anything about what was happening inside the building. Even if you did model down to every hook and nail, a model just ain't the real thing. For example, the real culprit in the collapse might have been faulty materials or construction. The fact that Hulsey claims his FEA has (or will) "prove" anything is just more evidence of an agenda-driven study.
 
I will gladly concede the point. I do believe they have constructed a full model but, I seriously doubt they have the resources to do anything meaningful on that full scale.

I suppose time will tell...........;)

Oh! If he'll ever get around to publishing such a full model, I will likely be quite unable to decide how meaningful that model, or what they do with it, are. We are eight years past the release of the NIST report, computer power and software smartness have increased considerably since, so I can't say that the UAF engineering department doesn't have the resources.

However, they'll have to publish something, anything, first - and explain what their game plan is.
You and I know that, in keeping with Truther tradition, they'll be wrong on multiple levels. They'll be wrong on the top-most level of what their objectives and premises are - that's all we need to point out then.

Garbage in - garbage out, no matter how expansive their resources are to grind garbage.
 
NIST didn't even get to make the determination on withholding the data. The inspector general for the department of transportation made that determination. The FOIA process is a strict statutory process and when departmental legal counsel responds, it is responding in that strict statutory framework. Does the government always get it right? No, of course not. The government's default position is to underdisclose. But that's why the FOIA process makes all such departmental determinations directly appealable to federal court. In the case of the NIST FOIA, however, no one ever appealed the decision, so it remains an open question whether the government had a sound reason for claiming the models themselves were exempt from statutory disclosure to the general public. (I'm guessing their theory was that, owing to NIST's conclusion that WTC7 would. have collapse entirely without fires of column 79 were removed between floors 11 and 13, that their model could be used to pinpoint other buildings with similar catastrophic vulnerabilities, but that's just my guess.)

Note, however, that an FOIA denial does not mean that NIST is not allowed to discuss and share its research. Again, FOIA requests fall into a very strict statutory regime. If you read the affidavits of the Aegis Insurance experts, they state plainly that they coordinated with NIST when building their models. Did those experts see the whole NIST model? Unclear. But real researchers would do what they did and coordinate directly with NIST on their research.

Thank you and the others who posted a response to my question. I really do appreciate your willingness to share what you know.
 
I've just stumbled upon this post by jaydeehess while I was searching for something else:
!!!!! I astound myself.:D I had forgotten I made that post.

ETA: This is what I was looking for. Gerrycan replies:

That's probably where I got the idea that it was going to be a full scale model.

Note also that even gerrycan gives outstanding importance to the release of all the data.

,, and yet here we are with nothing more than a video presentation, no more up to date published info than from November of last year, no data, and so far only a modelling of the specific location of girder and column having been modeled.

AE911T, and surrogates on this forum, Tony Szamboti and Criteria, must be so disappointed that this project has fallen so very short of the promises made.
 
Criteria, now that you are out of the mountains, and I hope you have a nice time, perhaps you will address the lack of a published report from Hulsey and the seeming ignoring of the promises made about continual updates.
 
Criteria said:
If you have an issue about the fire conclusions, I suggest you focus on where you believe the study was flawed.


So are we to conclude that no one here can pin point flaws in Dr. Hulsey's research and findings?
Neither you or TSz gave even mentioned the fact that this study simply cannot be examined in any detail.
Hulsey has basically given a speech about his study but has not actually made his study available to, it seems, anyone at all.

Hard to "pin point flaws" when one is disallowed from viewing the research and findings. The only info available is from dang near a year ago now! The issue was brought up in post #3.

Care to comment on that yet, keeping in mind the openness and transparency promised in the beginning?........
.

Seems Criteria was confused about the question I was asking. Seems he thought I was merely backing up Oystein asking about what Criteria regarded as "minutia".

So here it is again, parsed to avoid any such confusion.
 
Last edited:
”If you have an issue about the fire conclusions, I suggest you focus on where you believe the study was flawed.”
”To me it's actually a very rare opportunity to see inside how AE911Truth operates, plus it sheds light on the credibility of a study that is already making an extraordinary claim, which, if taken seriously, would have massive implications for the public, and thus understanding all aspects of such study would be massively in the public interest. Given that AE911Truth chose a public university to conduct the study, it is very low hanging fruit to pick. So why not besides possible harassment from conspiracy nuts? Like I said, I'd rather not get involved directly (but I will if no one else does), but I'd be more than willing to help someone else (drafting/funding) who is also curious about these public records. Many on this board are already publicly known to conspiracy theorists, so I figured someone might want to do this at no cost/risk.

ETA: also, we actually don't know how much public funds, if any, were spent by Dr. Hulsey in connection with this project. That's another reason to request such information.”
”So are we to conclude that no one here can pin point flaws in Dr. Hulsey's research and findings?
Seems Criteria was confused about the question I was asking.

Seems he thought I was merely backing up Oystein asking about what Criteria regarded as "minutia".

So here it is again, parsed to avoid any such confusion.
”…Neither you or TSz gave even mentioned the fact that this study simply cannot be examined in any detail.
Hulsey has basically given a speech about his study but has not actually made his study available to, it seems, anyone at all.

Hard to "pin point flaws" when one is disallowed from viewing the research and findings. The only info available is from dang near a year ago now! The issue was brought up in post #3.

Care to comment on that yet, keeping in mind the openness and transparency promised in the beginning?”

”…Neither you or TSz gave even mentioned the fact that this study simply cannot be examined in any detail.”

What study?

Dr. Hulsey was not presenting ‘the study’.

He made a relatively short, ‘streamed video presentation’, outlining and summarizing both the investigative approach and findings which lead to his team’s 100% conclusive determination that fire was not a factor in the collapse of WTC7.

Based on what Dr. Hulsey said in his ‘speech/presentation’, these current findings represent only part of his team’s planned investigation.

Now that they have ruled out fire, Dr. Hulsey and his team are investigating what actually did lead to the sudden collapse of WTC7.

While Dr. Hulsey and his associates continue their investigation, the rest of us will have to cool our heels, because unless they get funding to spend extra time and money to prepare and write an interim report…
 
Dr. Hulsey was not presenting ‘the study’.

He made a relatively short, ‘streamed video presentation’, outlining and summarizing both the investigative approach and findings which lead to his team’s 100% conclusive determination that fire was not a factor in the collapse of WTC7.

Based on what Dr. Hulsey said in his ‘speech/presentation’, these current findings represent only part of his team’s planned investigation.

Now that they have ruled out fire, Dr. Hulsey and his team are investigating what actually did lead to the sudden collapse of WTC7.

While Dr. Hulsey and his associates continue their investigation, the rest of us will have to cool our heels, because unless they get funding to spend extra time and money to prepare and write an interim report…

So why did you ask this question?

”So are we to conclude that no one here can pin point flaws in Dr. Hulsey's research and findings?


What research can be examined?

I can answer your question, no we should not conclude this based on insufficient evidence. OK?
 
Now that they have ruled out fire, Dr. Hulsey and his team are investigating what actually did lead to the sudden collapse of WTC7.

While Dr. Hulsey and his associates continue their investigation, the rest of us will have to cool our heels, because unless they get funding to spend extra time and money to prepare and write an interim report…


It is accurate to say at this point that Dr. Hulsey has found no other evidence since previous investigations have determined that fire, in conjunction with impact damage, was responsible for the collapse of WTC 7, and he will find NO evidence that thermite and explosives were responsible when he releases his report.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom