How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
You have had this question answered several times now. Anybody can setup a rival to bitcoin (I have seen at least one attempt) but unless it offers something that the existing bitcoin setup doesn't, it is unlikely to entice existing bitcoin holders to switch.

But then, for everybody who doesn't have bit-coins, wouldn't it make sense to get in early to a new system?

And from what I see here, it wouldn't take a lot of effort to make any new system more attractive than the old one - just get an actual merchant to support the system!
 
But then, for everybody who doesn't have bit-coins, wouldn't it make sense to get in early to a new system?
No.

The only people who can benefit from the introduction of a new commodity are the people who actually introduce it.

For everybody else, it's a case of buy at one price and sell at another.
 
No.

The only people who can benefit from the introduction of a new commodity are the people who actually introduce it.

For everybody else, it's a case of buy at one price and sell at another.

I suppose it's pedantic, but some of the early adopters of bitcoin weren't necessarily "people who introduced it," right? Early on, the keys were easier to find, so early miners got enough bitcoins to earn some dough once other people adopted and put money in the system, right?

That was my understanding of the system, anyway.
 
That's cool. The only reason that I keep bumping this thread is that everybody keeps saying that bitcoin won't last.

The truth is that nobody can say when a commodity might lose its value.
 
I wouldn't say bitcoin won't last. But I don't think it's functioning very well as a currency; its value is too unstable.
 
No.

The only people who can benefit from the introduction of a new commodity are the people who actually introduce it.

For everybody else, it's a case of buy at one price and sell at another.

You seem to be using "benefit" and "introduce" in very special ways.

I mean, the way you're using those words, it seems like you would say, "the only people who can benefit from the introduction of a polio vaccine are the people who actually introduce it. For everybody else, it's a case of buy it at one price and... not get polio."

The way I figure--what I would call the normal use of the words "benefit" and "introduce"--anybody who benefits from trading commodities could potentially benefit from the introduction of another commodity to the marketplace.

Take second-hand bookstores, for example. Would you say that only the author benefits from introducing a new book to the market? Does the publisher simply buy at one price and sell at another? What about the reader? Is there no benefit to the reader, in buying the book at one price, reading it, and then selling it to the used bookseller at another price?

Is there no benefit to the bookseller, in buying the book at one price, and selling it at another?
 
Last edited:
There is no utility (satisfaction) or depreciation associated with bitcoin so comparisons between a commodity like bitcoin and a product like a book are not all that straight forward. About the only benefit you can get from bitcoin is from making a profit out of it (unless you count "medium of exchange" as a benefit) where as a book also offers non financial benefits (such as a good story).

I can think of two ways one might benefit from a commodity. One is to trade it profitably (the "trading benefit") and the other is to make it then sell it (the "manufacturing benefit"). I hope that these made up terms help to clarify the issue for you.

Now stop trying to make me appear less profound! ;)
 
Notice how I haven't used the word "currency" here.

So it seems you are chiding people for saying Bitcoin would disappear, when it hasn't. Which makes sense, at a certain level.

But I think one of the intents people have in saying Bitcoin won't last is that it won't last as a medium of exchange, or a currency, which is its supposed purpose.

If you mean it will survive as a commodity, you are probably right there, at least in the immediate future.

So this became sort of a meta-post about the structure of the discussion. I hope it helps at least one person. :)
 
A year or two.

I've been predicting a total collapse of the dollar in or around 2012 for some time now.

I hope you are still at the forum in a year.

Ok, it's mid 2012, and the dollar shows no more signs of collapse then when you wrote this, which was July 19th, 2011. I hope you see this post. I'm really tired of people making these predictions, then not being called on them.
 
Last edited:
The dollar is safe (at least for now) so long as one or more of the following conditions still obtains:

1) the dollar remains the "reserve currency". Right now there is no credible challenger. The Euro is a mess as is the Eurozone. The BRIC nations (Brazil, Russia, India, China) have been discussing a new, at least partially "backed" global reserve currency for a few years, but haven't made a lot of progress to date on it. If and when they do...watch out.

2) The US manages to at least stay one step ahead of it's debt problem. Reserve currency or not, the dollar is a goner if the international financial community even seriously suspects the US might go Greece.

3) no "black swan" event (a major world-wide drought, a ME war, etc) kicks the legs out from under the entire international system. If that happens, and global trade were to be significantly impacted, we're ALL in trouble.
 
Ok, it's mid 2012, and the dollar shows no more signs of collapse then when you wrote this, which was July 19th, 2011. I hope you see this post. I'm really tired of people making these predictions, then not being called on them.

Just during Obama’s presidency alone, each taxpayer has been made responsible for paying back $64,219.88 worth of new government debt. If each taxpayer were forced to pay off the entire debt, each would owe $193,989.72. And that doesn’t count unfunded liabilities. If we count unfunded liabilities, each one owes $1,221,147.51.

Given the obvious fact that America doesn’t have the resources to meet its future financial obligations, its sovereign credit rating is eventually going to be downgraded substantially. And when that happens, interest rates will sky rocket. And when that happens, the state will no longer have the tax revenues necessary to meet the interest payments on its debt obligations. And when that happens, people aren’t going to lend us any money or sell us anything in exchange for our money. They will demand payment in “things,” rather than paper money. And when that happens, our standard of living will drop to that of a third world country.

Don't worry, it will happen. Exactly when the whole house of cards will finally implode is anyone's guess, but it's going to happen. There's still plenty of time left in the year for my prediction to come true. We are barely half way through 2012.
 
I don't think that it's obvious that we don't have the resources to meet our financial obligations.

It's scary to put that number out there and divide it to a fixed amount for each American, but what if the number were distributed to a percent of 10-year income? What percentage would be needed? And that's even assuming a flat instead of progressive burden.
 
I don't think that it's obvious that we don't have the resources to meet our financial obligations.

It's scary to put that number out there and divide it to a fixed amount for each American, but what if the number were distributed to a percent of 10-year income? What percentage would be needed? And that's even assuming a flat instead of progressive burden.

Sure, if you distribute it over 10 years, the state might be able to take enough resources from the private sector to make the payments it owes. However, this assumes that no new debt will be added. If the government keeps running a budget deficit, its eventually going to hit a wall.

In order for the government to simply balance its books, the entire state apparatus would have to reduce itself in size by two thirds. - and that will never happen.

This nation will experience a currency crisis, because it is run by sociopaths.
 
Sure, if you distribute it over 10 years, the state might be able to take enough resources from the private sector to make the payments it owes. However, this assumes that no new debt will be added. If the government keeps running a budget deficit, its eventually going to hit a wall.

In order for the government to simply balance its books, the entire state apparatus would have to reduce itself in size by two thirds. - and that will never happen.

This nation will experience a currency crisis, because it is run by sociopaths.

You don't think they could be idiots?
 
Why is everyone so extreme in this forum? I'm pretty sure there's at least a little happy ground between "this will cure AIDs and spawn puppies from thin air" and "it's the cancer that's killing the economy."

Counterfeiting is counterfeiting. It is criminal.
 
The European Union I'm sure will be shocked to hear that we're not supposed to trade with you guys any more ...

That's not even a good dodge, Rasmus. The Euro is a legitimate currency authorized and issued by a legitimate government. Bitcoin is not.
 
Nice to know you're a bootlicking statist, and would-be tyrant. Bitcoin isn't a counterfeit anything. It's a decentralized, digital currency. No one using bitcoin is confusing it with Federal Reserve Notes. The "legitimacy" of the fiat dollar is based on fraud, theft, and perpetual war.

The dollar, while a fiat currency (and I have made myself clear that I do not like fiat currencies), is authorized by Congress and issued under the auspices of the US government, which is the legal standard for legitimate currency.

Bitcoin is not authorized by Congress, and is not issued under US auspices.

It is NOT legitimate currency.

Seig heil!

Godwin noted.

May I suggest you read this document called the US Constitution, and take your tyrannical, nanny-state advocacy to some other country.

Article 1, Section 8. Congress and only Congress has the power to coin money and fix it's value.

http://www.usconstitution.net/xconst_A1Sec8.html

Show me the law where Congress has authorized Bitcoin and fixed it's value.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom