John Albert
Illuminator
- Joined
- Apr 10, 2010
- Messages
- 3,425
So, all of the hard work that went into developing bitcoin was done with the expectation that there would be some reward. This isn't surprising, nor is it illegal. What is illegal, is fraud, and you have zero evidence (because there isn't any), that anyone was "swindled".
You're either sadly misinformed about the storied history of Bitcoin, or else you're just lying. The fake currency known as "Bitcoin" has been the primary vehicle of a large number of fraudulent scams over the past few years.
All of the objections in this thread are as ignorant as yours.
Poisoning the well. You're just dismissing all opposing viewpoints with derisive rhetoric instead of actually addressing them.
I've demonstrated sufficient understanding of Bitcoin, its operation, its history, and many of the the related economic concepts, to back up my opinion that it operates as a scam on a number of levels.
You, on the other hand, have offered nothing substantial at all in its defense except your own (apparently misinformed) opinion.
There is nothing "fake" about bitcoin, it is not falsely represented, nor is it represented as anything other than what it is, an alternative digital crypto-currency.
It is certainly touted as "an alternative digital crypto-currency," but what does that really even mean?
Any unbiased, critical thinker who's been following the story of Bitcoin for the past few years will recognize how ill-suited it is for the purpose of facilitating monetary transactions, the surprising number of scams and alleged "thefts" that have been associated with it, and how disproportionately risky it is as an investment product.
In fact it's quite practical for its intended purpose
On what basis do you judge the "practicality" of Bitcoin, relative to other currencies?
- Compared with other currencies, Bitcoin is extremely insecure. The cryptography behind the generation and trade of the coins may or may not be immediately vulnerable, but the plain fact is that the Bitcoin exchanges (which form an integral and indispensable part of the overall system) have generally proven to be extremely unreliable, untrustworthy, or otherwise insecure. Even the largest and best-reputed exchanges have allegedly fallen victim to alleged "hacks," in which hundreds of thousands of BTC have been allegedly "stolen." Either way, lots of people lost their money.
- The market value of Bitcoin is wildly unstable. That makes it extremely risky for investors and merchants alike, thereby severely hindering its reliability as a medium of trade.
- Bitcoin is not backed by any reliable securities or commodities nor is it guaranteed by any government surety. It is not legal tender, therefore there is no legal recourse should one's bitcoins get stolen or misappropriated through fraud.
- Given the above issues, it's hardly surprising that Bitcoin has not found general acceptance as a currency. Only a handful of merchants actively use it, and very few goods and services of real practical value can be purchased with it. Even most of the people touting its virtues on the Internet have to admit they don't actually use it to pay for stuff. The lack of general use is perhaps its greatest hindrance to its practicality as a currency.
It was not deliberately programmed to award its creators or other early adopters anything, as they have to mine the currency in the exact same way as everyone else. They merely had a head start
Your misrepresentation of the economics of Bitcoin "mining" is either honestly ignorant or extremely disingenuous.
Everyone knows (everyone who's been following this thread, anyway), that "head start" of the early Bitcoin adopters is no "mere" advantage.
The handful of people who started "mining" in the first few months after the launch of Bitcoin (when the "difficulty" function had just started its logarithmic increase) had an outrageous advantage over later investors and were able to rack up tremendous shares of the total monetary units by doing essentially nothing. They basically awarded themselves huge fortunes (by the measure of today's exchange rate) for the "work" of merely running a screensaver app on their computers for a few months.
However, all that fake "money" was totally valueless until many months later, after the difficulty ramped up and it was no longer viable to merely "mine" for BTC with a screensaver app. By then the word had spread, and all the suckers who believed the libertarian hype began buying in with actual cash.
and the value of bitcoins has to do with the fact that they are voluntarily accepted, a fact you seem to be completely out of touch with.
Strawman argument.
I never said bitcoins weren't voluntarily accepted.
Being "voluntarily accepted" is one of the defining characteristics of a scam.
Clearly, you don't understand the difference between an alternative currency, and a ponzi scheme. I suspect it would be mostly a waste of time to attempt to explain it to you.
Another red herring, peppered with another ad hominem.
I understand the difference. You apparently don't recognize a fraudulent investment bubble when you see one.
Last edited: