How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
And that is what motivates you. The fact that some people got their bitcoins for free. It doesn't matter whether others made a bigger profit than they did or not, they got their bitcoins "by paying absolutely nothing".

Ad hominem again. You might want to stop trying to ascertain people's motivations, since you're, you know, criticising others for trying to ascertain people's motivations.
 
So if someone buys bitcoins at $5 and sells them at $10 they are just stupid suckers who gave their money to the early investors?

Yes, as they bought them for $0 and also get to sell them for $10.
The bottom line is that the early adoptors and creator made intrinsically worthless pieces of computer code and then conned other people into pumping in money.
Eventually someone is going to cash in and collect that real money, making the code worthless again. Now, maybe someone else along the line can make a tiny bit of profit, but like similar pyramid schemes the whole process is geared towards disproportionally rewarding the ones on top, fleecing all the ones at the bottom (whoever the last persons pumping in money were).

What I find funny about it is that from what I gather on the internet the vast majority of people pumping in money are the ones who distrust the evil government and want to keep their earnings hidden and safe, and these people will be the ones ultimately losing it all, at which point I suspect a fair number will start clamoring that this is a scam and the self same government they distrust should have prevented it.
 
Yes, as they bought them for $0 and also get to sell them for $10.
The bottom line is that the early adoptors and creator made intrinsically worthless pieces of computer code and then conned other people into pumping in money.
Eventually someone is going to cash in and collect that real money, making the code worthless again. Now, maybe someone else along the line can make a tiny bit of profit, but like similar pyramid schemes the whole process is geared towards disproportionally rewarding the ones on top, fleecing all the ones at the bottom (whoever the last persons pumping in money were).

After reading the last few pages of this, I can't see it as a scam. The code is open source, the method has been transparent.
That the creators/early adopters got them for less (not quite $0, even the earliest miners needed to pay for electricity, even if it was much less), does not make it a scam. Lots of things (trading cards, comic books) were originally given away free or promotionally but are later worth a lot of money.
"Intrinsically worthless" is a meaningless complaint. As long as someone is willing to barter/purchase them, they're not worthless.

Some speculators will lose money, some won't.
According to my googling, 13% of bit coins were created in 2009, when they would have been easy to make and relatively few miners. That's a lot of bit coin, but not enough for one person to crash the entire market single-handedly. Early on they were trading for pennies. Some early adopters probably cashed out when it first hit $1.


To be a "scam," you have to show where bitcoin users were lied to or defrauded by the creator. So far I haven't seen that, not even anything resembling that.
 
Yes, as they bought them for $0 and also get to sell them for $10.
The bottom line is that the early adoptors and creator made intrinsically worthless pieces of computer code and then conned other people into pumping in money.
Eventually someone is going to cash in and collect that real money, making the code worthless again. Now, maybe someone else along the line can make a tiny bit of profit, but like similar pyramid schemes the whole process is geared towards disproportionally rewarding the ones on top, fleecing all the ones at the bottom (whoever the last persons pumping in money were).

What I find funny about it is that from what I gather on the internet the vast majority of people pumping in money are the ones who distrust the evil government and want to keep their earnings hidden and safe, and these people will be the ones ultimately losing it all, at which point I suspect a fair number will start clamoring that this is a scam and the self same government they distrust should have prevented it.
WOW! Not only did these evil programmers create a secret weapon to extract wealth from "suckers" but having accumulated all that wealth, they plan to destroy it all by crashing bitcoin.

These conspiracy stories are getting weirder all the time.
 
Last edited:
WOW! Not only did these evil programmers create a secret weapon to extract wealth from "suckers" but having accumulated all that wealth, they plan to destroy it all by crashing bitcoin.

These conspiracy stories are getting weirder all the time.

How is this a conspiracy theory?
The wealth is not 'destroyed', its transferred from the late investors to the initial investors. The initial investors end up with no bitcoins and a lot of dollars, the late investors end up with a lot less dollars and bitcoins.
Its not all dissimmilar from selling stocks in companies that have no way of actually making profit.
You just need to convince people this empty stuff is worth money and sell before the market crashes. Usually in such a way that crashes the market.

As I mentioned before, if I missed a mechanism that *prevents* the creator of the program from churning out tens of thousands of bitcoins in 1 second by altering his/her code a bit followed by dumping it all on the open market, feel free to enlighten me.
 
To be a "scam," you have to show where bitcoin users were lied to or defrauded by the creator. So far I haven't seen that, not even anything resembling that.
Without getting into dictionary definitions, I'm not sure that it's necessary that people be explicitly lied to. There are some ponzi and pyramid schemes out there that don't pretend that they are other than ponzi or pyramid schemes. I'm not sure the psychology of suckers is necessarily such that they need to be deceived about what they are getting in to, so long as they have some hope of being one of the winners in the "scam".
 
WOW! Not only did these evil programmers create a secret weapon to extract wealth from "suckers" but having accumulated all that wealth, they plan to destroy it all by crashing bitcoin.

These conspiracy stories are getting weirder all the time.

The quality of the drivel you post would improve dramatically if you could, just once in a while, respond to what people actually wrote, not just some demented strawman of your own creation.
 
After reading the last few pages of this, I can't see it as a scam. The code is open source, the method has been transparent.

I don't see how this indicates that it's not a scam. The creators and their plan for BTC are obscure, and again, the way it's constructed, open or not, should raise some flags.

Lots of things (trading cards, comic books) were originally given away free or promotionally but are later worth a lot of money.

To the very people who made them ?

"Intrinsically worthless" is a meaningless complaint.

I agree. It's worth something only if people give it worth, like any other currency. But there are lots of legitimate complaints about BTC's worth.
 
What I find funny about it is that from what I gather on the internet the vast majority of people pumping in money are the ones who distrust the evil government and want to keep their earnings hidden and safe

That's another reason I find this suspicious: it appeals to exactly the kind of person you'd want to scam.
 
To the very people who made them ?

Well, yes. If you sell comic books I am sure you could easily secure a few copies for yourself.

But the comparison is still invalid: The comic books are all - or nearly all - sold at the same time and for the same price initially and may or may not become valuable afterwards.

They don't sell the 5th volume off the printing press for more than the third, and the 500th doesn't have a different price than the 5th, either.

This s a model where I can't go into any comic book store, though: I have to stand in line at the printing press. The press gets slower over time and each volume is more expensive than the previous one.

So, yes, it might turn into a collectors' item - but that will benefit mostly those who bought - or got for free - the first few books. Everybody else in the line cannot win as much - whilst it is desirable to get the que as long as possible.
 
Well, yes. If you sell comic books I am sure you could easily secure a few copies for yourself.

I'm not sure comic book vendors qualify as "the people who make them".

This s a model where I can't go into any comic book store, though: I have to stand in line at the printing press. The press gets slower over time and each volume is more expensive than the previous one.

:p
 
I'm not sure comic book vendors qualify as "the people who make them".

I meant the original sellers, in the sense of "publishers" - but all I know about comic books was what I learned on The Big Bang Theory...
 
And that is what motivates you. The fact that some people got their bitcoins for free. It doesn't matter whether others made a bigger profit than they did or not, they got their bitcoins "by paying absolutely nothing".


That's what makes it a scam, don't you see?

The originators paid no money in, and others who came later did pay money in, and the originators can withdraw cash from the market that was paid in entirely by other people.

The specific mechanics may be different, but that aspect of Bitcoin is fundamentally the same as a Ponzi or a pyramid scheme. All the money in the system comes from investors (not from profits), and the people who paid nothing in are able to take out the money that the investors put in.

I can't believe you're so stupid that you can't understand this simple concept. It's got to be obstinacy or denial.
 
Last edited:
I can't believe you're so stupid that you can't understand this simple concept. It's got to be obstinacy or denial.

He had no problem trying to milk a known pyramid scheme, and I'd read his comments about the "air-plane game" as appreciative ...
 
Yes, as they bought them for $0 and also get to sell them for $10.
The bottom line is that the early adoptors and creator made intrinsically worthless pieces of computer code and then conned other people into pumping in money.
Eventually someone is going to cash in and collect that real money, making the code worthless again. Now, maybe someone else along the line can make a tiny bit of profit, but like similar pyramid schemes the whole process is geared towards disproportionally rewarding the ones on top, fleecing all the ones at the bottom (whoever the last persons pumping in money were).


Not to even mention the enormous number of ancillary scams associated with this totally unregulated fake economy: the Bitcoin pyramid and Ponzi schemes, the stolen Bitcoin "wallets," the Bitcoin botnets, the sysadmins abusing their employers' servers to mine bitcoins, the "hacked" exchanges...


What I find funny about it is that from what I gather on the internet the vast majority of people pumping in money are the ones who distrust the evil government and want to keep their earnings hidden and safe, and these people will be the ones ultimately losing it all, at which point I suspect a fair number will start clamoring that this is a scam and the self same government they distrust should have prevented it.


Yeah, right?

It reminds me of the fictional conspiracy theorist Dale Gribble from King of the Hill, who sees a colossal conspiracy everywhere he looks, but can't even manage to figure out that his own wife has been cheating on him for 12 years and his own son is not even his.
 
Last edited:
And that is what motivates you. The fact that some people got their bitcoins for free. It doesn't matter whether others made a bigger profit than they did or not, they got their bitcoins "by paying absolutely nothing".

By the way, I thought I told you this before: a scammer doesn't care whether ALL of his victims lose money, as long as HE makes money.
 
After reading the last few pages of this, I can't see it as a scam. The code is open source, the method has been transparent.


The method of the "Airplane Game" was equally transparent, but few would deny that's a scam.


That the creators/early adopters got them for less (not quite $0, even the earliest miners needed to pay for electricity, even if it was much less), does not make it a scam.


True, just as a wagging tail does not make a dog. But this argument likewise focuses on just one aspect while ignoring the rest of the picture.

The fact that they created a computerized economy intentionally preprogrammed to behave as an investment bubble, granted themselves controlling shares in that economy, then hyped others to feed money into the economy is what makes it a scam.


Lots of things (trading cards, comic books) were originally given away free or promotionally but are later worth a lot of money.


Not the same thing at all. Trading card companies do not reserve huge stockpiles of baseball cards for themselves, then publicly release only a fraction of those in logarithmically decreasing quantities for the purpose of gaming the collector market.


"Intrinsically worthless" is a meaningless complaint. As long as someone is willing to barter/purchase them, they're not worthless.


The fact that they do not exist in any material form, are programmed into existence on a logarithmic decreasing scale, and can be irrevocably destroyed to further drive down availability is not meaningless.


Some speculators will lose money, some won't.
According to my googling, 13% of bit coins were created in 2009, when they would have been easy to make and relatively few miners. That's a lot of bit coin, but not enough for one person to crash the entire market single-handedly. Early on they were trading for pennies. Some early adopters probably cashed out when it first hit $1.


The number of bitcoins created in 2009 is an arbitrary figure that has little to do with the ability of a given investor (or group of investors) to have come to dominate the market by 2012. Presumably, the early adopters have continued to trade and mine bitcoins after the year 2009.


To be a "scam," you have to show where bitcoin users were lied to or defrauded by the creator. So far I haven't seen that, not even anything resembling that.


Not so. Take for example the "Airplane Game" that I mentioned above. Some implementations of that particular scam were hyped by handing out printed pamphlets that described the workings of the system in detail, complete with "boarding passes," "seating charts," and "officer ranks."

Some scams can prey merely on the lack of economic or mathematical savvy of the intended marks. By all appearances, Bitcoin is designed to appeal to technophiles, currency kooks, libertarians, anarchists, and other anti-government ideologues who are not so well-versed in economics.

The economics of something like this is sufficiently complex and arcane that it will fly over the heads of most average, financially non-savvy people. For example, just look at the number of people right here in this thread who are unable to comprehend or unwilling to accept the plain facts of how the BTC economy is unfairly skewed in favor of the creators and their friends.
 
Last edited:
I know, so was I. But the publishers don't _make_ the comics.

I am not sure I am following you ...

are you talking about the artists, then? (What they make is unique - they supply the original art.)

But I suggest we end the derail here, unless you think it matters vis-avis bitcoins.
 
I have already shown that bitcoin does not share common characteristics of either a ponzi or pyramid scheme.


Where have you "shown" that? That's obviously another bald-faced lie.

Actually, the common characteristics have already been pointed out many times, and you have never even bothered to try refuting any of them.

You may have pointed out several differences between Bitcoin and pyramids/Ponzis, but that's not at all the same as "showing that there are no common characteristics."
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom