How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
The subdivision ability makes the "inevitable" loss of some Bitcoins over time a non-problem. If he knew that, he would never have asked the question, and if you knew that you wouldn't be making an issue of it either.

:confused:

It means the system can continue to function, but it creates further pressure that increases the value of the originator's hoard (assuming he has really stringent back-up systems to be sure he isn't a victim of such loss).

The subdivision is just a needed thing to keep the system functioning under attrition due to the capped number of coins.

The system is designed to enrich the originators dispropotionately who have invested next to nothing.
 
They were investing something of value. Time.

Do you recognize that time has value?

They had to buy the computer. Furthermore, there is a thing called "opportunity cost" which indicates other things you could have devoted those resources toward doing.


You're ignoring the fact that Bitcoin is engineered to operate as a scam.


You're trying to run off on another incorrect tangent before you've even gotten through this basic point.

Instant, fee and oversight free sending of money worldwide.

Or you don't like giving Paypal your social security number. Any number of things.


Transaction processing is a huge industry, and there are many other companies besides PayPal that don't require a social security number.

Bitcoin, however, is the only one pretending to be its own discrete "currency." If you don't see that pretense as a huge red flag, then I honestly don't know what to tell you.


A number of things were invested in creating Bitcoin, including, at the most basic-level, time. Time has value. You seem to be struggling with this basic concept.


I don't have a problem with the concept of time having value.

The concept I have a problem with is when people design something for the obvious purpose of taking other peoples' money and making it theirs, and then justifying it on some goofy ideological pretense.

Evoking this "time is money" argument is disingenuous at best. Running a distributed processing screensaver app on a computer is a trivial thing that does not require any major time commitment. Lots of people do it just for kicks. Back in 2009-2010 when the vast majority of BTC were created, there was very little transaction going on in the system so those early adopters contributed little or no service value to the system, just by running a background process on their machines. It's really a red herring to equate the trivial "contribution" of some guys running what basically amounts to a computer game to people who actually invested their hard earned savings into Bitcoin.


No. Artificial scarcity implies that someone is trying to manipulate the market like a diamond dealer.


Which is exactly what the Bitcoin system does, except that manipulation is actually a software program designed to generate fake, immaterial virtual monetary units, and do so on a schedule that causes dwindling availability over time.

It's even worse than what a diamond dealer does, because the diamond dealer has to have possession of a real-world commodity in the first place, in order to corner the market and restrict availability. But with Bitcoin there is no real-world commodity. The entire thing is a fiction, and there's no reasonable basis for generating it on a dwindling scale other than to artificially drive up market value to make the early adopters' holdings appear more valuable.


The creation of Bitcoin isn't controlled by a person, it's controlled by the client itself, by design, and it is extraordinarily difficult if not impossible (given current understanding of cryptography) to counterfeit. It is built-in scarcity, but it is genuine scarcity.


It's inbuilt, artificial scarcity. The scarcity is artificial because the "commodity" itself is artificial.

If they really intended to create a useful, functional currency, they could have designed Bitcoin to operate more in the fashion of a useful, functional currency. But instead they designed it to operate as a fake "commodity" which becomes increasingly scarce over the course of 24 years, and marketed it under the pretense of an alternative currency in order to attract investors from the anti-gobmint libertaritard/gold-bug/posse comitatus community.

That's how Bitcoin is engeneered to operate as a scam.
 
Last edited:
:confused:

It means the system can continue to function, but it creates further pressure that increases the value of the originator's hoard (assuming he has really stringent back-up systems to be sure he isn't a victim of such loss).
The system will continue to function with no problems. Furthermore, coins entering or leaving the system will increase or decrease the value, but any holder of Bitcoins will not profit until he exchanges them for something. Since the inflation or deflation rate of coins is out of any individuals control, it cannot benefit creator more than any other speculator or early adopter. It is irrelevant.

The system is designed to enrich the originators dispropotionately who have invested next to nothing.
The Bitcoin client has years worth of programming and development behind it. Do you understand that time has value?
 
Last edited:
EGarrett, your "Time Is Money" argument is a red herring.

None of your arguments address the fact that Bitcoin is plainly engineered to:
  • create a virtual commodity with zero intrinsic value
  • award its creators and their friends vast majority shares in that commodity
  • implement planned scarcity
  • generate an investment bubble
  • position themselves to profit handsomely at the expense of the latecomers who invested actual money.

Anyone with even a basic understanding of economics will recognize this.
 
Last edited:
You're ignoring the fact that Bitcoin is engineered to operate as a scam.
Answer the question. Do you recognize that if someone spends time on a thing, they have invested something of value into that thing?

Transaction processing is a huge industry, and there are many other companies besides PayPal that don't require a social security number.
Yes, transaction processing is a huge industry, it also requires a heavy amount of personal information to be divulged, and online, is heavily overseen, and not always by people who are trustworthy or well-intentioned.

I don't have a problem with the concept of time having value.

The concept I have a problem with is when people design something for the obvious purpose of taking other peoples' money and making it theirs, and then justifying it on some goofy ideological pretense.
You claimed they invested nothing into it. This is flatly wrong, because they invested at the very least, time and opportunity-cost. In the case of the designers, we're talking about years of their time.

Do you recognize that something of value was invested in Bitcoin by these people?

Which is exactly what the Bitcoin system does, except that manipulation is actually a software program designed to generate fake, immaterial virtual monetary units, and do so on a schedule that causes dwindling availability over time.

It's even worse than what a diamond dealer does, because the diamond dealer has to have possession of a real-world commodity in the first place, in order to corner the market and restrict availability. But with Bitcoin there is no real-world commodity. The entire thing is a fiction, and there's no reasonable basis for generating it on a dwindling scale other than to artificially drive up market value to make the early adopters' holdings appear more valuable.
There is a distinction between a person purposefully withholding a product to manipulate a market, and a program that does so according to a separate protocol that is outside the control of any person.


It's inbuilt, artificial scarcity. The scarcity is artificial because the "commodity" itself is artificial.
This is a sloppy and incorrect equivocation. Artificial scarcity refers to how the scarcity is created. Not the product itself. There can be artificial scarcity of a real product, and there can be genuine scarcity of a virtual product.

If they really intended to create a useful, functional currency, they could have designed Bitcoin to operate more in the fashion of a useful, functional currency. But instead they designed it to operate as a fake "commodity" which becomes increasingly scarce over the course of 24 years, and marketed it under the pretense of an alternative currency in order to attract investors from the anti-gobmint libertaritard/gold-bug/posse comitatus community.

That's how Bitcoin is engeneered to operate as a scam.
So far all your attempts to demonstrate this are based on fallacies and misunderstandings of economics.
 
Answer the question. Do you recognize that if someone spends time on a thing, they have invested something of value into that thing?


I already answered the question, and pointed out why it's irrelevant.

By your own logic, the guy who runs a Ponzi scheme is justified in scamming people because he spent so much time, effort and expense to create a fake company, lease a P.O. box, find gullible marks, print up fake financial statements, etc.

It's a red herring. Just because somebody spent years working on a con game, that doesn't detract from the fact that it's a scam.


Yes, transaction processing is a huge industry, it also requires a heavy amount of personal information to be divulged, and online, is heavily overseen, and not always by people who are trustworthy or well-intentioned.


Again, irrelevant. At least consumers have some protections and legal recourse when dealing through many of those companies. With Bitcoin, you have no idea who you're dealing with, and some of the biggest names promoting Bitcoin have turned out to be career criminals.


You claimed they invested nothing into it. This is flatly wrong, because they invested at the very least, time and opportunity-cost. In the case of the designers, we're talking about years of their time.


I never claimed they invested nothing at all. I said they invested no money into the system yet they're deriving the vast majority of equity out of it, and all the monetary value in the system has been paid in by people investing at the bottom.

As I pointed out before, the number of man-hours that went into Bitcoin is a red herring. Just because you spend years working on a con game, that doesn't make it any less of a scam.


Do you recognize that something of value was invested in Bitcoin by these people?


Something of value? I suppose that would depend on the "value" of creating fake commodities for the purposes of generating investment bubbles for themselves to profit from.


There is a distinction between a person purposefully withholding a product to manipulate a market, and a program that does so according to a separate protocol that is outside the control of any person.


It's rather disingenuous of you to present it as if the "protocol" wasn't explicitly designed and implemented by the creators, for the purpose of granting themselves the lion's share of equity in the fake commodity and then deliberately restricting availability to drive up the market value. Bitcoin did not just spontaneously create itself or randomly start behaving this way. It was programmed by the creators to work the way it does, for the obvious purpose of enriching themselves at other peoples' expense.


It's inbuilt, artificial scarcity. The scarcity is artificial because the "commodity" itself is artificial.


This is a sloppy and incorrect equivocation. Artificial scarcity refers to how the scarcity is created. Not the product itself. There can be artificial scarcity of a real product, and there can be genuine scarcity of a virtual product.

So far all your attempts to demonstrate this are based on fallacies and misunderstandings of economics.


Wrong. You keep on trying to poison the well by calling my arguments fallacies when they're not.

The scarcity of the fake commodity is controlled by the software that generates the fake commodity itself. Therefore, the commodity and the scarcity are both artificial: created and managed by the software for an intended purpose.

The BTC units are themselves artificial; they're not real, material things. They're being generated artificially according to an algorithm which is deliberately designed to produce less and less of them as time goes on. That scarcity is every bit as artificial as when Apple, for example, deliberately restricts production of the new iPad—even though they could easily produce plenty more—in order to artificially inflate the market value.

You're flapping around a lot of red herrings and splitting semantic hairs in order to avoid addressing the real crux of the issue, which is:

Bitcoin is engineered to operate as a scam.
 
Last edited:
Bernie Madoff invested time in his scam. That doesn't make it any less of a scam.
But if you claimed he invested nothing, you would be wrong irrespective of anything else. You claimed that the Bitcoin programmers and early adopters invested little to nothing. And you are wrong. Do you recognize this?
 
I already answered the question, and pointed out why it's irrelevant.

By your own logic, the guy who runs a Ponzi scheme is justified in scamming people because he spent so much time, effort and expense to create a fake company, lease a P.O. box, find gullible marks, print up fake financial statements, etc.

It's a red herring. Just because somebody spent years working on a con game, that doesn't detract from the fact that it's a scam.
I didn't say whether or not it was justified. I said that your claim that they invested next-to-nothing was untrue. Do you recognize that the claim that they invested next-to-nothing is wrong?

I never claimed they invested nothing at all. I said they invested no money into the system yet they're deriving the vast majority of equity out of it, and all the monetary value in the system has been paid in by people investing at the bottom.
"My complaint is that the early adopters made large amounts of money for no investment whatsoever."

That is copy/pasted. From you.
 
They were investing something of value. Time.

Do you recognize that time has value?

No time was spent. While doing whatever they were going to do anyway, their computer made bitcoins. They didn't do anything extra.

Computer cycles have no value.
 
I didn't say whether or not it was justified. I said that your claim that they invested next-to-nothing was untrue. Do you recognize that the claim that they invested next-to-nothing is wrong?

"My complaint is that the early adopters made large amounts of money for no investment whatsoever."

That is copy/pasted. From you.

I wonder about this. There are lots of game systems out there with alternative currencies and even "farming" algorithms. There's nothing inherent to Bitcoin that isn't to be found in the others that have come before. It's entirely plausible that the whole thing was lifted from one of these systems and the name changed.
 
Through Bitcoin, people "made" millions of dollars of other peoples' money for running a screen-saver app on their computer for a few months back in 2009. Other people invested their entire life savings and lost it all in the "Bitcoin market."

So yeah, I consider being awarded millions of dollars of other peoples' money, just for running a screensaver to be "making large amounts of money for no investment whatsoever."

Bitcoin is engineered to operate as a scam.
 
No time was spent. While doing whatever they were going to do anyway, their computer made bitcoins. They didn't do anything extra.

Computer cycles have no value.
"The system is designed to enrich the originators dispropotionately who have invested next to nothing." -Almo
 
I wonder about this. There are lots of game systems out there with alternative currencies and even "farming" algorithms. There's nothing inherent to Bitcoin that isn't to be found in the others that have come before. It's entirely plausible that the whole thing was lifted from one of these systems and the name changed.
And which online video game do you think provided the model for the Bitcoin client?
 
No time was spent. While doing whatever they were going to do anyway, their computer made bitcoins. They didn't do anything extra.
Mining for bitcoins might not take much time (for humans) but it will take a powerful (ie expensive) computer to do it.

OTOH designing a bitcoin algorithm and all the associated software does take time - lots of it. Whether the inventor got anything back for this time was very iffy when he first started the project.
 
Last edited:
Through Bitcoin, people "made" millions of dollars of other peoples' money for running a screen-saver app on their computer for a few months back in 2009. Other people invested their entire life savings and lost it all in the "Bitcoin market."

So yeah, I consider being awarded millions of dollars of other peoples' money, just for running a screensaver to be "making large amounts of money for no investment whatsoever."

Bitcoin is engineered to operate as a scam.
The peo who profited the most, and the one you're complaining the most about, the programmers, made a substantial investment. Your statement that they profited from "no investment whatsoever" is wrong. Especially when dealing with the programmers. Do you acknowledge this?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom