How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
The main reason why bitcoin is not suitable as a currency is that there will never be any more than 21 million of them. Instead of the generation rate tapering off like it does, it should have been held constant for 40 years and thereafter, the generation rate should increase so that there is a constant inflation rate of 2.5%.

The other problem with bitcoin is the unfair way it rewards miners who have the most powerful computers. A more equitable system would allocate new currency packages to users at random. (For example, every time somebody spent some of these coins, he could be eligible to receive a currency package).

If a bit currency was ever invented along these lines (and adopted by a country) then it could render checkable bank deposits obsolete so expect the banks to have something to say about that.

I'm honestly a little surprised we agree on the inflation issue. I had you pegged for a goldbug, to whom even considering it would have been high sacriledge. Sorry for thinking so little of you. What do you think about the high initial difficulty to mitigate early-adopter dominance?

To disagree on one point, I actually like bitcoin's mining model. In an anonymous currency, there's no way to separate legitimate transactions from someone buying eggs from himself. If your random distribution triggered on random transactions people would buy their own eggs one at a time. If you factored in transaction size, people would onan a gross in one go. To truly distribute the inflation equitably, you'd have to track most or all transactions.

Tying it to computation, however, inherently limits the fraud without sacrificing anonymity or decentralization. It does probably mean you have to have money to make money, but that's true of the real world as well. Plus IIRC miners also carry the vast majority of transaction calculations, with transaction fees to sweeten the deal, so you'd need some other incentive for people to volunteer their cpu time to financial upkeep anyway.
 
There is no pyramid because nobody is being recruited to sell bitcoins.


Look at Bernie Madoff's scam. It was a pyramid scheme that didn't require people to recruit new investors. In fact, Madoff actively restricted "membership" to very wealthy people whom he knew personally. That did not make his scam any less of a pyramid.

The "pyramid" metaphor comes primarily from the fact that all value in the system is derived from a large number of people buying in with real money at the bottom, with the vast majority of that value getting concentrated among the founders at the top who paid nothing into the system in the first place. Bitcoin certainly fits that model.


If you sell me some bitcoins then the only person who makes money out of the transaction is you. None of the other bitcoin holders benefit from the transaction.


The founders and early adopters benefit exponentially more than anyone else whenever new (real) money is introduced into the system. More people buying in makes the market price go up, and the early adopters capitalize on that dynamic. Because they hold the disproportionate majority of shares, they can use that power to manipulate the market for their own benefit.


Bitcoin miners can make a profit purely from the mining activity but this is true of any commodity that is being mined.


Bitcoins are not a commodity. "Mining" bitcoins is a fiction. They are not actually mined in the way that actual resources are mined. They're generated by the system according to an algorithm, thus there's no such thing as getting lucky and "hitting a rich vein" that yields vast wealth. The algorithm is specifically engineered to decrease availability as time goes on, thereby driving up the market price, artificially keeping the system afloat, and enriching the investors who control the market.


No it isn't. It lacks the "middle levels" of the hierarchy, and the money flow (while strongly favoring early adoptors) isn't hierarchical either. That's very necessary; it's what puts the pyramid in the pyramid scheme.


The "middle levels" are the exchanges, the marketers, webmasters, bloggers, and other promoters, and the "miners" who got in on the wavefront of the boom two years ago while "mining" was still a profitable endeavor.


If anything, bitcoin was designed and implemented as a pump and dump stock scheme. And operated as one, repeatedly.


Absolutely. It's implemented to enrich its founders in that way too. It's a combination of pyramid and pump-and-dump schemes.


The thing I'm noticing is, while all of these criticisms are quite well deserved, none of them are inherent to the tech of crypto currency, just bitcoin's particular implementation of it.


That's also a good point. Bitcoin incorporates some ingenious technology that could find use in a number of legitimate applications, including a secure and open implementation of DNS.
 
Last edited:
The thing I'm noticing is, while all of these criticisms are quite well deserved, none of them are inherent to the tech of crypto currency, just bitcoin's particular implementation of it. Since bitcoin's open source, I'd be curious to hear what you'd think of an alternate currency/virtual-commodity/what-the-hell-ever with the serial numbers filed off and the terrible economics replaced with something more sensible.

To wit:
  • Pick an inflation rate generally considered healthy for economies - 5%, say?
  • Choose a difficulty function that follows Moore's Law so as to constrain mining operations to that rate. It would still be exponentially increasing, but instead of crapping out at 21 million coins or whatever, computers should just barely be able to keep up.
  • Set the initial difficulty rate high, so that early adoptors are essentially just mining the inflation on a larger nonexistent economy. This means real inflation will start out high (though not Zimbabwe high) and asymptotically approach the ideal over time as compound inflation begins to dominate.
  • Call the result tibcoins, or <3coins, or sharecoins or something. It's not bitcoins, just operates on similar platforms.

I think that should address your concerns - there's no initial gold rush of easily hoarded wealth, nor built-in deflation to increase market leverage. Any surge or run of participants only has the effect of shifting the inflation rate relative to Moore's Law, which being exponential, isn't going to move that much. [ETA] Anyone coming late to the game isn't going to be making anyone else richer; whether they buy <3 directly or the equipment to mine their own should make little difference overall.

Thoughts?


Setting the initial difficulty too high would probably discourage people from getting on board early, thereby hindering the system's adoption in the first place. Also, a system setting the difficulty so that "computers should just barely be able to keep up" would not induce inflation. It would still induce artificial scarcity, leading to deflation.

Instead of restricting the supply of coins, the system would need to continually mete out coins according to some metric of inflation. For example, it might be determined by something like the rate of exchange in relation to other currencies (not sure this would work; just brainstorming). The objective would be to always keep producing just a little bit more coin than necessary to meet demand, to keep the inflation at a moderate rate between 3-5% or whatever.

But that still would not solve the other serious issues with Bitcoin, such as the fact that it's not legal tender and it offers no form of insurance against failure of the exchange companies, therefore there's no recourse in cases where money is lost to theft, fraud, an exchange going bankrupt, etc.

In a small, yet completely free and open economy like that, there's no practical way to deal with the problem of wealth eventually becoming concentrated into the hands of a few people who can then dominate the entire economy. Once that happens, you'll have day trader sharks exploiting the market, creating instability for their own benefit through pumping-and-dumping, short-selling and then buying back into the system. It would eventually run into all the same problems we've seen with Bitcoin.

Some elements of the transaction process might be useful for use in decentralized, open-source online gaming economies or other situations that didn't necessarily involve the investment of real money.
 
Last edited:
Look at Bernie Madoff's scam. It was a pyramid scheme that didn't require people to recruit new investors. In fact, Madoff actively restricted "membership" to very wealthy people whom he knew personally. That did not make his scam any less of a pyramid.
What made it not a pyramid was the fact that it wasn't a pyramid scheme in the first place, but a Ponzi scheme. The principal difference between the two is precisely the lack of hierarchy. The Ponzi interacts with each patsy personally, while the Pharaoh at the top of the pyramid gets his money from the first tier (and each of them, from the next).

If you're going to throw accusations around, at least make sure they're correct ones.

Setting the initial difficulty too high would probably discourage people from getting on board early, thereby hindering the system's adoption in the first place. Also, a system setting the difficulty so that "computers should just barely be able to keep up" would not induce inflation. It would still induce artificial scarcity, leading to deflation.

Well, the artificial scarcity is part of the point. The whole idea is to use it like any other currency; as a proxy for effort and resources. I'm not following the deflation thing though, unless you mean deflation caused by more people adopting the currency (thus adding value to it) than it inflates to keep up. But such a deflationary process would be both temporary and accompanied by exactly the kind of economic growth inflation is meant to stimulate, so hey.

Instead of restricting the supply of coins, the system would need to continually mete out coins according to some metric of inflation. For example, it might be determined by something like the rate of exchange in relation to other currencies (not sure this would work; just brainstorming). The objective would be to always keep producing just a little bit more coin than necessary to meet demand, to keep the inflation at a moderate rate between 3-5% or whatever.

This is, I assume, using the same definition of inflation/deflation as above? Because otherwise I don't see what this would accomplish, other than tying the currency to a particular rate of exchange. Is it necessary? No other currency does.

But that still would not solve the other serious issues with Bitcoin, such as the fact that it's not legal tender and it offers no form of insurance against failure of the exchange companies, therefore there's no recourse in cases where money is lost to theft, fraud, an exchange going bankrupt, etc.

In a small, yet completely free and open economy like that, there's no practical way to deal with the problem of wealth eventually becoming concentrated into the hands of a few people who can then dominate the entire economy. Once that happens, you'll have day trader sharks exploiting the market, creating instability for their own benefit through pumping-and-dumping, short-selling and then buying back into the system. It would eventually run into all the same problems we've seen with Bitcoin.

And? Very little of that has any impact on its use as a currency There will, no doubt, be fraud. People will lose their savings from bank failures, yes. The safety nets and graceful failures that come with the trappings of modern currency would be nice to have, I admit, but not at the cost of the anonymity, security, and decentralization which make up the whole reason to do all this in the first place.

As for wealth concentration, inflation tends to deal with that pretty tremendously. Under conditions of high inflation, extremely wealthy parties have a much shorter time window to act before their hoards shrivel in comparison to the size of their scheme. This reduces the efficacy of all the really profitable long-term market domination strategies. This may be part of why they like deflation so much: their money counts for more without them doing a single thing.

I've read of some economic experiments around the turn of the 20th century that had some good results with steady inflation rates of up to 20%.
 
Last edited:
Look at Bernie Madoff's scam. It was a pyramid scheme that didn't require people to recruit new investors.
I explained what a pyramid scheme was in post #758. Not only did you ignore that post but you continue to use "pyramid" and "ponzi" without defining either. You are just trying to associate bitcoin with bad sounding words.

New technology always offers the biggest rewards to its earliest users. Bitcoin is no different. Those people who acquired bitcoins before there was a market for them stand to make a pure profit. OTOH a number of large bitcoin holders dumped their holdings before the bubble and got nothing.

BTW you may not realize it but by continually saying that bitcoin gives a disproportionate reward to its early holders, you are implying that bitcoin will continue to rise in value.
 
I'm honestly a little surprised we agree on the inflation issue. I had you pegged for a goldbug, to whom even considering it would have been high sacriledge. Sorry for thinking so little of you. What do you think about the high initial difficulty to mitigate early-adopter dominance?
I have always maintained that fiat is the way to go (in spite of the power it gives to politicians). I am sympathetic to the wishes of those who want a currency that can't be meddled with by the government or the banks but the drawbacks of a currency that is fixed in supply can't be ignored.

It should be noted that by specifying fixed expansion rate, I am making the dangerous assumption that consumption can rise indefinitely. Maintaining economic prosperity without requiring ever increasing consumption is a problem that is not going to be solved with an electronic currency.

To disagree on one point, I actually like bitcoin's mining model. In an anonymous currency, there's no way to separate legitimate transactions from someone buying eggs from himself. If your random distribution triggered on random transactions people would buy their own eggs one at a time. If you factored in transaction size, people would onan a gross in one go. To truly distribute the inflation equitably, you'd have to track most or all transactions.
I see the problem here but I would still prefer a random distribution to donating bitcoins to major computing corporations or hackers who know how to use "bots". Ideally, people who are spending the currency should be rewarded since hoarding is likely to be a big problem with the existing bitcoin.

Making such a system abuse-proof will take some thinking however.
 
If a bit currency was ever invented along these lines (and adopted by a country) then it could render checkable bank deposits obsolete so expect the banks to have something to say about that.

And if unicorns ever appeared it would make current horses obsolete and I think the all-powerful horse racing syndicates would have something to say about that.
 
And if unicorns ever appeared it would make current horses obsolete and I think the all-powerful horse racing syndicates would have something to say about that.
You old fuddy-duddy. Don't you know how easy it is to make these things with modern technology? (virtual coins that is - not unicorns :D)
 
The "pyramid" metaphor comes primarily from the fact that all value in the system is derived from a large number of people buying in with real money at the bottom, with the vast majority of that value getting concentrated among the founders at the top who paid nothing into the system in the first place. Bitcoin certainly fits that model.

Early adopters did pay with CPU cycles and no one is promised anything other than the bitcoins that they purchase.

The founders and early adopters benefit exponentially more than anyone else whenever new (real) money is introduced into the system. More people buying in makes the market price go up, and the early adopters capitalize on that dynamic. Because they hold the disproportionate majority of shares, they can use that power to manipulate the market for their own benefit.

Do you have any data on the distribution of bitcoins? Why should a bitcoin user care is the early adopters made money as long as the bitcoins do what they are supposed to do for the user?

Bitcoins are not a commodity. "Mining" bitcoins is a fiction. They are not actually mined in the way that actual resources are mined. They're generated by the system according to an algorithm, thus there's no such thing as getting lucky and "hitting a rich vein" that yields vast wealth. The algorithm is specifically engineered to decrease availability as time goes on, thereby driving up the market price, artificially keeping the system afloat, and enriching the investors who control the market.

False. The algorithm keeps the creation of bitcoins constant. This does not drive market prices up, in fact it is inflationary until all coins are created. Demand drives market prices.
 
New technology always offers the biggest rewards to its earliest users. Bitcoin is no different. Those people who acquired bitcoins before there was a market for them stand to make a pure profit. OTOH a number of large bitcoin holders dumped their holdings before the bubble and got nothing.
I think the main objection is how blatantly bitcoin was built to reward early miners, chiefly whichever designer was using Satoshi as a pseudonym. How much is he supposedly sitting on? A million coins? More?

It's one thing to participate in a system that's biased towards those with the moxie to be there first. Any economic niche fits this. It's quite another to adopt a scheme deliberately designed to make one or a few parties exorbitantly wealthy at the cost of everyone who joins later.
 
I explained what a pyramid scheme was in post #758. Not only did you ignore that post but you continue to use "pyramid" and "ponzi" without defining either.


I didn't call it a Ponzi scheme. In fact, I deliberately made the distinction that it was not a Ponzi.

So perhaps the classic definition of "pyramid scheme" is not entirely accurate because recruitment is not a condition of returning on investment. However, Bitcoin is indeed a pyramidal economic structure engineered to create artificial demand for a spurious financial investment, inflating market value among a huge base of gullible investors, and then funnel most of the monetary value in the system directly to the system's creators.

Perhaps an "engineered economic bubble" would be far more accurate.


You are just trying to associate bitcoin with bad sounding words.


I don't need to do that. Bitcoin has already made enough of a bad name for itself on its own, especially considering some of the high profile swindlers and charlatans who've openly associated with it.


New technology always offers the biggest rewards to its earliest users. Bitcoin is no different.


That's a spurious argument. Bitcoin was engineered specifically to award its creators with the majority of units right off the bat, and then decrease in availability as more people came on board, thereby generating artificial value.

The system would be worth nothing at all it if weren't for people investing actual money into it. The creators effectively engineered a position for themselves to profit purely from other peoples' losses and nothing else.


Those people who acquired bitcoins before there was a market for them stand to make a pure profit.


By taking the money that latecomers paid for a fake "commodity" with no actual intrinsic value.


BTW you may not realize it but by continually saying that bitcoin gives a disproportionate reward to its early holders, you are implying that bitcoin will continue to rise in value.


You obviously don't understand the economics. Bitcoin doesn't have to rise in value to award a disproportionate reward to its early holders. The founders and early holders paid nothing to get in. Their profits are absolute and renewable no matter what BTC is going for on the open market, so long as the Bitcoin system remains afloat.

The major coin holders own enough of the market share to be able to effectively control the market to a large degree. They could easily sell off a significant share of their holdings at a huge profit—thereby collapsing the market—and then buy right back in again at a lower price. So no matter what BTC is going for on the open market, as long as they don't all dump all their holdings at the same time, they'll always have the opportunity to profit at other peoples' expense for as long as Bitcoin exists.
 
Last edited:
Early adopters did pay with CPU cycles and no one is promised anything other than the bitcoins that they purchase.


"Paid with CPU cycles?!? :boggled:

What does that even mean?

CPU cycles are not money. $ USD, $ CAD, € EUR, etc. are money.


Do you have any data on the distribution of bitcoins?


As of January 06, 2012:

Pop.% Wealth%

0.3% - 19.5%
0.5% - 34.8%
0.8% - 44.3%
1.0% - 50.0%
1.3% - 54.6%
1.5% - 59.0%
1.8% - 63.2%
2.1% - 65.7%
2.3% - 68.0%
4.1% - 79.6%
4.9% - 82.3%
8.0% - 89.9%
10.0% - 92.7%
14.9% - 96.3%
19.8% - 97.8%
29.8% - 99.2%
39.8% - 99.7%
49.9% - 99.9%
59.9% - 100.0%
http://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=51011.60

0.3% of Bitcoin investors hold almost 20% of the total value in the system.

0.5% of Bitcoin investors hold almost 35% of the total value in the system.

1% of Bitcoin investors hold 50% of the total value in the system.


Why should a bitcoin user care is the early adopters made money as long as the bitcoins do what they are supposed to do for the user?


Because Bitcoins are practically useless for the ostensible purpose they were created for.


False. The algorithm keeps the creation of bitcoins constant. This does not drive market prices up, in fact it is inflationary until all coins are created. Demand drives market prices.


This is not quite right. It may be true that demand drives market prices, but the supply of bitcoins is not constant.

The supply is determined by the "difficulty" algorithm which is built to always increase as time goes on. Increased difficulty means the same amount of processing power will produce fewer bitcoins less often. In addition to the artificial scarcity imposed by the difficulty algorithm, bitcoins that are lost or destroyed (say, in a hard drive crash) are irrecoverable. So over time, the scarcity of bitcoins is set to constantly increase, which causes a progressive state of overvaluation.
 
Last edited:
I think the main objection is how blatantly bitcoin was built to reward early miners, chiefly whichever designer was using Satoshi as a pseudonym. How much is he supposedly sitting on? A million coins? More?
A lot of people would find that irksome. It would only be a concern if he (or another group of individuals) held enough to influence the price of bitcoins.

We will never know how many bitcoins Satoshi initially acquired nor whether he has since sold any or acquired more. In the long run, it makes little difference to the viability of bitcoin.
 
A lot of people would find that irksome. It would only be a concern if he (or another group of individuals) held enough to influence the price of bitcoins.


As of January 06, 2012:


http://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=51011.60

0.3% of Bitcoin investors hold almost 20% of the total value in the system.

0.5% of Bitcoin investors hold almost 35% of the total value in the system.

1% of Bitcoin investors hold 50% of the total value in the system.


If 1% of investors hold 50% of all bitcoins, then a relatively minuscule group of individuals certainly hold quite enough to influence the price of bitcoins.
 
Last edited:
"Paid with CPU cycles?!? :boggled:

What does that even mean?

CPU cycles are not money. $ USD, $ CAD, € EUR, etc. are money.

Computational power is not free.

Because Bitcoins are practically useless for the ostensible purpose they were created for.

So we can stipulate your entire criticism of bitcoin only on it's use as a speculative investment.


This is not quite right. It may be true that demand drives market prices, but the supply of bitcoins is not constant.

The supply is determined by the "difficulty" algorithm which is built to always increase as time goes on. Increased difficulty means the same amount of processing power will produce fewer bitcoins less often. In addition to the artificial scarcity imposed by the difficulty algorithm, bitcoins that are lost or destroyed (say, in a hard drive crash) are irrecoverable. So over time, the scarcity of bitcoins is set to constantly increase, which causes a progressive state of overvaluation.

No, you are wrong. First, I never said the supply was constant, I said the rate of creation is constant and that is exactly what the difficulty algorithm does. It keeps the rate of bitcoin creation constant as a function of time. The difficulty only increases to compensate for increased computational effort. This does not impose any type of artificial scarcity. The supply of bitcoins is increasing at a constant and defined rate, no matter what the difficulty is.
 
Computational power is not free.


It is not money, either.

The fact that the creators and "miners" used a trivial amount of electricity and applied their computers' CPU and GPU cycles to a pointless task for a few months is basically irrelevant to my entire point:

BTC would be worth nothing at all if it weren't for people paying actual money into the system, but the originators and "miners" paid nothing into the system in exchange for their overwhelming equity. Now those people who paid nothing hold controlling shares over the entire economy that was built on the backs of the real money investors.

The system was created by people who specifically designed it to award themselves huge fortunes of the fake commodity before the general public started buying in with actual money. So no matter how many people eventually paid how much real money to get in, the vast majority of that value is now owned by the majority shareholders who contributed no money in the first place.


So we can stipulate your entire criticism of bitcoin only on it's use as a speculative investment.


We can also stipulate its uselessness as an actual currency on the facts that it's backed by no real value, it's extremely unstable and risky, it's not legal tender, and it's hardly accepted anywhere.


No, you are wrong. First, I never said the supply was constant, I said the rate of creation is constant and that is exactly what the difficulty algorithm does. It keeps the rate of bitcoin creation constant as a function of time.

The difficulty only increases to compensate for increased computational effort. This does not impose any type of artificial scarcity. The supply of bitcoins is increasing at a constant and defined rate, no matter what the difficulty is.


I'm sorry you've been misinformed about that. The rate of creation is set to decrease over time, as illustrated in this chart taken from the Bitcoin wiki:

vd2t5k.jpg
 
Last edited:
New technology always offers the biggest rewards to its earliest users.

You really think so? It seems to me early adopters are usually the ones who pay through the nose for the privilege of being beta testers. Look at how much VCRs cost when they first came out, or video cassettes for that matter. Or look at what happened to the early adopters of HD DVD.

For most technologies, jumping onboard once the bugs have been worked out and the market has been saturated makes the most financial sense.
 
So who is using this money and what are they buying and selling with it?

I know, late to the thread. Sorry. :o
 
It is not money, either.

The fact that the creators and "miners" used a trivial amount of electricity and applied their computers' CPU and GPU cycles to a pointless task for a few months is basically irrelevant to my entire point:

BTC would be worth nothing at all if it weren't for people paying actual money into the system, but the originators and "miners" paid nothing into the system in exchange for their overwhelming equity. Now those people who paid nothing hold controlling shares over the entire economy that was built on the backs of the real money investors.

Except the miners are paying something into the system: CPU cycles necessary to process bitcoin transactions. Without the miners, transactions would not be secure.

The system was created by people who specifically designed it to award themselves huge fortunes of the fake commodity before the general public started buying in with actual money. So no matter how many people eventually paid how much real money to get in, the vast majority of that value is now owned by the majority shareholders who contributed no money in the first place.

Why should anyone care as long at bitcoins do what they are supposed to do?

We can also stipulate its uselessness as an actual currency on the facts that it's backed by no real value, it's extremely unstable and risky, it's not legal tender, and it's hardly accepted anywhere.

And those would be potentially valid criticisms of bitcoin for its intended purpose, but criticizing bitcoin as an investment is just fighting a strawman.


I'm sorry you've been misinformed about that. The rate of creation is set to decrease over time, as illustrated in this chart taken from the Bitcoin wiki:

OK. The rate of creation has been constant and will continue to be until 2013, then it will slow down. This still refutes your claims of artificial scarcity for the reasons I previously stated.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom