psionl0
Skeptical about skeptics
That happens in the stock market all the time. When you gamble on the price of a commodity you always risk getting burned.Other people invested their entire life savings and lost it all in the "Bitcoin market."
That happens in the stock market all the time. When you gamble on the price of a commodity you always risk getting burned.Other people invested their entire life savings and lost it all in the "Bitcoin market."
No it is not. Read the quoted claims above.For what you're trying to argue it is.
That happens in the stock market all the time. When you gamble on the price of a commodity you always risk getting burned.
Mining for bitcoins might not take much time but it will take a powerful (ie expensive) computer to do it.
OTOH designing a bitcoin algorithm and all the associated software does take time - lots of it.
What, you think you could develop something like this during your afternoon tea break?Citation?
What, you think you could develop something like this during your afternoon tea break?
No it is not. Read the quoted claims above.
The peo who profited the most, and the one you're complaining the most about, the programmers, made a substantial investment. Your statement that they profited from "no investment whatsoever" is wrong. Especially when dealing with the programmers. Do you acknowledge this?
So now you need explanations of even the most basic aspects of programming in addition to economics and reminders of what you said in your own posts? You're wasting people's time.I asked you for a citation, not a snarky reply.
Do you acknowledge that what you said was wrong and that the programmers made a substantial investment?They spent their time working on what is effectively an investment scam.
As for the question whether "they profited from no investment whatsoever," I think the bigger question would be: "To what degree does that make them culpable?"
I'm going to tell you one more time. Read the quoted claims I posted above. They are in italics. Read them.I think you're confused. I believe Almo was talking about the initial batch of "miners", not just the programmers - I could whip up a venn diagram if you want. Unless you have some evidence that only the programmers are the big hoarders.
I'm going to tell you one more time. Read the quoted claims I posted above. They are in italics. Read them.
"The system is designed to enrich the originators dispropotionately who have invested next to nothing."
So now you need explanations of even the most basic aspects of programming in addition to economics and reminders of what you said in your own posts? You're wasting people's time.
Yes, and for my point it is completely relevant. Read it until you understand.Is it this one?
Cause if it is, you're still wrong. Acting like a jerk doesn't make you right. It never makes you right.
No you haven't because you don't understand that time is an investment. As is opportunity cost. Nor did you understand that there is a relatively higher value to early investor resources. Nor did you understand the value provided by a product that facilitates other activity. And those are just the ones off the top of my head.I think I've demonstrated more than adequate understanding of the economics in question. After all, I'm not in a state of denial about this thing obviously being little more than an investment scam wrapped up in a libertarian pipe dream.
Read the paper, it outlines the tremendous amount of development necessary.What I was asking for is some citation regarding the amount of "time" (in man-hours, perhaps) that Bitcoin took to develop.
Yes, and for my point it is completely relevant. Read it until you understand.
IOW When bitcoins were easy to mine, they were cheap but now that they are getting difficult to mine, they are more expensive.Today it does, but not in the beginning when the "mining difficulty" was low. Lots of people started out mining bitcoins by running what basically amounted to a screensaver on their desktop computers. As time went by and the difficulty ramped up, people started upgrading their machines with multiple high-end video cards to handle the processing. By late 2010, the original "boom" was over and some people had already moved on to dedicating racks of servers to their "mining operations," and some hackers even started building bitcoin mining functionality into their vast zombie botnets. I saw one web forum post where a tech at a co-lo bragged about having bitcoin mining running on all the unused servers. I wonder if his boss ever found out.
Time is money and just the idea alone is worth something to the originator. You could just as easily patent the idea and sell it.Development time isn't relevant to whether the initial investors (who, in any sane system, would include people outside the developers) made a great deal for little, to no, investment. It's the participation in the system. The system is what's under critique.
Read the quote. It is about the developers.It appears that you fail to understand even the simplest of concepts.
Development time isn't relevant to whether the initial investors (who, in any sane system, would include people outside the developers) made a great deal for little, to no, investment. It's the participation in the system. The system is what's under critique.
Read the paper, it outlines the tremendous amount of development necessary.
And, do you acknowledge that the programmers of Bitcoin did not make "no investment whatsoever?"