Merged Hulsey presents research arguing WTC7 not brought down by fires/University of Alaska

Not disputing that. But I still want to know what the actual terms are. It's a public university and the public has a right to know under the law.
I seriously doubt you could find what you're looking for. The grant is paying for lab time. If you want to launch a probe into Huseys use of time have at it. This concerns a small subset and is likely considered a private study (paid for by the client).

UAF has no part unless it's published and they endorse the findings.
 
I seriously doubt you could find what you're looking for. The grant is paying for lab time. If you want to launch a probe into Huseys use of time have at it. This concerns a small subset and is likely considered a private study (paid for by the client).

UAF has no part unless it's published and they endorse the findings.

Dear University of Alaska Department of Engineering,

Pursuant to [cite statute], I hereby request that you provide to me copies of (1) all correspondence between your department and any individual employed by [AE911Truth], including, but not limited to, Richard Gage, and (2) copies of all documentation pertaining to the grant from AE911Truth funding the [cite specific name of the research project] (including the terms thereof, the approval thereof, and records of any departmental deliberations concerned therewith, but excluding actual research reports, models, and similar materials produced in the course of the work associated with the grant).

Thank You,
Benthamitemetric

That's my 5 min version and I would certainly tune it, but it really wouldn't be hard at all to get what I am looking for. Not sure why you imagine it would be. Look at the law. Work done at a public university in Alaska is a public record. There is no exception in the Alaska FOIA law for work done pursuant to a private grant.
 
Last edited:
Dear University of Alaska Department of Engineering,

Pursuant to [cite statute], I hereby request that you provide to me copies of (1) all correspondence between your department and any individual employed by [AE911Truth], including, but not limited to, Richard Gage, and (2) copies of all documentation pertaining to the grant from AE911Truth funding the [cite specific name of the research project] (including the terms thereof, the approval thereof, and records of any departmental deliberations concerned therewith, but excluding actual research reports, models, and similar materials produced in the course of the work associated with the grant).

Thank You,
Benthamitemetric

That's my 5 min version and I would certainly tune it, but it really wouldn't be hard at all to get what I am looking for. Not sure why you imagine it would be. Look at the law. Work done at a public university in Alaska is a public record. There is no exception in the Alaska FOIA law for work done pursuant to a private grant.
I question why you would bother. This work will never be endorsed by the university and little to no public funds were spent.
 
I question why you would bother. This work will never be endorsed by the university and little to no public funds were spent.

To me it's actually a very rare opportunity to see inside how AE911Truth operates, plus it sheds light on the credibility of a study that is already making an extraordinary claim, which, if taken seriously, would have massive implications for the public, and thus understanding all aspects of such study would be massively in the public interest. Given that AE911Truth chose a public university to conduct the study, it is very low hanging fruit to pick. So why not besides possible harassment from conspiracy nuts? Like I said, I'd rather not get involved directly (but I will if no one else does), but I'd be more than willing to help someone else (drafting/funding) who is also curious about these public records. Many on this board are already publicly known to conspiracy theorists, so I figured someone might want to do this at no cost/risk.

ETA: also, we actually don't know how much public funds, if any, were spent by Dr. Hulsey in connection with this project. That's another reason to request such information.
 
Last edited:
To me it's actually a very rare opportunity to see inside how AE911Truth operates, plus it sheds light on the credibility of a study that is already making an extraordinary claim, which, if taken seriously, would have massive implications for the public, and thus understanding all aspects of such study would be massively in the public interest. Given that AE911Truth chose a public university to conduct the study, it is very low hanging fruit to pick. So why not besides possible harassment from conspiracy nuts? Like I said, I'd rather not get involved directly (but I will if no one else does), but I'd be more than willing to help someone else (drafting/funding) who is also curious about these public records. Many on this board are already publicly known to conspiracy theorists, so I figured someone might want to do this at no cost/risk.

ETA: also, we actually don't know how much public funds, if any, were spent by Dr. Hulsey in connection with this project. That's another reason to request such information.
The university is not conducting the study. Husey is doing this as an independent project.

I see no reason to think there would be "massive implications for the public". Do you really think anyone outside of a couple obscure forums actually knows about this, or cares?

Do you really think this will ever get published?
 
If Hulsey communicated with AE911Truth about the outcome and progress (including about a predetermined conclusion) of his study, the public has a right to know. Here's to hoping he used email.
It's already implicit and close to explicit in his progress reports. Why not an approach on the basis of professional misconduct?

I seriously doubt you could find what you're looking for. The grant is paying for lab time. If you want to launch a probe into Huseys use of time have at it. This concerns a small subset and is likely considered a private study (paid for by the client).

UAF has no part unless it's published and they endorse the findings.
Doesn't "chasing the financial details" make the same error of pursuing a derail side track that we are already seeing in forum discussions.

Forum "debate" is already taking the predictable track of debating technical details "Give me the data so I can check the model and calculations" sort of stuff. Missing the fatal or mendacious flaws in his framing of the project.

So I would be predicting yet another "Missing Jolt, "Axial impact v tilt"; "Girder walk-off" style lots of lengthy and detailed discussion. Missing the point that we are in the wrong "forest" as per your sig DGM. His project CANNOT legitimately achieve what he is claiming in his published statements. So why bother checking those aspects of his modelling which are irrelevant?

The minor amusement to me is that his false framing tactics follows the "New Strategy" that T Szamboti switched to about a year ago. So TWO AE911 related supporters following the same type of false argument.

But I doubt that any of them are bright enough to have made that switch deliberately.
 
Last edited:
The university is not conducting the study. Husey is doing this as an independent project.

I see no reason to think there would be "massive implications for the public". Do you really think anyone outside of a couple obscure forums actually knows about this, or cares?

Do you really think this will ever get published?

I think they could get some form of this published, yes. And AE911Truth will certainly use it for fundraising going forward, published or not.

And, again, it is not a private study. It is a privately-funded study conducted at a public university, using the university's facilities, grad students, licensed software, etc.

If you don't care about this topic so much, why are you posting about it? I find this exchange rather odd. No one will force you to read the documents produced by such a request, so don't worry if you're not interested.

I'd rather just know the truth as to how this study came about and was conducted. And, instead of speculating in circles on the internet all day, I'd rather make use of the law designed for the exact purpose of learning such truths.
 
Last edited:
Your beef might actually be with UAF. They are the ones profiting from this "study". ;)

It might be. All the more reason to actually understand the nature of the grant process at issue here. And, lucky for us, there is a ready legal mechanism that lets us do so.
 
It might be. All the more reason to actually understand the nature of the grant process at issue here. And, lucky for us, there is a ready legal mechanism that lets us do so.
Fact is, I think the reason the "study" has been cut back is because of lack of funds.

Hulsey expected more money for more lab time but funding has fallen short.

I'm collecting funding data now but, most will not be complete until filing next tax year. As things like this goes, this could be over a year from now.
 
For those of us who prefer the written word on grounds of fidelity of reproduction, is there any kind of written document we can study?

Dave

I have transcribed an important bit from between the 1:00 and 2:00 marks wheh Dr. Hulsey is speaking;

“We are making this study open, and transparent. Whether you are a physicist, engineer, architect, fire expert, or specialist in another field or just an ordinary citizen we want your participation.”

“We are making all of our data available on-line. Every aspect of our process regarding the model will be shared and we will be giving regular updates from the lab as we continue our work.”

“Join us in getting to the bottom of why World Trade Center 7 collapsed on September 11th, 2001”.
(emphasis added)

All of that IIRC was simply copped from their original project introduction video of last year.
 
Cue 9/11 anniversary... let's report that fires couldn't do it and NIST was lyin' bout that. This smells fishy to me... and has so from the time it was announced.

Didn't expect much and wasn't disappointed.
 
I'm watching the video.... about half way through. Plan to finish tomorrow.
So far this boils down to a disagreement with the NIST about whether their estimated collapse initiation point was one - accurate, and two - if the structural response could cause the collapse to initiate at that location. The NIST based their initial estimation of the initiation point based on videos of the exterior of the building at the time of collapse and then modeled that until they got a reasonable replication of what could be gathered from footage. Did he do the same? I suppose I'll find out when I watch the rest

Isn't it interesting that some here haven't even watched the 16 minute video...
I have to wonder if you even visited the URL of the video let alone watched it? It's almost 35 minutes long. I'll give benefit of the doubt that this might have been a typo, but use due diligence if you're going to utilize ad hominems against your critics. Errors like this aren't helping.
 
Last edited:
...
If you don't care about this topic so much, why are you posting about it? I find this exchange rather odd. No one will force you to read the documents produced by such a request, so don't worry if you're not interested.

I'd rather just know the truth as to how this study came about and was conducted. And, instead of speculating in circles on the internet all day, I'd rather make use of the law designed for the exact purpose of learning such truths.

I would be very much interested in this information - it might indeed, as you wrote elsewhere, reveal bits of how AE conducts business. Such as a who-is-who at Gage's inner circle, who is calling the shots. Also of course on what kinds of personal terms Hulsey is with any of the truthers.
I doubt that they would put in writing, even into the legal papers ruling the grant, that AE wants a certain conclusion. That they would have done on the "voice track" long before any paperwork got underway. But who knows what we might discover?
If and when the study comes out, I bet truthers will argue that UAF and Hulsey are "independent"; perhaps we'll know better then, and can prove it.

However, I don't feel that I am the person to write to the University. For starters, I am outside of North America - not sure if I am part of the "public" that FOIA has in mind.
 
"Is there a place where the totally open accounting of money is shown?

How much has been raised to date for this study?"

Unless you can show what relevance your interest in Dr. Hulsey's accounts has with respect to his finding that fire absolutely was not the reason for WTC7's collapse, I see nothing but a de-railing as well as another lame backdoor attempt to subvert the integrity of his work.

The actual terms of the grant and whether or not AE911Truth played any role in guiding the conclusions to date."

Another backdoor attempt to smear Dr. Hulsey's integrity. Dr. Hulsey and his doctorate associates were guided by their findings and most certainly not the money.

If you have an issue about the fire conclusions, I suggest you focus on where you believe the study was flawed.

As is all to common in this forum, when dealing with a non-member, the man is attacked but not his argument.

"To me it's actually a very rare opportunity to see inside how AE911Truth operates, plus it sheds light on the credibility of a study that is already making an extraordinary claim, which, if taken seriously, would have massive implications for the public, and thus understanding all aspects of such study would be massively in the public interest."

So are we to conclude that no one here can pin point flaws in Dr. Hulsey's research and findings?
 
Unless you can show what relevance your interest in Dr. Hulsey's accounts has with respect to his finding that fire absolutely was not the reason for WTC7's collapse, I see nothing but a de-railing as well as another lame backdoor attempt to subvert the integrity of his work.

I'm just looking for what they claimed they would provide, an open and transparent study. Do you think this study has met that promise?

So are we to conclude that no one here can pin point flaws in Dr. Hulsey's research and findings?

How can we verify or find flaws in a study that has shown none of it's data.
 
Last edited:
Unless you can show what relevance your interest in Dr. Hulsey's accounts has with respect to his finding that fire absolutely was not the reason for WTC7's collapse, I see nothing but a de-railing as well as another lame backdoor attempt to subvert the integrity of his work.

It isn't "Dr. Hulsey's accounts". Its not his money. Its the projects money. Dr. Hulsey promised the study would be "open and transparent." Shouldn't that also include how it was funded and how those funds were spent? What is unreasonable about that?

Another backdoor attempt to smear Dr. Hulsey's integrity. Dr. Hulsey and his doctorate associates were guided by their findings and most certainly not the money.

At this point your assertion is purely speculative. To date promises that the entire study would be open and transparent with all data made available on-line and public participation welcome have not been even remotely met. Even with this most recent finding no real data was presented so we don't actually know how they got from A to Z.

If you have an issue about the fire conclusions, I suggest you focus on where you believe the study was flawed. So are we to conclude that no one here can pin point flaws in Dr. Hulsey's research and findings?

How? They aren't sharing the data like they said they would do.
 
Unless you can show what relevance your interest in Dr. Hulsey's accounts has with respect to his finding that fire absolutely was not the reason for WTC7's collapse, I see nothing but a de-railing as well as another lame backdoor attempt to subvert the integrity of his work.



Another backdoor attempt to smear Dr. Hulsey's integrity. Dr. Hulsey and his doctorate associates were guided by their findings and most certainly not the money.

If you have an issue about the fire conclusions, I suggest you focus on where you believe the study was flawed.

As is all to common in this forum, when dealing with a non-member, the man is attacked but not his argument.

​

So are we to conclude that no one here can pin point flaws in Dr. Hulsey's research and findings?

I can he hasn't looked into fuel transport or dirrect oxidation effects that is clear, from the video.
 
So are we to conclude that no one here can pin point flaws in Dr. Hulsey's research and findings?

Rule of So: What you write is wrong.

There is a major flaw right at the root of his methodology:
He tries to recreate certain assumptions made by another team (NIST) that came to some set of rather specific conclusions ("heat made beams expand in floor 13 and push girder X off its seat, which cause..."). He tries to show that this specific scenario has a low probability of occurring. So far so acceptable.
Then comes the huge, flawed, silly, stupid, biased, moronic leap:
"Because NIST is wrong, fire cannot possibly be the cause of collapse".

Nonsense.

There is a universe of alternative paths by which fire could have been the cause, and we may never be able to prove one way or another which of the discovered and undiscovered paths actually did it, for lack of data.
Hulsey has not, and cannot, show that NO fire-induced collapse is possible or did happen.

What he needs to do, in order to replace the incumbent hypothesis ("fires made floor assemblies around columns 79-81 fail, leaving thos col's unsupported...") with a new hypothesis, is to actually spell out such an alternative hypothesis ("x pounds of high exexplosives placed on col's/girders/... Y to Z went off and at times t1 to tn and triggered") and demonstrate its viability and plausibility and compatibility with observed reality (e.g. the total lack of audible explosions with high brisance; the absence of any and all steel members showong signs of having been subjected to high explosives; a reconciliation with the exsistance of uncontrolled, fully involved fires in the very areas where many of the heat-sensitive explosive charges and their detonators would have been placed, etc etc etc).


tl;dr: "Showing NIST wrong" =/= "Fires didn't do it"
Scientific method demands instead: Spell out explosive CD hypothesis and prove it.
But neither Hulsey nor AE nor any Truther ever dares going there. There simply exists no hypothesis alternative to the "fires dunnit" one.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom