How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
As I mentioned before, if I missed a mechanism that *prevents* the creator of the program from churning out tens of thousands of bitcoins in 1 second by altering his/her code a bit followed by dumping it all on the open market, feel free to enlighten me.
That's not CT anymore - that's pure paranoia.

How could you possibly believe that the founders could sneak something like that into the bitcoin algorithm without anybody noticing?
 
I am not sure I am following you ...

are you talking about the artists, then? (What they make is unique - they supply the original art.)

But I suggest we end the derail here, unless you think it matters vis-avis bitcoins.

Yes, let's end it there. I was trying to make a point but it's not important.
 
The quality of the drivel you post would improve dramatically if you could, just once in a while, respond to what people actually wrote, not just some demented strawman of your own creation.
How do you sensibly deal with people who constantly bitch about the fact that some people got their bitcoins for nothing then say that isn't what bothers them? They insist that bitcoin is a scam but when it is pointed out that no deception is involved, they say that bitcoin is a scam because some people got bitcoins for "absolutely nothing". There is no sensible way to deal with circular logic like this.

And the way that the words "ponzi" and "pyramid" are bandied about (apparently they are automatically scams regardless of whether deception is involved), you could just as easily label all casinos as ponzi schemes.

The whole financial market is nothing more than institutionalized gambling. What do you thing trading shares is? What about shorts and longs, margin trading, call and put options, financial derivatives?

THEY ARE ALL BETS!

It is absolutely ridiculous to revere some forms of gambling then get all worked up under the collar about another form.
 
Where have you "shown" that? That's obviously another bald-faced lie.

Actually, the common characteristics have already been pointed out many times, and you have never even bothered to try refuting any of them.

You may have pointed out several differences between Bitcoin and pyramids/Ponzis, but that's not at all the same as "showing that there are no common characteristics."
It goes several pages back.

Bitcoin is no more a ponzi scheme than any other commodity. You have some people selling the commodity (taking money out of the "scheme") and you have people buying it (the new "suckers").
 
Not the same thing at all. Trading card companies do not reserve huge stockpiles of baseball cards for themselves, then publicly release only a fraction of those in logarithmically decreasing quantities for the purpose of gaming the collector market.

Okay, Rasmus, this was basically my point. :p
 
At this point, what is Bitcoin* supposed to be? A currency, a rival to things like Paypal, a scam, a gamble, what? From reading the last few months worth of posts, it seems like every time the argument against Bitcoin is finalised the supporters of it change what it's supposed to be.

*nearly made a Freudian slip. Left the second "i" out of "Bitcoin."
 
It goes several pages back.


Your waffling, ad hominem attacks and half-assed diversions have indeed been going on for quite a few pages now, but you haven't actually backed up a single one of your arguments with any facts, or even sound logic.

You certainly haven't disproven any of the similarities I've shown between Bitcoin and other scams like pyramid schemes, overvaluation via artificial scarcity, pump-and-dump schemes, and planned economic bubbles.


Bitcoin is no more a ponzi scheme than any other commodity. You have some people selling the commodity (taking money out of the "scheme") and you have people buying it (the new "suckers").


Bitcoin is similar a Ponzi scheme or Airplane Game in the basic sense that in all 3 cases they're literally buying and selling nothing.

Bitcoins, like the "Madoff Securities" fund and the "boarding passes" to fly on the "Airplane Game," are completely fictional. The "commodity" they ostensibly represent is nothing more substantial or transferable than useless wear and tear on somebody's video card. Bitcoin is not a commodity. It's a fraudulent pretense of a commodity. It has no monetary value at all beyond what the investors have paid into it.

The fact that the creators engineered it to decrease availability over time, awarded themselves controlling shares, and then hyped it up to bring in the suckers is evidence enough of a scam.
 
Last edited:
Not to even mention the enormous number of ancillary scams associated with this totally unregulated fake economy: the Bitcoin pyramid and Ponzi schemes, the stolen Bitcoin "wallets," the Bitcoin botnets, the sysadmins abusing their employers' servers to mine bitcoins, the "hacked" exchanges...

But scams to _acquire_ bitcoins are rather a different beast. There are lots of scams to acquire USD or gold as well. There will always be scams to acquire things that have value ("intrinsic" or not).

I'm not saying bitcoin is a _good investment_. But people are saying users are "conned" into "putting money in." But the only people "putting money in" are people who would rather buy them than mine them. That shows they have either a demand for a "cryptocurrency," or they're speculating there will be a demand in the future.

I don't see the difference between bitcoin and other commodities.
"Virtual" is a distinction without a difference, especially these days when items for online video games can sell for 10s or 100s of $.
People start listing the differences, like the originators getting them for almost free, no intrinsic value, more difficult to acquire over time (which is true true for most real-world resources as well) etc. When points are made about how those differences don't make it a scam, the response is that that difference actually wasn't important, and you have to look at the "big picture" to see how it's a scam.

Bitcoin's value is based on its demand. People only "put money in the system" by buying it. People who put money in _just to make money_ (like a pyramid/airplane game) are only being "scammed" if their speculation turns out to be incorrect. People who put money in so they can buy things on the tor/onion web, or make anonymous donations to wikileaks or hide from income tax, or whatever other purpose the internet can come up with are buying them because they are useful to them.

Does it disproportionately reward early investors? Yes, but only if and as long as demand increases, and only if those early investors sell at the right time. The same is true for people who bought Apple stock at $10. Or homesteaded beach property in Florida for free before "Spring Break" became a thing and drove prices to the millions.
 
How do you sensibly deal with people who constantly bitch about the fact that some people got their bitcoins for nothing then say that isn't what bothers them?


Well you apparently don't. I have yet to hear you reply sensibly to anything I've said.

The problem (that you keep on ignoring) is that the creators of Bitcoin engineered an economic bubble economy (complete with preprogrammed, logarithmically-dwindling stocks) based around a pretense of a commodity, then awarded themselves huge fortunes in that fake commodity, and hyped it as a "currency" for people to sink their money into.


They insist that bitcoin is a scam but when it is pointed out that no deception is involved, they say that bitcoin is a scam because some people got bitcoins for "absolutely nothing". There is no sensible way to deal with circular logic like this.


It's not circular logic. You're simply unwilling or incapable to acknowledge the logic for some strange reason. whereas most of the people in this thread can see it just fine.


And the way that the words "ponzi" and "pyramid" are bandied about (apparently they are automatically scams regardless of whether deception is involved)


Yeah, Ponzis and pyramids are scams, regardless of whether outright lying is involved. There are many known cases where a scammer laid out all the mechanics of his scam in plain language, and plenty of suckers still came and fell for it.

The operative element for a successful scam is for the perpetrator to inspire trust in his mark(s). This can be achieved by way of numerous techniques: by cultivating personal relationships, by making himself appear like-minded, by making himself appear exceptionally wealthy, successful or intelligent, by tapping into deeply-held beliefs like religion or politics, etc. If a good enough "come-on" is pitched to a sufficiently credulous and receptive populace, the scammer can inspire fervent confidence without even telling a lie.

Case in point: take a step back and look at yourself. Observe how unwilling you are to even entertain the notion that Bitcoin might be a scam.


you could just as easily label all casinos as ponzi schemes.


No, casinos are not Ponzi schemes.

Ponzi schemes operate on the false pretense of an investment that will definitely pay returns. Casinos are legally obliged to operate their games in an "above-board" fashion, and to fully inform their patrons about the statistical probabilities of winning their games. Ponzis do not.

Besides, neither I nor anyone else here actually accused Bitcoin of being a Ponzi scheme, only that it shares certain characteristics with Ponzi schemes.


The whole financial market is nothing more than institutionalized gambling. What do you thing trading shares is? What about shorts and longs, margin trading, call and put options, financial derivatives?

THEY ARE ALL BETS!

It is absolutely ridiculous to revere some forms of gambling then get all worked up under the collar about another form.


Yet we have a system of laws in place to regulate financial markets, to punish fraudsters and to recoup losses of individuals who lose their money due to banking fraud and theft. Bitcoin has none of that, and we're seeing the dismaying results of a totally unregulated "free market" every time a Bitcoin exchange "goes down" to the tune of hundreds of thousands of dollars in losses (which seems to happen roughly once or twice a month nowadays).
 
Last edited:
But scams to _acquire_ bitcoins are rather a different beast. There are lots of scams to acquire USD or gold as well. There will always be scams to acquire things that have value ("intrinsic" or not).


The difference is that bitcoins are not legal tender, and not subject to laws governing finance fraud. You have no legal recourse if you lose all your bitcoins. The exchanges have no oversight, and the thieves are never caught.


I'm not saying bitcoin is a _good investment_. But people are saying users are "conned" into "putting money in." But the only people "putting money in" are people who would rather buy them than mine them. That shows they have either a demand for a "cryptocurrency," or they're speculating there will be a demand in the future.


People have to "buy in" because "mining" is completely unprofitable by now, as a result of the design of the system itself. Besides, the system would have no monetary value whatsoever if nobody had ever paid for bitcoins in the first place. Without investors paying cash for them (in real-world currencies that have actual monetary value), BTC would be about as valuable as Monopoly money.


I don't see the difference between bitcoin and other commodities.


Go back and read the past 20 or so pages of this thread. Many people have explained that in thorough detail.


"Virtual" is a distinction without a difference, especially these days when items for online video games can sell for 10s or 100s of $.


Besides being "virtual," those things also have uses (outside of trading purposes), whereas bitcoins do not.

Bitcoins are intrinsically valueless placeholders that represent the amount of money that bitcoin seekers are willing to pay for them, leveraged against all the monetary value that all investors have paid into the system, with the top 1% of all Bitcoin holders owning a 50% share of that value to do with as they wish.


People start listing the differences, like the originators getting them for almost free, no intrinsic value, more difficult to acquire over time (which is true true for most real-world resources as well) etc.


There are no "originators" of real-world resources. Real-world resources are acquired at their source at cost to the producers, that also provides jobs and other market value in their given industry. Bitcoin mining contributes none of that. Bitcoin mining unnecessarily consumes electricity and wears out one's computer hardware for no constructive purpose.

Real-world resources are not simply artificially restricted over time in a preplanned, logarithmic fashion the way bitcoins are.

There's no good economic reason for the creators to have designed a currency with an engineered economic crisis of dwindling availability like that. The only discernible purpose for doing that is to create an economic bubble for them to cash in on. If you can think of a reasonable purpose for having explicitly designed the system to implode itself in that way, I'd sure love to hear it.


When points are made about how those differences don't make it a scam, the response is that that difference actually wasn't important,


When did I say that? I just said it's a single factor among other important factors that indicate Bitcoin is engineered to operate as an economic scam.


you have to look at the "big picture" to see how it's a scam.


Just like any successful scam, a major point is to kind of hide the fact that it's a scam beneath layers of complexity that the average person will either fail to comprehend, or else simply ignore out of complacency and/or enthusiasm.


Bitcoin's value is based on its demand. People only "put money in the system" by buying it. People who put money in _just to make money_ (like a pyramid/airplane game) are only being "scammed" if their speculation turns out to be incorrect.


Or if a Bitcoin exchange happens to get "hacked" (as they all do), or somebody reneges on a purchase leaving them high and dry, or any number of bad things happen (as they inevitably do) when dealing with non-legal funny money instead of legal tender.


People who put money in so they can buy things on the tor/onion web, or make anonymous donations to wikileaks or hide from income tax, or whatever other purpose the internet can come up with are buying them because they are useful to them.


By looking at the charts, it appears that Mt. Gox transactions alone represent more than 70-80% of all Bitcoin traffic, so from that it appears that most people are using it for speculation rather than evading taxes or buying crack or whatnot.

You might want to go back and reread the past few pages and pay attention to the criticisms for why Bitcoin is—by design—so ill-suited to use as a currency.


Does it disproportionately reward early investors? Yes, but only if and as long as demand increases, and only if those early investors sell at the right time.


Those investors can sell at any time and make a 100% profit. They paid nothing in, remember.


The same is true for people who bought Apple stock at $10. Or homesteaded beach property in Florida for free before "Spring Break" became a thing and drove prices to the millions.


No comparison. Paying money to buy actual real estate, or purchase stock in a real, legally-chartered, profitable company with real, physical assets is not the same thing as paying nothing and receiving money at the direct expense of a bunch of other people who paid.

A more apt comparison would be the people who went around making small fortunes fleecing groups of suckers in the "Airplane Games" of the 1980s. Except that this scam is being promoted and executed on a global scale, using specially-engineered software, YouTube, and Internet forums instead of old-school telephones, Xerox machines, hotel seminars, the US Postal Service, and Western Union money transfers.
 
Last edited:
That's not CT anymore - that's pure paranoia.

How could you possibly believe that the founders could sneak something like that into the bitcoin algorithm without anybody noticing?

Who says they need to sneak something like that in?
Its a computer program, which they wrote. What is stopping the programmer from taking the source code and re-writing the difficulty bit for himself?
All you need to do is set the mining difficulty to zero and run it for an hour or so, presto as many bitcoins as your harddrive can hold. Slot in a new harddrive and repeat.
Then start selling untill the costs of the transaction outweighs the profit.
Sure some others will sell too, but the vast majority of the money in the bitcoin bubble is now yours. And everyone else is left with nothing.


This is not a magical thing to do. As bitcoins are not a commodity. They are just pieces of code and whoever designed the program can make it dance to his tune.

And if the designer doesn't, one day soon some clever hacker is going to.

Hence my comparison to pyramid schemes. Someone at the top can at will cash in (nearly) everyone's money.

You keep saying that is paranoia. Conspiracy theory. So clearly you know of a compelling reason how/why this cannot happen. But I've not really seen you explain how.
How is the source code protected from re-programming by someone who has full access to said source code?
 
It's not even necessary for anyone to reprogram anything. All one of the early adopters would need to do is sell off portions of his or her stash incrementally while watching the market drop. Once the market has fallen to an acceptable degree, start buying back in (or have a confederate start buying back in for you).

In such a small, unregulated economy with such a tiny percentage of the top users holding such a dominant share of the stock, it would be very easy to manipulate the market in this way. Even easier would be to do this on a minor scale every single day: selling off a few thousand BTC to cash in, watching the market drop as you do so, then buy back in at a lower price.
 
Yeah, Ponzis and pyramids are scams, regardless of whether outright lying is involved. There are many known cases where a scammer laid out all the mechanics of his scam in plain language, and plenty of suckers still came and fell for it.

The operative element for a successful scam is for the perpetrator to inspire trust in his mark(s). This can be achieved by way of numerous techniques: by cultivating personal relationships, by making himself appear like-minded, by making himself appear exceptionally wealthy, successful or intelligent, by tapping into deeply-held beliefs like religion or politics, etc. If a good enough "come-on" is pitched to a sufficiently credulous and receptive populace, the scammer can inspire fervent confidence without even telling a lie.

Case in point: take a step back and look at yourself. Observe how unwilling you are to even entertain the notion that Bitcoin might be a scam.

I think the communication problem here is that psionl0 is missing the difference between a scam and a fraud. Fraud requires deception... scam does not.
 
I think the communication problem here is that psionl0 is missing the difference between a scam and a fraud. Fraud requires deception... scam does not.

It might also be a general attitude difference.
I assume the worst, namely that the entire bitcoin thing has been programmed as a fraud, either intentionally or because the founder overlooked a number of glaring errors that others could exploit to steal the community's money.

from my perspective psionl0 is assuming that the trading is all done in good faith, with good intentions on the part of everyone, rewarding those that put in the effort and trust to start things up.

I've just seen too many thieves, frauds and scammers ruin other people to trust something like this. I guess time will tell wether that is too cynical of me.
 
I think the communication problem here is that psionl0 is missing the difference between a scam and a fraud. Fraud requires deception... scam does not.
Then "scam" must be a weasel word in this context. No-one can say that bitcoin is a confidence game (the meaning of the word, "scam") so they just use the word "scam" and say it means something different if questioned too closely.
 
from my perspective psionl0 is assuming that the trading is all done in good faith, with good intentions on the part of everyone, rewarding those that put in the effort and trust to start things up.
The only assumption I am making is that the bitcoin technology is holding up.

You can be sure that every man and his dog is trying to make his own bitcoins. However, nobody so far has gotten around the algorithm. That is a testament to the robustness of the technology. That is not to say that the algorithm can't be broken in the future but it is not a big enough threat to make the market sit up and take notice.

Bitcoins themselves might not be incredibly useful but if the algorithm stands the test of time then the algorithm might play a useful role in financial transactions in the future.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom