How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
So who is using this money and what are they buying and selling with it?
According to http://www.bitcoindir.com/, there aren't too many places where you can spend your bitcoins and the products that you can buy are similarly limited. Of course the anonymous nature of bitcoin transactions makes it tailor-made for black market activities so you will hear plenty of (unsubstantiated) stories along this vein.

Unless some main stream merchants are willing to accept payments in bitcoins, bitcoin is likely to be a buy and hold commodity only.
 
Except the miners are paying something into the system: CPU cycles necessary to process bitcoin transactions. Without the miners, transactions would not be secure.


If transactions are actually going on, then the "miners" currently operating now are handling that business.

But what about the miners who started mining before Bitcoin had even caught on with the general public, who obtained their fortunes when little or no transactions were being conducted on the system? Those "miners" racked up enormous equity in the system by doing a relatively tiny amount of work. Ever since then, the system has deliberately made it progressively difficult to "mine" for bitcoins.

You're still ignoring my point, that none of those people contributed any money into the system yet they're getting the vast majority of money out of it. Plus they hold such enormous shares in the system that they can leverage their shares to effectively control the entire market to their own advantage.


Why should anyone care as long at bitcoins do what they are supposed to do?


Um, because it doesn't to what it's supposed to do?

Because it's being advertised as money when it is in fact not money?

Because it's a scam?

How many different ways do you want me to answer that question? You keep asking it over and over again.


And those would be potentially valid criticisms of bitcoin for its intended purpose, but criticizing bitcoin as an investment is just fighting a strawman.


I think you misunderstand the definition of a "strawman argument."

At the moment, all evidence indicates that its design makes it singularly ill-suited to use as a currency, but as an investment opportunity, and the vast majority of its users treat it as an investment opportunity therefore it's not a strawman at all.


OK. The rate of creation has been constant and will continue to be until 2013, then it will slow down. This still refutes your claims of artificial scarcity for the reasons I previously stated.


No, it doesn't. The thing is obviously intended to create artificial scarcity. Look at the curve on that graph. It's engineered to create an economic bubble and then continue to restrict availability to perpetuate that bubble for up to 24 years. Ask yourself why, if they intended for interest in this thing to decrease, would they have engineered dwindling availability into the system like that?
 
Last edited:
If transactions are actually going on, then the "miners" currently operating now are handling that business.

But what about the miners who started mining before Bitcoin had even caught on with the general public, who obtained their fortunes when little or no transactions were being conducted on the system? Those "miners" racked up enormous equity in the system by doing a relatively tiny amount of work. Ever since then, the system has deliberately made it progressively difficult to "mine" for bitcoins.

You're still ignoring my point, that none of those people contributed any money into the system yet they're getting the vast majority of money out of it.
You're assuming that at all times in the history of Bitcoins, mining them and contributing to their growth had an equal amount of value.

This is an error, early adoption of something is far more valuable to the growth of that thing then late adoption, even if what you actually did is the same thing at both times.

Scenario: It's 2004 and a kid named Mark Zuckerberg comes up to me and says he has an idea for a website called Facebook, but he's completely poor and has no money to get the necessary manuals or pay whatever it costs to register the site. He has no other way to get this money and will give up on the project if I can't help him.

I like him, so I give him $100 which will allow him to do what he needs to do. This money is invaluable to the creation of Facebook, Facebook would not exist without it.

Now, it's 2012. I walk up to Mark Zuckerberg, the billionaire. I give him $100, he doesn't care. This money means nothing to the creation of Facebook.

But...it's the same amount of money! Yes, but a small amount of money (or time) to a growing company, on speculation, is actually worth much more than it is to an established company with a proven track record. Therefore, the contributions of early Bitcoin miners are actually more valuable than those of the current adopters, and the risk they took was higher, thus they receive a greater reward and have a more prominent role if they company/property/project succeeds.
 
I don't think disproportionately rewarding the early miners/creator is sufficient to make it a scam. It was designed to mimic a real world resource. Like copper in Michigan or gold in California the "early adopters" were able to pull huge nuggets out of the ground or sift it right out of rivers. Over time it becomes more expensive and more difficult to acquire the same amount.
In the early days of bitcoin when they were easy, miners were trading 1000s of bitcoins for items in MMOs, or 10,000s for computers or xboxes. It's not sufficient to have been an early adopter, one must have both earned a bunch of bitcoins when they were cheap and flowing like water, and held on to them for 2-3 years until they gained value.

I also don't see any deception or fraud. I searched bitcoin forums a bit and was able to find quite a few people linking to small independent sites, selling computers, video games, clothes, jewelry, etc. That's ignoring their .onion use as an exchange for drugs.
The founder making money depends on there being enough actual demand for bitcoins to raise the price.

I've bought lots of software packages that costs $200-300 during beta but raise to $700+ afterward. That's not a scam, that's just good business. How much money the developer may or not make does not make something a scam.
I don't have a use for bitcoins, so I won't be buying them. But people who do have a use of them, or are buying them and gambling that the price goes up, are not being scammed.
Anyone can read how bitcoins are made, who made them, what they're used for, etc. Madoff never told his investors that he was stealing their money.
The situations are not analogous at all.
 
But I would argue the whole Bitcoin system obfuscates what is likely its purpose: to funnel money to the creator.
 
You're assuming that at all times in the history of Bitcoins, mining them and contributing to their growth had an equal amount of value.

This is an error, early adoption of something is far more valuable to the growth of that thing then late adoption, even if what you actually did is the same thing at both times.

Scenario: It's 2004 and a kid named Mark Zuckerberg comes up to me and says he has an idea for a website called Facebook, but he's completely poor and has no money to get the necessary manuals or pay whatever it costs to register the site. He has no other way to get this money and will give up on the project if I can't help him.

I like him, so I give him $100 which will allow him to do what he needs to do. This money is invaluable to the creation of Facebook, Facebook would not exist without it.

Now, it's 2012. I walk up to Mark Zuckerberg, the billionaire. I give him $100, he doesn't care. This money means nothing to the creation of Facebook.

But...it's the same amount of money! Yes, but a small amount of money (or time) to a growing company, on speculation, is actually worth much more than it is to an established company with a proven track record. Therefore, the contributions of early Bitcoin miners are actually more valuable than those of the current adopters, and the risk they took was higher, thus they receive a greater reward and have a more prominent role if they company/property/project succeeds.


All of this is irrelevant.

Facebook is a company, with real assets, a real product that it produces, and real services that it provides for a profit. When Facebook goes public later this year (reportedly next month), its investors will be buying into a profitable enterprise that has been scrutinized and verified by a critical legal authority with the intention of making sure their operations are legal and their financials are honest and legitimate.

Bitcoin, on the other hand, is not a company, does not have any material assets, produces no product, does not turn a profit, does not adhere to any laws or answer to any form of authority to ensure its users aren't getting ripped off. Bitcoin takes all its investors' money and redistributes it into shares, 50% of which are held by 1% of the shareholders who can effectively control the entire market. Like a Ponzi scheme, Bitcoin generates no profits beyond what the investors pay in.

Bitcoin is a fake currency that displays none of the desirable qualities of a real currency: it's not viable, stable, or legal tender. It's hardly accepted anywhere. The only feature of Bitcoin that resembles actual money is that you can pay money in exchange for it. It is in fact engineered not to behave as a currency ought to, but as a fake commodity with built-in artificial scarcity for the obvious purpose of creating an economic bubble. If you invest in BTC and get ripped off, there's absolutely no legal recourse for getting any of your money back.

Ask yourself these simple questions:

If Bitcoin was really engineered to perform as a currency, wouldn't you think they would have engineered it for maximum stability and sufficient availability to meet growing demand?

If Bitcoin was really engineered as a viable currency, and intended to take off with worldwide adoption as a currency, then why in the hell would they have engineered it to have logarithmic dwindling of availability over the course of 24 years? That's not good behavior for a currency at all. Scarcity of funds doesn't stimulate economic growth, it inhibits it.

If Bitcoin was really engineered as a viable currency, why was it engineered to artificially generate an economic bubble, instead of behaving like a stable, useful currency?
 
Last edited:
But but but... Bitcoins can be subdivided! You don't need more than the capped amount!

I have a question... say I have a Bitcoin wallet. What happens if I delete it? Are those coins gone forever? I think they are. So you also have that effect. Slowly, they will be taken out of circulation by people losing them.
 
All of this is irrelevant.

Facebook is a company, with real assets, a real product that it produces, and real services that it provides for a profit. When Facebook goes public later this year (reportedly next month), its investors will be buying into a profitable enterprise that has been scrutinized and verified by a critical legal authority with the intention of making sure their operations are legal and their financials are honest and legitimate.

Bitcoin, on the other hand, is not a company, does not have any material assets, produces no product, does not turn a profit, does not adhere to any laws or answer to any form of authority to ensure its users aren't getting ripped off. Bitcoin takes investors' money and divides it into shares, 50% of which are held by 1% of the shareholders who can effectively control the entire market. Like a Ponzi scheme, Bitcoin does not generate any profits beyond what the investors pay in.

Bitcoin is a fake currency that displays none of the desirable qualities of a real currency: it's not viable, stable, or legal tender. It's hardly accepted anywhere. The only feature of Bitcoin that resembles actual money is that you can pay money in exchange for it. It is in fact engineered not to behave as a currency ought to, but as a fake commodity with built-in artificial scarcity for the obvious purpose of creating an economic bubble. If you invest in BTC and get ripped off, you're **** outta luck my friend, because there's absolutely no legal recourse for getting any of your money back.

Ask yourself these simple questions:

If Bitcoin was really engineered to perform as a currency, wouldn't you think they would have engineered it for maximum stability and sufficient availability to meet growing demand?

If Bitcoin was really engineered as a viable currency, and intended to take off with worldwide adoption as a currency, then why in the hell would they have engineered it to have logarithmic dwindling of availability over the course of 24 years? That's not good behavior for a currency at all. Scarcity of funds doesn't stimulate economic growth, it inhibits it.

If Bitcoin was really engineered as a viable currency, why was it engineered to artificially generate an economic bubble, instead of behaving like a stable, useful currency?
You ignored the point and ran off on a half-dozen irrelevant and incorrect tangents.

Your complaint that early adopters of Bitcoin were able to make large amounts of money for a small amount of work. This is an invalid complaint because it is correct that they made this amount of money. Because the early adopter's contribution, even for a small amount of money, was worth more to the growth of the property than the same amount of dollars or the same time invested now. They also took a much greater risk since the fate of Bitcoins as a possession was unknown.

The same is true for early investors in any company or possession. It is not wrong for them to make more money, because that is the incentive for people to invest in new things in the first place.

Do you recognize this?
 
Yep. They get lost forever, and all other Bictoins in existence "increase in value." Bitcoin generates no profits whatsoever, so all value in the system comes at somebody's loss.
 
But but but... Bitcoins can be subdivided! You don't need more than the capped amount!

I have a question... say I have a Bitcoin wallet. What happens if I delete it? Are those coins gone forever? I think they are. So you also have that effect. Slowly, they will be taken out of circulation by people losing them.
This is completely irrelevant and a non-concern. Maybe instead of mocking the point about subdivision, you should pay more attention, because you didn't grasp it.
 
Yep. They get lost forever, and all other Bictoins in existence "increase in value." Bitcoin generates no profits whatsoever, so all value in the system comes at somebody's loss.
No. They can enable transactions that are beneficial to everyone involved. That's one way that services can create value in a market.
 
You ignored the point and ran off on a half-dozen irrelevant and incorrect tangents.


No, your point is irrelevant.


Your complaint that early adopters of Bitcoin were able to make large amounts of money for a small amount of work.


That's not my complaint. My complaint is that the early adopters made large amounts of money for no investment whatsoever. All the money they can take out of the system was put in by other people.


This is an invalid complaint because it is correct that they made this amount of money. Because the early adopter's contribution, even for a small amount of money, was worth more to the growth of the property than the same amount of dollars or the same time invested now. They also took a much greater risk since the fate of Bitcoins as a possession was unknown.


You're ignoring the whole point. They took little or no risk at all.

The creators and early adopters put zero money into the system. Who cares if they ran a background process on their computer for a few months or a year? That's totally irrelevant to the fact that they're taking money for something that has no value other than what others pay into it.


The same is true for early investors in any company or possession. It is not wrong for them to make more money, because that is the incentive for people to invest in new things in the first place.


You're ignoring the point that the system is blatantly engineered for no purpose other than to create a virtual, valueless commodity with built-in artificial scarcity to drive up the market price.


Do you recognize this?


Of course I recognize that early investors are rewarded when investing in a viable economic enterprise, but as I said before, it's irrelevant because Bitcoin is not a viable company with assets and profits. It's a scam, intended to present the illusion of value for the purpose of drawing investors into an engineered economic bubble.

What you fail to recognize is that the pretense of a "currency" is totally false. It does not behave like a currency, it has none of the benefits of an actual currency, it's not legal tender, it is backed by nothing except a marketing strategy aimed at a malcontent, conspiracist, anti-government mentality, and it's hardly accepted anywhere.

Despite the marketing: instead of behaving like a currency, it's engineered to behave like an investment bubble with built-in scarcity.

That's the point that you keep on ignoring.
 
Last edited:
No, your point is irrelevant.
It's totally relevant, as you demonstrate immediately after.

That's not my complaint. My complaint is that the early adopters made large amounts of money for no investment whatsoever. All the money they can take out of the system was put in by other people.
A single penny or a single moment of time is an investment. Early adopters in ANY commodity or company stand to gain the most, and also stand to lose if it doesn't work or grow in popularity.

You're ignoring the whole point. They took little or no risk at all.
Lost time is a risk.

The creators and early adopters put zero money into the system. Who cares if they ran a background process on their computer for a few months or a year? That's totally irrelevant to the fact that they're taking money for something that has no value other than what others pay into it.
You keep repeating the same mistake. Furthermore, if Bitcoins save time or effort for others by making transactions more convenient, than Bitcoins have created value for them. If I did something that allowed a car company to grow, and people used the cars, I could rightfully profit from that.

You're ignoring the point that the system is blatantly engineered for no purpose other than to create a virtual, valueless commodity with built-in artificial scarcity to drive up the market price.
See above. There are a lot of basic economic concepts that you're missing.

Of course I recognize that early investors are rewarded when investing in a viable economic enterprise, but as I said before, it's irrelevant because Bitcoin is not a viable company with assets and profits.
You're right. That's why if you look at my earlier post I said that it's not just companies that give profits to early investors, it's also properties or commodities or any form of tool or possession that is unique and can grow in popularity.

What you fail to recognize is that the pretense of a "currency" is totally false. It does not behave like a currency, it has none of the benefits of an actual currency, it is backed by nothing except a marketing strategy aimed at a malcontent, conspiracist anti-government mentality, and it's hardly accepted anywhere.
You're trying to run off on a tangent with a half-dozen more fallacies.

Despite the marketing: instead of behaving like a currency, it's engineered to behave like a economic bubble with built-in scarcity. .
I'm glad that you used the phrase "built-in" instead of "artificial," that's an important difference.
 
Last edited:
This is completely irrelevant and a non-concern. Maybe instead of mocking the point about subdivision, you should pay more attention, because you didn't grasp it.

You don't grasp Bitcoin in general, so I'm not inclined to make much of your admonition.
 
It's totally relevant, as you demonstrate immediately after.


No it isn't. They were providing no service to anyone by running a program on their computers. Bitcoins were worth nothing until somebody first paid actual money for them.


A single penny or a single moment of time is an investment. Early adopters in ANY commodity or company stand to gain the most, and also stand to lose if it doesn't work or grow in popularity.


You're ignoring the whole point. They took little or no risk at all.


Lost time is a risk.


:rolleyes:

What time is lost by running a background process on your computer, that only uses processor cycles during idle time?

Just because the creators of a Ponzi scheme might spend a modicum of time and money generating and printing up fake financial statements, that doesn't justify the whole enterprise or negate the fact that it's specifically engineered to swindle.


You keep repeating the same mistake. Furthermore, if Bitcoins save time or effort for others by making transactions more convenient, than Bitcoins have created value for them.


:boggled:

In what way has Bitcoin made transactions "more convenient"?

I mean, unless you're buying something illegal and want to cover your paper trail?

There are many legitimate alternatives to Bitcoin that are far safer, more secure, more reliable, and are accepted in places where most people actually shop.


If I did something that allowed a car company to grow, and people used the cars, I could rightfully profit from that.


Which car companies accept bitcoins?


You're right. That's why if you look at my earlier post I said that it's not just companies that give profits to early investors, it's also properties or commodities or any form of tool or possession.


But all those things actually have real-world value behind them, whereas Bitcoins do not. Bitcoins are "play money" in every sense of the term, except for the fact that real people have actually lost their entire life savings by investing in them.


What you fail to recognize is that the pretense of a "currency" is totally false. It does not behave like a currency, it has none of the benefits of an actual currency, it is backed by nothing except a marketing strategy aimed at a malcontent, conspiracist anti-government mentality, and it's hardly accepted anywhere.


You're trying to run off on a tangent with a half-dozen more fallacies.


No fallacies. All those things I said are 100% true.

You can't refute them with facts so you try to poison the well by calling them "fallacies."


I'm glad that you used the phrase "built-in" instead of "artificial," that's an important difference.


There really isn't. The dwindling availability/artificial scarcity was engineered right into the Bitcoin software. Scroll up and look at that chart I posted.

The system is intentionally designed to make the units more and more scarce over time, so that the original holders' hoards become more and more artificially overvalued. For what other reason would they design the system to operate like that? That's certainly not indicative of a healthy economy.
 
Last edited:
You don't grasp Bitcoin in general, so I'm not inclined to make much of your admonition.
Wrong. Furthermore, if you understood why people were bringing up subdivision in the first place, you would never have asked such an ignorant question.
 
Wrong. Furthermore, if you understood why people were bringing up subdivision in the first place, you would never have asked such an ignorant question.


I think you're the guy who doesn't understand why people criticize the "subdivision" issue.
 
No it isn't. They were providing no service to anyone by running a program on their computers. Bitcoins were worth nothing until somebody first paid actual money for them.
They were investing something of value. Time.

Do you recognize that time has value?

:rolleyes:

What time is lost by running a background process on your computer, that only uses processor cycles during idle time?
They had to buy the computer. Furthermore, there is a thing called "opportunity cost" which indicates other things you could have devoted those resources toward doing.

Just because the creators of a Ponzi scheme might spend a modicum of time and money generating and printing up fake financial statements, that doesn't justify the whole enterprise or negate the fact that it's specifically engineered to swindle.
You're trying to run off on another incorrect tangent before you've even gotten through this basic point.

:boggled:

In what way has Bitcoin made transactions "more convenient"?
Instant, fee and oversight free sending of money worldwide.

I mean, unless you're buying something illegal and want to cover your paper trail?
Or you don't like giving Paypal your social security number. Any number of things.

But all those things actually have real-world value behind them, whereas Bitcoins do not. Bitcoins are "play money" in every sense of the word.
A number of things were invested in creating Bitcoin, including, at the most basic-level, time. Time has value. You seem to be struggling with this basic concept.

No fallacies. All those things I said are 100% true.

You can't refute them with facts so you try to poison the well by calling them "fallacies."
No I call them fallacies because they are fallacies. But there's no point moving on when the very first point remains unhandled.

There really isn't. The dwindling availability/artificial scarcity was engineered right into the software. The system is intentionally designed to make the units more and more scarce over time, so that the original holders' hoards become more and more artificially overvalued.
No. Artificial scarcity implies that someone is trying to manipulate the market like a diamond dealer. The creation of Bitcoin isn't controlled by a person, it's controlled by the client itself, by design, and it is extraordinarily difficult if not impossible (given current understanding of cryptography) to counterfeit. It is built-in scarcity, but it is genuine scarcity.
 
I think you're the guy who doesn't understand why people criticize the "subdivision" issue.
The subdivision ability makes the "inevitable" loss of some Bitcoins over time a non-problem. If he knew that, he would never have asked the question, and if you knew that you wouldn't be making an issue of it either.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom