How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yeah, Bitcoin is sort of the inverse of this: as long as you carry it around personally, it's secure. If you deposit it in an institution, it becomes vulnerable.
 
Yes. The currency is secure. You need to explain how it's not secure. Associating whatever security flaws or shenanigans happen inside and around exchanges says nothing about bitcoin as a secure currency.

Without the exchanges, it's not possible to do very much with Bitcoin at all -- because in most cases you have to convert it to and from RealBucks™, and the exchanges have been the centralized/convenient place to do that. If the exchanges aren't secure, then the majority of the Bitcoin economy isn't secure, regardless of any bulletproof cryptography.

You can securely, or at least as securely as with any digital currency, buy and sell using bitcoin.
But nowhere near as securely as I can with a simple VISA card.

Comparing Bitcoin's security to cash is not a positive, by the way. Cash has always had the same problems Bitcoin has now; it's why the world has moved away from cash where possible, because transaction accountability and reversibility play a big part of security... and more importantly, trust. When the creator(s?) of Bitcoin designed it as digital cash, they built in some inherent security flaws that simply don't go away.

Credit card numbers do get stolen, but it's trivial to fix that sort of thing in the modern world... and it's also trivial to prevent a great deal of that from happening in the first place.

Oh, and trust matters a great deal, by the way. The USD is backed by this thing called "the full faith and credit of the US government", which is essentially your trust that you can take your dollar to the gubmint and the gubmint will honor that dollar as a dollar's worth of whatever. There's also the law declaring that dollars are "legal tender for all debts, public and private", which forcibly extends part of that trust across the nation; without the capacity to trust the gubmint to enforce that law, I would have to worry that my mortgage company would suddenly refuse to accept dollars, and I'd be screwed.

One of the blocks to Bitcoin's acceptance right now is that I, Joe Consumer, cannot trust that my Bitcoin is worth anything at all; some people value it at $600, some at $400, and some people won't accept it at all, including my mortgage company. That's a big problem that Bitcoin must overcome before it can be considered a currency.
 
This is very distressing, but let's be honest now. Do you really think this has something to do with bitcoin protocol or rather with the security measures of the exchange?

More of the latter but I think even individuals are having some issues with security and must resort to cold wallets just to be safe. That means that the bitcoin isn't spendable when it's in a cold wallet and then it's not particularly portable in that fashion. I guess you could carry around a USB and load your phone when you need to buy something.


To me it seems like thousands of coders leaped at the opportunity to create a bitcoin exchange startup. Some of these coders had questionable knowledge how to run such a startup, business- or technology-wise. Now we are seeing the results.



Then there is the issue of "exchanges" which are modern money changers. They are cesspools of opportunists with the occasional crook lurking around. Some of the exchanges are more naive than the users and I think this may be why some of the failures have happened. VC money isn't very smart and it funds incompetence on a regular basis, I know because I was in that business. I worked with a lot of startups in my career and so I know how they form. What is happening with the exchanges is much as you describe.

That being said, exchanges contribute to the instability in price and a lot of the bad publicity vis-a-vis security. The thing that the exchanges have brought to bitcoin is notoriety through prices rising and falling as well as security and financial gaffes. On the whole, I don't think they have been a positive but bitcoin supporters are free to disagree.
 
Credit card numbers do get stolen, but it's trivial to fix that sort of thing in the modern world...

True story. At one point my number got stolen, and my bank immediately picked it up, blocked the transactions, and canceled my card. Less than 48 hours later I had received a new, functional card from them, and it didn't cost me a penny. Within a few hours I was able to transfer some pending internet orders onto the new card. No fuss.
 
It's the exact opposite of what you are saying. Anti-bitcoiners are saying, "bitcoin is unsound because exchanges". That is akin to saying that the US dollar is unsound because banks get robbed.

I'd love to see a comparison of the robbery rates of bitcoin exchanges vs banks.
 
It's amusing stuff. We can see now that it's definitely a Ponzi variant, too; only the people who got in early and got out on the initial rush have cashed in. Latecomers are holding the bag, blankly looking around them wondering where the magical internet money went.
:sdl: Yet another epitaph! I dare say you will be writing them for the rest of your life.
 
True story. At one point my number got stolen, and my bank immediately picked it up, blocked the transactions, and canceled my card. Less than 48 hours later I had received a new, functional card from them, and it didn't cost me a penny. Within a few hours I was able to transfer some pending internet orders onto the new card. No fuss.

Stolen, or just potentially stolen? Mine gets potentially stolen and reissued about three time a year. The dumb thing is that I only use temporary single-vendor numbers with a low limit, so nobody ever sees my "real" credit card number. The exception is when they cancel it, then for a few days temporary numbers are unavailable and I am forced to use the real number until a new card arrives. So the reissuing is unnecessary and reduces security.
 
Yeah, Bitcoin is sort of the inverse of this: as long as you carry it around personally, it's secure. If you deposit it in an institution, it becomes vulnerable.

Quite true. But one very important aspect of it is also secure - transactions from wallet to wallet, ie using it as a currency.

Without the exchanges, it's not possible to do very much with Bitcoin at all -- because in most cases you have to convert it to and from RealBucks™, and the exchanges have been the centralized/convenient place to do that. If the exchanges aren't secure, then the majority of the Bitcoin economy isn't secure, regardless of any bulletproof cryptography.

It's true exchanges are the central part of, well, bitcoin exchanging. But they aren't central to bitcoin nor using it as a currency. If one doesn't trust any of the exchanges, one can buy bitcoins from their local trusted(?) sellers. It's not really convenient as you mentioned. It's true that the exchange system needs an overhaul, either some technological (decentralization, eliminating the need for trust) or legislative (independent audits, insurance etc).

But nowhere near as securely as I can with a simple VISA card.

I seriously doubt that statement. I take it you're not talking about the lack of transaction reversal, which is not a security vulnerability. When I talk about bitcoin security, I mean the user being able to use it as intended without suffering any unauthorized access, manipulation or destruction of the process or information relevant to that process. This is what I mean as security. What's your meaning?

Comparing Bitcoin's security to cash is not a positive, by the way.

I was trying to put the whole insecurity claim into perspective.

Cash has always had the same problems Bitcoin has now; it's why the world has moved away from cash where possible, because transaction accountability and reversibility play a big part of security... and more importantly, trust. When the creator(s?) of Bitcoin designed it as digital cash, they built in some inherent security flaws that simply don't go away.

Saying bitcoin is not secure is like saying cash is not secure, and if we agree on the latter, then I agree with the former.

Btw, I think the world has moved away from cash not because of security, but because of convenience. Using plastic cards or doing online shopping introduces a whole plethora of security risks. You'd be more secure just using cash.

Credit card numbers do get stolen, but it's trivial to fix that sort of thing in the modern world... and it's also trivial to prevent a great deal of that from happening in the first place.

It's also trivial to prevent losing your bitcoin wallet.

Oh, and trust matters a great deal, by the way.

And I think that's that's a security flaw, not a feature. Trust shouldn't matter. One of the reasons bitcoin is decentralized, I believe.

The USD is backed by this thing called "the full faith and credit of the US government", which is essentially your trust that you can take your dollar to the gubmint and the gubmint will honor that dollar as a dollar's worth of whatever. There's also the law declaring that dollars are "legal tender for all debts, public and private", which forcibly extends part of that trust across the nation; without the capacity to trust the gubmint to enforce that law, I would have to worry that my mortgage company would suddenly refuse to accept dollars, and I'd be screwed.

One of the blocks to Bitcoin's acceptance right now is that I, Joe Consumer, cannot trust that my Bitcoin is worth anything at all; some people value it at $600, some at $400, and some people won't accept it at all, including my mortgage company. That's a big problem that Bitcoin must overcome before it can be considered a currency.

I understand and appreciate that.
 
Last edited:
It's amusing stuff. We can see now that it's definitely a Ponzi variant, too; only the people who got in early and got out on the initial rush have cashed in. Latecomers are holding the bag, blankly looking around them wondering where the magical internet money went.

You don't seem to actually understand what bitcoin is. If it is a ponzi why have entrepreneurs and venture capitalists invested hundreds of millions of dollars into bitcoin infrastructure? Why is the bitcoin network now hundreds of times larger than the top 500 supercomputers in the world combined? Bitcoin is no more a ponzi than a company stock is.

Without the exchanges, it's not possible to do very much with Bitcoin at all -- because in most cases you have to convert it to and from RealBucks™, and the exchanges have been the centralized/convenient place to do that. If the exchanges aren't secure, then the majority of the Bitcoin economy isn't secure, regardless of any bulletproof cryptography.

The security for the exchanges can be worked out. It's not even known what happened at the exchanges. They might have been hacked, or the owners might just be shady people that stole the money. (see http://hackingdistributed.com/2014/03/01/what-did-not-happen-at-mtgox/)

There are also non-exchanges like coinbase that buy and sell bitcoin but do not store customer cash or mediate user-to-user sales. This is how overstock.com converts millions of dollars worth of bitcoin into USD.

But nowhere near as securely as I can with a simple VISA card.

Except credit card fraud is huge( >$10 billion per year). Fraud with bitcoin is impossible and all transactions are irrevocable. The downside is less consumer protection and reversibility of theft. Credit cards aren't going away, but that doesn't mean there is no space for bitcoin as an international currency.

Comparing Bitcoin's security to cash is not a positive, by the way. Cash has always had the same problems Bitcoin has now; it's why the world has moved away from cash where possible, because transaction accountability and reversibility play a big part of security... and more importantly, trust. When the creator(s?) of Bitcoin designed it as digital cash, they built in some inherent security flaws that simply don't go away.

Bitcoin is actually more secure as a currency than cash because it cannot be counterfeited. Transactions cannot be 'intercepted.' For a theft to occur, they have to actually steal someones key, but keys can be generated and stored offline rendering them immune to theft from hackers.

Credit card numbers do get stolen, but it's trivial to fix that sort of thing in the modern world... and it's also trivial to prevent a great deal of that from happening in the first place.

$10 billion in damages per year (and growing) is trivial to you.

Oh, and trust matters a great deal, by the way. The USD is backed by this thing called "the full faith and credit of the US government", which is essentially your trust that you can take your dollar to the gubmint and the gubmint will honor that dollar as a dollar's worth of whatever. There's also the law declaring that dollars are "legal tender for all debts, public and private", which forcibly extends part of that trust across the nation; without the capacity to trust the gubmint to enforce that law, I would have to worry that my mortgage company would suddenly refuse to accept dollars, and I'd be screwed.

You can pay your taxes with USD, that's fantastic. USD is not going away. Bitcoin has intrinsic utility as a medium of exchange and is supported by the largest computer network in the world. It has value because people agree it has value. The volatility has been consistently decreasing over time.

One of the blocks to Bitcoin's acceptance right now is that I, Joe Consumer, cannot trust that my Bitcoin is worth anything at all; some people value it at $600, some at $400, and some people won't accept it at all, including my mortgage company. That's a big problem that Bitcoin must overcome before it can be considered a currency.

...It's new, do you expect widespread adoption of a new currency overnight?
 
It doesn't sound like it's an inherent property, since hundreds of millions of dollars worth of them seem to be missing.

If I lose my car keys, it's not the car keys that are insecure. If someone steals my car keys, it's not the car keys that are insecure. If I scam someone of their car keys, it's not their car keys that're insecure. The inherent security of your car keys is not affected by how you choose to protect or where to store them. If you toss them to the street or give to a stranger, expect that you might not see them nor your car again. Millions of dollars worth of BTC being missing is the result of a breach of trust, not security. It depends on what we're talking about. Being hacked is of course breach of security. Being scammed, not so much.

mtGox might have been one or the other, or both. People trusted it to behave as promised, but that was violated and if there was a theft, the security was breached. But again, not the security of bitcoin, it's the security of what stored the bitcoin. Another storage example would be an offline wallet, which is much harder to breach.
 
Last edited:
"AP Exclusive: Man said to create bitcoin denies it

LOS ANGELES — Dorian Prentice Satoshi Nakamoto said Thursday that he is not the creator of bitcoin, adding further mystery to the story of how the world’s most popular digital currency came to be." -- Full story: http://www.washingtonpost.com/busin...878e10-a590-11e3-b865-38b254d92063_story.html

"Alleged Bitcoin Founder Did Classified Work For U.S. Military

... Nakamoto remarked, “I am no longer involved in that and I cannot discuss it. It’s been turned over to other people. They are in charge of it now. I no longer have any connection.”" -- http://www.infowars.com/alleged-bitcoin-founder-did-classified-work-for-u-s-military/
 

Great link!

"Alleged Bitcoin Founder Did Classified Work For U.S. Military

... Nakamoto remarked, “I am no longer involved in that and I cannot discuss it. It’s been turned over to other people. They are in charge of it now. I no longer have any connection.”" -- http://www.infowars.com/alleged-bitcoin-founder-did-classified-work-for-u-s-military/


But he told an Associated Press reporter on Thursday: "I'm saying I'm no longer in engineering, that's it. And even if I was, when we get hired, you have to sign this document, contract, saying you will not reveal anything we divulge during and after employment. So that's what I implied.

"It sounded like I was involved before with Bitcoin and looked like I'm not involved now. That's not what I meant. I want to clarify that," he said.

Nakamoto said he was born in Japan and moved to America in 1959 and that English was not his first language.


I remain skeptical that this is the guy.
 
Without the exchanges, it's not possible to do very much with Bitcoin at all

Untrue, exchanges just make things more convenient. You can transfer Bitcoins to other wallets (i.e. buy something, sell something, trade for other coin types etc) without using an exchange.

If the exchanges aren't secure, then the majority of the Bitcoin economy isn't secure, regardless of any bulletproof cryptography.

I think that's a better way to put it. The economy (or *gag* ecosystem) has security issues, not because of Bitcoin, but because people building the ecosystem are using inferior "materials", like if some banks built their vaults with wood because they didn't fully understand the physical properties of their materials.

But nowhere near as securely as I can with a simple VISA card.

I'd say Bitcoin transfers are MORE secure, I can think of ways that a VISA purchase could be hijacked or your VISA info be compromised, but that would simply not be possible with Bitcoin short of hacking almost every singly copy of the block chain across the world.

Comparing Bitcoin's security to cash is not a positive, by the way.

Positive or negative depends on the criteria, both Bitcoins and cash are positive and negative depending on what you are comparing it to and what criteria you are using.

Cash has always had the same problems Bitcoin has now

Right, and the solutions for cash are all around the infrastructure, not the nature of cash itself. Bitcoin infrastructure could also benefit from analogues to the infrastructure around cash.

When the creator(s?) of Bitcoin designed it as digital cash, they built in some inherent security flaws that simply don't go away.

What security flaws in Bitcoin itself? Be specific.

Oh, and trust matters a great deal, by the way.

I agree with this, as you say national currencies have all kinds of things around them to protect the system, where Bitcoin has much less of it currently. Money developed over a long time.

Trust isn't a boolean value, on or off, there's degrees of trust. The cryptocurrencies obviously have enough trust of enough people to not disappear overnight. And over time either the systems around Bitcoin et al will earn the trust of more and more people, or they won't.

Bitcoin could benefit from some really smart people identifying problems that money worked through in the past.
 
Somebody in this thread just stated that bitcoin is the most secure form of currency there is. Only one response to that:

:dl:


It's pretty clear that bitcoin supporters are now going purely on faith,and motivated more by a messed up Libertarian ideology then a sound knowledge of economic realities.
And like most faith driven movements,they are very good at ignoring unpleasent realities.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom