How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
If I read correctly the Mt.Gox home page, they have a daily volume of 25.000 BTC traded (maybe the same one several times?).
You must be reading a different MtGox home page than the one I am reading.

At the top of https://mtgox.com/ it says, "Last price:$12.37010 High:$12.45000 Low:$12.12000 Volume:27739 BTC Weighted Avg:$12.36336".
 
You must be reading a different MtGox home page than the one I am reading.

At the top of https://mtgox.com/ it says, "Last price:$12.37010 High:$12.45000 Low:$12.12000 Volume:27739 BTC Weighted Avg:$12.36336".

So?
Is there a significant difference between a rounded figure of 25k and 29k (the number right now) or 26k (roughly the number I saw yesterday when checking)?

But since you are more knowledgeable about bitcoin, do you have an average of the volume for Mt.Gox, or even better for all -major- exchanges? Since that was my original question.
 
So?
Is there a significant difference between a rounded figure of 25k and 29k (the number right now) or 26k (roughly the number I saw yesterday when checking)?

But since you are more knowledgeable about bitcoin, do you have an average of the volume for Mt.Gox, or even better for all -major- exchanges? Since that was my original question.
Ah! When you wrote 25.000 you weren't using a decimal point (we use commas there).

The bitcoin charts show the daily volumes for MtGox. There were a couple of mini-dumps on Aug 17 and 19 of well over 200k BTC which saw the price fall by 20%.
 
Ah! When you wrote 25.000 you weren't using a decimal point (we use commas there).

The bitcoin charts show the daily volumes for MtGox. There were a couple of mini-dumps on Aug 17 and 19 of well over 200k BTC which saw the price fall by 20%.

20% is a pretty huge dip for a currency. I'd hate (or love) to see what would happen with larger dumps.
 
A fiat currency is one that is enforced by government decree and backed by nothing.

A market currency is one that people voluntarily chose to use.

Historically market currencies have been commodities based because this means they can not be infinitely reproduced.

Bitcoins meet all the qualifications of a gold standard and then some.

What happens when people voluntarily use a fiat currency, such as when Saudis use US bucks?
 
It would appear that much of John Albert's objections to bitcoin are worded similarly to that of a blog by Adam Cohen in http://www.quora.com/Bitcoin/Is-the-cryptocurrency-Bitcoin-a-good-idea.

The rebuttals on that site might make interesting reading.


I share most of Mr. Cohen's objections to Bitcoin, but he eventually retracted his contention that Bitcoin is a scam under a significant amount of fire and downvotes from Bitcoin advocates. If you look farther down the conversation, you'll see that I also posted in that thread.

The rebuttals in that Quora question are just more of the same parroted sales pitches, libertarian sloganeering, false assumptions, anti-gubmint rants, logical fallacies, etc. that we've heard from the Bitcoin advocates in this thread.
 
A fiat currency is one that is enforced by government decree and backed by nothing.

A market currency is one that people voluntarily chose to use.

Historically market currencies have been commodities based because this means they can not be infinitely reproduced.

Bitcoins meet all the qualifications of a gold standard and then some.
What happens when people voluntarily use a fiat currency, such as when Saudis use US bucks?


You do realize that he's fundamentally wrong about every single one of those statements...
 
Indeed. I'm just not sure they can withdraw significant amounts at one time, and you seem to imply that I'm right on this.


There's obviously some point at which the price will drop to $0.00. It's happened several times already, most notably after the major exchange "hacks."
 
There's obviously some point at which the price will drop to $0.00. It's happened several times already, most notably after the major exchange "hacks."
If the price of bitcoin ever dropped to zero then the early adopters would get nothing for their efforts. Sure, they could wait for the price to go up again but they would have not have had any advantage over the "late" adopters at that time. The moral issue wouldn't exist.

Of course, the facts don't bear this out. After the Mt Gox scare, the price of bitcoin was decimated over the next five months but it never got to zero and it has been recovering since.
 
Fair enough, that instutes some level of protection, but even so, somewhere in that code must be some form of limitition on the number of bitcoins, otherwise the system would not work
That limitation needs to be protected somehow, I'm not a programmer, but it needs to be there or again, the system would not work.
And the original programmer knows exactly what that is and how it works.

Being open source would make it a bit harder to circumvent this, but I doubt its impossible and if *I* were the programmer I would have this ready before I went public. It needs not be in the open source program of course, it just needs to know how to get in to deceive or modify the program to knock off a few million bitcoins in a second, then dump it on the market.
The conversation has moved on from this, but allow me to address this with an analogy.

I have invented bitping. I provide a vat of 1 million ping pong balls. 10,000 are red, the rest are white. Only the red are valuable. To mine for bitpings, you reach into the vat blindly and pull a ball out. If it is red it is yours to keep, if white, you toss the ball back in the vat.

So, at first the mining goes fast - roughly every 100th try yields a red ball. But as time goes on the # of red balls declines, while the # of white balls stays the same. Before long it takes 1000 tries before you get a red ball. After awhile it takes 2000 tries. Eventually, when the number of red balls is very low, it takes close to a million tries to get a red ball. Finally, no matter how many times you reach into that vat, you will never pull out more than 10,000 balls.

This is an analogy: of course it would be easy to manufacture a red ball behind the scenes. That is where the analogy fails.

bitcoin is a numerical algorithm that performs a seach in a defined numerical space. There is no known way to 'instantly' generate 1,000,000 answers in secret. Quick, find me the 1,345,0454,3453,455,545,389,432th prime! Quick! What's taking you so long? I gave you the algorithm to test if a # is the nth prime (let's pretend),so why can't you instantly tell what the 1,345,0454,3453,455,545,389,432th prime is? Because a test for validation is often completely different than generating the result to be tested.

That is not the bitcoin algorithm either, but you see my point I hope? It's a mathematical search in a space that no one knows how to mathematically cheat. Well, it's related to cryptography, so maybe the NSA does, but no one outside of the super secret part of cryptography does. It's costly to compute, but cheap to check for correctness.

Make sense?
 
The conversation has moved on from this, but allow me to address this with an analogy.

I have invented bitping. I provide a vat of 1 million ping pong balls. 10,000 are red, the rest are white. Only the red are valuable. To mine for bitpings, you reach into the vat blindly and pull a ball out. If it is red it is yours to keep, if white, you toss the ball back in the vat.

So, at first the mining goes fast - roughly every 100th try yields a red ball. But as time goes on the # of red balls declines, while the # of white balls stays the same. Before long it takes 1000 tries before you get a red ball. After awhile it takes 2000 tries. Eventually, when the number of red balls is very low, it takes close to a million tries to get a red ball. Finally, no matter how many times you reach into that vat, you will never pull out more than 10,000 balls.

This is an analogy: of course it would be easy to manufacture a red ball behind the scenes. That is where the analogy fails.

bitcoin is a numerical algorithm that performs a seach in a defined numerical space. There is no known way to 'instantly' generate 1,000,000 answers in secret. Quick, find me the 1,345,0454,3453,455,545,389,432th prime! Quick! What's taking you so long? I gave you the algorithm to test if a # is the nth prime (let's pretend),so why can't you instantly tell what the 1,345,0454,3453,455,545,389,432th prime is? Because a test for validation is often completely different than generating the result to be tested.

That is not the bitcoin algorithm either, but you see my point I hope? It's a mathematical search in a space that no one knows how to mathematically cheat. Well, it's related to cryptography, so maybe the NSA does, but no one outside of the super secret part of cryptography does. It's costly to compute, but cheap to check for correctness.

Make sense?

I understand the analogy, and like I said, it does provide better security then I thought.
But cryptography is ludicrously easy to crack for anyone with the decoder ring (so to speak)
And somewhere in the computer program of the whole bitcoin system there is a subroutine that has to check wether the ball is red. That subroutine is checking something in the bitcoin code and if you know how to fool that you can pass every white ball off as red.
Now I'm not saying that that is going to happen, but it IS possible.

Its hard to get your hands on a minting press, but that has happened too.

The difference is that counterfeiting money is a crime, and counterfeiting bitcoins is not, hence my worry for it as a commodity.
IF someone were to want to scam everyone else this way, they literally are free to do so, and if I were the one designing the system, I would have made sure I could do so.
 
There was talks during the recent Swiss experiment that a certain number of the "blockchain confirmation" (which confirms which ip has mined bitcoins) were indeed false. That does not mean they were awarded it however.

There's a number of safechecks in theory: difficulty adjusts itself depending on the mining success (every few days, I believe?). Also the expected rate of creation is public and the number of bitcoins is capped. But since it is an "untraceable" commodity, there's actually little to no way to account for all the BTC. If an user dies, deletes its wallet, burn his computer, the bitcoins are lost forever and no one can know.

I totally agree that the system favors early-adopters, and that the creator(s) could probably manipulate the thing even further for his own gain... but there's a very constraining condition there: as we currently discuss, it's not clear the bitcoin economy as it now exists is big or liquid enough to absorb a huge number of bitcoins being put on sale.

Some estimates that Mt.Gox is representing 18% of the current exchange market, which would put the total exchange market at the 125k-150k range (if its volume is indeed 25k-30k daily). Plus the security considerations, difficulties related to specific exchanges (foreign ones)...

If some early-adopters hoarded bitcoins early on, it's still a gamble whether they'll even be able to cash out big.
 
So you're saying that the value of bitcoins is due to the "greater fool" theory? How comforting.


Exactly.

He's arguing that there will always be some supply of suckers who are willing to pay a dollar amount for nothing, on the amoral pipe-dream of scamming some other future sucker at a later date.

It can't continue forever. Sooner or later the thing will run out of steam, and/or its security will be compromised. The law of averages demands it.
 
Not according to bitcoin charts. The price had been skating at under 10c until sometime in October 2010 when it began to rise. By the end of the year, it was trading at 30c.


Pretty sure it dropped below a penny at least a few times during that period. All it takes is for the sellers not to be able to find a buyer at any price for any appreciable length of time.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom