How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think most intelligent people, unlike you, understand that limiting the supply of bitcoin serves to preserve higher bitcoin prices, and thus bitcoin purchasing power, not lower ones.

How does that work, since the newer subscribers get less money ?

In fact, if bitcoin were a scam, it would be designed to reward insiders with a fast track to counterfeiting it (like the US Dollar), not in fact limiting the new supply of bitcoins over time.

It's designed to reward the first users i.e. the founders of the system. It's the only sensible explanation, unless they were total economic ignoramuses.
 
That can be said about any argument about any proposal of uncertain merit.

Being mindful of risk is how people avoid bad investments.
 
Any scarcity of bitcoins is artificial. The market perks along, rising slowly until one of the early adopters decides to cash out and dumps some huge number of bitcoins on the market. A system as easily manipulated as that isn't a system I'm going to be putting any money into, thank you very much.
 
John Albert is convincing me with a careful line of reasoned argumentation. The Bitcoin supporters are losing me with non-rebuttals that amount to "nuh-UH!"

If the BC supporters hope to gain some ground in this debate, I suggest offering up some evidence to support your contentions.
 
Then why has it tended to be so valuable historically, not, of course, to primitive cultures that barely even have barter, but to merchant cultures that didn't have electroplating or industrial applications for it? Why do central banks keep gold and not, for example, diamonds or obsidian, or perhaps even barrels of oil, which is certainly more relevant to modern functions than gold? Why is it so commonly used for coins historically? Why does it always seem to end up being gold specifically over other valuable, rare and/or pretty things?


Gold tends to be so valuable because it is a physical element with historical, cultural, religious and aesthetic significance.

This argument is a red herring though. As I pointed out in my last post, bitcoins are not gold. It's a comparison that Bitcoin boosters keep repeating, but it's completely inapt.

Gold is a real commodity with physical substance with universal demand and a wide variety of uses, whereas Bitcoins are not.


I've already answered your claims about the "nefarious" nature of it ad nauseam. No point in repeating myself and it gets boring very quickly.


You may have "answered" my claims, but you certainly have not countered them with any real facts or evidence.
 
Last edited:
I think most intelligent people, unlike you, understand


Ad hominem


limiting the supply of bitcoin serves to preserve higher bitcoin prices, and thus bitcoin purchasing power, not lower ones.


Merely limiting the supply, certainly. I never argued that money ought to be generated and given away willy-nilly without any clear reasoning.

But what's the reasoning behind this plan of allowing the first few million monetary units to be generated freely to the early adopters, then dwindling the production of new units to nothing over the span of 24 years after people have started sinking actual money into it?

That is the part that operates like a scam. I haven't yet seen anyone show me a good reason why it ought to be set up to operate like that, besides being a program designed to enrich its creators over and above any other purpose.


In fact, if bitcoin were a scam, it would be designed to reward insiders with a fast track to counterfeiting it ... not in fact limiting the new supply of bitcoins over time.


False dichotomy. Plenty of scams operate without the need for the scammer to counterfeit anything.

The scam of Bitcoin is not for the originators to counterfeit bitcoins.

The scam is to build a system that awards the originators huge fortunes of the currency with little difficulty, then increases the difficulty sharply, limiting availability for everybody else and encouraging people to invest real money into the system.

As more and more people invest into the system that is subsequently restricting availability of new coins, that causes the existing coins to skyrocket in value and make the originators' hoards extremely valuable.

Then, after people have invested millions of dollars in real cash, the originators hold controlling shares in the currency so they can influence the entire market at their whim, drawing out real cash contributed by others despite having paid nothing in.

Can you really not recognize how this is set up to operate as a scam?


(like the US Dollar)


Your example of the USD makes no sense. The US Treasury Department is the only agency legitimately empowered by law to authorize the production of US dollars, so when they do so it is by definition not counterfeiting.

You also appear to have a very poor understanding of macroeconomics. If the US government started dwindling or severely limiting the supply of USD, the dollar would artificially rise in value, causing people to hoard it instead of spending. That would in turn have a chilling effect on commerce, which would in turn damage the US economy, which would in turn ruin world confidence in the USD, which would ruin the US economy and the US dollar.


Most of the problems that have plagued bitcoin relate to problems that have little to do with bitcoin itself, namely the security of exchanges, and problems relating to trust in vendors.


Contrary to your own false assumption, all those things have everything to do with "Bitcoin itself."

Why do you assume they shouldn't?

Would you also restrict discussions of the USD from mention of the Federal Reserve and the rest of the US banking system? Of course you wouldn't, because those things are part of what makes up the USD.


The recent ponzi scheme which promised 7% weekly returns had nothing to do with bitcoin itself, and everything to do with the fact that bitcoin is quickly and easily spent/transferred. Ponzi schemes can and are denominated in many different currencies.


I didn't even mention that particular scam, but thanks for bringing it up. That's just yet another example of the huge number of ancillary scams being perpetrated within the Bitcoin economy.

Whie it's true that scams can be perpetrated in any economy, it's also true that some economies foster a more tolerant environment for fraud than others. Thus, one can certainly enumerate the number of scams being perpetrated within a given economy, and evaulate the level of fraudulent activity relative to the size of that economy.

Compared with most currencies, Bitcoin harbors a lot of fraud.


Solving the problems of ponzis, the security of exchanges, and the problem of trust over the internet are well beyond the scope of bitcoin


I don't know what you mean by the "scope of bitcoin."

When I talk about Bitcoin, I'm discussing the system in its entirety, as it is promoted in the media and proselytized by its promoters, as it has been implemented and as it is being used. I'm considering it as it operates within the world economy along with other currencies and exchange systems.

The Bitcoin exchanges are an integral part of that system. Without them, the entire house of cards would collapse because BTC would no longer be directly fungible with other currencies. Therefore, you cannot discuss Bitcoin without taking the exchanges into account, just as you cannot discuss the USD without discussing the Federal Reserve and the rest of the US banking system along with all attendant laws and regulations.

If the Bitcoin system harbors a lot of fraudulent activity (as it does), then it's incumbent on the administrators and regulators of that monetary system to address that situation and provide solutions.

But who are the administrators and regulators of Bitcoin? There do not appear to be any.

Nor do there appear to be any laws or regulations at all set up to control this system or ensure ethical behavior of its participants.

The exchanges appear to be the closest thing Bitcoin has to any form of established oversight. Disregarding them, all that's left is a networking protocol for securing secret transactions (something we already had plenty of before Bitcoin came along), and a distributed protocol for doling out a dwindling supply of fake monetary units as compensation for grinding down your computer hardware.


and thus it is irrational to blame the currency itself for the existence of these problems.


You're not making any sense. You're positing false premises and deriving a false conclusion from them.

It would be irrational not to discuss all those problems inherent to dealing with that particular currency, just as it would be meaningless to separate the USD from the entire system of laws and establishments set in place to support it. Bitcoin would be meaningless and useless without the exchanges to facilitate monetary transactions, and gauge its value relative to the real commodities in the world.
 
Last edited:
John Albert is convincing me with a careful line of reasoned argumentation. The Bitcoin supporters are losing me with non-rebuttals that amount to "nuh-UH!"

If the BC supporters hope to gain some ground in this debate, I suggest offering up some evidence to support your contentions.
If you expect everybody except John Albert to backup their posts with evidence then he must be preaching to the choir.

All John Albert has been doing in this forum is repeat the same affirmations ad-nauseum:
* Bitcoin is designed to "unfairly" enrich its originators
* Bitcoin is designed to be a "fraudulent" currency
* Bitcoin is a "Ponzi" scheme.
* Bitcoin is a "Pyramid"

He hasn't provided any evidence for these claims (although he backtracked slightly on the last two claims when he couldn't counter arguments about how bitcoin differed from a ponzi or pyramid).
 
I haven't followed.


Is it still the most important creation in the history of Man?
No it isn't. ATM bitcoin is just a virtual commodity that speculators can experiment with.

It's peerless transfer mechanism is interesting however. It could lead to peerless banking (with official currencies) in the future. People would not need to open up bank accounts in order to transfer funds electronically.
 
My objection to bitcoin is the same as my objection to gold: it can be "mined", which results in a lot of pointless effort that does not create any utility.
 
* Bitcoin is designed to "unfairly" enrich its originators
* Bitcoin is designed to be a "fraudulent" currency
* Bitcoin is a "Ponzi" scheme.
* Bitcoin is a "Pyramid"

It certainly appears to be set up to do the first one.
The second one is sort of a de facto thing; it's naturally open to fraud, as evidenced by the issues with the exchanges.

I won't comment on the last two points.
 
I did not say Bitcoin is a Ponzi scheme. That's another lie you keep repeating to try and discredit me. I compared Bitcoin to a pyramid scheme, and I stand by that comparison.

While it's not strictly a classic multilevel "pyramid game," its wealth distribution and marketing style closely resemble one in a number of ways:

  • The investment "commodity" in question is nothing more than a pretense with no intrinsic value whatsoever.
  • The scheme is hyped as a "revolutionary new system," with promises of financial independence in exchange for little or no actual work.
  • The marketing is especially targeted at fiscally and economically non-savvy individuals, political discontents, extremist ideologues, criminals, and other rebellious types who have few qualms about operating in legal gray areas outside the economic mainstream.
  • All monetary value enters the system at the bottom, paid in by a large number of investors who expect a bigger return on their money.
  • The system pools the incoming wealth and then redistributes it into "shares," of which the originators own an overwhelming majority even though they personally contributed no money of their own into the system.

Bitcoin is fraudulent in that it purports to be a currency without providing any of the protections, legalities, or widespread acceptance that consumers expect of a legitimate currency. In that regard, Bitcoin is misrepresented by its promoters as safe, secure, and widely-accepted, none of which is true.

Besides the fraudulent claims made by Bitcoin promoters, there's been an astounding amount of fraud, graft and theft associated with Bitcoin. Even worse, there's currently no legal recourse for anyone who gets scammed through the use of bitcoins so their losses are irrecoverable and the culprits are almost never brought to justice (I've yet to hear of a single Bitcoin hacker being prosecuted).

So the entire system effectively operates as a safe haven for all sorts of scammers to operate with impunity.
 
  • All monetary value enters the system at the bottom, paid in by a large number of investors who expect a bigger return on their money.
  • The system pools the incoming wealth and then redistributes it into "shares," of which the originators own an overwhelming majority even though they personally contributed no money of their own into the system.
What is this "system" you keep referring to?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom