Beelzebuddy
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Jun 10, 2010
- Messages
- 11,009
The main reason why bitcoin is not suitable as a currency is that there will never be any more than 21 million of them. Instead of the generation rate tapering off like it does, it should have been held constant for 40 years and thereafter, the generation rate should increase so that there is a constant inflation rate of 2.5%.
The other problem with bitcoin is the unfair way it rewards miners who have the most powerful computers. A more equitable system would allocate new currency packages to users at random. (For example, every time somebody spent some of these coins, he could be eligible to receive a currency package).
If a bit currency was ever invented along these lines (and adopted by a country) then it could render checkable bank deposits obsolete so expect the banks to have something to say about that.
I'm honestly a little surprised we agree on the inflation issue. I had you pegged for a goldbug, to whom even considering it would have been high sacriledge. Sorry for thinking so little of you. What do you think about the high initial difficulty to mitigate early-adopter dominance?
To disagree on one point, I actually like bitcoin's mining model. In an anonymous currency, there's no way to separate legitimate transactions from someone buying eggs from himself. If your random distribution triggered on random transactions people would buy their own eggs one at a time. If you factored in transaction size, people would onan a gross in one go. To truly distribute the inflation equitably, you'd have to track most or all transactions.
Tying it to computation, however, inherently limits the fraud without sacrificing anonymity or decentralization. It does probably mean you have to have money to make money, but that's true of the real world as well. Plus IIRC miners also carry the vast majority of transaction calculations, with transaction fees to sweeten the deal, so you'd need some other incentive for people to volunteer their cpu time to financial upkeep anyway.
