How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
So, all of the hard work that went into developing bitcoin was done with the expectation that there would be some reward. This isn't surprising, nor is it illegal. What is illegal, is fraud, and you have zero evidence (because there isn't any), that anyone was "swindled".


You're either sadly misinformed about the storied history of Bitcoin, or else you're just lying. The fake currency known as "Bitcoin" has been the primary vehicle of a large number of fraudulent scams over the past few years.


All of the objections in this thread are as ignorant as yours.


Poisoning the well. You're just dismissing all opposing viewpoints with derisive rhetoric instead of actually addressing them.

I've demonstrated sufficient understanding of Bitcoin, its operation, its history, and many of the the related economic concepts, to back up my opinion that it operates as a scam on a number of levels.

You, on the other hand, have offered nothing substantial at all in its defense except your own (apparently misinformed) opinion.


There is nothing "fake" about bitcoin, it is not falsely represented, nor is it represented as anything other than what it is, an alternative digital crypto-currency.


It is certainly touted as "an alternative digital crypto-currency," but what does that really even mean?

Any unbiased, critical thinker who's been following the story of Bitcoin for the past few years will recognize how ill-suited it is for the purpose of facilitating monetary transactions, the surprising number of scams and alleged "thefts" that have been associated with it, and how disproportionately risky it is as an investment product.


In fact it's quite practical for its intended purpose


On what basis do you judge the "practicality" of Bitcoin, relative to other currencies?

  • Compared with other currencies, Bitcoin is extremely insecure. The cryptography behind the generation and trade of the coins may or may not be immediately vulnerable, but the plain fact is that the Bitcoin exchanges (which form an integral and indispensable part of the overall system) have generally proven to be extremely unreliable, untrustworthy, or otherwise insecure. Even the largest and best-reputed exchanges have allegedly fallen victim to alleged "hacks," in which hundreds of thousands of BTC have been allegedly "stolen." Either way, lots of people lost their money.
  • The market value of Bitcoin is wildly unstable. That makes it extremely risky for investors and merchants alike, thereby severely hindering its reliability as a medium of trade.

  • Bitcoin is not backed by any reliable securities or commodities nor is it guaranteed by any government surety. It is not legal tender, therefore there is no legal recourse should one's bitcoins get stolen or misappropriated through fraud.
  • Given the above issues, it's hardly surprising that Bitcoin has not found general acceptance as a currency. Only a handful of merchants actively use it, and very few goods and services of real practical value can be purchased with it. Even most of the people touting its virtues on the Internet have to admit they don't actually use it to pay for stuff. The lack of general use is perhaps its greatest hindrance to its practicality as a currency.

It was not deliberately programmed to award its creators or other early adopters anything, as they have to mine the currency in the exact same way as everyone else. They merely had a head start


Your misrepresentation of the economics of Bitcoin "mining" is either honestly ignorant or extremely disingenuous.

Everyone knows (everyone who's been following this thread, anyway), that "head start" of the early Bitcoin adopters is no "mere" advantage.

The handful of people who started "mining" in the first few months after the launch of Bitcoin (when the "difficulty" function had just started its logarithmic increase) had an outrageous advantage over later investors and were able to rack up tremendous shares of the total monetary units by doing essentially nothing. They basically awarded themselves huge fortunes (by the measure of today's exchange rate) for the "work" of merely running a screensaver app on their computers for a few months.

However, all that fake "money" was totally valueless until many months later, after the difficulty ramped up and it was no longer viable to merely "mine" for BTC with a screensaver app. By then the word had spread, and all the suckers who believed the libertarian hype began buying in with actual cash.


and the value of bitcoins has to do with the fact that they are voluntarily accepted, a fact you seem to be completely out of touch with.


Strawman argument.

I never said bitcoins weren't voluntarily accepted.

Being "voluntarily accepted" is one of the defining characteristics of a scam.


Clearly, you don't understand the difference between an alternative currency, and a ponzi scheme. I suspect it would be mostly a waste of time to attempt to explain it to you.


Another red herring, peppered with another ad hominem.

I understand the difference. You apparently don't recognize a fraudulent investment bubble when you see one.
 
Last edited:
Nominated. You've demolished all of his arguments. Bravo.
 


I see what you did there. It's not very funny or clever, just kind of pathetic and trollish.

BTW, I just noticed that in my posts above, I neglected to even mention the most damning aspect of the Bitcoin situation:

Something on the order of 1% of Bitcoin holders control over 50% of the total coins in existence.

That tiny minority can easily wield total control over the market, influencing its valuation for their own economic gain, at their own whims. If you don't even understand how easily that degree of monopolization can be exploited to game an openly traded commodity (let alone a currency!), then you're completely unqualified to comment on the economics at work here.

We've seen the BTC market take enormous nose dives several times throughout the past several years, due to enormous "hacking thefts" and massive sell-offs. Every time, it creates a panic with investors selling out and buying back in, trying to make a quick buck off the sudden volatility. How many of them lose money in those transactions? How naive must a person be, to even get caught up in such an obvious scam without realizing that Bitcoin is useless as a currency and downright hazardous as an investment product?

Just look at that chart I posted above. The thing is engineered to award the creators and early adopters enormous "fortunes" in the fake currency right at the start, then to logarithmically diminish the generation rate to zero over the course of 24 years to keep drawing in the suckers (I mean "investors").

Why would anyone create an ostensible "currency" deliberately preprogrammed to operate with dwindling availability like that, unless it was intended to perpetrate a long-term investment scam? What other purpose can be served by such a thing?

I think most readers here are intelligent and critical-minded enough to understand what I'm saying, even if some are not.
 
Last edited:
Just look at that chart I posted above. The thing is engineered to award the creators and early adopters the lion's share of money, then to logarithmically diminish in availability to zero units over the course of 24 years.
Why would anyone create an ostensible "currency" preprogrammed to operate like that, unless it's intended to operate as a long-term investment scam? What other purpose can be served by such a thing?

I figure that around that time the original inventor (who is still just a web handle that may or may not represent several people, IIRC) will introduce their new 'Bytecoin', the most important creation in the history of man since the last time we did this, and suck in a bunch of new investors who've forgotten bitcoin.
 
I don't doubt that Bitcoin could be rebranded and recast as some other form of investment opportunity in the future.

This kind of virtual digital investment bubble scam just might become a recurring con in the Information Age, just like the Ponzi scheme and the "Airplane Game" did back in the 20th Century.


If you're not interested in bitcoin, don't use bitcoin. No one is forcing you.


I'm not just avoiding it myself, I'm raising awareness about this sophisticated investment scam, to warn other people off in the hopes that fewer newcomers will get drawn in and lose their money like so many others already have.
 
I don't doubt that Bitcoin could be rebranded and recast as some other form of investment opportunity in the future.

This kind of virtual digital investment bubble scam just might become a recurring con in the Information Age, just like the Ponzi scheme and the "Airplane Game" did back in the 20th Century.

I'm not just avoiding it myself, I'm raising awareness about this sophisticated investment scam, to warn other people off in the hopes that fewer newcomers will get drawn in and lose their money like so many others already have.
One question for you: Why does gold have value?
 
If it's fictional, it should be able to be addressed directly, and shown wrong with ease. Like we do here all the time, even with the silliest of claims.
 
If it's fictional, it should be able to be addressed directly, and shown wrong with ease. Like we do here all the time, even with the silliest of claims.
John Albert has been replied to repeatedly in this thread, he's repeating the same things like a broken record. It gets to the point of silliness.
 
How To Avoid Bitcoin – The Most Hyped Creation In The History Of Man

John Albert has been replied to repeatedly in this thread, he's repeating the same things like a broken record. It gets to the point of silliness.
John Albert is a voice of reason in this thread. He has repeatedly demolished the bitcoiners' silly arguments, and revealed its true nature. Sadly, some are too blind to see it...

John Albert said:
* Compared with other currencies, Bitcoin is extremely insecure. The cryptography behind the generation and trade of the coins may or may not be immediately vulnerable, but the plain fact is that the Bitcoin exchanges (which form an integral and indispensable part of the overall system) have generally proven to be extremely unreliable, untrustworthy, or otherwise insecure. Even the largest and best-reputed exchanges have allegedly fallen victim to alleged "hacks," in which hundreds of thousands of BTC have been allegedly "stolen." Either way, lots of people lost their money.

* The market value of Bitcoin is wildly unstable. That makes it extremely risky for investors and merchants alike, thereby severely hindering its reliability as a medium of trade.

* Bitcoin is not backed by any reliable securities or commodities nor is it guaranteed by any government surety. It is not legal tender, therefore there is no legal recourse should one's bitcoins get stolen or misappropriated through fraud.

* Given the above issues, it's hardly surprising that Bitcoin has not found general acceptance as a currency. Only a handful of merchants actively use it, and very few goods and services of real practical value can be purchased with it. Even most of the people touting its virtues on the Internet have to admit they don't actually use it to pay for stuff. The lack of general use is perhaps its greatest hindrance to its practicality as a currency.
A brilliant synopsis of what bitcoin is really all about, and why everybody should avoid it!
 
One question for you: Why does gold have value?


Gold is a physical, chemical element with many applications (industrial, cultural, and aesthetic), and its availability is limited by nature. Gold can be used to manufacture real, useful things. Bitcoins cannot be used to manufacture anything. As the system is designed, it is ill-suited to its stated purpose and the purpose it is apparently best suited for is a nefarious one.

Bitcoins are a fake "commodity" created on the pretense of an alternative currency, but ill-suited to that purpose because its inbuilt properties run contrary to that purpose.

In order to serve as an effective medium of exchange, currencies must be stable so all parties engaging in a transaction can have a secure, trusted basis of value that isn't going to wildly fluctuate in market value during and after the deal is negotiated. Bitcoin was not designed with any mechanism in place to ensure that market stability. It has no inbuilt method for stabilizing its market value according to exchange volume. Lacking any reliable means of stability, Bitcoin does not represent a useful model for a modern currency, especially when so many other currencies abound that are successfully managed to be stable.

Bitcoin actually does have a crude method in place to manipulate its own valuation, but that method is extremely clumsy, wasteful and exploitative, and it runs completely contrary to the ostensible, stated purpose of Bitcoin being designed as a viable currency.

The notion of generating new monetary units through a process of computational resource hogging is nothing but a pointless waste of energy. The exercise of hashing and re-hashing arbitrary values may present the appearance of cryptographic sophistication, but that model really does nothing to support Bitcoin's usefulness or security as a currency. It's basically just a denial-of-service attack leveraged against greedy speculators in order to impose dwindling availability over time.

And what's up with that dwindling availability over time? If one were designing a model for creating a currency, why on Earth would one want it to become less and less available as time goes on? Presumably, adoption would increase as time goes on, requiring a steady influx of new monetary units to keep equilibrium. So why the regressive scarcity model? Doesn't that defeat the whole purpose of a currency in the first place? Modern, state-of-the-art currencies are supposed to maintain a stable value over time so their value can be relied upon. They're intended to be circulated as a medium of trade, not socked away to appreciate over time like a collection of baseball cards or comic books. That artificial scarcity model encourages hoarding and discourages trade, which is supposed to be the primary function of a currency in the first place.

The thing is, this ever-increasing artificial scarcity model—so contrary to the way currencies are supposed to work—has been implemented as the central economic feature of the entire Bitcoin system. The fact that the entire system was built on top of this singularly bad design decision does not indicate a development strategy aimed at creating a viable currency to facilitate trade at all.

But if Bitcoin was not engineered to behave as a proper currency, then what is it engineered to do?

Why is it even necessary to create an entirely new currency outside the bailiwick of governments? What good can they hope to achieve through that approach, that couldn't be better accomplished by simply applying their cryptographic acumen to a sleek, distributed, open-source payment system that facilitates exchange between existing currencies, without purporting to be its own non-legal tender alternative?

Think about that one for a minute. It's not really a proper currency, because it's not really designed to operate like one. It's designed to operate more like a contrived approximation of a natural commodity, yet it lacks the implied intrinsic value that defines a commodity. So what exactly is Bitcoin?

Here we have a completely valueless product being pimped hard, using similar hyperbolic rhetoric to that used by MLM promoters and pseudoscience peddlers. This marketing is deliberately aimed at disenfranchised gubmint-haters, anarchist hackers, gold-bugs, extremist libertarians, and other assorted currency cranks. We typically hear touts like, "This new paradigm will make Big Banking obsolete," "Bitcoin will topple tyrannical governments and end wars," "you can buy whatever you want, even contraband, safely and securely without leaving any paper trail for the Feds," "It's The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man!"

We have slick, animated YouTube videos and sleazy salesmen with criminal backgrounds in finance fraud on Internet TV touting this valueless, theoretical computer protocol as the new Information Age alternative to traditional money. The gist of the videos is that you can use Bitcoin to buy anything you want without paying taxes or processing fees, and you can accumulate digital wealth (that the government can't possibly track down) simply by running a program on your computer.

What does the economic formula of hyperbolic marketing + dwindling scarcity mean to you? Ever hear of the South Sea Bubble, or the Dutch tulip mania of the 1630s? How about Ponzi schemes and pump-and-dump scams?

I'm not asserting that everyone associated with Bitcoin is a con artist or that the original intentions of the creators was necessarily to swindle people. However, I do wonder why, if that's not the case, why did they design the thing to operate the way it does? But I also acknowledge the probability that at least some of the creators and boosters associated with this thing really believe they're working on something good, but are just too enthusiastic to look at it critically. Consider the Kony 2012 meme for example. Perhaps many of them just don't understand enough economics to see what's really going on there.

It's difficult to ignore the fact that least one of the very highest-profile promoters in the Bitcoin elite is known to be a career con artist with a rap sheet full of finance fraud cases all over the US, and he's well known to be closely associated with one particular Bitcoin exchange that suddenly disappeared for awhile along with the majority of its clients' money, then re-emerged weeks later with a familiar story about having been "hacked." You can interpret that however you like, but I'm highly skeptical.

The very originators of Bitcoin are anonymous, and that makes me highly suspicious also.

On a basic level, Bitcoin operates not as a currency ought to, but appears to function more like a program engineered to create an economic bubble under the pretext of an online payment system.

Also, a single-digit percentage of BTC holders control 50% of all monetary units in existence, easily enough of a monopoly to influence the entire market at their whim, and that's a very bad thing. That's many orders of magnitude greater than the wealth disparity in the US, and all those people are totally anonymous. How can you even consider trusting a system with that level of inequity and opacity?

Also, there have been an astonishing number of high-profile hacks, robberies, and swindles associated with Bitcoin exchanges—even the largest, best-established and most trusted ones—yet nobody has ever been caught or prosecuted for any of those heists. The victims were not compensated for their losses, and the exchanges are not beholden to any form of oversight or accountability. That is totally unacceptable, and indicative of an extremely insecure and corrupt system.

By the way, I keep repeating these arguments (along with references) because they make sense to me and have not been refuted, yet some people in this thread continue to call me a liar. You think I'm making all this stuff up? Then please point out where anything I've said is wrong.
 
Last edited:
Why would anyone create an ostensible "currency" deliberately preprogrammed to operate with dwindling availability like that, unless it was intended to perpetrate a long-term investment scam? What other purpose can be served by such a thing?

I think most readers here are intelligent and critical-minded enough to understand what I'm saying, even if some are not.

I think most intelligent people, unlike you, understand that limiting the supply of bitcoin serves to preserve higher bitcoin prices, and thus bitcoin purchasing power, not lower ones. In fact, if bitcoin were a scam, it would be designed to reward insiders with a fast track to counterfeiting it (like the US Dollar), not in fact limiting the new supply of bitcoins over time.

Most of the problems that have plagued bitcoin relate to problems that have little to do with bitcoin itself, namely the security of exchanges, and problems relating to trust in vendors. The recent ponzi scheme which promised 7% weekly returns had nothing to do with bitcoin itself, and everything to do with the fact that bitcoin is quickly and easily spent/transferred. Ponzi schemes can and are denominated in many different currencies.

Solving the problems of ponzis, the security of exchanges, and the problem of trust over the internet are well beyond the scope of bitcoin, and thus it is irrational to blame the currency itself for the existence of these problems. I'm sure that won't stop you from trying and failing again and again.
 
Last edited:
Gold is a physical, chemical element with many applications (industrial, cultural, and aesthetic), and its availability is limited by nature. Gold can be used to manufacture real, useful things.
Then why has it tended to be so valuable historically, not, of course, to primitive cultures that barely even have barter, but to merchant cultures that didn't have electroplating or industrial applications for it? Why do central banks keep gold and not, for example, diamonds or obsidian, or perhaps even barrels of oil, which is certainly more relevant to modern functions than gold? Why is it so commonly used for coins historically? Why does it always seem to end up being gold specifically over other valuable, rare and/or pretty things?

Bitcoins cannot be used to manufacture anything. As the system is designed, it is ill-suited to its stated purpose and the purpose it is apparently best suited for is a nefarious one.
I've already answered your claims about the "nefarious" nature of it ad nauseam. No point in repeating myself and it gets boring very quickly.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom