How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Not just the US, also any other government or organisation.
As has been pointed out many times, there is no "organization" issuing bitcoins. You might as well say that the law also bans barter, LETS or the use of any other medium of exchange (eg gold).

The real objection to bitcoin is that it has probably made its originators fabulously wealthy. This is just the politics of envy.
 
I would phrase it differently--that it is more useful for enriching its originators than it is for a medium of exchange.

That is not politics of envy... that is unwillingness to partake of a scam.
 
Ok so

any false or fictitious instrument, document, or other item appearing, representing, purporting, or contriving through scheme or artifice, to be an actual security or other financial instrument issued under the authority... of an organization

is a shortened version pertaining to such issues not related to impersonating the US Govt. So the thing you can't do is issue an "actual security" or "other fiancial instrument"?

Do I have this right now? If so, and BitCoin meets the definition of "other financial instrument," then there's a real legal issue. Right?

As has been pointed out many times, there is no "organization" issuing bitcoins. You might as well say that the law also bans barter, LETS or the use of any other medium of exchange (eg gold).

Barter is not an "actual security" or "financial instrument."
 
Last edited:
is a shortened version pertaining to such issues not related to impersonating the US Govt. So the thing you can't do is issue an "actual security" or "other fiancial instrument"?

Do I have this right now? If so, and BitCoin meets the definition of "other financial instrument," then there's a real legal issue. Right?

No, the law says you can't make a forgery of an actual financial instrument. That is, you can't make a copy of an actual financial instrument issued by someone. You are to issue your own financial instruments that are not copies of someone else's (at least as far as this law is concerned. Other laws and regulations will limit how and when you can issue financial instruments. Bitcoins may or may not fall foul under some of those, but it's hard to see how a US court could impose jurisdiction considering the way Bitcoins are "issued".)

In short, you're allowed to print gift vouchers for your own shop, but you're not allowed to print false gift vouchers for the shop next door.
 
Last edited:
I should point out, that though bitcoin may or may not be a ponzi scheme, pyramid scheme, or other kind of scam... the "you're just envious of success" argument is used by scammers frequently. It's also what the Amway salesperson will tell you if you question the model.
 
I should point out, that though bitcoin may or may not be a ponzi scheme, pyramid scheme, or other kind of scam... the "you're just envious of success" argument is used by scammers frequently. It's also what the Amway salesperson will tell you if you question the model.
I'm not sure I like being compared to an Amway salesperson. :mad: Of course any suggestion that all people who use this argument are scammers is a non sequitur.

When the issue is how much money the bitcoin originators and early adopters (lucky buggers!) are making then "politics of envy" is perfectly apt. Many posts in this thread focus on this aspect of bitcoin. It seems to be the driving force behind all of these "Bitcoin is an illegal fraudulent counterfeit currency" type arguments.
 
Yes, it's not logical proof that it's a scam. But hearing the defense a scammer would use doesn't instill confidence in me. It's focusing on my mental state instead of defending the model.

The aspect we're discussing is the driving force behind my objection--though I have never declared that I think it is illegal or fraudulent. I just think its primary purpose is and always has been to enrich its founders; and I've no interest in playing that game for their benefit. The benefits suggested to me don't convince me that it's worth it.

If someone gets rich on something that is quite useful to me as a customer, I have no beef with them, envy or otherwise. So if you still think envy is the reason, you have to ask yourself why it's selective.
 
Last edited:
There are many commodities or commodity portfolios that I could have made money on in the past few months. Hindight makes it easy to pick winners.

The fact that the price fluctuates means that people can make money off of it. That proves nothing about its utility as a medium of exchange.

Are you abandoning the "envy" argument then? Do you concede that point?
 
The real objection to bitcoin is that it has probably made its originators fabulously wealthy. This is just the politics of envy.


Poisoning the well.

The objection is not merely that it has made its originators wealthy; it's that it has been specifically engineered to make the originators wealthy at the expense of all investors who came along later and contributed actual money into the system (many of whom have been swindled out of significant fortunes).


When the issue is how much money the bitcoin originators and early adopters (lucky buggers!) are making then "politics of envy" is perfectly apt. Many posts in this thread focus on this aspect of bitcoin. It seems to be the driving force behind all of these "Bitcoin is an illegal fraudulent counterfeit currency" type arguments.


Wrong.

Many of the objections in this thread specifically criticize how the system is clearly set up to operate as a scam: it creates a fake currency, highly impractical for its intended purpose, which has been deliberately programmed to award the creators and other early adopters huge percentages of all units and then artificially appreciate in value as new investors place their actual money into the system.

Saying that anyone who objects to such a scam is "just jealous" is highly disingenuous. The same could be said of scammers like Kenneth Lay and Bernie Madoff: "the only reason why the government went after them is because people are jealous of their wealth."
 
Last edited:
. . . it has been specifically engineered to make the originators wealthy at the expense of all investors who came along later . . .
And that's the lie.

The only bitcoin investors who lose out are those who buy high and sell low. The only time this happened was when the Mt Gox exchange was hacked. Other than that, the price of bitcoin has always been on the rise.

If there are losers from the introduction of bitcoin, it is the sellers of other commodities (like gold) who have to sell at a lower price than they might otherwise.
 
And that's the lie.

The only bitcoin investors who lose out are those who buy high and sell low. The only time this happened was when the Mt Gox exchange was hacked. Other than that, the price of bitcoin has always been on the rise.

If there are losers from the introduction of bitcoin, it is the sellers of other commodities (like gold) who have to sell at a lower price than they might otherwise.

It is quite possible for all of this to be true, and for the system still to be designed so that early adopters increase their value at a far better rate than later adopters. Even if a few johnny-come-latelies make some chump change, the system is still performing its primary duty of enriching the people that invented it. Which is fine if people don't mind. I'm not interested.
 
Poisoning the well.

The objection is not merely that it has made its originators wealthy; it's that it has been specifically engineered to make the originators wealthy at the expense of all investors who came along later and contributed actual money into the system (many of whom have been swindled out of significant fortunes).

So, all of the hard work that went into developing bitcoin was done with the expectation that there would be some reward. This isn't surprising, nor is it illegal. What is illegal, is fraud, and you have zero evidence (because there isn't any), that anyone was "swindled".

Many of the objections in this thread specifically criticize how the system is clearly set up to operate as a scam: it creates a fake currency, highly impractical for its intended purpose, which has been deliberately programmed to award the creators and other early adopters huge percentages of all units and then artificially appreciate in value as new investors place their actual money into the system.

All of the objections in this thread are as ignorant as yours. There is nothing "fake" about bitcoin, it is not falsely represented, nor is it represented as anything other than what it is, an alternative digital crypto-currency. In fact it's quite practical for its intended purpose, which was to create a decentralized digital currency for which the supply is not infinite or arbitrary, and for the purpose of making fast and convenient micro-payments over the internet. It was not deliberately programmed to award its creators or other early adopters anything, as they have to mine the currency in the exact same way as everyone else. They merely had a head start, and the value of bitcoins has to do with the fact that they are voluntarily accepted, a fact you seem to be completely out of touch with.

Saying that anyone who objects to such a scam is "just jealous" is highly disingenuous. The same could be said of scammers like Kenneth Lay and Bernie Madoff: "the only reason why the government went after them is because people are jealous of their wealth."

Clearly, you don't understand the difference between an alternative currency, and a ponzi scheme. I suspect it would be mostly a waste of time to attempt to explain it to you.
 
It is quite possible for all of this to be true, and for the system still to be designed so that early adopters increase their value at a far better rate than later adopters. Even if a few johnny-come-latelies make some chump change, the system is still performing its primary duty of enriching the people that invented it. Which is fine if people don't mind. I'm not interested.

If you're not interested in bitcoin, don't use bitcoin. No one is forcing you.

This is obviously quite different from claiming that it is a scam, and advocating that the government attack it.
 
If you're not interested in bitcoin, don't use bitcoin. No one is forcing you.

This is obviously quite different from claiming that it is a scam, and advocating that the government attack it.

I think you have not been reading my comments carefully.

I do believe it to be a scam in the sense that I mistrust the intentions of its creators--I think their vision was money for themselves and that they determined that others' interest in the hype about the next generation of currency would bring money to them.

I have never once said that I believe it to be illegal, or advocated the government attack it. All I have done is not participate and explain why I'm not interested.
 
...it has been specifically engineered to make the originators wealthy at the expense of all investors who came along later...


And that's the lie.


It's not a lie. It's how the entire system has been engineered.

Total_bitcoins_over_time_png_scaled1000.png


See? Artificial scarcity is a deliberately engineered function of the system. It's set up so that the number of new "coins" introduced into circulation becomes regressively scarcer and scarcer over time.

Insisting that it isn't so is just one of the lies that you and other Bitcoin supporters keep repeating.

Before anyone invested their own actual money into the system, the whole thing operated in an economic vacuum. It had no real value at all until people started putting money into it. Those investments have awarded the originators disproportionately over everyone else, and have fueled the countless other scams that have cropped up around this fake "commodity."


The only bitcoin investors who lose out are those who buy high and sell low.


You're forgetting the numerous investors whose savings were "wiped out" in the various recurring incidents where exchanges have been "hacked" and bitcoins "stolen."

Basically, investors have bought into a line of bull **** and gave their money away to a bunch of con-men, and gotten ripped off in exchange. Surprise, surprise.

Bitcion is totally unnecessary and practically useless as a currency. Its main purpose is to provide a fraudulent "commodity" as a pretense around which to conjure a fake "economy" for purposes of scamming the credulous.


If there are losers from the introduction of bitcoin, it is the sellers of other commodities (like gold) who have to sell at a lower price than they might otherwise.


You clearly have no idea what you're talking about. The trades of real commodities are not suffering because of a fraudulent commodity like Bitcoin.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom