LSSBB
Devilish Dictionarian
My thought momentarily, and then I remembered:Well, according to Zen, if nobody was there to hear it...
Dave
This particular forest had tons of recording devices and the eyes and ears of the world on it.
My thought momentarily, and then I remembered:Well, according to Zen, if nobody was there to hear it...
Dave
Well, according to Zen, if nobody was there to hear it...
Dave
Are you an engineer? I am an engineer, and your statement is BS. A claim based on bias, paranoia, and gullibility. What engineering school did you go to? Most engineers understand fire and steel, and 9/11 truth has what appears to be a subset of the insane, complacent, or nutcase engineers; with less than 0.1 percent of all engineer.
It only takes a grade school education to know CD is a fantasy born in ignorance. Does the, http://cem.uaf.edu/ , college of engineering know the CD head, http://cem.uaf.edu/cee/people/leroy-hulsey.aspx , is a CT BS artist.
Gee, most engineers understand fire and steel, we were taught how to do research, we did research papers, etc... Hulsey spews BS opinons about steel which fool you into thinking he is qualified.How do we know what you are?
Self-proclaimed credibility from a nameless source means nothing more than hot air.
Bias is a meaningless point. Who doesn't have bias?
Paranoia? I do not recall that as a subject covered in engineering. Do you have professional qualifications as a psychologist as well?
Gullibility? Who is more gullible? The person waving the flag or the person concerned that the flag is being waved for the right reasons?
Since when did the engineering school I went to matter? Are you arguing that Dr. Hulsey lacks credibility because he is not associated with a school that meets your standards?
Since when do "most" engineers have a forensic knowledge of "fire" and "steel"?
You do know there are a lot of different types of engineering do you not?
Dr. Hulsey would appear to be especially qualified to make the determination that he reached.
Did you learn your understanding of engineering in grade school?
Insult me all you want but I feel much more trusting of someone with Dr. Hulsey's proven credentials making a no-fire determination than some anonymous flag waver smearing everyone that disagrees with them.
How do we know what you are?
Self-proclaimed credibility from a nameless source means nothing more than hot air.
Bias is a meaningless point. Who doesn't have bias?
Paranoia? I do not recall that as a subject covered in engineering. Do you have professional qualifications as a psychologist as well?
Gullibility? Who is more gullible? The person waving the flag or the person concerned that the flag is being waved for the right reasons?
Since when did the engineering school I went to matter? Are you arguing that Dr. Hulsey lacks credibility because he is not associated with a school that meets your standards?
Since when do "most" engineers have a forensic knowledge of "fire" and "steel"?
You do know there are a lot of different types of engineering do you not?
Dr. Hulsey would appear to be especially qualified to make the determination that he reached.
Did you learn your understanding of engineering in grade school?
Insult me all you want but I feel much more trusting of someone with Dr. Hulsey's proven credentials making a no-fire determination than some anonymous flag waver smearing everyone that disagrees with them.
Of course that is ONE reason why he is wrong. There are many of them INCLUDING the (also) fatal error of foundation structure of logic.And this is why Hulsey's claim of 100% certainty that WTC7 was a CD is complete nonsense. He has addressed a single specific collapse initiation scenario; his conclusion is a classic case of denying the antecedent.
Sure. Just because I deliberately focussed the fatal error of foundation logic doesn't imply that I don't comprehend errors in those specific detailed examples.P1: If NIST's conclusion is correct, then WTC7 collapsed due to fire.
Hulsey's P2: NIST's conclusion is incorrect.
Hulsey's fallacious C: WTC7 did not collapse due to fire.
To give an analogy, suppose a tree is found lying on its side in the forest. A conspiracy theorist happens to see it and asks a forest ranger for the details of how it fell. The forest ranger replies that, as far as he believes, it was cut down with a 1kg felling axe. The conspiracy theorist then argues that the tree was actually blown up with dynamite. He points to the axe marks on the tree and explains that they are 20% too large to have been made by a 1kg felling axe, that therefore the official explanation provided by the forest ranger is incorrect, and claims that he is 100% certain that the tree was blown up.
True - not that I ever said otherwise. My point still stands SINCE the foundation logic is fatally flawed THEN whether or not his one or more examples are true or false is moot - doesn't change the fatal error.That's nonsense even if the tree is in the right forest.
Interesting point but why the innuendo?Which is why, despite Oz and oy bellyakin about us getting trapped talking about a tree when the forest is wrong, I keep harping on a free body.
Agreed AND understood respectively. Those are not aspects that I have disputed or would dispute.If they have proved NIST wrong on an inconsequential detail, they ought to be able to show it, right?
They can't even make that case.
How do we know what you are?
Dr. Hulsey lacks credibility because he is not associated with a school that meets your standards?
Have you skipped over a good 30% of the posts in this thread?
Neither you or TSz gave even mentioned the fact that this study simply cannot be examined in any detail.
Hulsey has basically given a speech about his study but has not actually made his study available to, it seems, anyone at all.
Hard to "pin point flaws" when one is disallowed from viewing the research and findings. The only info available is from dang near a year ago now! The issue was brought up in post #3.
Care to comment on that yet, keeping in mind the openness and transparency promised in the beginning?
Now it has been noted that the video is 35 minutes long, Gage takes the stage at 30 minutes in. Yet inexplicably you and TSz have characterized the video as being 16 minutes long. It seems to indicate that while trying to deride debunkers for nit watching this video, you haven't bothered to do so yourselves.
I watched it myself but did not bother watching the clock. I admit I skiped over the parts with Gage at the podium.
Do you really have such little interest in Dr. Hulsey's investiigation that you feel it necessary to constantly obsess on the minutiae?
Still no reply.I'm confused as to what you woulf like debunkers to do, Criteria. You say we should look at the study to see if it has flaws but when we ask to see it you call that "minutia".
Hence the phrase "inconsequential detail"Interesting point but why the innuendo?
I have said that:
1) Hulsey claims to be showing one or multiple explanations wrong (his story has changed over time)
2) No matter how many other explantions he shows wrong will not make his claim right; AND
3) The only valid way to "prove the negative" is to prove the "opposite" hypothesis is true. AKA to prove it "wasn't fire" he has to "prove" what it actually was.
AND the combination of those three means his foundation logic is wrong.
You are "harping" (your word) on one aspect - and it is valid AFAICS - I've been identifying the many detailed critiques without necessarily assessing them. Yours is one of them. But even if by some miracle he persuades you that he understands and agrees your claim .. so what? The overall structure IMO remains false.
Are you claiming that I am wrong on that assessment of false overall logic? If so please show me the error.
Do you disagree with my assertion that - whether Hulsey is right or wrong on any specific example e.g. NIST - his overall structure of argument is fatally flawed?
Agreed AND understood respectively. Those are not aspects that I have disputed or would dispute.
It's the "proven wrong" aspect thats being exploited. Criteria has made no specific claim references to "CD". Only that wtc 7 must be reinvestigated because the NIST is incorrect in its conclusions. The inference people make is that hulseys conclusions mean that it is a pro "CD" analysis but avoiding direct mention of that gives such individuals as Szamboti et al "wiggle room" to snipe at counter arguments for being too presumptuous even if the interpretation of the claims accurately goes in the general direction of the claims leading to "CD"There really is no minutia. Need a certain level of results for that, I think.
Then again, it's interesting you blow right by the point of why the whole exercise is pointless as far as proving anything regarding controlled demolition.
Stick to that script!
It's the "proven wrong" aspect thats being exploited. Criteria has made no specific claim references to "CD". Only that wtc 7 must be reinvestigated because the NIST is incorrect in its conclusions. The inference people make is that hulseys conclusions mean that it is a pro "CD" analysis but avoiding direct mention of that gives such individuals as Szamboti et al "wiggle room" to snipe at counter arguments for being too presumptuous even if the interpretation of the claims accurately goes in the general direction of the claims leading to "CD"
It goes back to the whole notion to them that direct mention of "CD" is the kiss of death to having any argument with those people they view as fence sitters
Of course... but the objective is to argue for CD without being explicit about it. The foundational argument is incorrect... but its the only argument that will be postedEven with CD absent, there have been other collapse mechanisms proposed, however nothing to eliminate the basic finding of fire and damage led to collapse.
WTC7 was on fire on simultaneous multiple floors for 5-6 hours. To assign ZERO (0%) probability for the building to have failed due to fire and before his modeling is complete and publicly available as he promised, is evidence Hulsey is a mistaken incompetent nutter;ZERO chance that the fires caused the collapse of WTC7!
<snip>
If nothing else, the non-engineer/non-technical lurkers can see that if they run away from their own details, they obviously can't be all that rigorous in their approach...

:
I get asked this by a particularly annoying troll on a different message board a lot. What is the reason that NIST doesn't release their data set for their FEAs? I've tried searching for this, but it's difficult. As long as you brought it up, I thought I'd throw the question in.
They stated concerns of national security.I get asked this by a particularly annoying troll on a different message board a lot. What is the reason that NIST doesn't release their data set for their FEAs? I've tried searching for this, but it's difficult. As long as you brought it up, I thought I'd throw the question in.