John Albert
Illuminator
- Joined
- Apr 10, 2010
- Messages
- 3,425
Yeah, the total number of Bitcoins that will ever be generated is limited to 21 million.
Last edited:
I thought he meant the 21 million limit.
Yeah, the total number of Bitcoins that will ever be generated is limited to 21 million.
So apparently the creator(s) ran the application long enough to generate a single block of 50 BTC, then shut it down, then started it back up after publishing the app on Sourceforge and publicizing it on the cryptography mailing list. That's weird. I wonder why they wouldn't just start a new blockchain at the same time they took the thing public?
Are the "addresses" in that page basically the unique ID of a Bitcoin "wallet"?
Of course not! Gambling is gambling. It is ridiculous to approve of some forms of gambling (casinos, stock market, etc) yet be morally outraged by another form of gambling like bitcoin.So you really don't care who created the system for what purpose, or where the money comes from, so long as you figure you can turn a profit on it?
I didn't see how divisibility of bitcoin would achieve that when you first mentioned it (unless you expect the value of bitcoin to soar) and I still don't have an explanation.More concisely, that it even further concentrates an even greater majority of wealth into the hands of a few, at the expense of the many.
If you've been saying that, then it's just one more in the long list of things you've been consistently wrong about.
Additionally, the first block did not in fact create 50 BTC; the starting block is used to identify the public blockchain, but its contents does not itself become a part of the chain of valid transactions. The first real 50 BTC in circulation were actually created in the next block, on the day of the release.
Gambling is gambling. It is ridiculous to approve of some forms of gambling (casinos, stock market, etc) yet be morally outraged by another form of gambling like bitcoin.
In spite of your attempts to claim otherwise, there is no deception with bitcoin. There is no "insider trading" or "ponzi" structure or any other dirty tricks.
There were no meetings where the originators discussed ways to make it easier for them to use bitcoin to extract money from suckers.
Nobody had any idea that the market would run with bitcoin when it was first released. Those "early adopters" were essentially playing around with a valueless commodity and became the recipients of a genuine windfall.
I didn't see how divisibility of bitcoin would achieve that when you first mentioned it (unless you expect the value of bitcoin to soar) and I still don't have an explanation.
You have always argued that the 21M limit was an evil plot to engineer "artificial scarcity" and further extract money from the suckers. Why would you suddenly approve of the 21M limit now?
Neither is the stock market but speculating in stocks is gambling in its purest form (not that anybody in the stock market will describe it that way).But Bitcoin is not advertised or promoted as a game of chance.
Yes, that is why it was created and it may yet fulfill that role but ATM the opportunities to buy things with bitcoins is too limited. The only other possible use is as a speculative investment and that seems to be its main role so far.Bitcoin is, at least ostensibly, a "currency."
That is just meaningless drivel. It's been shown conclusively that the originators would gain nothing from creating something just for "a tiny cabal of users who invested nothing initially". The originators would have to mine/buy their bitcoins just like anybody else and would have no special advantage over anybody else.By the way it's been set up to function, that role as a currency is subsidiary at best, to its role as a scheme to attract investors to a market that is easily dominated and controlled by a tiny cabal of users who invested nothing initially.
I agree but "fraudulent" means that you are falsely representing something (concealed risk, fraudulent product, false odds etc). With bitcoin, all of the risks are known (including insecure bitcoin exchanges). Of course, the originators couldn't have possible known all of the risks in advance because it wasn't known how bitcoin would fare in the market.What I find to be morally objectionable is having no qualms about promoting fraudulent "investment opportunities" simply because one sees a chance to make a profit at somebody else's expense.
Bitcoin exchanges that lack proper security are not a "design feature" of bitcoin. They are hazards of the market. Paypal or some form of government regulation might make buying and selling bitcoins safer but current policy seems to be that bitcoin users are on their own. So the risks of dealing with bitcoin exchanges must be factored into the overall risk of getting involved in bitcoins.There is plenty of deception and many, many "dirty tricks" associated with Bitcoin: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=83794.0
You have never successfully argued this. When the differences between bitcoin and the distinguishing features of pyramids are pointed out you claim that bitcoin shares some of the features of a pyramid.As I've pointed out, the entire system of Bitcoin is pyramidic in structure, taking money from many investors at the bottom and redistributing the majority of shares to a tiny group of oligarchs at the top.
That sort of speculation can be made of any company. You never know when a stock price change is due to changing market conditions or if the company plotted some illegal activities.How are so sure there's no "insider trading" going on? There's certainly no SEC or anything to regulate and monitor fraudulent activity.
The extreme volatility in the market, with occasional eruptions due to tens of thousands of BTC getting dumped within a short span of time, would appear to bear out my suspicions of high-level cartel action. (Source?)
I'm not alleging the originators definitely had any such meetings, but how do you know they didn't?
No, the entire system was designed to be a peerless currency. It just happened to be more useful as a commodity for speculative purposes so far.The entire system appears worked out in order to attract investors and then create an economic bubble. How do you account for that? Just happenstance? Maybe they just created a monetary system designed to appeal to currency kooks and drug dealers, that just accidentally resembles a financial scam?
The airplane game was just another way to gamble with your money. If you got in and out quick enough, you could make an eight-fold increase in your money.And the promoters of the "Airplane Game" had no idea how many people would actually pay money for pretend airplane tickets that promised them returns of tens of thousands of dollars. Those people also made a "windfall." Just because some people got rich does not mean the system is not gamed to take advantage of investors for the benefit of the creators.
That still doesn't make sense to me. Splitting a bitcoin worth $10 will only give you two half-bitcoins worth $5 each.The "divisibility" basically allows the shares of the top holders to "split" like stocks, with the potential to exponentiate nearly indefinitely (assuming the overvaluation game doesn't collapse long before that point). Do you really not understand how that degree of wealth disparity might be bad thing in a market economy like this?
Yes, bitcoin would be more successful as a currency if it had perpetual growth.I said there was a 21 million BTC limit to the number of bitcoins created, and you appeared to deny that fact.
ETA: I just went back and reread your statement, and realize I took it the wrong way. You were stating an opinion that you think the 21 million BTC cap is a bad thing, and I totally agree.
It completely defeats the purpose of Bitcoin being a persistent and stable currency for the long term.
Just because the originators failed to design growth in the bitcoin algorithm doesn't mean they did it on purpose to rip off buyers. It just means that they didn't appreciate the desirability of growth. A lot of people think that currency doesn't need to be able to grow (just ask Tippit).As I've said before, I feel that fact further supports my point that the entire Bitcoin system was designed primarily as a homebrewed trading market for the originators to get rich off of.
Then why does the first block credit 50 BTC to an address, just like the rest of the blocks? Are you saying that address belongs to nobody?
Of course not! Gambling is gambling. It is ridiculous to approve of some forms of gambling (casinos, stock market, etc) yet be morally outraged by another form of gambling like bitcoin.
In spite of your attempts to claim otherwise, there is no deception with bitcoin. There is no "insider trading" or "ponzi" structure or any other dirty tricks. There were no meetings where the originators discussed ways to make it easier for them to use bitcoin to extract money from suckers.
That is just meaningless drivel.
They are hazards of the market.
The airplane game was just another way to gamble with your money.
That still doesn't make sense to me. Splitting a bitcoin worth $10 will only give you two half-bitcoins worth $5 each.
The originators would have to mine/buy their bitcoins just like anybody else and would have no special advantage over anybody else.
Just because the originators failed to design growth in the bitcoin algorithm doesn't mean they did it on purpose to rip off buyers. It just means that they didn't appreciate the desirability of growth. A lot of people think that currency doesn't need to be able to grow (just ask Tippit).
Neither is the stock market but speculating in stocks is gambling in its purest form (not that anybody in the stock market will describe it that way).
Yes, that is why it was created and it may yet fulfill that role but ATM the opportunities to buy things with bitcoins is too limited. The only other possible use is as a speculative investment and that seems to be its main role so far.
It's been shown conclusively that the originators would gain nothing from creating something just for "a tiny cabal of users who invested nothing initially".
The originators would have to mine/buy their bitcoins just like anybody else and would have no special advantage over anybody else.
It is incomprehensible that they would set up a "scam" that they couldn't profit from.
I agree but "fraudulent" means that you are falsely representing something (concealed risk, fraudulent product, false odds etc).
With bitcoin, all of the risks are known (including insecure bitcoin exchanges).
Bitcoin exchanges that lack proper security are not a "design feature" of bitcoin. They are hazards of the market.
Nothing about the bitcoin algorithm makes exchanges more or less secure.
Paypal or some form of government regulation might make buying and selling bitcoins safer but current policy seems to be that bitcoin users are on their own.
You have never successfully argued this.
When the differences between bitcoin and the distinguishing features of pyramids are pointed out you claim that bitcoin shares some of the features of a pyramid.
The truth is that it is just person A selling X coins to person B at an agreed price. That's as linear as you can get. It is exactly what happens in the stock market or the trade in any commodity.
Of course, like any commodity with a limited supply, bitcoin can be cornered in the market and it appears that this is the case.
This does not mean that bitcoin was designed to be a cornered commodity and it doesn't make bitcoin a ponzi or pyramid scheme.
That sort of speculation can be made of any company.
You never know when a stock price change is due to changing market conditions or if the company plotted some illegal activities.
All we know is that it is (theoretically) possible for the top 1% of bitcoin holders to act as a cartel to control the price of bitcoins.
No, the entire system was designed to be a peerless currency. It just happened to be more useful as a commodity for speculative purposes so far.
The airplane game was just another way to gamble with your money. If you got in and out quick enough, you could make an eight-fold increase in your money.
Most games of chance rely on the average punter being unable to calculate the odds and therefore, being unable to decide if a bet is "fair" or not. If a closed community decided to play the airplane game (this was apparently popular with the monied classes), then everybody had the same chance of winning or losing. This makes the airplane game "fair" unlike anything you will find in a casino.
That still doesn't make sense to me. Splitting a bitcoin worth $10 will only give you two half-bitcoins worth $5 each.
If your claim is that "splitability" is likely to make the value of bitcoins rise faster than otherwise expected then I doubt that I will hear a bitcoin buyer complaining.
Yes, bitcoin would be more successful as a currency if it had perpetual growth.
Just because the originators failed to design growth in the bitcoin algorithm doesn't mean they did it on purpose to rip off buyers. It just means that they didn't appreciate the desirability of growth.
A lot of people think that currency doesn't need to be able to grow (just ask Tippit).
Wait a minute.. he's just dumping it all over the floor?!? What an idiot.
Actually, I don't think that would necessarily hurt you unless you stood in a puddle of it for long enough to get frostbite.
Here's the proper way to cool a CPU using LIN: