How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
So what do you want to talk about?

Nothing in particular I guess.
You seem to think that all those are regrettable, separate accidents, which in the big picture are common in the economic system (Bitcoin or not).
Myself, as an outsider, sees a no-small part of the Bitcoin community rife with incompetence, dishonesty or outright fraud; and wonders how much of that may be structural.
 
Wow, talk about a non-sequitur!

The irony is that you are convinced that the price of bitcoins will continue to rise.

Moreover, you maintain that the originators knew that bitcoin would be a big hit. They even had the foresight to design limited growth and divisibility into the algorithm to ensure that its price would rise exponentially for ever!

You are the best ad for buying bitcoins - EVER! :D

Just once in a ******* lifetime, could you PLEASE respond to what someone ACTUALLY wrote?
 
I'm apparently on Psio's ignore list. Could someone find out for me if he's a libertarian or not ?
I apologize for missing this question earlier.

I believe that governments and corporations should not be allowed to get too big but I am no libertarian.
 
Last edited:
Just once in a ******* lifetime, could you PLEASE respond to what someone ACTUALLY wrote?
I don't know what you are whingeing about. John Albert's posts are too lengthy and numerous for me to respond to line by line (although I did one for your sake).

In view of the statements he makes, it seems perfectly legitimate to me to put it to him that he expects the price of bitcoins to continue to rise. I also believe that it is perfectly legitimate to put it to him that his views are based mostly on moral grounds.
 
In view of the statements he makes, it seems perfectly legitimate to me to put it to him that he expects the price of bitcoins to continue to rise. I also believe that it is perfectly legitimate to put it to him that his views are based mostly on moral grounds.

You could try reading his statements, line by line, before deciding what he thinks. But apparently that, too, is too much for you.
 
I don't know what you are whingeing about. John Albert's posts are too lengthy and numerous for me to respond to line by line.


Your lackadaisical approach to discourse is not my problem. You consistently call me a liar and misrepresent the things I say, apparently without even bothering to read or consider them.


In view of the statements he makes, it seems perfectly legitimate to me to put it to him that he expects the price of bitcoins to continue to rise. I also believe that it is perfectly legitimate to put it to him that his views are based mostly on moral grounds.


What might "seem perfectly legitimate to you" is objectively wrong.

I have never said that I expect the price of Bitcoins to continue to rise. I do not believe the price of bitcoins will continue to rise. I believe the price of bitcoins will continue to fluctuate wildly until they inevitably crash for the last time and become completely valueless.

Although I agree that there is an ethical component to my viewpoint, you are also incorrect to assume it is "based mostly on moral grounds." I have pointed out numerous reasons why Bitcoin is by design a pointless, misguided and destructive endeavor, and an extremely foolish investment.
 
To be honest I kind of fail to see how there could be any meaningful endgame for bitcoin if it doesn't seriously expand its real use as a currency. Apart from buying drugs, and maybe some other activities (strip cams on reddit, I am told...), there's not much you can do with it: even the fabled money laundering scheme seems difficult right now, since at current exchange rate, the whole BTC economy is 100m USD approx. and the exchanges are shaky.

The entire thing only has value insofar you can expect to cash out, at least for now. It will be interesting to see how the mining arms race and the halving of "mined blocks" will affect the market (esp. since the halving should be done in December and "mining-wunderdevice" ASICs should hit the market in the next 6 months): it may actually contract the network and the number of people invested in the economy. Once mining get really difficult, it's up to the transaction fees to entice people in "devoting" computing power: is there enough transactions to actually make that worthwhile?

To be honest, if early adopters indeed have hoarded large amount of the thing, I would expect them to have already cashed out of the thing gradually when the market peaked: BTC went up twice to 30$, is it correct? It's a small market, and a couple of people dumping tons of BTC would surely crash the thing hard. It's what I would have done, anyway: the possibility of a definitive crash is very real...

EDIT: Short version: not sure why bitcoin would appeal to external demand (which will be needed to prop the price) in its current state
 
Last edited:
And two of the majors hurdles comes down to... well, convenience.

Installing the client for a random normal dude seems to be a really long, tedious experience now as it seems you must download the ever-growing archive of all transactions.

I also seem to understand that transactions may take up to ten minutes since they must be confirmed in "processed blocks".

Anyway...
Do we know the daily volume of transactions in bitcoin?
 
Last edited:
As mining becomes less and less profitable, the smaller players will eventually drop out until it eventually becomes dominated by one single player who holds nearly all the computational power (assuming it doesn't completely collapse before that point). Despite the ostensible goal of being distributed and decentralized, everything about the actual economics of Bitcoin appear rigged to consolidate control into the hands of a relatively small oligarchy.
 
It seems a Zurich university (ETH Zürich) has conducted an experiment, claimed all blocks during a short period of time and uncovered a yet undisclosed loophole.
 
To be honest, if early adopters indeed have hoarded large amount of the thing, I would expect them to have already cashed out of the thing gradually when the market peaked: BTC went up twice to 30$, is it correct?

Yeah but can they really manage to withdraw all that money ? Who pays ?
 
Yeah but can they really manage to withdraw all that money ? Who pays ?

That's why I think they would have gradually liquidated their stash over several days (or during peaks). The summer 2011 peak lasted a few weeks over 10 USD, I believe. If you were sitting on inexpensive bitcoins, that's quite a return even at 5$. I would be milking it, myself...

But indeed, I'm not sure you could even drop 100.000btc/day without seriously affecting the market.

I'm no Captain of Industry, so who knows?

EDIT: Zürich must be on something, because they are indeed very successful at mining (or cheating) despite "only" providing 10% of computational power into the fray. Would they exploit double-spending(?) for this, or another thing? You'll find a link to the university paper, if you can be bothered.

The thread itself is a far more humorous read though "We're under attack by the Swiss-watchdog of the filthy fiat money!"
 
Last edited:
It's unclear whether they really "mined" those blocks, or so I would suppose by reading the bitcointalk thread.

Nevertheless, the Swiss university is definitely on something there...
 
Yeah but can they really manage to withdraw all that money ? Who pays ?


Just like in any market, the buyers pay.

Say I want to cash in 10,000 BTC for $USD. I go to Mt Gox and make a transaction to put 10,000 BTC on the market. Let's assume that at the moment BTC are trading at $12 per $USD, so Mt Gox needs to find enough buyers to take possession of my 10,000 BTC. That could mean finding a single person willing to buy $120,000 worth of bitcoins (good luck!), or 10,000 people willing to pay $12 (again, good luck!), or any permutation in between.

Of course there might not even be 10,000 people willing to pay $12 apiece for bitcoins. Maybe I'll only be able to sell off about 100 BTC at that price, before nobody else will pay that much to take them off my hands. So once I've saturated the market, the price will begin to drop. I might find some people willing to spend $11.50, or $10, or $9.80 or whatever. Once the price starts to drop, a selling panic may take hold causing it to fall even further. If the price starts falling too fast some people might try to sell at $9.50, but the exchange rate might drop so far during the course of their transaction that they may end up getting only $8.20 or $5.50, or even just a few cents per bitcoin.

By the time I've ended up selling off my entire run of 10,000 BTC, I might end up getting only like $30,000 USD total for them, but I'll be leaving the market with a 10,000 BTC glut, meaning the price will be really low. At this point I could take some of that $30,000 and start buying back into the market at the new, lower price.

Of course, once I start buying back in, the price will start to rise again due to the sudden demand. Some people may be willing to sell at $2 a BTC, but other BTC traders might hold out for more. Eventually the price will creep back up though it may take days or weeks.

Of course this is a pretty radical example. I'd be willing to guess that the Bitcoin upper classes manage their money far more carefully, "milking" the system as much as possible by waiting until the peak times and then only selling off enough BTC at once to net a modest profit. Do that with small sums regularly enough and you'd probably be able to make a pretty good profits just gaming the market.

Make no mistake though, all the actual cash that the "early adopters" might take out of the market has come at the direct expense of investors buying in later. Because the early adopters paid nothing initially to enter the market, it's all free money to them.
 
Last edited:
Indeed. I'm just not sure they can withdraw significant amounts at one time, and you seem to imply that I'm right on this.

Which begs the question: where are those 10m bitcoins already issued?

As I said, "pirate" was able to scam 500k BTC between Oct 2011 and August 2012, but it is unclear if he cashed some of that. There was speculation that he lost the money... in an USD ponzi scheme :D but who knows?
You also had last year maybe a couple hundred thousand BTC lost to exchange hacks and such.

Where are they and where did they go?

If I read correctly the Mt.Gox home page, they have a daily volume of 25.000 BTC traded (maybe the same one several times?). Last I heard, this was the biggest exchange out there.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom