How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
The only inflow of money into Bitcoin comes from investors. It contains no assets and generates no profits. Thus, investors pay to get into an economy which is dominated by a small class of users amounting to less than 1% of all, who collectively hold over 50% of all value in the system, yet who've paid nothing to gain entry.

I think this is a very crucial point. In the event that you're right and the original users of bitcoins withdraw their money value from the market, they are essentially going to get 100% of the value of the entire market for putting in 0% of the investment, while the people who collectively put in 100% of the investment will get 0%.

Sounds like a scam to me, assuming this is the plan.
 
They sacrificed stability and sustainability for the apparent purpose of creating overvaluation, and calculated that function to effect an economic bubble.

It's odd, isn't it ? Most economies thrive well under inflation, if such inflation is somewhat controlled. Given my previous post about 100% vs 0%, it's hard to believe the artificial deflation, in addition to all the features of BTC was accidental.
 
Also, the history of bitcoin is kind of hilarious, between the fact that it is hardly cost-sensitive to mine with the silly arms-race going on ("miners" buy computers solely dedicated and engineered to that end)

Since I assume they are buying high-end machines, that's a hell of an investment considering how few BTCs are generated now.

Speaking of, how fast are those things generated as of today ?
 
I'd like to borrow from somethingpsionl0 said that I think might better separate the concept of a scam from a fraud. A fraud is done through outright lying--the money isn't used for what they say it is, for example.

A scam could be defined as something that has a transparent operation but where the implications are concealed.
 
There's apparently a bitcoin forum (bitcointalk) where scamming happens every month or so. There were recently a huge collapse of Ponzi schemes because of the default of a major one (promised 7% a week!). Numerous other "investments opportunities" folded while they supposedly were different operations, "insurances" were not met because it turns out they were invested in the top Ponzi after all, and the man running the big operation (screen name: "Pirate"... I kid you not!) continued to have another "venture" at the side (he's buying GPU cycles to mine Bitcoin and offers 1.2BTC for each 1 mined... in short, a bitcoin laundering operation).
Is this supposed to be something unusual?

My spam folder is full of "get rich quick" scams. Bitcoin holders are just as likely to be targeted by scammers as anybody else.
 
I'd like to borrow from somethingpsionl0 said that I think might better separate the concept of a scam from a fraud. A fraud is done through outright lying--the money isn't used for what they say it is, for example.

A scam could be defined as something that has a transparent operation but where the implications are concealed.
Sometimes the word "scam" is used to describe a scheme that (although above board) nets the schemer money without delivering anything that is particularly useful. The word "scam" in this case is subjective and depends on what you mean by "particularly useful". If that was the context that "scam" is used in this thread I would probably have no problem with it.

However, most of the posters here are using the word "scam" to imply that there is something fraudulent going on (and it is all to do with the true motives of the originators). That position can not be justified.
 
Is this supposed to be something unusual?

My spam folder is full of "get rich quick" scams. Bitcoin holders are just as likely to be targeted by scammers as anybody else.

Are they?
The major "exchanges" sites all seem to have an history of being hacked.
And while bitcointalk may not be representative of all bitcoin users, the number of scams running there is unnerving. The one I mention, by pirate, was supposedly concerning 500.000 BTC. Maybe an inflated figure but we're speaking of roughly 5% of all the BTC circulated (approx. 10m) lost to something barely more sophisticated than a Nigerian prince e-mail: I mean really... a 7% weekly return without any details, for a currency that so far have very few prospects of investments, and all this without any proper paperwork?

The relative "confidentiality" of the Bitcoin system, coupled with the fact currency movements are "final" and can't be overturned does not alleviate those problems, on the contrary.

But heh, as I said, maybe it's not an indictment of the whole system: maybe just of some of the crowd heavily invested in BTC.

Since I assume they are buying high-end machines, that's a hell of an investment considering how few BTCs are generated now.

Speaking of, how fast are those things generated as of today ?

As of June, if what I read is correct, 7200btc / day. Maybe a tad less today.
"Blocks" will be halved somewhere around December, yielding 25 BTC instead of 50 today.

"Butterfly Labs", who apparently sell "high end" mining rig, sell a computer for 15.000$ and has pre-orders for one at 30.000$.
And well, their CEO may or may not have a past...
 
You changed the subject!

The security of bitcoin exchanges has nothing to do with whether scammers are trying to separate bitcoin holders from their bitcoins.

Please.
Did you read beyond this sentence?

As I said the pirate scheme and the whole pyramid that ties into it may have collected 500K btc : do you agree that it is a lot considering the current amount of btc available, lost to a "single" fraudulent investment?

The security of exchanges is not directly the subject but as an outside observer I can't help but to notice that there is some consistency in the problems: Bitcoinica, hacked at least twice for something like 65.000BTC according to reports, and maybe once by its own creator (a 17 year old Chinese...), showed some serious flaws in security and design. The absence of any meaningful guarantee that even a rookie investor would expect from such services paints a bleak picture of the maturity of a large part of the bitcoin market as of today: Bitcoinica and Mt Gox* were/are (resp.) not bit players. Thus I wonder if they are not symbolic of a bigger, systematic problem that you cannot boil down to the fact that a sucker is born every minute.

Yes, I do not pretend any of this is a "scientific" observation: feel free to disagree on how representative this all is, or to counter that the USD/"real" economy is not very different. The later may probably be true.

* I have a problem taking seriously an economy where a major player is a former Magic the Gathering site. Call me prejudiced.
 
Last edited:
Please.
Did you read beyond this sentence?

As I said the pirate scheme and the whole pyramid that ties into it may have collected 500K btc : do you agree that it is a lot considering the current amount of btc available, lost to a "single" fraudulent investment?
Of course I did. You conflated scamming with insecure bitcoin exchanges.

If you want to argue about the scams that involve bitcoin I don't have a counter argument. As long as there is money in any form, there will be scamming.

If you want to discuss the security of bitcoin exchanges then I have a few thoughts about that.

So what do you want to talk about?
 
However, most of the posters here are using the word "scam" to imply that there is something fraudulent going on (and it is all to do with the true motives of the originators). That position can not be justified.


Using basic principles of deduction, one can objectively examine a system—its structure, its design, the manner in which it functions—and conclusively determine its purpose.

For example, one can look at the design and functioning of an automobile and reliably conclude that it's intended as a conveyance to move a person from place to place by means of manual control. Even if one had never seen an automobile before, it would be quite possible to examine all its parts and their functioning in relation to the whole, and reliably determine that it was built to serve as a conveyance. That conclusion is even more obvious if we're able to actually observe the behavior of the automobile while in operation.

Conversely, one can also postulate some of the kinds of features a given system lacks, and make reliable conclusions as to what purposes that system is not intended to serve. For example, the fact that an automobile does not contain a source of clean water, a place to keep food fresh, or a sanitary system might lead one to the conclusion that it was not designed to serve as a domicile. That some people might choose to misuse an automobile as a home and live out of their car, is contrary to the purpose for which the automobile was originally designed. (That too will be evident by their car looking and smelling like a nasty, stinky mess.)

Furthermore, if the system is a human-engineered one, then it's entirely possible to make a reliable assessment of the motivations of the individuals who designed that system. One can make inferences about their technical ability, their knowledge of relevant concepts to its operating environment, and given the right set of circumstances one can even fairly reliably deduce their motives in building the system.

This kind of deductive logic is widely used in most modern legal systems. For example, if a person mounts a shotgun to the edge of a doorjamb and rigs a wire between the trigger and the doorknob in such a way that opening the door causes the shotgun to discharge into the doorway at a height of 4 feet, it is a fair assumption that the creator intended to kill somebody and wasn't just hunting squirrels.

The fact that Bitcoin is set up to operate the way it is, indicates a few things about its true purpose that all the advertising blurbs and cutesy animated marketing videos and informational Wikis fail to mention.

From the way this thing has been set up to operate, it does not appear to operate in the manner that a currency ought to. It lacks some key elements that make currencies appropriate for the purpose of facilitating exchange.

The originators of Bitcoin have set it up to make it very easy for themselves and their closest associates to quickly obtain controlling shares in a totally immaterial economy, then restrict the availability of those shares as more and more people come on board. In other words, they engineered a valuation bubble. Then they began to hype their bubble economy in the media, to lure investors to put actual cash value into the system. What does that tell you about the motives of the originators of Bitcoin?

The originators of Bitcoin have set their system up with no mechanism for stabilizing its value, making investments and exchanges a crap shoot from minute to minute, hour to hour, and day to day. That indicates that either the creators of Bitcoin were totally ignorant of the function and purpose of a currency, or else Bitcoin was never intended to really function as a reliable currency. What does that tell you about the motives of the originators of Bitcoin?

The originators of Bitcoin have also chosen to conceal their own identities from the public. What does that tell you about the motives of the originators of Bitcoin?
 
Last edited:
My spam folder is full of "get rich quick" scams. Bitcoin holders are just as likely to be targeted by scammers as anybody else.


Maybe the word that you're into Bitcoin is circulating among the techno-grifter community.

I never get emails about "get rich quick schemes," unless you count IT recruiters advertising programming jobs.
 
John: I get those e-mails regularily (not the Ponzi ones, but some banker in a country with some 'lost' money to launder and, conveniently, my e-mail address as a potential collaborator. If only I put in some of my own money up front, or give him my details, I'll get hundreds of thousands, or even millions, in short order. If I believed all of them, I'd be a millionaire a hundred times over by now), even though nothing in my internet behaviour has ever marked me as someone interested in those things.
 
Last edited:
You haven't been paying attention to the news for the past year or so, have you?
Wow, talk about a non-sequitur!

The irony is that you are convinced that the price of bitcoins will continue to rise.

Moreover, you maintain that the originators knew that bitcoin would be a big hit. They even had the foresight to design limited growth and divisibility into the algorithm to ensure that its price would rise exponentially for ever!

You are the best ad for buying bitcoins - EVER! :D
 
The irony is that you are convinced that the price of bitcoins will continue to rise.


Where did I say that? I said it was designed to create artificial overvaluation.


Moreover, you maintain that the originators knew that bitcoin would be a big hit. They even had the foresight to design limited growth and divisibility into the algorithm to ensure that its price would rise exponentially for ever!


I never said any of those things.
 
John: I get those e-mails regularily (not the Ponzi ones, but some banker in a country with some 'lost' money to launder and, conveniently, my e-mail address as a potential collaborator. If only I put in some of my own money up front, or give him my details, I'll get hundreds of thousands, or even millions, in short order. If I believed all of them, I'd be a millionaire a hundred times over by now)


Oh, you mean the "419" scams. I haven't seen one of those in awhile. Though I do get lots of spam for medical services, sex services, and trying to sell me gold.

One perplexing email I did receive last week claimed to be from the FBI/DHS, purporting to tell me I won $10.5 million in a foreign lottery campaign and the US authorities suspect possible terrorist involvement.


nothing in my internet behaviour has ever marked me as someone interested in those things.


I was being facetious. It's called a "joke."
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom