How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Every confidence game listed in this WIKI involves deception.


Wrong.

Pyramid schemes (for one example) do not always involve deception. The promoters of pyramid schemes usually explain the workings of the scheme in full. You even said yourself that you got into a pyramid scheme knowing full well how it operated.
 
Wrong.

Pyramid schemes (for one example) do not always involve deception. The promoters of pyramid schemes usually explain the workings of the scheme in full. You even said yourself that you got into a pyramid scheme knowing full well how it operated.
That just means that not all pyramid schemes are confidence tricks.

Of course bitcoin is not a pyramid. The essential features (recruiting others to sell bitcoins and needing an increasing supply of new entrants) are simply not there.
 
The only assumption I am making is that the bitcoin technology is holding up.

You can be sure that every man and his dog is trying to make his own bitcoins. However, nobody so far has gotten around the algorithm. That is a testament to the robustness of the technology. That is not to say that the algorithm can't be broken in the future but it is not a big enough threat to make the market sit up and take notice.

Bitcoins themselves might not be incredibly useful but if the algorithm stands the test of time then the algorithm might play a useful role in financial transactions in the future.

But, what stops the designer of the program from editing out the algorithm and dumping bitcoins in the market to cash in on everyone else's money?
Because you still haven't answered that.

And if the answer is nothing but his own conscience, then I have my doubts about the valitidy of the system. Be it all at once, or a bitcoin at a time to string it out, it puts the designer (the top) in the position to take the money of everybody else at his leisure.

If a government does this, it faces repercussions. If you do something similar as a bank or stockbroker you get accused of fraud. If you sell things you do not actually possess the same. But since bitcoin is nothing but the code it is not even illegal to do so.

Or is the fact that that hasn't happened yet a proof that it won't happen in the future?
 
The mining difficulty is not controlled by anybody. It increases in response to the number of computers doing the mining.

The fact that it rewards those with the most computing power is probably the reason that the ownership of bitcoins is so concentrated.

I wasn't aware of that and can't find clear documentation on that point, however if it is indeed the "number of computers doing the mining" then it is manipulable. Further it is not related to any economic quantity that we should expect to be used to control currency. We want quantity of Currency to match production, not be independent of it.
 
Last edited:
Somebody else who quotes my answer to a question then asks the same identical question again. :boggled:

Your answer was that the algorithm so far wasnt broken.
But breaking the algorithm means that someone other than the designer is trying to hack it.

By definition the designer does not NEED to break the algorithm, he has the source code/program and can edit this as he wishes.

So, no, you did not answer that particular question at all.
 
I wasn't aware of that and can't find clear documentation on that point, however if it is indeed the "number of computers doing the mining" then it is manipulable.
The only manipulable aspect of bitcoin mining is who ends up with the packet. The rest is up to the market.

Further it is not related to any economic quantity that we should expect to be used to control currency. We want quantity of Currency to match production, not be independent of it.
That is why bitcoin can't be a national currency. Even if it were to operate side by side with a national currency (merchants accepting payments in either national currency or bitcoins) it could harm the national currency. Since bitcoin would be seen as inflation resistant, most people would rather keep their money in bitcoin format than leave it in an inflation prone bank account where the meagre interest the bank pays is taxed.

Of course, the level of mistrust in bitcoin is too high for this to be a reality any time in the near future.
 
Your answer was that the algorithm so far wasnt broken.
But breaking the algorithm means that someone other than the designer is trying to hack it.

By definition the designer does not NEED to break the algorithm, he has the source code/program and can edit this as he wishes.

So, no, you did not answer that particular question at all.
The algorithm is available to anybody who can reverse engineer software. Bitcoin is a fully decentralized system meaning that there is no central computer where you can "change a few lines of code".

So the designer has no advantage over anybody else when it comes to trying to generate his own bitcoins.

There are other technical reasons why the algorithm is unlikely to get cracked but you will disagree with me no matter what.
 
The algorithm is available to anybody who can reverse engineer software. Bitcoin is a fully decentralized system meaning that there is no central computer where you can "change a few lines of code".

So the designer has no advantage over anybody else when it comes to trying to generate his own bitcoins.

There are other technical reasons why the algorithm is unlikely to get cracked but you will disagree with me no matter what.

Why would the designer need to crack the algorithm? What stops him from generating as many bitcoins as he likes?
 
The algorithm is available to anybody who can reverse engineer software. Bitcoin is a fully decentralized system meaning that there is no central computer where you can "change a few lines of code".

So the designer has no advantage over anybody else when it comes to trying to generate his own bitcoins.

There are other technical reasons why the algorithm is unlikely to get cracked but you will disagree with me no matter what.

Cracked I will agree on, but why do you find it so hard that the person who programmed the algorithm can also program an algorithm that rewards him, and only him with untold numbers of bitcoins?
There is no need for a central computer, just his own.

I get the feeling you act as if a piece of software is somehow inviolate.
But its a stupid set of lines of code, and a programmer can make them do what HE wants, not what everyone else wants.

The hard bit in bitcoins is the algorithm that makes it more diffucult each time a bitcoin is generated to get a new one. Someone put that in there. So someone knows how to circumvent that. And if I were that someone I would wait until I thought I could get the maximum profit and then do exactly that.
 
The hard bit in bitcoins is the algorithm that makes it more diffucult each time a bitcoin is generated to get a new one. Someone put that in there. So someone knows how to circumvent that. And if I were that someone I would wait until I thought I could get the maximum profit and then do exactly that.

I am not sure I completely understand the process of bitcoin generation, but it looks like that wouldn't be possible. I don't understand how it works, but the creation of a new bitcoin would have to be confirmed by the rest of the machines in the network, or at least by a majority of those machines. I think.

Setting up one machine to churn out "bitcoins" is not how it seems to be working.
 
Cracked I will agree on, but why do you find it so hard that the person who programmed the algorithm can also program an algorithm that rewards him, and only him with untold numbers of bitcoins?
There is no need for a central computer, just his own.

I get the feeling you act as if a piece of software is somehow inviolate.
But its a stupid set of lines of code, and a programmer can make them do what HE wants, not what everyone else wants.

The hard bit in bitcoins is the algorithm that makes it more diffucult each time a bitcoin is generated to get a new one. Someone put that in there. So someone knows how to circumvent that. And if I were that someone I would wait until I thought I could get the maximum profit and then do exactly that.
I think he wouldn't even have to do that.
The evidence is in the way it gets harder to generate more bitcoins when there are more bitcoins in existence and when there are more computers in the network.
How about day one? When there might have been 1 computer, or 2 if the algoritm really needs a network. How easy was the generating of bitcoins starting with the very first batch?
One batch every hour? Every minute? Every second? Faster?
That's what I would do. Run it in my own home first and when the generating of batches would be a few hours apart set it free on the world. That way other early entrants also get a nice amount of bitcoins that will suck in other people. All the time the very first batch of generated bitcoins get more and more valuable. And that batch is what it is all about. No other batches count.
 
Last edited:
Of course, the level of mistrust in bitcoin is too high for this to be a reality any time in the near future.

I would say that bitcoin is too insecure, not that the level of mistrust is too high. The mistrust is well-founded on its insecurity. That insecurity comes from the fragility of the wallet file and lack of recourse if your stuff is lost or stolen.

The algorithm is available to anybody who can reverse engineer software. Bitcoin is a fully decentralized system meaning that there is no central computer where you can "change a few lines of code".

So the designer has no advantage over anybody else when it comes to trying to generate his own bitcoins.

My understanding of the system is that you are correct about this, though they did have a huge advantage in the first weeks.
 
I am not sure I completely understand the process of bitcoin generation, but it looks like that wouldn't be possible. I don't understand how it works, but the creation of a new bitcoin would have to be confirmed by the rest of the machines in the network, or at least by a majority of those machines. I think.

Setting up one machine to churn out "bitcoins" is not how it seems to be working.

And you think the main programmer cannot circumvent the security system he himself implemented?

I'd say that is the lie that makes the whole setup a scam.
The premise is that there is a finite amount of bitcoins, of which there never will be more. And the person claiming this is the very person that programmed that limit in and is in the position to circumvent that limit himself.
All the while saying 'Trust ME, not the banks'
 
That just means that not all pyramid schemes are confidence tricks.


But you just said... oh, never mind. It's not even worth it to point out all the inconsistencies in your arguments. I have better things to do.


Of course bitcoin is not a pyramid. The essential features (recruiting others to sell bitcoins and needing an increasing supply of new entrants) are simply not there.


Once again, I never said it was a classic pyramid scheme. I said it shares some common characteristics of a pyramid scheme, especially the collection of wealth from new investors at the bottom, redistribution of that wealth, and concentration of the wealth among the creators and early adopters at the top.



Or is the fact that that hasn't happened yet a proof that it won't happen in the future?


It actually may have happened numerous times already. The Bitcoin market has been a pretty bumpy ride. As long as there are suckers ready to buy back into the market when the price is low, it will just keep on going.


I wasn't aware of that and can't find clear documentation on that point, however if it is indeed the "number of computers doing the mining" then it is manipulable. Further it is not related to any economic quantity that we should expect to be used to control currency. We want quantity of Currency to match production, not be independent of it.


Yeah, the "difficulty" is adjusted every time a new "block" of bitcoins is generated. It's adjusted to account for the total global amount of processing power being applied to the hashing algorithm, and also ramped upward on some exponential basis according to the time factor.


Your answer was that the algorithm so far wasnt broken.
But breaking the algorithm means that someone other than the designer is trying to hack it.

By definition the designer does not NEED to break the algorithm, he has the source code/program and can edit this as he wishes.

So, no, you did not answer that particular question at all.


Everyone can have the source code. It's an open-source software project. You can download the source code from here.

As others have pointed out, the system is distributed, self-governing and self-protected by strong encryption. All nodes on the Bitcoin network are constantly receiving an updated ledger of all transactions, including all new bitcoins being created. The inner-workings of the system are well understood by a lot of programmers, many of whom have been poring over the code for years now. If the creator(s) had installed some hidden "backdoor" in the code to allow himself to generate BTC willy-nilly, I'm sure some astute C++ programmer would have discovered it by now.


I think he wouldn't even have to do that.
The evidence is in the way it gets harder to generate more bitcoins when there are more bitcoins in existence and when there are more computers in the network.
How about day one? When there might have been 1 computer, or 2 if the algoritm really needs a network. How easy was the generating of bitcoins starting with the very first batch?
One batch every hour? Every minute? Every second? Faster?


Exactly. Maybe a handful of creators generated millions of BTC for themselves within those first 6 days before the thing ever went public. Who knows?


That's what I would do. Run it in my own home first and when the generating of batches would be a few hours apart set it free on the world. That way other early entrants also get a nice amount of bitcoins that will suck in other people. All the time the very first batch of generated bitcoins get more and more valuable. And that batch is what it is all about. No other batches count.


Well there's also the problem of the mining/transaction processing becoming concentrated into fewer and fewer hands. Right now a single mining pool called DeepBit is so huge that it alone processes over a third of all BTC transactions worldwide. With processing power becoming more and more lopsided, it's only a matter of time before somebody accures enough to upset the balance and breaks the algorithm, allowing them to create BTC at their own will.

The whole "computational brute-force vs. greed" is just a flawed model from the get-go. It's a waste of resources and it's ultimately doomed to fail, with disastrous consequences fro anyone caught in the market when that happens.
 
And you think the main programmer cannot circumvent the security system he himself implemented?

I actually believe this to be true. At least, the changes would not be trivial, and they would have to be done on the majority of computers that are in the network.

I'd say that is the lie that makes the whole setup a scam.
The premise is that there is a finite amount of bitcoins, of which there never will be more. And the person claiming this is the very person that programmed that limit in and is in the position to circumvent that limit himself.
All the while saying 'Trust ME, not the banks'

My understanding of the system is very limited - but it looks to me like there cannot be an arbitrarily high number of bitcoins in the system.

Say you define a bitcoin as a file that has a 6-digit serial number. You can only ever have a million of these files. Changing your own program and your own computer to use 7 or 8 digit serial numbers will not help you, because no other machine would accept those bit-coins.
 
I would say that bitcoin is too insecure, not that the level of mistrust is too high. The mistrust is well-founded on its insecurity. That insecurity comes from the fragility of the wallet file and lack of recourse if your stuff is lost or stolen.


I'd say that by far, the weakest link in the chain is the exchanges. They just keep on getting "hacked" (assuming they're not just perpetrating fraud on their own; we have no way of knowing) to the tune of tens and hundreds of thousands worth of BTC. The system is just too unreliable and the people involved are far too untrustworthy, because there's absolutely no central authority to maintain oversight and ensure accountability.
 
And you think the main programmer cannot circumvent the security system he himself implemented?

I'd say that is the lie that makes the whole setup a scam.
The premise is that there is a finite amount of bitcoins, of which there never will be more. And the person claiming this is the very person that programmed that limit in and is in the position to circumvent that limit himself.
All the while saying 'Trust ME, not the banks'


The code is open-source. Anyone can download and inspect it. If there's anything untoward in the code, I'd expect it would certainly have been discovered by now.

Furthermore, Bitcoin is a distributed system, not just a single program running in a centralized location. That means that the work of maintaining the ledger of all bitcoins in existence and the transactions among them is shared by all nodes on the network. If somebody started generating loads of BTC on their own, the ledger would be thrown off balance and that would get noticed by everyone watching the markets and the system (and believe me, there are a lot of people watching this system).

You're not wrong to distrust the Bitcoin creators and other high-level players. They've created a mini-economy that is easily dominated, and engineered with decreasing availability so their "currency" will artificially increase in value like a stock bubble; not only that, but it's a system with an insane amount of wealth/power disparity. That alone is a good enough reason to be very suspicious.
 
Last edited:
Exactly. Maybe a handful of creators generated millions of BTC for themselves within those first 6 days before the thing ever went public. Who knows?

I don't think that's possible. From what I understand, the network tracks the transaction history of all bitcoins since creation to the last owner. Indeed, having public and verified transaction history is required for any bitcoins to be accepted as legitimate by the network.

Save for some cryptographic weakness in the algorithm, nobody can be secretly holding any "private" bitcoins that the rest of the network wouldn't know about - simply because being "known about" is what validates the bitcoins in the first place.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom