Sure. As long as people honor it, it will have value.
But right now it's this weird little fringe thing that people think is cool. No one wants to screw it up. The people with lots of bitcoins certainly don't, because they would lose value. The people with only a few bitcoins don't, because that would destroy their game.
But suppose it gets to the point that a lot of people have heard of it. At that point, a merchant may decide whether or not to take bitcoins, and at that point, he'll also have to decide about meadcoins. Of course, no one would take meadcoins all that seriously, but suppose Zuckerberg gets on the bandwagon and starts minting Facecoins. What then? And Google will have gCoins. And some intern at Citicorp will have Citicoins, and....where does it stop. What's so special about this one algorithm and collection of "miners" and all the rest of the bitcoin infrastructure to distinguish it from someone else who wants to do the exact same thing.
Once upon a time, banks printed their own money, and it was backed by the bank, and people exchanged the bank notes as if they were "real money" i.e. gold. However, it turned out this was a bad idea, and this practice was ended. Now, once again, we have private entities minting their own money. As long as it's some sort of novelty, it won't do any harm, but if it ever became enough of a real presence to have an impact on the real economy, it seems like it can't last.