Mainly because you don't have any facts.
This is a blatant lie. I have presented numerous facts in this thread, along with citations to back them up.
* You don't know what was discussed when the founders first mooted bitcoin.
Totally irrelevant. We can look at how the system operates and draw reliable conclusions from that.
* You don't know how many bitcoins are still held by the founders
* You don't know how many bitcoins are still held by the early adopters
* You don't know if they are still holding on to them or if they sold them off too early.
I know that over 50% of all bitcoins in existence are controlled by less than 1% of the holders. While I don't know exactly who those people are (the "founders" are likewise totally anonymous), I know that is an extremely suspicious and dangerous circumstance for any economy.
The possibility of cartel action might be a concern
Given all that we know about Bitcoin, I'd say it's definitely an
extremely grave "concern."
If you choose to ignore that and participate in this sham economy, that's your own business. But one has to wonder why anyone would proselytize so vehemently on behalf of something that is so obviously fraudulent.
but even if the worst case scenario that you presented was true, the history of the founders/early adopters has nothing to do with whether the price of bitcoin will rise or fall tomorrow.
SO you're actually arguing that it doesn't matter that it's a scam, so long as you might be able to make some money off of it?
That's a shockingly cynical, amoral stance. Now we see what caliber of people we're dealing with in this Bitcoin thing. I guess a guy like Bruce Wagner is not quite the exception that proves the rule.
Is that why you keep alleging that the only reason people might oppose this scam is because they're "jealous" of somebody getting rich off another person's hardship? Because greed and jealousy are the only human emotions you're able to identify with? Have you no ethics? Is this what "libertarian free-market capitalism" has come to?
Even if you cut the morality factors totally out of the equation, you still have to realize that Bitcoin is an extremely foolish investment by any standard. It's obviously a gamed system, and there are no laws, no recourse if you get screwed. Plus the returns are not that great, unless you're one of the early adopters with a huge pile of Bitcoins by which you can leverage the swindling of investors.
Unless you're one of them, you don't know who the early adopters are any better than I do, nor do you know the identity of the top 1% of Bitcoin holders who effectively wield total control over the market. What reason can you possibly have to trust that those people are motivated to act in the best interest of the market, and aren't just gaming the system for their own benefit?
Why would you assume that level of trust, of a group of people who have set up this system that favors themselves at the expense of others, and who've chosen to remain completely anonymous? Why would you trust their system, given the obviously scammy way it's been designed to operate? Given the astonishing number of high-level scams and thefts perpetrated therein in the short span of 3 years, with no accountability at all of the people in charge of maintaining the system?
It's blatantly obvious that this is a plan to amass monetary wealth from many small investors and concentrate it into the hands of a few people who paid nothing to enter into the economy. It's the exact kind of situation that the conspiracist goldbugs proclaim is wrong with the Federal Reserve System and the US dollar—except the wealth disparity is several orders of magnitude worse—yet here they are hailing it as "The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man!"
I have to wonder why anyone would willingly place their money into a system like this, unless they're totally ignorant of the economics behind it and have honestly been duped by the hype, or else they're amoral swindlers or criminals seeking to cash in on it. Or, maybe a little of both.
I guess it's not surprising, given that willful ignorance and blind ambition often go together.