How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Counterfeiting is counterfeiting. It is criminal.

Counterfeiting is associated with two concepts. The concept of producing an imitation of something, and the concept of the profit that results from producing an imitation of something or more of an "authentic" token, and exchanging it for something real, and valuable.

By the first standard, the "dollar", or Federal Reserve Note, is not counterfeit. It is an authentic Federal Reserve Note, whatever that entails. Neither is bitcoin counterfeit. It is what it is, and it doesn't claim otherwise.

By the second, the dollar is most certainly counterfeit. The issuance of each "authentic" dollar, whether electronically or in print, serves to devalue each pre-existing dollar proportional to the increased supply, resulting in massive profits for its issuers. This is basic supply and demand. The law of supply and demand will not be conned, not even with regard to what that state decrees as money. The property of bitcoin to be "countefeited" in this second regard is cryptographically limited, specifically by the infeasibility of factoring very large numbers in a reasonable amount of time.

So you are correct, counterfeiting is a crime. It is a moral crime which has been legally institutionalized and monopolized in the form of central banking, for the exclusive benefit of an elite few, in the form of unlimited "credit" issued by the central bank to private cronies. The ability to "steal" value from existing bitcoins requires CPU power, time, and technological innovation, all things which are far from costless, and resemble the costs associated to mine or extract precious metals from the ground.

So it seems your disdain of counterfeiting, should be misdirected from the miners and users of bitcoin, to the institutional counterfeiters who steal from the poor by manipulating our money supply.
 
Last edited:
The dollar, while a fiat currency (and I have made myself clear that I do not like fiat currencies), is authorized by Congress and issued under the auspices of the US government, which is the legal standard for legitimate currency.

Clearly, you like fiat currencies by default, and hence, runaway government deficit spending and endless credit (and therefore, endless debt). You do this out of sheer ignorance, of course, not realizing that currency debasement is a regressive tax that harms the poor, middle class, and ultimately anyone who isn't an insider.

Bitcoin is not authorized by Congress, and is not issued under US auspices.

It is NOT legitimate currency.

Who cares? It's not "legitimate" in the sense that the IRS will not accept it as remittance for tax debts, or that you may not be able to buy a barrel of light sweet crude oil from the Rockefeller dynasty with it, but plenty of people are obviously willing to accept and/or save in bitcoin anyway. This isn't enough for you, the statist, jackboot tyrant. You ignorantly advocate making bitcoin illegal, even though it isn't a counterfeit anything, and it is voluntarily accepted by many. On this basis, why should anyone be allowed to own gold, silver, or anything else they deem valuable?

Godwin noted.

Don't make remarks that are better suited for tyrannical mass-murderers like Hitler, and Godwin won't be invoked.

Article 1, Section 8. Congress and only Congress has the power to coin money and fix it's value.

http://www.usconstitution.net/xconst_A1Sec8.html

Oddly enough, "coin" has a very specific meaning, which renders our entire monetary system totally unconstitutional. Thank you for helping to point that out.

Show me the law where Congress has authorized Bitcoin and fixed it's value.

There is none required, as there is no law prohibiting me from voluntarily exchanging all sorts of things with all kinds of people, including digital bits.
 
Clearly, you like fiat currencies by default, and hence, runaway government deficit spending and endless credit (and therefore, endless debt). You do this out of sheer ignorance, of course, not realizing that currency debasement is a regressive tax that harms the poor, middle class, and ultimately anyone who isn't an insider.

[snip]

Why do you think Muldur likes fiat currencies by default?
 
Why do you think Muldur likes fiat currencies by default?

Because he's prevaricating through his teeth. I have repeatedly and publicly spoken in favor of a "backed" or "commoditized" currency, as opposed to a fiat one.

That said, the Federal Reserve Note, fiat or not, IS the legitimate and the ONLY legitimate form of currency in the US. Yes, merchants may if they choose accept the legitimate currencies of other nations if they so chose, but that is a courtesy and not a legal requirement.

Tippit is a dyed-in-the-wool anarchist Libertarian (as if the two words weren't almost the same thing to begin with) and government hater.

He knows perfectly well that Bitcoin is a counterfeit currency, NOT legal tender in any way shape or form, Congress has not authorized Bitcoin. Congress has not set the value of Bitcoin. To proffer it as a medium of exchange in the US is a violation of democratically decided laws designed to protect the fundamental legitimacy of our economy.
 
You'll have to come up with a much better definition of the word "counterfeiting" if you want anybody to understand you.

BTW What aspect of bitcoin makes it a currency to you and not just a commodity?

coun·ter·feit (kountr-ft)
v. coun·ter·feit·ed, coun·ter·feit·ing, coun·ter·feits
v.tr.
1. To make a copy of, usually with the intent to defraud; forge: counterfeits money.

http://www.thefreedictionary.com/counterfeiting

Congress has made the law that the Federal Reserve Note, and ONLY the Federal Reserve Note (and coins) is legal tender in the US.

The profferers of Bitcoin tout it as a "sounder money" than the FRN, implying that it too has legal standing as a currency in the US.

That claim is false, as is clearly and widely known.

Hence, the "mining", "minting", and or attempting to circulate Bitcoin constitute an attempt to pass off an imitation "currency", which is fraudulent in it's intent.

Therefore Bitcoin is a counterfeit, and should be suppressed by any and all means necessary in order to protect the legitimacy of the dollar as our national currency.

And yes, it pains me to call any fiat currency as being "legitimate", but it clearly is the currency of the nation, NOT Bitcoin.
 
Congress has made the law that the Federal Reserve Note, and ONLY the Federal Reserve Note (and coins) is legal tender in the US.

The profferers of Bitcoin tout it as a "sounder money" than the FRN, implying that it too has legal standing as a currency in the US.

That claim is false, as is clearly and widely known.

Hence, the "mining", "minting", and or attempting to circulate Bitcoin constitute an attempt to pass off an imitation "currency", which is fraudulent in it's intent.

Therefore Bitcoin is a counterfeit, and should be suppressed by any and all means necessary in order to protect the legitimacy of the dollar as our national currency.

And yes, it pains me to call any fiat currency as being "legitimate", but it clearly is the currency of the nation, NOT Bitcoin.

Would you consider units of currencies in MMORRPGS (that can be bought with real money) to be counterfeit? They can be considered to have value, but they're not intended to replace other currencies.
 
Would you consider units of currencies in MMORRPGS (that can be bought with real money) to be counterfeit? They can be considered to have value, but they're not intended to replace other currencies.

I raise you a Dollhouse-Dollar. A table dance bar in my hometown prints their own currency, since the Euro doesn't have small denomination bills that could be slipped into the dancers' clothes.
 
Would you consider units of currencies in MMORRPGS (that can be bought with real money) to be counterfeit? They can be considered to have value, but they're not intended to replace other currencies.

These currencies don´t pretend to be real, real-world money, do they? Nobody claims that WoW gold pieces are as good as, or better than, Federal Reserve Notes as a means of storing wealth, do they?
 
Congress has made the law that the Federal Reserve Note, and ONLY the Federal Reserve Note (and coins) is legal tender in the US.

The profferers of Bitcoin tout it as a "sounder money" than the FRN, implying that it too has legal standing as a currency in the US.

That claim is false, as is clearly and widely known.

Hence, the "mining", "minting", and or attempting to circulate Bitcoin constitute an attempt to pass off an imitation "currency", which is fraudulent in it's intent.

Therefore Bitcoin is a counterfeit, and should be suppressed by any and all means necessary in order to protect the legitimacy of the dollar as our national currency.

And yes, it pains me to call any fiat currency as being "legitimate", but it clearly is the currency of the nation, NOT Bitcoin.

Clearly, in addition to having problems understanding basic arithmetic (as was evident from prior posts of yours), you have problems understanding the basic meaning of words and how they apply. I think we're wasting our time here.
 
Clearly, in addition to having problems understanding basic arithmetic (as was evident from prior posts of yours), you have problems understanding the basic meaning of words and how they apply. I think we're wasting our time here.

Could you make a more specific dismissal of his statements please?
 
I'm not sure any counterfeiting or other legal tender issues are in play unless someone asserts the right to settle a debt using bitcoin--that is, someone else can be legally forced to accept it as payment.
 
These currencies don´t pretend to be real, real-world money, do they? Nobody claims that WoW gold pieces are as good as, or better than, Federal Reserve Notes as a means of storing wealth, do they?

But if I make those claims I am clearly saying that bitcoins are not US Dollars. I am comparing something that is not a US Dollar to a US Dollar, after all.

And I don't think saying that something is good (or bad) to store wealth in makes any claims about it being legal tender, anywhere. I could make the claim about gold, diamonds, euros, real estate, bio energy stocks and chicken McNuggets, without thereby implying that any of them would be legal tender in any specific location.
 
Bitcoin is now being solicited by IP pirates as a means of transaction now that they are being systematically cut off from their other sources of financing their criminal activities.

http://tuebl.com/

TUEBL is under a financial blockaid by people who don't understand basic copyright laws in the United States and Canada. However, we don't need PayPal. With bitcoin, you can send us a donation that is peer to peer with no middleman. You can also use Moneybookers who are also a fairly friendly company. Thank you for your support, we know that we will be victorious but it will only be with the support of amazing people like our TUEBLers.

More criminal activity associated with Bitcoin, the counterfeit money.
 
It is being proffered as a replacement forFRNs,
I don't recall anybody saying you won't need FRNs if you have bitcoins. It is difficult to see a commodity that can't grow threatening a national currency.

which are the ONLY authorized legal tender in the US.
All that means is that if you offer somebody bitcoins to settle a debt, he can say "nuh uh" without loosing the debt.
 
^No, which means that it is a counterfeit currency with ZERO value whatsoever.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom