After reading the last few pages of this, I can't see it as a scam. The code is open source, the method has been transparent.
The method of the "
Airplane Game" was equally transparent, but few would deny that's a scam.
That the creators/early adopters got them for less (not quite $0, even the earliest miners needed to pay for electricity, even if it was much less), does not make it a scam.
True, just as a wagging tail does not make a dog. But this argument likewise focuses on just one aspect while ignoring the rest of the picture.
The fact that they created a computerized economy intentionally preprogrammed to behave as an investment bubble, granted themselves controlling shares in that economy, then hyped others to feed money into the economy is what makes it a scam.
Lots of things (trading cards, comic books) were originally given away free or promotionally but are later worth a lot of money.
Not the same thing at all. Trading card companies do not reserve huge stockpiles of baseball cards for themselves, then publicly release only a fraction of those in logarithmically decreasing quantities for the purpose of gaming the collector market.
"Intrinsically worthless" is a meaningless complaint. As long as someone is willing to barter/purchase them, they're not worthless.
The fact that they do not exist in any material form, are programmed into existence on a logarithmic decreasing scale, and can be irrevocably destroyed to further drive down availability is
not meaningless.
Some speculators will lose money, some won't.
According to my googling, 13% of bit coins were created in 2009, when they would have been easy to make and relatively few miners. That's a lot of bit coin, but not enough for one person to crash the entire market single-handedly. Early on they were trading for pennies. Some early adopters probably cashed out when it first hit $1.
The number of bitcoins created in 2009 is an arbitrary figure that has little to do with the ability of a given investor (or group of investors) to have come to dominate the market by 2012. Presumably, the early adopters have continued to trade and mine bitcoins after the year 2009.
To be a "scam," you have to show where bitcoin users were lied to or defrauded by the creator. So far I haven't seen that, not even anything resembling that.
Not so. Take for example the "Airplane Game" that I mentioned above. Some implementations of that particular scam were hyped by handing out printed pamphlets that described the workings of the system in detail, complete with "boarding passes," "seating charts," and "officer ranks."
Some scams can prey merely on the lack of economic or mathematical savvy of the intended marks. By all appearances, Bitcoin is designed to appeal to technophiles, currency kooks, libertarians, anarchists, and other anti-government ideologues who are not so well-versed in economics.
The economics of something like this is sufficiently complex and arcane that it will fly over the heads of most average, financially non-savvy people. For example, just look at the number of people right here in this thread who are unable to comprehend or unwilling to accept the plain facts of how the BTC economy is unfairly skewed in favor of the creators and their friends.