How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Bitcoin is not authorized by Congress. Bitcoin has not had it's value set by Congress.

ONLY a debt instrument that has been duly authorized and had it's value fixed by Congress is a legitimate currency. THAT is the law according to the Constitution.

Bitcoin has no value whatsoever, as it is not legal tender for ANY transactions. To proffer it to pay any transaction as if it had legal tender value of any kind is counterfeiting. Bitcoin has exactly as much legitimacy as a currency as Monopoly money.
 
All you are trying to do is redefine "legitimate", "currency", "counterfeit" and "legal tender".

This is a big ask of somebody who can't tell the difference between simple and compound interest.
 
Um... I lost the thread of this debate while I was reading, but exactly how is Bitcoin a currency, counterfeit or otherwise? It's not issued or backed by a bank, sovereign state or other governmental institution, and it's not pretending to be, either. Nor does it seem to have actual precious metals backing it, so it's a fiat... something. Some sort of aethereal internet...thing. I don't even think there's a word for it, because the one thing it's not is a currency.
 
psionI0, show me the law passed by Congress (as prescribed by the Constitution) authorizing Bitcoin as legal tender currency and fixing it's value.

THEN I will admit to being wrong.

Not holding my breath, because that law doesn't exist.
 
Last edited:
Um... I lost the thread of this debate while I was reading, but exactly how is Bitcoin a currency, counterfeit or otherwise? It's not issued or backed by a bank, sovereign state or other governmental institution, and it's not pretending to be, either. Nor does it seem to have actual precious metals backing it, so it's a fiat... something. Some sort of aethereal internet...thing. I don't even think there's a word for it, because the one thing it's not is a currency.

It's being proffered as a currency, and touted on it's supporters' websites as having legitimate value vs national currencies, particularly "fiat" ones.

They are saying "use Bitcoin...it has REAL value, unlike those dollars/euros/etc".

Thus there is a clear presentation of, and intent to commit fraud using this phony "currency".
 
Probably the best description of bitcoin is "virtual commodity". It exists but only in cyber-space. Like any commodity, the value of bitcoin is set by the people who want to buy it.

Being relatively scarce and difficult to manufacture means that bitcoin satisfies the minimum requirements for a "medium of exchange" but it can't replace a national currency because it can't grow.
 
psionI0, show me the law passed by Congress (as prescribed by the Constitution) authorizing Bitcoin as legal tender currency and fixing it's value.
I don't have to. If it's not illegal (and there is no evidence that congress has banned it) then it's legal.
 
^That tack doesn't work either. Bitcoin cannot be a "commodity", virtual or otherwise, because there is nothing there of value. It is a bunch of useless 1s and 0s that are fraudulently asserted to have "value" because Bitcoin's people claim they do. It has no legal authorization, no government-fixed value.

It has no backing whatsoever, not even the "full faith and credit" power of the government.

Therefore to attempt to exchange value using Bitcoin IS fraudulent, and counterfeiting as it is proffered as a "currency" by the accepted definition of the word.
 
Advertised as a virtual commodity, I'm not sure it's fraudulent. They seem pretty upfront about the whole 'not in physical existence' thing. Not saying I'd trust it or use it at this point, but I wouldn't break out the secret service.
 
I don't have to. If it's not illegal (and there is no evidence that congress has banned it) then it's legal.

The law of the land and the Constitution say that you DO have to show me the law:

Article 1 - The Legislative Branch
Section 8 - Powers of Congress

<<Back | Table of Contents | Next>>

The Congress shall have Power To lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises, to pay the Debts and provide for the common Defence and general Welfare of the United States; but all Duties, Imposts and Excises shall be uniform throughout the United States;

To borrow money on the credit of the United States;

To regulate Commerce with foreign Nations, and among the several States, and with the Indian Tribes;

To establish an uniform Rule of Naturalization, and uniform Laws on the subject of Bankruptcies throughout the United States;

To coin Money, regulate the Value thereof, and of foreign Coin, and fix the Standard of Weights and Measures;

Show me the law where Congress has authorized Bitcoin. Show me the law that regulates it's value.

By definition, if Congress has not EXPLICITLY authorized Bitcoin, it is NOT legal tender, nor is it legitimate currency. Res ipsa loquitur.
 
Advertised as a virtual commodity, I'm not sure it's fraudulent. They seem pretty upfront about the whole 'not in physical existence' thing. Not saying I'd trust it or use it at this point, but I wouldn't break out the secret service.

If you look at Bitcoin's own proponent propaganda, they tout it as a replacement for the dollar and other legitimate currencies. The OP also touted it's value in evading taxes (a further crime).
 
By definition, if Congress has not EXPLICITLY authorized Bitcoin, it is NOT legal tender, nor is it legitimate currency.
Whatever.

Let's short circuit this debate and say that in our next 10 posts each we keep repeating ourselves and never reach a consensus.
 
I think Bitcoin was set up as a sort of pyramid scheme of sorts by its founders to make a pile of cash from suckers who buy in later.

As such, I think it's a scam. This is all my opinion though. But I would never call it illegal or counterfeit, because it is neither of these things.

Now it would be nice if we could drop this aspect of the debate, because it's a sidetrack that isn't relevant.
 
I think Bitcoin was set up as a sort of pyramid scheme of sorts by its founders to make a pile of cash from suckers who buy in later.

As such, I think it's a scam.
Don't let the fact that other people might be making a bigger profit than you blind you to the possibility that you might be able to use bitcoin profitably yourself. Relatively low cost international transfers (where other options are not feasible) is one possibility. "Buy and hold" is another.

Just hope that I don't buy any. I'm a jinx. :D
 
Right. If I start using my DVDs as currency (no chance of that happening) between my friends and I, shouldn't that be ok ?
Sure. The only issue is, should you find yourself in a situation where a friend owes you a DVD, and offers its value in cash instead (or whatever's legal tender in your area), you have to accept that.

If your system really takes off the IRS (or equivalent) might come knocking, since barter is generally taxed too. But that's just them wanting their cut.
 
Sure. The only issue is, should you find yourself in a situation where a friend owes you a DVD, and offers its value in cash instead (or whatever's legal tender in your area), you have to accept that.

Curious: This assumes that the DVDs are explicitly used as a method of payment, right? (As in: They need to be creating a debt that is measured in dollars, rather than an obligation to deliver a DVD.)

I mean, if I buy a DVD from you, it's not enough that you send me money back, right?
 
Rather than start a new Bitcoin thread, I'll throw this in here:

http://bitcoin.stackexchange.com/

A Q+A site about Bitcoin. This is not considered a healthy beta by normal StackExchange standards, so it may not be up a whole lot longer. But in the meantime, you can find interesting stuff, like info about double-spend attacks. :)
 
Curious: This assumes that the DVDs are explicitly used as a method of payment, right? (As in: They need to be creating a debt that is measured in dollars, rather than an obligation to deliver a DVD.)

I mean, if I buy a DVD from you, it's not enough that you send me money back, right?
Hm. I thought I'd already replied to this. Maybe the nets ate my post.

Anyway, I believe offering the customer a full refund is all you're legally obligated to do in most states. This is where I pull my IANAL card, though, so who knows.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom