How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
^That tack doesn't work either. Bitcoin cannot be a "commodity", virtual or otherwise, because there is nothing there of value. It is a bunch of useless 1s and 0s that are fraudulently asserted to have "value" because Bitcoin's people claim they do.

I think you are confusing "value" and "physical". Yes bitcoins are a bunch of 1s and 0s and therefor they are not a physical object. However, to claim they don't have value would be to say the same about virtual items in games like WoW and D3, and any game anywhere which uses its own currency, such as Rage of Bahamut using mooba coins.

You are not the sole universal arbiter of what does and does not have value. Something has value because someone somewhere believes it does.

Also, if the US Government is in debt almost $16trillion what exactly is our currency backed by?
 
Last edited:
I think you are confusing "value" and "physical". Yes bitcoins are a bunch of 1s and 0s and therefor they are not a physical object. However, to claim they don't have value would be to say the same about virtual items in games like WoW and D3, and any game anywhere which uses its own currency, such as Rage of Bahamut using mooba coins.

For that matter, what about the games themselves, or any software? Nothing but 1´s and 0´s in a computer.
 
However, to claim they don't have value would be to say the same about virtual items in games like WoW and D3, and any game anywhere which uses its own currency, such as Rage of Bahamut using mooba coins.
This is not a perfect analogy.

Even if you have to pay real money for them, game currencies can only be used in the game. Bitcoins are used in the real world.
 
For that matter, what about the games themselves, or any software? Nothing but 1´s and 0´s in a computer.

You can play games. You can't play with bitcoins.

They aren't an application, they aren't a readable file, they don't store any data beyond the single number for the amount of them you have.

It's like having a game's currency without there being a game to spend them in, so they suggest spending them in the real world instead of actual currency, putting them in the counterfeit section.
 
You can play games. You can't play with bitcoins.

I didn´t mean to imply that you can.

They aren't an application, they aren't a readable file, they don't store any data beyond the single number for the amount of them you have.

It's like having a game's currency without there being a game to spend them in, so they suggest spending them in the real world instead of actual currency, putting them in the counterfeit section.

My point was, BitCoin doesn´t become worthless just by virtue of being purely electronical. As pointed out, it has value as long as someone believes it has, and as P.T. Barnum said, there´s a sucker born every minute.
 
Originally Posted by ehcks View Post
. . . . putting them in the counterfeit section.
You should read more of this thread before you start mimicking Mulder.

LOL why don't people just read the definition of counterfeit? I don't get it, it's so damn simple to see it's not counterfeit. Why do people keep saying that ?
 
Whether or not it's counterfeit is a legal issue, so a simple dictionary definition will not suffice. The legality or lack thereof is a matter for the Federal prosecutors and courts to determine.

The plain fact is that Bitcoin is by no means the first "alternative currency." The Federal government has in the past cracked down on other such purported "currencies," most notably the Liberty Dollar back in 2007.

According to Federal Law (18 U.S.C. § 514):

(a) Whoever, with the intent to defraud—

(1) draws, prints, processes, produces, publishes, or otherwise makes, or attempts or causes the same, within the United States;

(2) passes, utters, presents, offers, brokers, issues, sells, or attempts or causes the same, or with like intent possesses, within the United States; or

(3) utilizes interstate or foreign commerce, including the use of the mails or wire, radio, or other electronic communication, to transmit, transport, ship, move, transfer, or attempts or causes the same, to, from, or through the United States,​
any false or fictitious instrument, document, or other item appearing, representing, purporting, or contriving through scheme or artifice, to be an actual security or other financial instrument issued under the authority of the United States, a foreign government, a State or other political subdivision of the United States, or an organization, shall be guilty of a class B felony.
http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/514

That's not the law that the Liberty Dollar founders were convicted under, but it certainly might be applicable in the case of Bitcoin. The only portion where applicability to Bitcoin might be in question is the phrase, "...with intent to defraud..."

On the other hand it might not be too difficult to make a case for fraudulent intent, considering the creators engineered their monetary system to explicitly grant themselves and their closest associates enormous shares of the overall units right from the start, even before any actual monetary value had been paid into the system.
 
Last edited:
For that matter, what about the games themselves, or any software? Nothing but 1´s and 0´s in a computer.

as, funnily enough is the vast majority of currency in "circulation" around the world these days.

if the electronic grid remains stable enough over the next few years I see actual paper money becoming purely symbolic pretty quickly, (even assuming the current system survives) because paying by microchip (phone) is a much better way of coraling the herd and ensuring not a single one can escape any taxes due, than giving them bits of paper they can use and not report in some way.

naughty flock.

its already started in Europe, banning cash transactions over 2500, preventing (Spanish) people in Spain from making more than one bank transfer per day over 3k.. the screws are tightening.
 
to be an actual security or other financial instrument issued under the authority of the United States

I think this clause prevents Bitcoin from being prosecuted under the cited law. Nobody claims that Bitcoin is issued under authority of the US.

ETA: The Liberty Dollar thing was pegged for this:

wikipedia said:
Bernard von NotHaus is charged with one count of conspiracy to possess and sell coins in resemblance and similitude of coins of a denomination higher than five cents, and silver coins in resemblance of genuine coins of the United States in denominations of five dollars and greater

They couldn't get Bitcoin on that one.
 
Last edited:
to be an actual security or other financial instrument issued under the authority of the United States

I think this clause prevents Bitcoin from being prosecuted under the cited law. Nobody claims that Bitcoin is issued under authority of the US.


You apparently neglected to read the rest of that passage. It continues...

[...]a foreign government, a State or other political subdivision of the United States, or an organization, shall be guilty of a class B felony.


Bitcoins are most certainly promoted as "an actual security or financial instrument," as a replacement for the USD in general commerce, under the false authority of an organization other than the United States Treasury.


ETA: The Liberty Dollar thing was pegged for this:

Bernard von NotHaus is charged with one count of conspiracy to possess and sell coins in resemblance and similitude of coins of a denomination higher than five cents, and silver coins in resemblance of genuine coins of the United States in denominations of five dollars and greater
​


Yeah, I know.


They couldn't get Bitcoin on that one.


As I already pointed out:

That's not the law that the Liberty Dollar founders were convicted under...
 
Last edited:
I think this clause prevents Bitcoin from being prosecuted under the cited law. Nobody claims that Bitcoin is issued under authority of the US.

ETA: The Liberty Dollar thing was pegged for this:

They couldn't get Bitcoin on that one.
This is not strictly true. There is enough ambiguity in the quoted legislation for the courts to make any ruling they like (not that they need legislative ambiguity to do that).

Also, trying to crack down on bitcoins might make a wonderful distraction for politicians under poll threatening criticism. This would only make things worse but short term political gain would make it worth while for the politicians.
 
Bitcoins are most certainly promoted as "an actual security or financial instrument," as a replacement for the USD in general commerce, under the false authority of an organization other than the United States Treasury.

Which organisation would that be, then?

I honestly don't know, but I was under the impression that bitcoin was entirely decentralized and was not controlled by any entities.

Even if you could argue that there is an organisation behind bitcoin, the currency would not be under the authority of that organisation, or any other authority, for that matter.

and since that seems to be one of the major selling points, it doesn't really appear to be pretending otherwise, either.
 
Even if you could argue that there is an organisation behind bitcoin, the currency would not be under the authority of that organisation, or any other authority, for that matter.

And even if there was an organization behind Bitcoins, bitcoins wouldn't be a "false or fictitious instrument ... [appearing] to be an actual security or other financial instrument issued under the authority of ... an organization", they would be that organization's real financial instrument.

Bitcoins is a silly notion, but they're not counterfeits or forgeries any more than monopoly money or World of Warcraft gold coins are.
 
And even if there was an organization behind Bitcoins, bitcoins wouldn't be a "false or fictitious instrument ... [appearing] to be an actual security or other financial instrument issued under the authority of ... an organization", they would be that organization's real financial instrument.

Upon re-reading that, we are even further away from counterfeit money: It really does say you have to make something that looks like somebody else's something. You cannot, therefore, counterfeit your own money.

Bitcoins is a silly notion, but they're not counterfeits or forgeries any more than monopoly money or World of Warcraft gold coins are.

What would be my crime if I invented my own country and made up a currency of that country and then persuaded people to accept that currency? Just plain fraud?
 
What would be my crime if I invented my own country and made up a currency of that country and then persuaded people to accept that currency? Just plain fraud?

I don't think it necessarily is a crime, unless you make material falsehoods about what or how your currency is backed. In that case, yes, it would be fraud. (And probably also a violation of your own weight in financial regulations and rules.)
 
You apparently neglected to read the rest of that passage. It continues...

I don't understand. The law seems to me to say that you have to be trying to make it look like your fake currency is issued by the US, and the Liberty Dollar got nailed because it had to potential to be confused with real US currency.

I'm not trying to be obstinate, as Bitcoin isn't something I really want to defend. I just don't see how they can use this law against it.
 
I don't understand. The law seems to me to say that you have to be trying to make it look like your fake currency is issued by the US,

Not just the US, also any other government or organisation.


and the Liberty Dollar got nailed because it had to potential to be confused with real US currency.

There was a thread here back at the time, and I seem to recall that they were advertised in a way that at least provoked that confusion. (It may have been that it masqueraded as a special strike, or a commemorative coin.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom