How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Dump enough of any commodity and you will ruin the other investors but you won't get anything worth a cracker for your sale. Bitcoin is not different in this regard.

That is not to say that a majority bitcoin holder can't manipulate the price or won't hold a fire sale. That is the problem you get when a small number of investors corner a commodity market.

Yes, BUT most other commodities are not created in a way that ensure that early investors will corner the market, nor do they have a hidden creator that can poison the market at his/her leasure for his/her own profit.
And since bitcoins are the result of a computer program, the programmer can do whatever he/she wants with it.
Now I'm not saying that will happen, or that that is the programmers intention, but should it happen there is absolutely nothing anyone can do about it, and the programmer cannot be held accountable in any way.

In my opinion anyone proposing to use something that inherently unstable as an actual currency goes from trusting international governments, linked by international agreements, backed by a countries production and stability to trusting someone on the internet who won't even come forward about his/her identity.

Hence my comparison to a pyramid scheme. Its a high risk commodity, depending on a large amount of late investors to pump in money, which can at any time be cashed without repercussions by a single unknown person who made up the whole commodity. (Or the first hacker to crack the code, which IS going to happen).
 
. . . Isn't that the case?

Why quote my answer to your question then repeat your question again?

The only information I can add is that at the time that I became aware of bitcoin, you could have purchased it on the market for a negligible price. That means that a lot of the early miners failed to see the potential for bitcoin on the market and diddled themselves out of a fortune.
 
Last edited:
In my opinion anyone proposing to use something that inherently unstable as an actual currency goes from trusting international governments, linked by international agreements, backed by a countries production and stability to trusting someone on the internet who won't even come forward about his/her identity.
It has already been long established that bitcoin is not a suitable replacement for a national currency - let alone a world currency.

It is just a gamble - like anything else on the money market.
 
Why quote my answer to your question then repeat your question again?


Why? If I wasn't clear it was because you said, "I don't think that you are fundamentally disagreeing with me here," but in fact I am disagreeing with your post:

The fact that it rewards those with the most computing power is probably the reason that the ownership of bitcoins is so concentrated.


It is not computing power that is the main reason for concentrated ownership of bitcoins, but actually early entry into the system is the main reason.

Bitcoin rewards the early adopters, not to mention its creators, disproportionately. Do you disagree?
 
I have never heard of a "scam" where the victims can make a profit. By its very definition, being "scammed" means that you have lost your money. In a typical scam or Confidence Trick, the scammer is usually long gone before the "mark" smells a rat.

The early adopters in a ponzi scheme or pyramid often make a profit. It's the later folks who get scammed. Of course the earliest adopters are the founders of the pyramid. They get great returns. Some of Ponzi's earliest investors had great payouts at first. Paying out at the beginning makes the whole thing look legit, and then the folks who got in at the point where the profits decline stick around in hopes of recovering their sunk costs because the folks before them made money. No one is as virulent a defender of a scheme as someone who has their life savings invested and either has to defend the scheme or admit they were a fool.
 
It is not computing power that is the main reason for concentrated ownership of bitcoins, but actually early entry into the system is the main reason.

Bitcoin rewards the early adopters, not to mention its creators, disproportionately. Do you disagree?
I don't know how to answer this because I don't know what you saw in my previous posts.

The bitcoin originators might have amassed any number of bitcoins before putting it out into the public domain. After that, it is the people with the computers that got the new coins. Initially you might have gotten away with using a single mainframe but as other miners came on line, the mining became more difficult.

None of this does them any good if they sold off too early. Those early adopters who held on to their bitcoins stand to make a big profit. Those who didn't, don't.
 
The early adopters in a ponzi scheme or pyramid often make a profit. It's the later folks who get scammed. Of course the earliest adopters are the founders of the pyramid. They get great returns. Some of Ponzi's earliest investors had great payouts at first. Paying out at the beginning makes the whole thing look legit, and then the folks who got in at the point where the profits decline stick around in hopes of recovering their sunk costs because the folks before them made money. No one is as virulent a defender of a scheme as someone who has their life savings invested and either has to defend the scheme or admit they were a fool.
"Scam" is not synonymous with "ponzi" or "pyramid" (although most ponzi/pyramid schemes are scams).

See also posts #1135 & #1136.
 
Last edited:
The fact that you would choose such an inappropriate word together with the lengthy post about how "amoral" I am shows that for you this is just a moral issue.


The word "scam" is not inappropriate, when you compare Bitcoin to other fraudulent operations which function in a very similar manner.

It's not just a moral issue. I've also indicated numerous practical reasons why Bitcoin is a bad investment, and why I believe it won't work in the long run because (like a pyramid scheme) it hasn't been planned or implemented with long-term sustainability in mind. Its design seems to have been specified for the purpose of enriching its creators at the sole expense of investors, while its practicality as a currency is singularly ill-designed.


You have no interest in whether a potential investor can weigh up the pros and cons of bitcoin.


Ad hominem. My own personal motives are irrelevant to the validity of my argument, which you have utterly failed to discredit in any way.

But what are you actually accusing me of here? You appear to be saying, "some of us have a good thing going here, so why don't you just butt out?"

If a potential investor doesn't understand how the thing works, then they are unable to make an informed decision in the first place. The Bitcoin salesmen and the radical ideologues are already hyping their alleged "pros," so I'm trying to raise awareness by pointing out the cons. I see an obviously predatory operation that a lot of people seem to be getting taken in by, so I'm raising awareness of that.


You just want it outlawed because the originators might have made too much money.


Another ad hominem attack.

Nope. Sorry, try again.
 
I have never heard of a "scam" where the victims can make a profit. By its very definition, being "scammed" means that you have lost your money. In a typical scam or Confidence Trick, the scammer is usually long gone before the "mark" smells a rat.

The fact that you would choose such an inappropriate word together with the lengthy post about how "amoral" I am shows that for you this is just a moral issue.
The word "scam" is not inappropriate, when you compare Bitcoin to other fraudulent operations which function in a very similar manner.
And that is how you "prove" yourself.
 
The bitcoin originators might have amassed any number of bitcoins before putting it out into the public domain.


That right there, together with the fact that the originators engineered the supply of bitcoins to dwindle logarithmically over time ought to make any sensible investor extremely suspicious of Bitcoin.

I'm not pretending to know the motives of the originators of this thing, and I'm certainly not assuming they're "evil-doers" as stevea suggests.

But given all that we know about how this thing operates, what reason is there to assume it isn't a scam? It is certainly set up to operate in the manner of one.

Even if the originators purposefully intended to create a workable, stable alternative to national currencies and all other fungible commodities, the question is still open as to why they would even want to do such a thing. It seems to be a solution in need of a problem. There's no shortage of currencies to use for buying things. There's also no shortage of real, physical, material commodities to invest in. What's the need to invent a imaginary, fake "commodity" based in wasted processing cycles on one's computer hardware?

Ask yourself what possible motives one might have for creating a false economy based on no physical resources whatsoever, setting the thing up to restrict the availability of wealth for everyone else who comes in later, giving oneself enough of a head-start to amass an enormous fortune in the fake stock, then hyping people into investing their real money into your artificially rigged, completely fictional economy?
 
Last edited:
Initially you might have gotten away with using a single mainframe but as other miners came on line, the mining became more difficult.


Initially, you could generate 50 BTC every few hours using "regular computer hardware" (not mainframe computers) according to "Satoshi" in his introductory post on the cryptography mailing list.

And the creators had a 6-day head start to amass BTC even before the system had ramped the "mining difficulty" up to that level. The creators amassed their coins much, much more easily.


None of this does them any good if they sold off too early.


What's this "too early"? You seem to be trying to obfuscate the facts of the matter, or else you have no idea what you're talking about.


Those early adopters who held on to their bitcoins stand to make a big profit. Those who didn't, don't.


The originators and early adopters acquired giant hoards of BTC by paying absolutely nothing in. No matter how much they can manage to sell off, at whatever price, they stand to make nothing but profit. Whether their selling price is $15.00 per BTC or .01¢, it's still 100% profit for them.

In addition to that, by effectively picking the timing and amount of their sell-off, they can effectively game the market to their advantage, driving down the price and then recouping their BTC at a lower price. Only somebody with enormous market share can do that. It's rather rare for any supplier of in real-world commodities to be able to do that, but it's extremely easy for a Bitcoin early adopter, because they generated their shares of BTC for practically nothing, without the high expenses of acquiring a real-world commodity. (Besides, abuses like that are illegal in the real world, but there are no economic regulations governing Bitcoin.)
 
Last edited:
I once bought into a pyramid for $60. However, it was marketed as a pyramid and the instructions left no doubt about how it worked. I managed to recover my $60 investment but I never got the thousands that the scheme promised. Was I scammed? No! I took a calculated risk and ended up even.


Wrong. You got scammed. then turned around and scammed somebody else.
 
The originators and early adopters acquired giant hoards of BTC by paying absolutely nothing in. No matter how much they can manage to sell off, at whatever price, they stand to make nothing but profit. Whether their selling price is $15.00 per BTC or .01¢, it's still 100% profit for them.
And that is what motivates you. The fact that some people got their bitcoins for free. It doesn't matter whether others made a bigger profit than they did or not, they got their bitcoins "by paying absolutely nothing".
 
And that is what motivates you. The fact that some people got their bitcoins for free. It doesn't matter whether others made a bigger profit than they did or not, they got their bitcoins "by paying absolutely nothing".
Presumably it matters in the same way it matters in a pyramid scheme. That profit comes out of the pockets of a large number greedy schmucks.
 
And that is what motivates you. The fact that some people got their bitcoins for free. It doesn't matter whether others made a bigger profit than they did or not, they got their bitcoins "by paying absolutely nothing".

Since they stand to make their profit by luring in other people and getting them to invest time and money, which they can then cash in on, I can see how that be felt as somewhat unfair.
But hey, a sucker is born every minute, if someone is stupid enough to actually give these early investors their money, that would be their own fault.
 
But hey, a sucker is born every minute, if someone is stupid enough to actually give these early investors their money, that would be their own fault.
So if someone buys bitcoins at $5 and sells them at $10 they are just stupid suckers who gave their money to the early investors?
 
I think psionl0 is ahead here and tho' JAlbert makes many valid points he sounds a bit shrill and negative and overly reliant on unevidenced assumptions about the bitcoin-founders being evil-doers.

Perhaps we are being a but ungenerous towards the system. But given its characteristics, one can never be too careful.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom