Merged Hulsey presents research arguing WTC7 not brought down by fires/University of Alaska

If you bothered to watch the ~16 minute presentation you would know that Dr. Hulsey's investigation is still a work-in-progress.
I did.

His initial goal was to determine whether or not it was possible for fire to accomplish what the NIST claimed.
Saw that, and ok, so test one aspect of one proposed initiations scenario. Got it!

At this point in time he and his research assistants have made the certain determination that there was a zero percent chance that fire led to a the sudden total collapse of WTC7.

,,,, and there we have it, a conclusion that does not necessarily follow from the work done.

His current goal is to find a science-based explanation that does explain the collapse.

Perhaps looking at other fire based scenarios would be the most fruitful. IIRC there are several others already out there from professional engineering organizations.

He was strongly encouraged to speculate that CD was the cause but he refused, insisting that it was necessary to make a determination based solely on science.

Will we be seeing his work and data set any time soon, as promised? You do realize that it is seemingly hypocritical of AE911T to blast NIST for that while having the very same thing going on with their own commissioned study?
 
Yes Tony. From what I have observed in this sub-forum the majority are too lazy to read or watch any presentation that is at odds with their chosen beliefs.

Dr. Hulsey, PHD., SE, Chairman, Dept. of Civil Engineering University of Alaska brings his knowledge and experience as both a structural engineer and a forensic structural engineer to this research.

Anyone honestly claiming to care about the truth behind the sudden total collapse of WTC7 should be interested in what he and his associates uncovered.


Uncovered what? Since it has been determined what cause the collapse of WTC 7, his time and effort is a waste of time.
 
If you bothered to watch the ~16 minute presentation you would know that Dr. Hulsey's investigation is still a work-in-progress.

I do not need to watch -16 minutes of presentation to know that Hulsey is 3/4 of the way through a 2 year project. I can do basic math. Odd though that they should have reached such a far-reaching global conclusion already after studying just one aspect - more on that below.

His initial goal was to determine whether or not it was possible for fire to accomplish what the NIST claimed.

Not according to the original AE911T press release which reads as follows:

"With the models now partly developed, Dr. Hulsey and his team have begun to analyze how the building responds to various conditions. Eventually they will examine the fire-based scenario put forward by NIST, which involves the thermal expansion of long-span beams near WTC 7’s column 79."

Seems to me like they did an unannoucned 180 and prioritized AE911T's agenda of NIST was wrong, therefore no fire.

At this point in time he and his research assistants have made the certain determination that there was a zero percent chance that fire led to a the sudden total collapse of WTC7.

Based on a very narrow focus investigation of just a single scenario? Such a broad global conclusion from such a limited examination seems like a bit of a reach, doncha think?

His current goal is to find a science-based explanation that does explain the collapse.

Just now that's the goal? I thought that was the goal all along?

He was strongly encouraged to speculate that CD was the cause but he refused, insisting that it was necessary to make a determination based solely on science.

While your comment seems purely speculative, I find it entirely plausible given the motive force behind the effort and their particular agenda.
 
Last edited:
You mean we prevent the truth from being exposed by forcing the tony's and other "engineers" to abandon avenues of investigation by asking to see something that they have actually done? Like Tony running to this thread after running away from several others because we ask for a 5 minutes effort on his part (if he had actually don't the analysis he claimed)?

Yes, but apparently that means we're lazy.

Dave
 
Isn't it interesting that some here haven't even watched the 16 minute video but feel okay with making negative remarks about the WTC 7 Evaluation project? If I were to bet on it I would have to say that the only goal of a number of individuals on this forum is to denigrate the project and stifle any reaction to its results.

The reactions to the project by these individuals seem extreme and more indicative of an agenda to stifle rather than getting at what actually caused the collapse.

OK then, what are your thoughts on the WTC 7 Evaluation project so far?

Any concerns?

Do you think the project to date has lived up to the goals and expectations and delivered on the promises outlined in the original press release presented in post #41 of this thread?

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11488386&postcount=41
 
OK then, what are your thoughts on the WTC 7 Evaluation project so far?

Any concerns?

Do you think the project to date has lived up to the goals and expectations and delivered on the promises outlined in the original press release presented in post #41 of this thread?

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=11488386&postcount=41
Why would Tony have any concerns? Hulsey has drawn his conclusion on the same principles that Tony draws his.

I think Hulsey is over his head on what he proposed to achieve. I think they ran out of money and this we be the last we hear from this study.
 
Why would Tony have any concerns? Hulsey has drawn his conclusion on the same principles that Tony draws his.

I'm just interested in a purely objective point of view, since clearly all the rest of us are hopelessly jaded and biased. :o
 
He was strongly encouraged to speculate that CD was the cause but he refused, insisting that it was necessary to make a determination based solely on science.

Is it common and natural for seekers of truth to attempt to subvert the scientific process by strong encouragement to declare a cause that has not been studied?

AE911T would have fit in well with the big tobacco companies in the middle of the last century and how they commissioned "research".

How wonderfully ironic is the oft repeated cry that a new investigation, beyond the self interested influence of government, is required.
 
Last edited:
I'm just interested in a purely objective point of view, since clearly all the rest of us are hopelessly jaded and biased. :o

Originally Posted by Criteria
He was strongly encouraged to speculate that CD was the cause but he refused, insisting that it was necessary to make a determination based solely on science.

No biases to be detected in Criteria though. Shame on you debunkers......
 
Is there a place where the totally open accounting of money is shown? How much has been raised to date for this study?

What was the money used for? Is this a side "job" for Hulsey? Does he pay the grad students for their time? Rent for a office? Computers? tel-Comm?

or is he a full time professor with salary? and using unpaid grad students working on a PhD thesis or similar?

Would the accounting of the cost of the research be part of the transparency?
 
What was the money used for? Is this a side "job" for Hulsey? Does he pay the grad students for their time? Rent for a office? Computers? tel-Comm?

or is he a full time professor with salary? and using unpaid grad students working on a PhD thesis or similar?

Would the accounting of the cost of the research be part of the transparency?
Hulsey is a full time professor. I doubt his assistants are paid.

Likely any money is paying lab time directly to UAF.

I contacted the university and they will be getting back to me with the proper contact person to answer grant information for this project.
 
It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that CD explosives and thermite had nothing to do with the destruction of WTC 7. Remember, fires raged out of control within WTC 7 for almost 7 hours after a huge hole, that spanned several stories, was gouged on the south wall of the building.

Buckling observed by witnesses was another indication that fire was slowly weakening the steel structure of WTC 7, and once again, there was no explosive or thermite evidence found in the rubble of WTC 7 and remember, explosives create a lot of noise and thermite creates extremely bright flashes of light, neither of which was evident as WTC 7 collapsed.

Nice pasta.
 
https://www.alaska.edu/files/counsel/Public-Info-Handout-for-Records-Requests-2010-02.pdf

If anyone wants to make a filing re Dr. Hulsey's communications with AE911Truth, I will reimburse you for any costs associated with the production of documents. (I would make the filing myself, but I'd rather not potentially open myself up to a bunch of real life harassment from AE911Truth diehards.) If Hulsey communicated with AE911Truth about the outcome and progress (including about a predetermined conclusion) of his study, the public has a right to know. Here's to hoping he used email.
 
Last edited:
https://www.alaska.edu/files/counsel/Public-Info-Handout-for-Records-Requests-2010-02.pdf

If anyone wants to make a filing re Dr. Hulsey's communications with AE911Truth, I will reimburse you for any costs associated with the production of documents. (I would make the filing myself, but I'd rather not potentially open myself up to a bunch of real life harassment from AE911Truth diehards.) If Hulsey communicated with AE911Truth about the outcome and progress (including about a predetermined conclusion) of his study, the public has a right to know. Here's to hoping he used email.
I don't really see the point. They are 1.5 years into a two year study. I've inquired as to grant and financial aspects.

What are you hoping to find?
 
I don't really see the point. They are 1.5 years into a two year study. I've inquired as to grant and financial aspects.

What are you hoping to find?

The actual terms of the grant and whether or not AE911Truth played any role in guiding the conclusions to date.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom