How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Read the quote. It is about the developers.

It does not say anything about devs and through the context of the thread I've come to the conclusion that the only group that it would need to be about is the initial investor group. I've tried to be clear, I even offered to make a venn diagram to help you out, but if you aren't actually willing to go beyond "I'm right because I say so" I see no reason to continue. Heck, I could be wrong. Almo could come say he meant the devs (for whatever inane reason), but you have just as much information as I do into someone else's post so you bare assertions don't really pull much weight.
 
It really can't be that difficult. The program tells your PC to run a specific calculation that takes an expected amount of time, and adds 1 to a counter. When that counter is equal to a randomly generated number, you get a bitcoin. Every time someone gets a bitcoin, the random number generator increases its range of values.

All the difficulty is in the math you need to use to make sure the system profits you more than anyone else.

Since, apparently, the calculation it's doing is part of a distributed crypotgraphy computation I'm pretty sure it wasn't a simple days work. It probably also underwent a not insignificant amount of testing - or at least I would hope it did. But then as freeware software there's a good chance it was started as a side project while the went to school or worked, so it they may not have been particularly dedicated either.
 
But if you claimed he invested nothing, you would be wrong irrespective of anything else. You claimed that the Bitcoin programmers and early adopters invested little to nothing. And you are wrong. Do you recognize this?

You are wrong that this matters. Bernie Madoff invested time and effort in his Ponzi scheme. That does not make it less of a scam. Do you recognize this?
 
A look at the 6 month price history shows that the price of bitcoin has stabilized quite remarkably this year - suggesting that it has found a niche in the market. Since March, the price has been reasonably steady at $5 US.

Not surprisingly, the price has climbed quite a bit since the beginning of June when news about Spain and Greece hit the fan. It is currently trading at about $6.50

LINK
 
I am astonished that this counterfeit "currency" is still being allowed to circulate. They put an end to the Liberty Dollar, arguably a far more legitimate form or currency in that it was "backed", and not a fiat currency.
 
I recently stumbled onto the existence of Bitcoin. I had seen this thread, but only skimmed the first page of it. I recently read the Wired article from a few months ago, and found it quite fascinating.

However, it seems to me there's a rather obvious problem with Bitcoin, and I wonder if any Bitcoin enthusiasts would care to point out the problem with what I'm thinking. This has probably been addressed somewhere in the thread, so I apologize for bringing it up again, but it just seemed like an obvious question to me.

The inventor of Bitcoin did a fantastic job of creating a brand new currency that is a nice fit for the cyber age. What stops anyone else from doing it again? Can I make Meadcoins? I'll use the same algorithm and methods, and now there will be a new currency. And then I'll do it again. And my neighbors will do it. What is it that prevents a plethora of "bit" currencies from being created, and why would anyone honor one over the others? The only way I could see to prevent it would be if a government (or corporation?) stepped in to regulate it, and then Bitcoin would lose the thing that gave it its cool factor.

Come to think of it, I would think the government(s) would love to see something like Bitcoin succeed. A currency where every transaction is recorded? Sounds like something the IRS would love to get in on.

It's cool, but I just don't see much of a future for it. If it were to really take off, either a slew of imitators or a gaggle of regulators would kill it.
 
I recently stumbled onto the existence of Bitcoin. I had seen this thread, but only skimmed the first page of it. I recently read the Wired article from a few months ago, and found it quite fascinating.

However, it seems to me there's a rather obvious problem with Bitcoin, and I wonder if any Bitcoin enthusiasts would care to point out the problem with what I'm thinking. This has probably been addressed somewhere in the thread, so I apologize for bringing it up again, but it just seemed like an obvious question to me.

The inventor of Bitcoin did a fantastic job of creating a brand new currency that is a nice fit for the cyber age. What stops anyone else from doing it again? Can I make Meadcoins? I'll use the same algorithm and methods, and now there will be a new currency. And then I'll do it again. And my neighbors will do it. What is it that prevents a plethora of "bit" currencies from being created, and why would anyone honor one over the others? The only way I could see to prevent it would be if a government (or corporation?) stepped in to regulate it, and then Bitcoin would lose the thing that gave it its cool factor.

Come to think of it, I would think the government(s) would love to see something like Bitcoin succeed. A currency where every transaction is recorded? Sounds like something the IRS would love to get in on.

It's cool, but I just don't see much of a future for it. If it were to really take off, either a slew of imitators or a gaggle of regulators would kill it.

Who would you spend your meadcoins with? Bitcoin has value because people in the free market say it does. simple (just my opinion, I'm no expert)
 
Last edited:
I am astonished that this counterfeit "currency" is still being allowed to circulate. They put an end to the Liberty Dollar, arguably a far more legitimate form or currency in that it was "backed", and not a fiat currency.

My understanding was that in a way its backed by the power of the cryptography creating it. Is that wrong?
 
Who would you spend your meadcoins with? Bitcoin has value because people in the free market say it does. simple (just my opinion, I'm no expert)

Sure. As long as people honor it, it will have value.

But right now it's this weird little fringe thing that people think is cool. No one wants to screw it up. The people with lots of bitcoins certainly don't, because they would lose value. The people with only a few bitcoins don't, because that would destroy their game.

But suppose it gets to the point that a lot of people have heard of it. At that point, a merchant may decide whether or not to take bitcoins, and at that point, he'll also have to decide about meadcoins. Of course, no one would take meadcoins all that seriously, but suppose Zuckerberg gets on the bandwagon and starts minting Facecoins. What then? And Google will have gCoins. And some intern at Citicorp will have Citicoins, and....where does it stop. What's so special about this one algorithm and collection of "miners" and all the rest of the bitcoin infrastructure to distinguish it from someone else who wants to do the exact same thing.

Once upon a time, banks printed their own money, and it was backed by the bank, and people exchanged the bank notes as if they were "real money" i.e. gold. However, it turned out this was a bad idea, and this practice was ended. Now, once again, we have private entities minting their own money. As long as it's some sort of novelty, it won't do any harm, but if it ever became enough of a real presence to have an impact on the real economy, it seems like it can't last.
 
A look at the 6 month price history shows that the price of bitcoin has stabilized quite remarkably this year - suggesting that it has found a niche in the market. Since March, the price has been reasonably steady at $5 US.

Not surprisingly, the price has climbed quite a bit since the beginning of June when news about Spain and Greece hit the fan. It is currently trading at about $6.50

LINK

If the US dollar showed 30% change in value over a few months, people would be freaking out.
 
I am astonished that this counterfeit "currency" is still being allowed to circulate. They put an end to the Liberty Dollar, arguably a far more legitimate form or currency in that it was "backed", and not a fiat currency.

This has been touched on several times in this thread. One of the reasons for its continued survival is as a means of transferring value where other currencies are not well supported. In addition to the obvious covert uses, there are still parts of the world where there is little to no formal banking system, no Amex, Western Union, or Wells Fargo office to send money to, but this requires no more than an internet connection and a willing partner to accept a transfer of funds.

IOW, it survives for practical reasons, neither because of nor in spite of its status as a legitimate currency.
 
Sure. As long as people honor it, it will have value.

But right now it's this weird little fringe thing that people think is cool. No one wants to screw it up. The people with lots of bitcoins certainly don't, because they would lose value. The people with only a few bitcoins don't, because that would destroy their game.

But suppose it gets to the point that a lot of people have heard of it. At that point, a merchant may decide whether or not to take bitcoins, and at that point, he'll also have to decide about meadcoins. Of course, no one would take meadcoins all that seriously, but suppose Zuckerberg gets on the bandwagon and starts minting Facecoins. What then? And Google will have gCoins. And some intern at Citicorp will have Citicoins, and....where does it stop. What's so special about this one algorithm and collection of "miners" and all the rest of the bitcoin infrastructure to distinguish it from someone else who wants to do the exact same thing.

Once upon a time, banks printed their own money, and it was backed by the bank, and people exchanged the bank notes as if they were "real money" i.e. gold. However, it turned out this was a bad idea, and this practice was ended. Now, once again, we have private entities minting their own money. As long as it's some sort of novelty, it won't do any harm, but if it ever became enough of a real presence to have an impact on the real economy, it seems like it can't last.

so you're saying people shouldn't be free to trade with whatever they feel is safest and has value ?, and that governments should dictate what can be used as a medium of exchange. That would sure suck if banks and governments decided to collude and defraud their populations of wealth, oh wait....
 
Last edited:
What stops anyone else from doing it again? Can I make Meadcoins? I'll use the same algorithm and methods, and now there will be a new currency. And then I'll do it again. And my neighbors will do it. What is it that prevents a plethora of "bit" currencies from being created, and why would anyone honor one over the others?

From what I've read, all you have to do to create a "new currency" with the bitcoin software is generate a new initial cryptographic seed. Convincing other people that "Meadcoins" have (or will have) value would be (as you hint above) the real trick.
 
It's cool, but I just don't see much of a future for it. If it were to really take off, either a slew of imitators or a gaggle of regulators would kill it.
Imitators probably will try and set up rivals to bitcoin but unless they offer an advantage over bitcoin, they will have a hard time getting up. (A virtual currency that grows perpetually might be one such advantage).

Each bitcoin has its "wallet" history but individuals can generate as many wallets as they like so it would be difficult to track which individuals have had access to the coins.

Killing off bitcoin by regulation would be no easier than killing off the cash economy.
 
Killing off bitcoin by regulation would be no easier than killing off the cash economy.

That's a good analogy, yet it seems to me more like a decentralized barter system — not something I'd care to invest in speculatively, but certainly something to take note of.
 
A look at the 6 month price history shows that the price of bitcoin has stabilized quite remarkably this year - suggesting that it has found a niche in the market. Since March, the price has been reasonably steady at $5 US.

Not surprisingly, the price has climbed quite a bit since the beginning of June when news about Spain and Greece hit the fan. It is currently trading at about $6.50

LINK

Given the demise of all but a few exchanges, and the volumes we see, this is only being used for speculation. The price is artificially being propped up by the large holders. Outside of the illegal drug trade, nobody is using BTCs to buy anything, so this is not a currency.
 
Given the demise of all but a few exchanges, and the volumes we see, this is only being used for speculation. The price is artificially being propped up by the large holders. Outside of the illegal drug trade, nobody is using BTCs to buy anything, so this is not a currency.
Source?
 
so you're saying people shouldn't be free to trade with whatever they feel is safest and has value ?, and that governments should dictate what can be used as a medium of exchange. That would sure suck if banks and governments decided to collude and defraud their populations of wealth, oh wait....

Well, I guess I am saying something awfully close to that.

The issuance of currency or of currency-like instruments is an area that is just rife for abuse, corruption, and fraud.

Sovereign governments want a monopoly on that sort of thing.;)

But seriously, this just screams fraud. If Bitcoin itself is not thoroughly corrupt, if it is successful it will spawn imitators, and an awful lot of those will be corrupt.

As for advantages that those Bitcoin imitators would have to have, I could make something exactly like Bitcoin. It would have no advantages over Bitcoin, but it would have no inherent disadvantages, either. Would people use it? There's no reason not to, which means some people would, which would mean that the only thing keeping Bitcoin's value up would be the collective consciousness of a bunch of users who would have to say that among a bunch of identical options, we'll only use this one. That's not worth the magnetic blips the money is printed on.
 
Sovereign governments want a monopoly on that sort of thing.;)
Evidently, you are unaware of where most of the money we use comes from.

But seriously, this just screams fraud.
By that I gather you mean that either you can't get the advertised price of bitcoins from the traders or that it is possible to conceal your transactions from the government (as with cash).
 
Are there exchanges in various currencies? And what are transaction fees like?

The reason I ask is from the thread about sending a cheque from USA to UK, if the fees are competitive (with bank charges, bureaux de change or paypal for example) it could be a potential use.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom