Counterfeiting is counterfeiting. It is criminal.
Counterfeiting is associated with two concepts. The concept of producing an imitation of something, and the concept of the profit that results from producing an imitation of something or more of an "authentic" token, and exchanging it for something real, and valuable.
By the first standard, the "dollar", or Federal Reserve Note, is not counterfeit. It is an authentic Federal Reserve Note, whatever that entails. Neither is bitcoin counterfeit. It is what it is, and it doesn't claim otherwise.
By the second, the dollar is most certainly counterfeit. The issuance of each "authentic" dollar, whether electronically or in print, serves to devalue each pre-existing dollar proportional to the increased supply, resulting in massive profits for its issuers. This is basic supply and demand. The law of supply and demand will not be conned, not even with regard to what that state decrees as money. The property of bitcoin to be "countefeited" in this second regard is cryptographically limited, specifically by the infeasibility of factoring very large numbers in a reasonable amount of time.
So you are correct, counterfeiting is a crime. It is a moral crime which has been legally institutionalized and monopolized in the form of central banking, for the exclusive benefit of an elite few, in the form of unlimited "credit" issued by the central bank to private cronies. The ability to "steal" value from existing bitcoins requires CPU power, time, and technological innovation, all things which are far from costless, and resemble the costs associated to mine or extract precious metals from the ground.
So it seems your disdain of counterfeiting, should be misdirected from the miners and users of bitcoin, to the institutional counterfeiters who steal from the poor by manipulating our money supply.
Last edited: