Yes. The currency is secure. You need to explain how it's not secure. Associating whatever security flaws or shenanigans happen inside and around exchanges says nothing about bitcoin as a secure currency.
But nowhere near as securely as I can with a simple VISA card.You can securely, or at least as securely as with any digital currency, buy and sell using bitcoin.
This is very distressing, but let's be honest now. Do you really think this has something to do with bitcoin protocol or rather with the security measures of the exchange?
To me it seems like thousands of coders leaped at the opportunity to create a bitcoin exchange startup. Some of these coders had questionable knowledge how to run such a startup, business- or technology-wise. Now we are seeing the results.
Credit card numbers do get stolen, but it's trivial to fix that sort of thing in the modern world...
It's the exact opposite of what you are saying. Anti-bitcoiners are saying, "bitcoin is unsound because exchanges". That is akin to saying that the US dollar is unsound because banks get robbed.
It's amusing stuff. We can see now that it's definitely a Ponzi variant, too; only the people who got in early and got out on the initial rush have cashed in. Latecomers are holding the bag, blankly looking around them wondering where the magical internet money went.
Yet another epitaph! I dare say you will be writing them for the rest of your life.True story. At one point my number got stolen, and my bank immediately picked it up, blocked the transactions, and canceled my card. Less than 48 hours later I had received a new, functional card from them, and it didn't cost me a penny. Within a few hours I was able to transfer some pending internet orders onto the new card. No fuss.
Yeah, Bitcoin is sort of the inverse of this: as long as you carry it around personally, it's secure. If you deposit it in an institution, it becomes vulnerable.
Without the exchanges, it's not possible to do very much with Bitcoin at all -- because in most cases you have to convert it to and from RealBucks™, and the exchanges have been the centralized/convenient place to do that. If the exchanges aren't secure, then the majority of the Bitcoin economy isn't secure, regardless of any bulletproof cryptography.
But nowhere near as securely as I can with a simple VISA card.
Comparing Bitcoin's security to cash is not a positive, by the way.
Cash has always had the same problems Bitcoin has now; it's why the world has moved away from cash where possible, because transaction accountability and reversibility play a big part of security... and more importantly, trust. When the creator(s?) of Bitcoin designed it as digital cash, they built in some inherent security flaws that simply don't go away.
Credit card numbers do get stolen, but it's trivial to fix that sort of thing in the modern world... and it's also trivial to prevent a great deal of that from happening in the first place.
Oh, and trust matters a great deal, by the way.
The USD is backed by this thing called "the full faith and credit of the US government", which is essentially your trust that you can take your dollar to the gubmint and the gubmint will honor that dollar as a dollar's worth of whatever. There's also the law declaring that dollars are "legal tender for all debts, public and private", which forcibly extends part of that trust across the nation; without the capacity to trust the gubmint to enforce that law, I would have to worry that my mortgage company would suddenly refuse to accept dollars, and I'd be screwed.
One of the blocks to Bitcoin's acceptance right now is that I, Joe Consumer, cannot trust that my Bitcoin is worth anything at all; some people value it at $600, some at $400, and some people won't accept it at all, including my mortgage company. That's a big problem that Bitcoin must overcome before it can be considered a currency.
It's amusing stuff. We can see now that it's definitely a Ponzi variant, too; only the people who got in early and got out on the initial rush have cashed in. Latecomers are holding the bag, blankly looking around them wondering where the magical internet money went.
Without the exchanges, it's not possible to do very much with Bitcoin at all -- because in most cases you have to convert it to and from RealBucks™, and the exchanges have been the centralized/convenient place to do that. If the exchanges aren't secure, then the majority of the Bitcoin economy isn't secure, regardless of any bulletproof cryptography.
But nowhere near as securely as I can with a simple VISA card.
Comparing Bitcoin's security to cash is not a positive, by the way. Cash has always had the same problems Bitcoin has now; it's why the world has moved away from cash where possible, because transaction accountability and reversibility play a big part of security... and more importantly, trust. When the creator(s?) of Bitcoin designed it as digital cash, they built in some inherent security flaws that simply don't go away.
Credit card numbers do get stolen, but it's trivial to fix that sort of thing in the modern world... and it's also trivial to prevent a great deal of that from happening in the first place.
Oh, and trust matters a great deal, by the way. The USD is backed by this thing called "the full faith and credit of the US government", which is essentially your trust that you can take your dollar to the gubmint and the gubmint will honor that dollar as a dollar's worth of whatever. There's also the law declaring that dollars are "legal tender for all debts, public and private", which forcibly extends part of that trust across the nation; without the capacity to trust the gubmint to enforce that law, I would have to worry that my mortgage company would suddenly refuse to accept dollars, and I'd be screwed.
One of the blocks to Bitcoin's acceptance right now is that I, Joe Consumer, cannot trust that my Bitcoin is worth anything at all; some people value it at $600, some at $400, and some people won't accept it at all, including my mortgage company. That's a big problem that Bitcoin must overcome before it can be considered a currency.
Stolen, or just potentially stolen?
It doesn't sound like it's an inherent property, since hundreds of millions of dollars worth of them seem to be missing.
Oh, they actually used it to buy stuff.
"AP Exclusive: Man said to create bitcoin denies it
LOS ANGELES — Dorian Prentice Satoshi Nakamoto said Thursday that he is not the creator of bitcoin, adding further mystery to the story of how the world’s most popular digital currency came to be." -- Full story: http://www.washingtonpost.com/busin...878e10-a590-11e3-b865-38b254d92063_story.html
"Alleged Bitcoin Founder Did Classified Work For U.S. Military
... Nakamoto remarked, “I am no longer involved in that and I cannot discuss it. It’s been turned over to other people. They are in charge of it now. I no longer have any connection.”" -- http://www.infowars.com/alleged-bitcoin-founder-did-classified-work-for-u-s-military/
"Alleged Bitcoin Founder Did Classified Work For U.S. Military
... Nakamoto remarked, “I am no longer involved in that and I cannot discuss it. It’s been turned over to other people. They are in charge of it now. I no longer have any connection.”" -- http://www.infowars.com/alleged-bitcoin-founder-did-classified-work-for-u-s-military/
Why is the bitcoin network now hundreds of times larger than the top 500 supercomputers in the world combined?
Without the exchanges, it's not possible to do very much with Bitcoin at all
If the exchanges aren't secure, then the majority of the Bitcoin economy isn't secure, regardless of any bulletproof cryptography.
But nowhere near as securely as I can with a simple VISA card.
Comparing Bitcoin's security to cash is not a positive, by the way.
Cash has always had the same problems Bitcoin has now
When the creator(s?) of Bitcoin designed it as digital cash, they built in some inherent security flaws that simply don't go away.
Oh, and trust matters a great deal, by the way.
Why don't you start a thread in the CT forum?
Someone got stiffed with the bill, but I guess since it wasn't you it's okay!
