How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
The code is open-source. Anyone can download and inspect it. If there's anything untoward in the code, I'd expect it would certainly have been discovered by now.

Furthermore, Bitcoin is a distributed system, not just a single program running in a centralized location. That means that the work of maintaining the ledger of all bitcoins in existence and the transactions among them is shared by all nodes on the network. If somebody started generating loads of BTC on their own, the ledger would be thrown off balance and that would get noticed by everyone watching the markets and the system (and believe me, there are a lot of people watching this system).

You're not wrong to distrust the Bitcoin creators and other high-level players. They've created a mini-economy that is easily dominated, and engineered with decreasing availability so their "currency" will artificially increase in value like a stock bubble; not only that, but it's a system with an insane amount of wealth/power disparity. That alone is a good enough reason to be very suspicious.

Fair enough, that instutes some level of protection, but even so, somewhere in that code must be some form of limitition on the number of bitcoins, otherwise the system would not work
That limitation needs to be protected somehow, I'm not a programmer, but it needs to be there or again, the system would not work.
And the original programmer knows exactly what that is and how it works.

Being open source would make it a bit harder to circumvent this, but I doubt its impossible and if *I* were the programmer I would have this ready before I went public. It needs not be in the open source program of course, it just needs to know how to get in to deceive or modify the program to knock off a few million bitcoins in a second, then dump it on the market.
 
Fair enough, that instutes some level of protection, but even so, somewhere in that code must be some form of limitition on the number of bitcoins, otherwise the system would not work
That limitation needs to be protected somehow, I'm not a programmer, but it needs to be there or again, the system would not work.
And the original programmer knows exactly what that is and how it works.

The limitation is built into the algorithm. You can of course write your own implementation that does anything you want, breaking any limitations whatsoever - however, anything produced by your implementation will fail verification and thus be rejected by all the other nodes in the network that do work according to the the publicly specified algorithm.

Being open source would make it a bit harder to circumvent this, but I doubt its impossible and if *I* were the programmer I would have this ready before I went public. It needs not be in the open source program of course, it just needs to know how to get in to deceive or modify the program to knock off a few million bitcoins in a second, then dump it on the market.

The problem is how to modify the programs that are running on the other nodes of the network. You can generate anything you like on your computer, but the transaction must be verified by other nodes in the network in order to be accepted.

There isn't even a single implementation of the program - there are all sorts of implementations by different people, and the only thing they have in common is that they all implement the same Bitcoin algorithm (because if they didn't, they wouldn't accept each other's results).
 
I don't think that's possible. From what I understand, the network tracks the transaction history of all bitcoins since creation to the last owner. Indeed, having public and verified transaction history is required for any bitcoins to be accepted as legitimate by the network.

Save for some cryptographic weakness in the algorithm, nobody can be secretly holding any "private" bitcoins that the rest of the network wouldn't know about - simply because being "known about" is what validates the bitcoins in the first place.


I know.

I didn't say they held "'private' bitcoins that the rest of the network [doesn't] know about."

It's a known fact that the Bitcoin blockchain was created and mining was done for 6 days prior to the application being posed on Sourceforge and publicized on the cryptography mailing list.

I just admitted to not knowing how many coins were created during those 6 days, and what their distribution was.

BTW, the maximum number of Bitcoins that will ever be created is 21 million. The algorithm will stop producing them at that point. However, a large number of BTC have already been lost due to various system failures, so the total BTC in existence will never even reach that point.
 
Last edited:
I don't think that's possible. From what I understand, the network tracks the transaction history of all bitcoins since creation to the last owner.

...from the point that the system went online. We have no idea what happened before it did. It's still irrelevant, as they could have used the algorithm to simply rack up a whole bunch of bitcoins.
 
BTW, the maximum number of Bitcoins that will ever be created is 21 million.

That's a very small number, considering the number of people who would use it if it became mainstream. It almost seems as though the creators will cash in once the limit has almost been reached.

Which brings up a question: how many BTC have yet been mined ?
 
That's a very small number, considering the number of people who would use it if it became mainstream. It almost seems as though the creators will cash in once the limit has almost been reached.


The limited number of bitcoins is handled by—get this—subdivision of each BTC into decimal places, like the splitting of stocks. So even after the system is done generating new BTC and the entire motivation for "mining" dries up, the wealthiest BTC holders will still be able to capitalize off the income from investors (assuming any speculative interest still persists by that point).

It's yet another feature of the system that blatantly (and exponentially) favors the wealth of the richest few percent of BTC holders.


Which brings up a question: how many BTC have yet been mined ?


Total # of bitcoins in circulation: http://blockexplorer.com/q/totalbc
 
Last edited:
It's a known fact that the Bitcoin blockchain was created and mining was done for 6 days prior to the application being posed on Sourceforge and publicized on the cryptography mailing list.

I just admitted to not knowing how many coins were created during those 6 days, and what their distribution was.

I see. Apparently, in the first 6 days, no bitcoins were created at all. The first block was generated on January 3, 2009, and the next block on January 9, which is the date that Bitcoin was released. Since then, the amount of bitcoins mined has been rising steadily.

BTW, the maximum number of Bitcoins that will ever be created is 21 million. The algorithm will stop producing them at that point. However, a large number of BTC have already been lost due to various system failures, so the total BTC in existence will never even reach that point.

I guess that depends on the definition of "existence" :). The bitcoins will exist all right; it's just that some of them will remain locked in accounts that nobody has the key to unlock. However, there is no way to distinguish those from bitcoins locked in accounts that the owner can access, but doesn't choose to.
 
Last edited:
...from the point that the system went online. We have no idea what happened before it did. It's still irrelevant, as they could have used the algorithm to simply rack up a whole bunch of bitcoins.

Bitcoins are those and only those bitcoins that were mined and have been tracked since the system went online. A "bitcoin" only exists because the network knows its full history. That's the very core of bitcoin validation. There are, by definition, no bitcoins outside the public database of transactions.

Save for exploiting some yet-unknown cryptographic weakness, there is no real way to covertly generate or own bitcoins.
 
Bitcoins are those and only those bitcoins that were mined and have been tracked since the system went online. A "bitcoin" only exists because the network knows its full history. That's the very core of bitcoin validation. There are, by definition, no bitcoins outside the public database of transactions.

Save for exploiting some yet-unknown cryptographic weakness, there is no real way to covertly generate or own bitcoins.

I really whish I'd have a better understanding of how the system works - but it seems that at one stage, it relies on the majority of machines to be correct about the history of each bitcoin.

What would happen if a majority of machines was under the control of people that wanted to abuse the system?

I am not sure if there is a trivial exploit for that situation, and then, it is an unlikely scenario - but it could be done.
 
Bitcoins are those and only those bitcoins that were mined and have been tracked since the system went online. A "bitcoin" only exists because the network knows its full history. That's the very core of bitcoin validation. There are, by definition, no bitcoins outside the public database of transactions.

Save for exploiting some yet-unknown cryptographic weakness, there is no real way to covertly generate or own bitcoins.

Well that's at least slightly reassuring.

I'm still not too keen on the 21 million limit.
 
I really whish I'd have a better understanding of how the system works - but it seems that at one stage, it relies on the majority of machines to be correct about the history of each bitcoin.

What would happen if a majority of machines was under the control of people that wanted to abuse the system?

The algorithm is designed in such a way that in order to endanger the security of system, one would need to get a majority of the computing power in the network. The proponents claim that this is not feasible and becomes increasingly less so as more and more computing power is thrown into mining bitcoins.

If they're wrong and someone does pull that off anyway, there are additional design features meant to limit the extent of what the attacker could do while in control - for example, they still could not convince legitimate network nodes to accept as valid any transactions blatantly breaking the rules, such as someone suddenly mining lots of coins or spending coins that are not theirs. They could, however, disrupt the network and get away with some kinds of fraudulent operations (such as making a transaction appear confirmed and then undoing it anyway).

This, of course, does not preclude someone discovering some security flaw in the scheme that was previously unthought of.
 
I see. Apparently, in the first 6 days, no bitcoins were created at all. The first block was generated on January 3, 2009, and the next block on January 9, which is the date that Bitcoin was released. Since then, the amount of bitcoins mined has been rising steadily.
I never bothered to research this aspect of bitcoin because it doesn't seem particularly relevant to me who currently owns the bitcoins.

However the links show that the originators of bitcoin had no advantage over the early adopters and that these early adopters were mining/purchasing bitcoins without knowing whether the market would assign any value to these bitcoins.

As for the marketing hype about "bringing down big brother government", this is how Satoshi first announced it:
Announcing the first release of Bitcoin, a new electronic cash
system that uses a peer-to-peer network to prevent double-spending.
It's completely decentralized with no server or central authority.

There is a lot less to this "scam" than many are making out.
 
The limited number of bitcoins is handled by—get this—subdivision of each BTC into decimal places, like the splitting of stocks. So even after the system is done generating new BTC and the entire motivation for "mining" dries up, the wealthiest BTC holders will still be able to capitalize off the income from investors (assuming any speculative interest still persists by that point).
I gather that your objection here is that when the price of a bitcoin becomes beyond the reach of the average investor, they can still be "sucked in" by buying a fraction of a bitcoin.
 
Apparently, in the first 6 days, no bitcoins were created at all. The first block was generated on January 3, 2009, and the next block on January 9, which is the date that Bitcoin was released. Since then, the amount of bitcoins mined has been rising steadily.


So apparently the creator(s) ran the application long enough to generate a single block of 50 BTC, then shut it down, then started it back up after publishing the app on Sourceforge and publicizing it on the cryptography mailing list. That's weird. I wonder why they wouldn't just start a new blockchain at the same time they took the thing public?

Are the "addresses" in that page basically the unique ID of a Bitcoin "wallet"?


The algorithm is designed in such a way that in order to endanger the security of system, one would need to get a majority of the computing power in the network. The proponents claim that this is not feasible and becomes increasingly less so as more and more computing power is thrown into mining bitcoins.


But why would more and more power be poured into mining in the coming years, when the system itself is designed to make it less and less profitable as time goes on?

The competition has already rendered mining completely out of the reach of individuals and smaller groups. As the "difficulty factor" continues to increase at an exponential rate, the preprogrammed economics of artificial scarcity will render mining unprofitable for even the larger mining concerns. As they continue to drop out of the business, the diversity of interests will collapse and the BTC mining industry will inevitably consolidate into a handful of entities, or perhaps even just one. So much for Bitcoin being a "decentralized, distributed system" after all.

Even at this early stage of the game, we already have a single mining concern (DeepBit) handling over 33% of all transactions on the entire Bitcoin network.


If they're wrong and someone does pull that off anyway, there are additional design features meant to limit the extent of what the attacker could do while in control - for example, they still could not convince legitimate network nodes to accept as valid any transactions blatantly breaking the rules, such as someone suddenly mining lots of coins or spending coins that are not theirs. They could, however, disrupt the network and get away with some kinds of fraudulent operations (such as making a transaction appear confirmed and then undoing it anyway).


From the Bitcoin FAQ:
Attacker has a lot of computing power

An attacker that controls more than 50% of the network's computing power can, for the time that he is in control, exclude and modify the ordering of transactions. This allows him to:
  • Reverse transactions that he sends while he's in control. This has the potential to double-spend transactions that previously had already been seen in the block chain.
  • Prevent some or all transactions from gaining any confirmations
  • Prevent some or all other miners from mining any valid blocks
http://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Weaknesses#Attacker_has_a_lot_of_computing_power​


I've read elsewhere that a new vulnerability in the system (discovered within the last year and a half) can allow these kinds of "Mining cartel attacks" to be perpetrated by transaction handlers with as little as 30% of the total processing power under their command. (To be fair though, I haven't seen any citations or confirmation of that development.)


This, of course, does not preclude someone discovering some security flaw in the scheme that was previously unthought of.


That is bound to happen sooner or later, and a lot of people could lose their shirts when it does.

But for now the exchanges are by far the weakest links in the entire system, and yet the Bitcoin economy would immediately become entirely non-functional without them.

I think that if anything, Bitcoin will end up serving as an object-lesson about the inherent dangers of lawless, extra-legal "independent currencies." If your confidence in the US government (an entity which is under the control of the people at least to some extent) is so low that you can't even trust it to maintain a stable currency (something essential to all, rich and poor alike), then why on Earth would you trust some anonymous group of hackers with absolutely no legal accountability whatsoever?


I never bothered to research this aspect of bitcoin because it doesn't seem particularly relevant to me who currently owns the bitcoins.


So you really don't care who created the system for what purpose, or where the money comes from, so long as you figure you can turn a profit on it?


I gather that your objection here is that when the price of a bitcoin becomes beyond the reach of the average investor, they can still be "sucked in" by buying a fraction of a bitcoin.


More concisely, that it even further concentrates an even greater majority of wealth into the hands of a few, at the expense of the many.

And before you even say it: no, it's not a case of being "jealous."


Haven't I constantly said that the 21M limit is wrong?


If you've been saying that, then it's just one more in the long list of things you've been consistently wrong about.
 
Last edited:
What, you want me to expand on all the things he's been wrong about? I'm not really interested in turning this into a flame war.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom