How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.

Mt.Gox is the main surviving exchange, after all main competitors either left the market or were hacked out of existence. Bitcoin has been plagued with hacking attacks and heists, the last prominent victim being Bitcoinica, which had to shut down. To me this is the best evidence of a dying market.

As to the actual viability, check the volumes in Mt.Gox. The top volume spikes are at 8k BTC, with average ranging the 800-1k mark. This is nothing for the early adopters, who everyone agrees, have accumulated large amounts of BTC.

I'm not the first person to point out that there is market manipulation:
http://www.quora.com/Bitcoin/Is-the-cryptocurrency-Bitcoin-a-good-idea
http://nerdr.com/bitcoin-exchange-scam-bitcoins-are-worthless/

As to the actual market, I had a long look at their market list, and its filled with dodgy businesses, and most importantly, most of the listed sites do not accept Bitcoin now, if they ever did. Moreover, if you discount the BTC-related businesses (novelty coins, e wallets), the list is even more pitiful.
https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Trade

It is evident that people are not using Bitcoin as a currency, and everything points toward speculation.
 
Are there exchanges in various currencies? And what are transaction fees like?

The reason I ask is from the thread about sending a cheque from USA to UK, if the fees are competitive (with bank charges, bureaux de change or paypal for example) it could be a potential use.

The main exchange has transaction fees that range from .60% to %.25% depending on volume. This does not include any transaction fees from the other intermediary you need in order to transfer money in and out of Mt.Gox. For example, you need a Dwolla or Liberty Exchange account, and these charge you as well per transaction (flat rate of $.25 for Dwolla to receive funds, not sure how much to send).

In my opinion, once you take everything into account, and the real possibility of hacking and losing your money forever, it's just not worth it when compared to more expensive but simpler and more established methods. I prefer to have funds in PayPal knowing that they just won't disappear some day. If you read the BTC forums, this is a daily occurrence.
 
I am astonished that this counterfeit "currency" is still being allowed to circulate. They put an end to the Liberty Dollar, arguably a far more legitimate form or currency in that it was "backed", and not a fiat currency.

being allowed by whom exactly? isn't that it's strength, without shutting down the internet they cant stop it?
 
being allowed by whom exactly? isn't that it's strength, without shutting down the internet they cant stop it?

Regulators can make exchanges illegal, so it would be difficult to convert money.

This has taken place to some extent in Europe, where banks closed some accounts used to transfer funds because they did not comply with existing banking and electronic money regulations. See:
https://support.mtgox.com/entries/2...suspended-within-europe-with-immediate-effect
 
Mt.Gox is the main surviving exchange, after all main competitors either left the market or were hacked out of existence. Bitcoin has been plagued with hacking attacks and heists, the last prominent victim being Bitcoinica, which had to shut down. To me this is the best evidence of a dying market.

As to the actual viability, check the volumes in Mt.Gox. The top volume spikes are at 8k BTC, with average ranging the 800-1k mark. This is nothing for the early adopters, who everyone agrees, have accumulated large amounts of BTC.
There is no source there. That is just a personal opinion of yours and completely at odds with the daily 25K-50K volumes being shown on the bitcoin charts.

Those references are more than 12 months old. They are just personal opinions suggesting that bitcoin won't last and that only the greedy and corrupt would make use of bitcoin. (That's like saying that only drug pushers oppose the prohibition of marijuana).

As to the actual market, I had a long look at their market list, and its filled with dodgy businesses, and most importantly, most of the listed sites do not accept Bitcoin now, if they ever did. Moreover, if you discount the BTC-related businesses (novelty coins, e wallets), the list is even more pitiful.
https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Trade
The market is limited but bitcoins have value regardless.

It is evident that people are not using Bitcoin as a currency, and everything points toward speculation.
That's the only fair statement in your post.
 
There is no source there. That is just a personal opinion of yours and completely at odds with the daily 25K-50K volumes being shown on the bitcoin charts.

There are no authoritative sources in Bitcoin, it is too niche, and people have all sorts of opinions. Having studied closely Bitcoin since very early for professional reasons, to me it is clear that the market is perfect for manipulation, particularly given the volumes.

BTW, daily volumes are irrelevant when trying to determine price and manipulation, what matters is the offer and demand around bid walls, where relatively small transfers move the market in one way or the other. Given that we know for a fact that a few players have considerable BTC wealth, the prospect for manipulation cannot be ignored.

Those references are more than 12 months old. They are just personal opinions suggesting that bitcoin won't last and that only the greedy and corrupt would make use of bitcoin. (That's like saying that only drug pushers oppose the prohibition of marijuana).

The Quora answers are still relevant for the reasons pointed out above. Anyone who is willing to enter into a speculative market where a few early adopters hold immense power over price is asking to be taken for a mug. Moreover, the prevalence of hacking incidents leads one to believe that a large part of the BTC scene is indeed tremendously dodgy.

The market is limited but bitcoins have value regardless.

Everything has value, we have been discussing if Bitcoin is viable. I don't think that it is for the reasons stated.
 
being allowed by whom exactly? isn't that it's strength, without shutting down the internet they cant stop it?

They can arrest any and everyone using it for counterfeiting and fraud, seize their computers and make life a living nightmare for anyone else trying to use them.
 
They can arrest any and everyone using it for counterfeiting and fraud, seize their computers and make life a living nightmare for anyone else trying to use them.
Not everyone, just the people who are using it to launder money. The rest of the "investors" and hobby users who never convert their coins to $ aren't of any concern. A nice side effect of this would be the shutting-down of the serious miners, since they could no longer transfer the coins back to pay for all of their equipment. That'll make normal users competitive in generation again, and we can talk about restarting the currency without giving single parties such enormous market leverage. So the sooner the better, imo.
 
They can arrest any and everyone using it for counterfeiting and fraud, seize their computers and make life a living nightmare for anyone else trying to use them.
That could actually happen.

Politicians would love to ban bitcoins then use that as a pretext for governments to take greater control over the internet.
 
Not everyone, just the people who are using it to launder money.

No, everyone. There is NO legitimate use for bitcoin. It is a counterfeit currency, and undermines what little legitimacy our current fiat dollar has.

NO one should be allowed to use bitcoin (or any other "alternative" form of currency) for any transactions.
 
Last edited:
That could actually happen.

Politicians would love to ban bitcoins then use that as a pretext for governments to take greater control over the internet.

That wouldn't be an entirely bad thing. We need more government control in certain areas, such as eradicating child porn and sites like NAMBLA's who promote sexual abuse of children.

We could also use enforcement of the First Amendment on chat rooms, bbses and forums, which are currently exempt as "private property" despite the fact that the internet is becoming the new public forum for communication, debate, and discussion.
 
No, everyone. There is NO legitimate use for bitcoin. It is a counterfeit currency, and undermines what little legitimacy our current fiat dollar has.

NO one should be allowed to use bitcoin (or any other "alternative" form of currency) for any transactions.
If we ban everything that might be of benefit to criminals, we would still be going around clubbing to death anybody who made a wheel.
 
No, everyone. There is NO legitimate use for bitcoin. It is a counterfeit currency, and undermines what little legitimacy our current fiat dollar has.

NO one should be allowed to use bitcoin (or any other "alternative" form of currency) for any transactions.
Why is everyone so extreme in this forum? I'm pretty sure there's at least a little happy ground between "this will cure AIDs and spawn puppies from thin air" and "it's the cancer that's killing the economy."
 
No, everyone. There is NO legitimate use for bitcoin. It is a counterfeit currency, and undermines what little legitimacy our current fiat dollar has.

NO one should be allowed to use bitcoin (or any other "alternative" form of currency) for any transactions.

The European Union I'm sure will be shocked to hear that we're not supposed to trade with you guys any more ...
 
No, everyone. There is NO legitimate use for bitcoin. It is a counterfeit currency, and undermines what little legitimacy our current fiat dollar has.

Nice to know you're a bootlicking statist, and would-be tyrant. Bitcoin isn't a counterfeit anything. It's a decentralized, digital currency. No one using bitcoin is confusing it with Federal Reserve Notes. The "legitimacy" of the fiat dollar is based on fraud, theft, and perpetual war.

NO one should be allowed to use bitcoin (or any other "alternative" form of currency) for any transactions.

Seig heil!

On the contrary, no one should be forced to use the Federal Reserve Note of confiscation. It looks like you've figured out that it's nothing more than a tax, and, being in favor of and having absolute faith in the central planners, bankers, and bureaucrats who run everything, you wouldn't want to deny them their lobster and crab dinners.

Maybe once you figure out it's a regressive tax that is crushing the poor and middle class, and benefits an elite group of bankers with extraordinary wealth, you will change your tune. Not really likely though. May I suggest you read this document called the US Constitution, and take your tyrannical, nanny-state advocacy to some other country.
 
No, everyone. There is NO legitimate use for bitcoin. It is a counterfeit currency, and undermines what little legitimacy our current fiat dollar has.

NO one should be allowed to use bitcoin (or any other "alternative" form of currency) for any transactions.

You can buy Nestor Games with bitcoins. He's trying to avoid depreciation of the Euro by doing so. That's a legitimate use. I think he's avoiding one problem and taking on another, but that's up to him.
 
Not everyone, just the people who are using it to launder money. The rest of the "investors" and hobby users who never convert their coins to $ aren't of any concern. A nice side effect of this would be the shutting-down of the serious miners, since they could no longer transfer the coins back to pay for all of their equipment. That'll make normal users competitive in generation again, and we can talk about restarting the currency without giving single parties such enormous market leverage. So the sooner the better, imo.

And if the government isn't keen on shutting them down and solving the existing problems, we could always just start another one.

That's the problem I see here. Bitcoins illustrate in some sense that fiat currencies are not any more "real" than bitcoins, but dollars do have one serious advantage over bitcoins. There really is, for the forseeable future, a government of the United States, and they have a vested interest, and a great deal of power, in ensuring that people take those dollars seriously. That whole "full faith and credit" language has some meaning.

Bitcoin is just a game. If you don't like it, you can start a new game, and now you have bitcoins 2.0 which have all of the same properties as bitcoins. Why would people decide that the original bitcoins are "special"?
 
Bitcoin is just a game. If you don't like it, you can start a new game, and now you have bitcoins 2.0 which have all of the same properties as bitcoins. Why would people decide that the original bitcoins are "special"?
You have had this question answered several times now. Anybody can setup a rival to bitcoin (I have seen at least one attempt) but unless it offers something that the existing bitcoin setup doesn't, it is unlikely to entice existing bitcoin holders to switch.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom