How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah, the total number of Bitcoins that will ever be generated is limited to 21 million.
 
Last edited:
So apparently the creator(s) ran the application long enough to generate a single block of 50 BTC, then shut it down, then started it back up after publishing the app on Sourceforge and publicizing it on the cryptography mailing list. That's weird. I wonder why they wouldn't just start a new blockchain at the same time they took the thing public?

No, that's not what "apparently" happened. The starting block cannot be generated by simply running the finished client. It had to be generated via special means prior to the completion of the application and then hardcoded into it before releasing it, so that the client application could lock onto the public blockchain identified by that starting block. (Aside from the official Bitcoin network used for moneykeeping purposes, there can be other Bitcoin networks with alternate blockchains. One example is the Bitcoin Testnet.)

Additionally, the first block did not in fact create 50 BTC; the starting block is used to identify the public blockchain, but its contents does not itself become a part of the chain of valid transactions. The first real 50 BTC in circulation were actually created in the next block, on the day of the release.

Are the "addresses" in that page basically the unique ID of a Bitcoin "wallet"?

The address is a hash of a public key; the corresponding private key may be in someone's wallet (or multiple wallets, or none). The address can be visualized as a number of an anonymous bank account that cash may be deposited into, and a wallet as a list of account numbers and access codes that allow to withdraw money from those accounts.

...

Next, you quote my reply to someone else's question, and react with some questions that seem to be addressed to Bitcoin proponents.
 
So you really don't care who created the system for what purpose, or where the money comes from, so long as you figure you can turn a profit on it?
Of course not! Gambling is gambling. It is ridiculous to approve of some forms of gambling (casinos, stock market, etc) yet be morally outraged by another form of gambling like bitcoin.

In spite of your attempts to claim otherwise, there is no deception with bitcoin. There is no "insider trading" or "ponzi" structure or any other dirty tricks. There were no meetings where the originators discussed ways to make it easier for them to use bitcoin to extract money from suckers.

Nobody had any idea that the market would run with bitcoin when it was first released. Those "early adopters" were essentially playing around with a valueless commodity and became the recipients of a genuine windfall.

More concisely, that it even further concentrates an even greater majority of wealth into the hands of a few, at the expense of the many.
I didn't see how divisibility of bitcoin would achieve that when you first mentioned it (unless you expect the value of bitcoin to soar) and I still don't have an explanation.

If you've been saying that, then it's just one more in the long list of things you've been consistently wrong about.
:confused:
You have always argued that the 21M limit was an evil plot to engineer "artificial scarcity" and further extract money from the suckers. Why would you suddenly approve of the 21M limit now?

Do you post contradictory opinions just to be disagreeable?
 
Additionally, the first block did not in fact create 50 BTC; the starting block is used to identify the public blockchain, but its contents does not itself become a part of the chain of valid transactions. The first real 50 BTC in circulation were actually created in the next block, on the day of the release.


Then why does the first block credit 50 BTC to an address, just like the rest of the blocks? Are you saying that address belongs to nobody?


Gambling is gambling. It is ridiculous to approve of some forms of gambling (casinos, stock market, etc) yet be morally outraged by another form of gambling like bitcoin.


But Bitcoin is not advertised or promoted as a game of chance.

Bitcoin is, at least ostensibly, a "currency." By the way it's been set up to function, that role as a currency is subsidiary at best, to its role as a scheme to attract investors to a market that is easily dominated and controlled by a tiny cabal of users who invested nothing initially.

What I find to be morally objectionable is having no qualms about promoting fraudulent "investment opportunities" simply because one sees a chance to make a profit at somebody else's expense.


In spite of your attempts to claim otherwise, there is no deception with bitcoin. There is no "insider trading" or "ponzi" structure or any other dirty tricks.


There is plenty of deception and many, many "dirty tricks" associated with Bitcoin: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=83794.0

As I've pointed out, the entire system of Bitcoin is pyramidic in structure, taking money from many investors at the bottom and redistributing the majority of shares to a tiny group of oligarchs at the top.

How are so sure there's no "insider trading" going on? There's certainly no SEC or anything to regulate and monitor fraudulent activity.

The extreme volatility in the market, with occasional eruptions due to tens of thousands of BTC getting dumped within a short span of time, would appear to bear out my suspicions of high-level cartel action.


There were no meetings where the originators discussed ways to make it easier for them to use bitcoin to extract money from suckers.


I'm not alleging the originators definitely had any such meetings, but how do you know they didn't?

The entire system appears worked out in order to attract investors and then create an economic bubble. How do you account for that? Just happenstance? Maybe they just created a monetary system designed to appeal to currency kooks and drug dealers, that just accidentally resembles a financial scam?


Nobody had any idea that the market would run with bitcoin when it was first released. Those "early adopters" were essentially playing around with a valueless commodity and became the recipients of a genuine windfall.


And the promoters of the "Airplane Game" had no idea how many people would actually pay money for pretend airplane tickets that promised them returns of tens of thousands of dollars. Those people also made a "windfall." Just because some people got rich does not mean the system is not gamed to take advantage of investors for the benefit of the creators.


I didn't see how divisibility of bitcoin would achieve that when you first mentioned it (unless you expect the value of bitcoin to soar) and I still don't have an explanation.


The "divisibility" basically allows the shares of the top holders to "split" like stocks, with the potential to exponentiate nearly indefinitely (assuming the overvaluation game doesn't collapse long before that point). Do you really not understand how that degree of wealth disparity might be bad thing in a market economy like this?


:confused:
You have always argued that the 21M limit was an evil plot to engineer "artificial scarcity" and further extract money from the suckers. Why would you suddenly approve of the 21M limit now?


I said there was a 21 million BTC limit to the number of bitcoins created, and you appeared to deny that fact.

ETA: I just went back and reread your statement, and realize I took it the wrong way. You were stating an opinion that you think the 21 million BTC cap is a bad thing, and I totally agree.

It completely defeats the purpose of Bitcoin being a persistent and stable currency for the long term. As I've said before, I feel that fact further supports my point that the entire Bitcoin system was designed primarily as a homebrewed trading market for the originators to get rich off of.
 
Last edited:
But Bitcoin is not advertised or promoted as a game of chance.
Neither is the stock market but speculating in stocks is gambling in its purest form (not that anybody in the stock market will describe it that way).

Bitcoin is, at least ostensibly, a "currency."
Yes, that is why it was created and it may yet fulfill that role but ATM the opportunities to buy things with bitcoins is too limited. The only other possible use is as a speculative investment and that seems to be its main role so far.

By the way it's been set up to function, that role as a currency is subsidiary at best, to its role as a scheme to attract investors to a market that is easily dominated and controlled by a tiny cabal of users who invested nothing initially.
That is just meaningless drivel. It's been shown conclusively that the originators would gain nothing from creating something just for "a tiny cabal of users who invested nothing initially". The originators would have to mine/buy their bitcoins just like anybody else and would have no special advantage over anybody else.

It is incomprehensible that they would set up a "scam" that they couldn't profit from.

What I find to be morally objectionable is having no qualms about promoting fraudulent "investment opportunities" simply because one sees a chance to make a profit at somebody else's expense.
I agree but "fraudulent" means that you are falsely representing something (concealed risk, fraudulent product, false odds etc). With bitcoin, all of the risks are known (including insecure bitcoin exchanges). Of course, the originators couldn't have possible known all of the risks in advance because it wasn't known how bitcoin would fare in the market.

There is plenty of deception and many, many "dirty tricks" associated with Bitcoin: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=83794.0
Bitcoin exchanges that lack proper security are not a "design feature" of bitcoin. They are hazards of the market. Paypal or some form of government regulation might make buying and selling bitcoins safer but current policy seems to be that bitcoin users are on their own. So the risks of dealing with bitcoin exchanges must be factored into the overall risk of getting involved in bitcoins.

Nothing about the bitcoin algorithm makes exchanges more or less secure.

As I've pointed out, the entire system of Bitcoin is pyramidic in structure, taking money from many investors at the bottom and redistributing the majority of shares to a tiny group of oligarchs at the top.
You have never successfully argued this. When the differences between bitcoin and the distinguishing features of pyramids are pointed out you claim that bitcoin shares some of the features of a pyramid.

The truth is that it is just person A selling X coins to person B at an agreed price. That's as linear as you can get. It is exactly what happens in the stock market or the trade in any commodity.

Of course, like any commodity with a limited supply, bitcoin can be cornered in the market and it appears that this is the case. This does not mean that bitcoin was designed to be a cornered commodity and it doesn't make bitcoin a ponzi or pyramid scheme.

How are so sure there's no "insider trading" going on? There's certainly no SEC or anything to regulate and monitor fraudulent activity.

The extreme volatility in the market, with occasional eruptions due to tens of thousands of BTC getting dumped within a short span of time, would appear to bear out my suspicions of high-level cartel action. (Source?)

I'm not alleging the originators definitely had any such meetings, but how do you know they didn't?
That sort of speculation can be made of any company. You never know when a stock price change is due to changing market conditions or if the company plotted some illegal activities.

All we know is that it is (theoretically) possible for the top 1% of bitcoin holders to act as a cartel to control the price of bitcoins.

The entire system appears worked out in order to attract investors and then create an economic bubble. How do you account for that? Just happenstance? Maybe they just created a monetary system designed to appeal to currency kooks and drug dealers, that just accidentally resembles a financial scam?
No, the entire system was designed to be a peerless currency. It just happened to be more useful as a commodity for speculative purposes so far.

And the promoters of the "Airplane Game" had no idea how many people would actually pay money for pretend airplane tickets that promised them returns of tens of thousands of dollars. Those people also made a "windfall." Just because some people got rich does not mean the system is not gamed to take advantage of investors for the benefit of the creators.
The airplane game was just another way to gamble with your money. If you got in and out quick enough, you could make an eight-fold increase in your money.

Most games of chance rely on the average punter being unable to calculate the odds and therefore, being unable to decide if a bet is "fair" or not. If a closed community decided to play the airplane game (this was apparently popular with the monied classes), then everybody had the same chance of winning or losing. This makes the airplane game "fair" unlike anything you will find in a casino.

The "divisibility" basically allows the shares of the top holders to "split" like stocks, with the potential to exponentiate nearly indefinitely (assuming the overvaluation game doesn't collapse long before that point). Do you really not understand how that degree of wealth disparity might be bad thing in a market economy like this?
That still doesn't make sense to me. Splitting a bitcoin worth $10 will only give you two half-bitcoins worth $5 each.

If your claim is that "splitability" is likely to make the value of bitcoins rise faster than otherwise expected then I doubt that I will hear a bitcoin buyer complaining.

I said there was a 21 million BTC limit to the number of bitcoins created, and you appeared to deny that fact.

ETA: I just went back and reread your statement, and realize I took it the wrong way. You were stating an opinion that you think the 21 million BTC cap is a bad thing, and I totally agree.

It completely defeats the purpose of Bitcoin being a persistent and stable currency for the long term.
Yes, bitcoin would be more successful as a currency if it had perpetual growth.

As I've said before, I feel that fact further supports my point that the entire Bitcoin system was designed primarily as a homebrewed trading market for the originators to get rich off of.
Just because the originators failed to design growth in the bitcoin algorithm doesn't mean they did it on purpose to rip off buyers. It just means that they didn't appreciate the desirability of growth. A lot of people think that currency doesn't need to be able to grow (just ask Tippit).
 
Then why does the first block credit 50 BTC to an address, just like the rest of the blocks? Are you saying that address belongs to nobody?

The address may or may not belong to somebody; it's impossible to tell. What I'm saying is that the transaction in the starting block is not recognized as valid by the Bitcoin network, for which the chain of valid transactions begins from, but not including, the starting block. So the block appears to credit 50 BTC to that address, but does not really. Making the transaction valid (thus actually creating those 50 BTC) would require a change in the way the network operates - in essence, a change of the Bitcoin protocol.
 
If I was a goldsmith working in some hypothetical medieval town, and I spent all my spare time pounding out little gold disks with faces on them, that would be just fine.

Not so fine when the king decrees that the little gold disks with faces on them are the new medium of exchange and I started making them a long time ago for my own supply, and only just now to trade to everyone else.

Really not cool at all when it comes out that I'm really a court official in disguise, and I had inside information on what the new medium of exchange was and a say in how they'd be made and distributed. In fact I had the king's ear and I showed him my little gold disks and suggested them as the new medium of exchange. Now I'm rich, you're not. That's OK though, I'll barter some of my little gold disks with faces on them to you at whatever price the market will bear. You shouldn't be so angry. I'm just rich because I got in first with my inside information

Oh, and I've got a private deal with the king; I got to made a couple thousand of my own little gold disks right at the beginning, and he's going to cap the supply at just 21,000 so that the value of the ones I made doesn't get diluted.

Of course when you say it isn't fair, I'll just point out that you could have spent your spare time pounding out little gold disks with faces on them if you'd wanted to. That'll make you feel better about it, right?

Oh, but here's the kicker; if you want to make your own little gold disks with faces on them, you can, as long as you use the tools I give you to do it. They're not quite as nice as my own, mind you, but I'll give them to you for free as long as you follow my rules; every so often I get to take the tools back and replace them with ones that don't work as well, so you can't make as many little gold disks each day. When the total supply hits the maximum number, I get to take your tools away permanently.

Oh, wait, this isn't how a currency system works! And here come the peasants with torches and pitchforks! Ooops, gotta go. :D
 
Of course not! Gambling is gambling. It is ridiculous to approve of some forms of gambling (casinos, stock market, etc) yet be morally outraged by another form of gambling like bitcoin.

By what definition of gambling is BTC gambling ?

In spite of your attempts to claim otherwise, there is no deception with bitcoin. There is no "insider trading" or "ponzi" structure or any other dirty tricks. There were no meetings where the originators discussed ways to make it easier for them to use bitcoin to extract money from suckers.

Wait, how do you know this ?

That is just meaningless drivel.

You misspelled "opinion".

They are hazards of the market.

Are you a libertarian ?

The airplane game was just another way to gamble with your money.

I think you're a bit confused as to the definition of gambling.
 
Last edited:
That still doesn't make sense to me. Splitting a bitcoin worth $10 will only give you two half-bitcoins worth $5 each.

No. If it gets split, then it's because there's more people to own bitcoins. Each half bitcoin might be worth 6$ instead, making everybody who held them a bit richer.
 
So, excuse me for the question, but how is bitcoin doing as a currency then, as in a currency to buy stuff, to exchange against goods & services?
Isn't that what it is supposedly for?
 
Last edited:
The originators would have to mine/buy their bitcoins just like anybody else and would have no special advantage over anybody else.

Except the special advantage of mining bitcoins when they were super easy to mine.

Just because the originators failed to design growth in the bitcoin algorithm doesn't mean they did it on purpose to rip off buyers. It just means that they didn't appreciate the desirability of growth. A lot of people think that currency doesn't need to be able to grow (just ask Tippit).

It doesn't mean it for sure, but when lacking that feature provides a tremendous financial incentive for the originators, it makes it rather suspicious.
 
Neither is the stock market but speculating in stocks is gambling in its purest form (not that anybody in the stock market will describe it that way).


Nobody in the stock market will describe it as pure gambling because it's not just pure gambling. Gambling is simply betting on some measure of uncertainty for the chance of acquiring more money. The stock market is far more complex than that and actually serves some positive benefits to the overall marketplace.

The stock market exists to allow public ownership of demonstrably profitable corporations, both to provide an influx of capital for business and to allow stockholders to share in the profits.


Yes, that is why it was created and it may yet fulfill that role but ATM the opportunities to buy things with bitcoins is too limited. The only other possible use is as a speculative investment and that seems to be its main role so far.


Why do you think "the opportunities to buy things with bitcoins is too limited"?

If Bitcoin has such potential as a useful, workable currency, then why do so few merchants accept it? Why doesn't PayPal accept it? Why doesn't Amazon accept it? Why doesn't the grocery store accept it?


It's been shown conclusively that the originators would gain nothing from creating something just for "a tiny cabal of users who invested nothing initially".


Really?

Where has that been "shown conclusively"?


The originators would have to mine/buy their bitcoins just like anybody else and would have no special advantage over anybody else.

It is incomprehensible that they would set up a "scam" that they couldn't profit from.


The originators themselves are part of the "tiny cabal of users" originally allowed to mine huge fortunes of bitcoins while the difficulty was extremely low and competition nearly nonexistent. The originators awarded themselves and their friends an unfair opportunity at the expense of people who would have to buy in with actual cash later.

It's not like they created a profitable company that attracted investors. There's no company at all, no employees, no assets, no profits. All they created is a fake funny money scheme designed to appeal to libertarian gold bugs and other currency cranks, that has proven to be a dismal failure in the purpose for which it was originally created.

Or maybe they were just misguided about economics and actually believed the system they were setting up would work as a currency. Maybe, but looking at how this thing has actually been set up to operate, I seriously doubt they could have been so naïve.


I agree but "fraudulent" means that you are falsely representing something (concealed risk, fraudulent product, false odds etc).


Lots of details about Bitcoin's operation are obscured from the public, simply by virtue of its technical complexity. To understand how it works, one would need to (at the very least) read the whitepaper, which requires some knowledge of arcane cryptography. Then there are the economic implications, which are even more complicated than that.


With bitcoin, all of the risks are known (including insecure bitcoin exchanges).


The full extent of those risks is just becoming evident now, as we see the news of more and more Bitcoin-related scams in the mainstream media. The risks were largely unknown for the investors who got in a year and a half ago when the popularity was just starting to blow up, prior to the "hacking" of Mt. Gox, Bitcoinica, MyBitcoin, etc. Yet we still have people proselytizing Bitcoin as if it's the new economic paradigm that will replace national currency, obviate bank fees, end war, and solve all the world's economic woes.


Bitcoin exchanges that lack proper security are not a "design feature" of bitcoin. They are hazards of the market.
Nothing about the bitcoin algorithm makes exchanges more or less secure.


This argument that you, EGarrett, Tippet, and other Bitcoin advocates keep repeating is based on a compositional fallacy.

Much is made of the security of the crypto used in the Bitcoin algorithm, but that's only partially relevant (at best) to the overall security of the economy as a whole. There's more to that economy than just the software that people run on their computers. If the entirety of Bitcoin was just the software, it would amount to nothing but a computer game with absolutely no purpose in the real world. Without exchanges, bitcoins would be completely infungible with other currencies, hence completely useless. So the exchanges are 100% mission critical services to the operation of this economy. If we're discussing the situation of bitcoins as a "currency" or a "commodity" exchangeable in the marketplace, then you must consider the entirety of the system including the exchanges.

Arguing that the exchange security is irrelevant is like arguing that car crashes are irrelevant to the safety of automobiles because of the reliability of the internal combustion engine.

When you really get down to it, there are 2 root causes of Bitcoin's insecurity: its extralegality, and its lack of central organization. With no applicable laws and no authority to provide oversight or accountability, there's absolutely nothing to prevent theft, graft or fraud at the highest levels of Bitcoin's financial services industry.


Paypal or some form of government regulation might make buying and selling bitcoins safer but current policy seems to be that bitcoin users are on their own.


Why do you suppose that is?

Why do you think none of the major retailers are interested in welcoming Bitcoin?

Why do you think governments are not interested in getting involved with this rogue currency whose enthusiasts hype it as a decentralized, anti-authoritarian, alternative shadow economy that people can use to evade taxes and purchase contraband?


You have never successfully argued this.


By what standards do you determine that?


When the differences between bitcoin and the distinguishing features of pyramids are pointed out you claim that bitcoin shares some of the features of a pyramid.


Yeah, that's what I've always argued.

The only inflow of money into Bitcoin comes from investors. It contains no assets and generates no profits. Thus, investors pay to get into an economy which is dominated by a small class of users amounting to less than 1% of all, who collectively hold over 50% of all value in the system, yet who've paid nothing to gain entry.

Thus, it draws in funds from investors at the bottom and concentrates that wealth among a tiny few barons at the top. The fundamental architecture is just like a pyramid scheme.



The truth is that it is just person A selling X coins to person B at an agreed price. That's as linear as you can get. It is exactly what happens in the stock market or the trade in any commodity.


See, what you're not getting is that Bitcoin is really just a metaphor, a pretense of being a currency. It's not a real currency because it lacks most of the properties of a real currency, most importantly general acceptance. In that sense, it's no more a "currency" than Linden Dollars, WoW gold, arcade tokens, or carnival tickets are "currencies." Its function is so ill-suited and its usefulness is so limited that calling it a "currency" is really a misnomer.

The fundamental difference between Bitcoin and the stock market is that in the stock market, investors buy shares of real companies with real, material assets and demonstrable profits, whereas in Bitcoin there is no company with no assets and no profits.

Likewise, the difference between Bitcoin and commodities trading is that in a commodities market, investors are buying shares in an actual, physical marketable good with real-world use as opposed to an immaterial, symbolic placeholder for wealth.

With Bitcion, there is no physical commodity at all. The entire Bitcoin market system is based on an idealistic fiction with unrealized promise: Bitcoins represent nothing more than a ledger balance of numbers completely disconnected from any real-world value beyond what some small segment of the population happen to believe BTC are worth.

In that sense, a "bitcoin" is not so very different from a "ticket" sold to a "passenger" on the Airplane Game. The primary differences are the metaphor being used ("a currency" as opposed to "an airline,") and the mechanics of the scam (an engineered economic bubble rather than an MLM scheme).
 
Last edited:
Of course, like any commodity with a limited supply, bitcoin can be cornered in the market and it appears that this is the case.


Of course it appears that way! Just look at the way the thing was designed. Bitcoin was specifically engineered to be a cornered market.

All one needed to do was get in early enough and one can wield total control over the entire thing. In other words, the creators and their friends created a homebrewed economy based on nothing, and set themselves up as bank barons of that economy. On top of that, they've convinced quite a few suckers to buy into their little fantasy gimmick with real cash.


This does not mean that bitcoin was designed to be a cornered commodity and it doesn't make bitcoin a ponzi or pyramid scheme.


I can't believe the level of denial at work here.

First of all, I specifically said it's not strictly a Ponzi scheme or a Pyramid scheme, but that it shares characteristics with both of those models. Yet you keep on begging the question with these remarks.

The entire system was engineered to be an easy-to-corner commodity right from the start! Everything about its design points to that purpose: the "mining difficulty factor" that started off "ridiculously easy" but increases exponentially over time, the restricted quantity of total units, the function of the units being "splittable" like stocks...

For what other reason do you suppose they would have engineered this thing with a built-in economic crisis like that?

Come on, man. Use your head. Just try looking at this thing with a critical mind for once.


That sort of speculation can be made of any company.


BUT BITCOIN IS NOT A COMPANY!

It's an engineered economic bubble!


You never know when a stock price change is due to changing market conditions or if the company plotted some illegal activities.


But here with Bitcoin we can actually see how the market is gamed, right from the start!

Look at this graph:

vd2t5k.jpg


What does that tell you about the economics of the way this thing has been planned out by its creators?


All we know is that it is (theoretically) possible for the top 1% of bitcoin holders to act as a cartel to control the price of bitcoins.


We also know its economics are totally bogus, rendering it practically useless for its stated purpose.

We also know it's extremely volatile, given to huge swings in valuation consistent with large scale manipulations of the market.

We also know that all the major monetary exchanges associated with Bitcoin are extremely untrustworthy; at the very least they're outrageously irresponsible, if not outright corrupt themselves.

Worst of all, we know the market is totally unregulated so there are no checks and balances against fraud, theft and deception.


No, the entire system was designed to be a peerless currency. It just happened to be more useful as a commodity for speculative purposes so far.


A "peerless currency"?

Actually, its design is singularly poor for use as a currency, with volatility akin to that of a continuously collapsing economy.

Maybe it's a scam intended to masquerade as a currency, or maybe it's an honest attempt at an alternative currency that's so horribly ill-conceived that it just happens to behave like a scam on accident.

Which seems more likely?

Does it even matter, from a practical perspective?

Just look at how many people have already been fleeced and much money has already been lost to this thing. Do you really mean to tell me that doesn't faze you in the slightest?


The airplane game was just another way to gamble with your money. If you got in and out quick enough, you could make an eight-fold increase in your money.


The Airplane Game was a con game, a scam. If you refuse to recognize that then, I have no reply other than to call your business ethics into question yet again.


Most games of chance rely on the average punter being unable to calculate the odds and therefore, being unable to decide if a bet is "fair" or not. If a closed community decided to play the airplane game (this was apparently popular with the monied classes), then everybody had the same chance of winning or losing. This makes the airplane game "fair" unlike anything you will find in a casino.


No, pyramid schemes are not "fair" at all. The perpetrator who starts the thing has the decided advantage over the people he collects money from. The farther you go down the food chain, the more "unfair" the pyramid scheme becomes. That's the reason why it's generally considered a scam, included in most lists of confidence games, and deemed illegal in many countries.

It sounds to me like you're using this "gambling" excuse as a cheap rationalization for engaging in some really underhanded, predatory business dealings.


That still doesn't make sense to me. Splitting a bitcoin worth $10 will only give you two half-bitcoins worth $5 each.


You seem unfamiliar with stock market economics. The purpose of stock splits is to increase liquidity in times of extremely high valuation, in order to maintain upward momentum during a stock run.


If your claim is that "splitability" is likely to make the value of bitcoins rise faster than otherwise expected then I doubt that I will hear a bitcoin buyer complaining.


My complaint is that it allows the wealth to continue consolidating in the hands of the holders even after the money supply has stagnated.


Yes, bitcoin would be more successful as a currency if it had perpetual growth.


Limiting its growth is a detrimental flaw. Not only did they limit its growth, but by capping its availability, they've deliberately built an economic crisis into their market.


Just because the originators failed to design growth in the bitcoin algorithm doesn't mean they did it on purpose to rip off buyers. It just means that they didn't appreciate the desirability of growth.


They sacrificed stability and sustainability for the apparent purpose of creating overvaluation, and calculated that function to effect an economic bubble.


A lot of people think that currency doesn't need to be able to grow (just ask Tippit).


"Ask Tippet"?

I'd just as soon ask Bill O'Reilly about celestial mechanics, or ask the Insane Clown Posse to explain the Standard Model of particle physics.
 
Last edited:
So, did some search on the thing, and well, the real currency use seems still to be buying drugs.

Also, the history of bitcoin is kind of hilarious, between the fact that it is hardly cost-sensitive to mine with the silly arms-race going on ("miners" buy computers solely dedicated and engineered to that end) and the few exchanges sites being hacked over and over again, sometimes it would seem by their own creator... but no-one called the police despite a six figure amount in USD of BTC being stolen, and most everyone readily accept the explanation of the possible culprit about a Chinese relic salesman having access to his accounts (!)

Bitcoin sounds like an interesting experiment, from which we may learn something, but future currency it is not.

EDIT: Holy ****
Youtube video of a man "cooling" his Bitcoin mining rig with liquid nitrogen
 
Last edited:
Wait a minute.. he's just dumping it all over the floor?!? What an idiot.
 
Last edited:
Actually, I don't think that would necessarily hurt you unless you stood in a puddle of it for long enough to get frostbite.

Here's the proper way to cool a CPU using LIN:

 
Actually, I don't think that would necessarily hurt you unless you stood in a puddle of it for long enough to get frostbite.

Here's the proper way to cool a CPU using LIN:


Read that it can be dangerous. It's also a totally inefficient way of cooling a computer which may suffer from the treatment.

On another note:
There's apparently a bitcoin forum (bitcointalk) where scamming happens every month or so. There were recently a huge collapse of Ponzi schemes because of the default of a major one (promised 7% a week!). Numerous other "investments opportunities" folded while they supposedly were different operations, "insurances" were not met because it turns out they were invested in the top Ponzi after all, and the man running the big operation (screen name: "Pirate"... I kid you not!) continued to have another "venture" at the side (he's buying GPU cycles to mine Bitcoin and offers 1.2BTC for each 1 mined... in short, a bitcoin laundering operation).

People on a message board, sometimes very young and with no credentials are able to convince people to "invest" their bitcoins in the several thousands (which could translate to a reasonable sum in USD) without any sort of business plan whatsoever, all this while giving updates on IRC. And they learn slowly (Warning: Not Safe For Sanity). The mind boggles.

This may not be an indictment of bitcoin itself, but it is not totally unexpected considering how little real-life use it has so far.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom