Merged Hulsey presents research arguing WTC7 not brought down by fires/University of Alaska

Unless you can show what relevance your interest in Dr. Hulsey's accounts has with respect to his finding that fire absolutely was not the reason for WTC7's collapse, I see nothing but a de-railing as well as another lame backdoor attempt to subvert the integrity of his work.


The fact he is working with AE911Truth, a discredited organization, pretty much spells it out as to where he is coming from.


Dr J Leroy Hulsey, chair of the University of Alaska Fairbanks’ Civil and Environmental Engineering Department, has partnered with Architects & Engineers for 9/11 Truth to begin a rigorous academic study into what really caused it to collapse.

Ted Walter, Director of Strategy and Development for A&E 9/11 Truth added:

We hope to gain significant traction in the engineering community by providing an authoritative refutation of NIST’s report, by showing that there is no way that fires could have brought down building 7.
http://www.globalresearch.ca/univer...ntrolled-demolition-of-wtc-building-7/5532408


A partner with a discredited organization. So much in the integrity of Dr. Hulsey.


Another backdoor attempt to smear Dr. Hulsey's integrity.


He smeared himself when he became a partner with a discredited organization well-known for its deception and lies!
 
Rule of So: What you write is wrong.

There is a major flaw right at the root of his methodology:
He tries to recreate certain assumptions made by another team (NIST) that came to some set of rather specific conclusions ("heat made beams expand in floor 13 and push girder X off its seat, which cause..."). He tries to show that this specific scenario has a low probability of occurring. So far so acceptable.
Then comes the huge, flawed, silly, stupid, biased, moronic leap:
"Because NIST is wrong, fire cannot possibly be the cause of collapse".

Nonsense.

There is a universe of alternative paths by which fire could have been the cause, and we may never be able to prove one way or another which of the discovered and undiscovered paths actually did it, for lack of data.
Hulsey has not, and cannot, show that NO fire-induced collapse is possible or did happen.

What he needs to do, in order to replace the incumbent hypothesis ("fires made floor assemblies around columns 79-81 fail, leaving thos col's unsupported...") with a new hypothesis, is to actually spell out such an alternative hypothesis ("x pounds of high exexplosives placed on col's/girders/... Y to Z went off and at times t1 to tn and triggered") and demonstrate its viability and plausibility and compatibility with observed reality (e.g. the total lack of audible explosions with high brisance; the absence of any and all steel members showong signs of having been subjected to high explosives; a reconciliation with the exsistance of uncontrolled, fully involved fires in the very areas where many of the heat-sensitive explosive charges and their detonators would have been placed, etc etc etc).


tl;dr: "Showing NIST wrong" =/= "Fires didn't do it"
Scientific method demands instead: Spell out explosive CD hypothesis and prove it.
But neither Hulsey nor AE nor any Truther ever dares going there. There simply exists no hypothesis alternative to the "fires dunnit" one.
I am so *********** sick and tired of all these "X couldn't have happened, so Y", without so much as a load diagram and free body of what was claimed vs what they say happened.
If you can't define the loads and properties, you can't support any argument you want to make
And when asked, they run and hide-- or start a new argument about something else.
 
What Oystein just said.

What he and Oystein just said.

"I spot a flaw in the conventional explanation, therefore [insert any old evidence-free carp that enters my head here]"

It's depressing that people can even think in this manner.
 
Unless you can show what relevance your interest in Dr. Hulsey's accounts..................

You may find this hard to believe but, I'm curious as to why Hulsey seems to have abbreviated his study (as he says in the video).

My feeling is there is simply not enough money to pay for the resources need to complete a full model as was promised.

Simply put. Visions of grandeur with little actual support.

I also find it curious that you don't even acknowledge these things. Like with the Basile study, you just support it on faith.
 
Last edited:
If you bothered to watch the ~16 minute presentation you would know that Dr. Hulsey's investigation is still a work-in-progress.

His initial goal was to determine whether or not it was possible for fire to accomplish what the NIST claimed.

At this point in time he and his research assistants have made the certain determination that there was a zero percent chance that fire led to a the sudden total collapse of WTC7.
His current goal is to find a science-based explanation that does explain the collapse.

He was strongly encouraged to speculate that CD was the cause but he refused, insisting that it was necessary to make a determination based solely on science.

Wait a minute. A clarification here: are you saying his results are that thermal expansion could not have walked the girder off its seat plate or that fire/heat could not have caused the final global release of the building? Because NIST does not state this is what occured.
 
If you have an issue about the fire conclusions, I suggest you focus on where you believe the study was flawed.


So are we to conclude that no one here can pin point flaws in Dr. Hulsey's research and findings?

Have you skipped over a good 30% of the posts in this thread?
Neither you or TSz gave even mentioned the fact that this study simply cannot be examined in any detail.
Hulsey has basically given a speech about his study but has not actually made his study available to, it seems, anyone at all.

Hard to "pin point flaws" when one is disallowed from viewing the research and findings. The only info available is from dang near a year ago now! The issue was brought up in post #3.

Care to comment on that yet, keeping in mind the openness and transparency promised in the beginning?



Now it has been noted that the video is 35 minutes long, Gage takes the stage at 30 minutes in. Yet inexplicably you and TSz have characterized the video as being 16 minutes long. It seems to indicate that while trying to deride debunkers for nit watching this video, you haven't bothered to do so yourselves.

I watched it myself but did not bother watching the clock. I admit I skiped over the parts with Gage at the podium.
 
Last edited:
How can we verify or find flaws in a study that has shown none of it's data.
Well, for starters, there's a flaw of logic: the conclusion doesn't follow from the results. We don't need the data that led to these results in order to determine that.
 
What he needs to do, in order to replace the incumbent hypothesis ("fires made floor assemblies around columns 79-81 fail, leaving thos col's unsupported...") with a new hypothesis, is to actually spell out such an alternative hypothesis ("x pounds of high exexplosives placed on col's/girders/... Y to Z went off and at times t1 to tn and triggered") and demonstrate its viability and plausibility and compatibility with observed reality (e.g. the total lack of audible explosions with high brisance; the absence of any and all steel members showong signs of having been subjected to high explosives; a reconciliation with the exsistance of uncontrolled, fully involved fires in the very areas where many of the heat-sensitive explosive charges and their detonators would have been placed, etc etc etc).
There is one etc. that is important: it must replicate the early motion observed prior to the EPH collapse.
 
Well, for starters, there's a flaw of logic: the conclusion doesn't follow from the results. We don't need the data that led to these results in order to determine that.

That's not necessarily true. The conclusion does not follow from results as we know. ;)
 
Well, for starters, there's a flaw of logic: the conclusion doesn't follow from the results. We don't need the data that led to these results in order to determine that.

clap.gif
clap.gif

In fact the conclusion doesn't follow from the overall logic - the structure of the foundation logic is wrong.

He is following T Szamboti's "New Strategy" of "false dichotomy" - "If I prove you wrong I MUST be right". Proof of "I am right" needs affirmative proof.
 
Last edited:
[qimg]http://conleys.com.au/smilies/clap.gif[/qimg] [qimg]http://conleys.com.au/smilies/clap.gif[/qimg]
In fact the conclusion doesn't follow from the overall logic - the structure of the foundation logic is wrong.

He is following T Szamboti's "New Strategy" of "false dichotomy" - "If I prove you wrong I MUST be right". Proof of "I am right" needs affirmative proof.
I wouldn't even mind that--Their proof that " ..you are wrong.." consists of pointing toward the sky and hollering "Look at that!" then running away when you glance up...
 
who let non-engineers into an elite engineering forum

ZERO chance that the fires caused the collapse of WTC7!

All you non-engineers ...
Are you an engineer? I am an engineer, and your statement is BS. A claim based on bias, paranoia, and gullibility. What engineering school did you go to? Most engineers understand fire and steel, and 9/11 truth has what appears to be a subset of the insane, complacent, or nutcase engineers; with less than 0.1 percent of all engineer.

It only takes a grade school education to know CD is a fantasy born in ignorance. Does the, http://cem.uaf.edu/ , college of engineering know the CD head, http://cem.uaf.edu/cee/people/leroy-hulsey.aspx , is a CT BS artist.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom