How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Somebody in this thread just stated that bitcoin is the most secure form of currency there is. Only one response to that:

:dl:


It's pretty clear that bitcoin supporters are now going purely on faith,and motivated more by a messed up Libertarian ideology then a sound knowledge of economic realities.
And like most faith driven movements,they are very good at ignoring unpleasent realities.

Posts like this are laughable because it's obvious you don't understand the technology at all. Do some research, read something other than the big headlines, listen to what financial experts and government regulators said when they testified before congress. Basically, get the facts, then you can have an opinion.
 
I think that's a better way to put it. The economy (or *gag* ecosystem) has security issues, not because of Bitcoin, but because people building the ecosystem are using inferior "materials", like if some banks built their vaults with wood because they didn't fully understand the physical properties of their materials.

I like this analogy. :)

Somebody in this thread just stated that bitcoin is the most secure form of currency there is. Only one response to that:

:dl:


It's pretty clear that bitcoin supporters are now going purely on faith,and motivated more by a messed up Libertarian ideology then a sound knowledge of economic realities.
And like most faith driven movements,they are very good at ignoring unpleasent realities.



Well, sure you say it is so, but it would help to be more specific and explain your belief. Perhaps quote the person who said it and we can see what's the context around it, and then explain why he or she isn't correct.

ETA: these flippant remarks do nothing but generate more snark from both sides, and into pointless quibbles we submerge again... let's try to avoid that.
 
Last edited:
Posts like this are laughable because it's obvious you don't understand the technology at all. Do some research, read something other than the big headlines, listen to what financial experts and government regulators said when they testified before congress. Basically, get the facts, then you can have an opinion.

He is right even if he used the wrong term. Bitcoin might be very secure as far as falsification goes. But you know, to buy stuff, because 99.9% of the shop and service do not accept bitcoin, you have to go thru an exchange...

And you know what ? If you are so kin on crypto and chain of trutst (or even physical analogy), you then will know that a whole chain, is only as strong as its weakest link.

It does not matter a bit if BTC cannot be falsified and are very secure, if at some point to use them in normal life, you have to go thru an insure link. Your whole chain of usage is then as trustable as the weakest link. And that is the point you and psionl0 seems to miss.
 
If I lose my car keys, it's not the car keys that are insecure. If someone steals my car keys, it's not the car keys that are insecure. If I scam someone of their car keys, it's not their car keys that're insecure. The inherent security of your car keys is not affected by how you choose to protect or where to store them. If you toss them to the street or give to a stranger, expect that you might not see them nor your car again. Millions of dollars worth of BTC being missing is the result of a breach of trust, not security. It depends on what we're talking about. Being hacked is of course breach of security. Being scammed, not so much.

mtGox might have been one or the other, or both. People trusted it to behave as promised, but that was violated and if there was a theft, the security was breached. But again, not the security of bitcoin, it's the security of what stored the bitcoin. Another storage example would be an offline wallet, which is much harder to breach.

In any case, you still don't have the use of your car. Which is sort of critical if you're going to refer to it as "transportation".
 
Last edited:
If I lose my car keys, it's not the car keys that are insecure. If someone steals my car keys, it's not the car keys that are insecure. If I scam someone of their car keys, it's not their car keys that're insecure. The inherent security of your car keys is not affected by how you choose to protect or where to store them. If you toss them to the street or give to a stranger, expect that you might not see them nor your car again. Millions of dollars worth of BTC being missing is the result of a breach of trust, not security. It depends on what we're talking about. Being hacked is of course breach of security. Being scammed, not so much.

mtGox might have been one or the other, or both. People trusted it to behave as promised, but that was violated and if there was a theft, the security was breached. But again, not the security of bitcoin, it's the security of what stored the bitcoin. Another storage example would be an offline wallet, which is much harder to breach.

Don't stop believing.
 
Don't stop believing.

Such post! Very contribution! Much appreciated!

In any case, you still don't have the use of your car. Which is sort of critical if you're going to refer to it as "transportation".

That's completely tangent to the security of your keys. This seems to be easily forgotten for some reason. Why isn't the method of loss relevant and only the outcome? Why isn't it relevant if your money was stolen or you burned your money yourself? Both have the same result - no money.
 
He is right even if he used the wrong term. Bitcoin might be very secure as far as falsification goes. But you know, to buy stuff, because 99.9% of the shop and service do not accept bitcoin, you have to go thru an exchange...

No, you don't, as has been explained, which makes the rest of your post moot.
 
Last edited:
In any case, you still don't have the use of your car. Which is sort of critical if you're going to refer to it as "transportation".

Yeah, everything he said are actually reasons car keys are not really considered all that secure. They're so widely used because they sit at a nexus between convenience and level of security, and therefore aren't a very good example to use if you want to prove that bitcoin is super secure.

I still hold that there is probably some implementation of crypto-currency coming down the pipe that may fulfill all the needs of regular consumers, but the more I learn and the more I'm exposed to the bitcoin community the more and more convinced I am that bitcoin is not it.
 
It's pretty clear that bitcoin supporters are now going purely on faith,and motivated more by a messed up Libertarian ideology then a sound knowledge of economic realities.
Isn't the value of fiat currency based on the "Full Faith and Credit" of the government?

Money of any sort is pretty much only a matter of "faith" so your post is only trivially true.
 
Yeah, everything he said are actually reasons car keys are not really considered all that secure.

Nope. But feel free not to explain yourself in any way.

They're so widely used because they sit at a nexus between convenience and level of security, and therefore aren't a very good example to use if you want to prove that bitcoin is super secure.

I wasn't trying to prove anything like that. :rolleyes:

Car keys was a random example, I chose it because people often tend to lose car keys (and then find them underneath a sofa or whatnot) - there's an aspect of human error to it. The point was it's your choice of storage itself that determines their security not the content of the storage - which was car key in my example. If you leave your key on the dashboard when you leave for the mall and return to no car, you can't go 'damn insecure keys!'. The dashboard as your choice of storage simply sucked.
 
He is right even if he used the wrong term. Bitcoin might be very secure as far as falsification goes. But you know, to buy stuff, because 99.9% of the shop and service do not accept bitcoin, you have to go thru an exchange...

And you know what ? If you are so kin on crypto and chain of trutst (or even physical analogy), you then will know that a whole chain, is only as strong as its weakest link.

It does not matter a bit if BTC cannot be falsified and are very secure, if at some point to use them in normal life, you have to go thru an insure link. Your whole chain of usage is then as trustable as the weakest link. And that is the point you and psionl0 seems to miss.

You don't need to go through exchanges at all. I explained this earlier. You can sell your coins for money on something like coinbase (not an exchange), you can sell directly to someone else without using an exchange, or you can save your bitcoins to purchase things directly with them. People have lived off of only bitcoins (without using normal money) for periods of time.

Dudalb was not right about anything, he is terribly ignorant. I could tell from that post that he knowns nothing about the currency other than the occasional headline he's read. Again, learn the facts first, then form opinion.
 
Last edited:
Isn't the value of fiat currency based on the "Full Faith and Credit" of the government?

Money of any sort is pretty much only a matter of "faith" so your post is only trivially true.

Dollars are backed by the full faith and credit of a stable government that has taxing privileges on a wealthy nation. Bitcoins are backed by faith that others still have faith that they have some value. Since it's based on nothing but speculation, Bitcoins' value is is far too volatile for them to be a practical currency of exchange, and there's not much reason to expect that they ever will be that stable.

What I predict is that eventually someone will take the underlying technology and fix some of the problems to create a Betterbitcoin. It will probably be very hard to buy any with your Bitcoins, so you'll probably want to quickly exchange them for some viable currency while there are some faithful Bitcoin evangelists left to buy them.
 
What I predict is that eventually someone will take the underlying technology and fix some of the problems to create a Betterbitcoin. It will probably be very hard to buy any with your Bitcoins, so you'll probably want to quickly exchange them for some viable currency while there are some faithful Bitcoin evangelists left to buy them.
Welcome to the Paranormal section.

Be warned that this thread is littered with the ashes of failed psychics - some of whom have predicted 100 of the last zero demises of bitcoin.
 
Isn't the value of fiat currency based on the "Full Faith and Credit" of the government?

Money of any sort is pretty much only a matter of "faith" so your post is only trivially true.

You sound like a fundie. Deliberately confusing multiple definitions of faith.
 
Other than the fact that you shouldn't gamble what you can't afford to lose, this is probably the truest post you have made in this thread.

I hope the forum is around in 10 years, so I can have a good laugh.

Of course, I suspect I'll be having that laugh long before that.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom