Sceptic-PK
Illuminator
- Joined
- Jun 22, 2010
- Messages
- 3,831
You just can't answer my post so you are playing silly word games.
You guys should be besties.
You just can't answer my post so you are playing silly word games.
I didn't say the protocols were insecure. The point is to mock the dumb notion that these events are tossed aside with "but the math is sound!" claims. It's an insecure currency, and no amount of saying "it's the exchanges, not the protocols" is going to change that fact. If many of the biggest US banks got robbed with the same frequency, it's akin to saying "but the US Dollar is still safe because reasons!"
That loud sound you just heard was me face palming. I don't even know where to start with what's wrong here. But it all stems from one source: you don't understand that a currency is only as good as you can trust it. And security is only as good as the weakest link. The perfectestly secure transaction math does. not. change. that. The fact that a sizeable percentage of the BC currency has been gained by malicious means is testament to that.
It's not about blame, it's about trust. And an currency riddled with theft and loss does not bring much trust. Being secure, or even the most secure currency doesn't change the fact that theft is a huge concern. Roughly a tenth of the total existing count of bitcoins in the past 6 months have been stolen from various bitcoin institutions. The name of the game is that bitcoins need to eventually be transferred to other parties, and that's where it gets hammered. The underlying protocol for transfers are safe, true, but many of the major players involved aren't.If banks got robbed people would not blame the currency. Bitcoin IS secure, that is one of it's main advantages. In fact, bitcoin can be used in ways that are more secure than any other currency in the world.
Bitcoin can be trusted more than any other currency. It is immune to counterfeiting and the transactions are irrevocable. If someone gained 51% of the computing power, they could do some double spending attacks, but other than 51% attacks it is secure. You don't seem to understand what secure means. Even the financial experts and government regulators have testified before congress that bitcoin is highly secure. When someone gets scammed or forgoes utilizing security measures, it doesn't mean the currency is not secure.
It's not about blame, it's about trust. And an currency riddled with theft and loss does not bring much trust. Being secure, or even the most secure currency doesn't change the fact that theft is a huge concern. Roughly a tenth of the total existing count of bitcoins in the past 6 months have been stolen from various bitcoin institutions. The name of the game is that bitcoins need to eventually be transferred to other parties, and that's where it gets hammered. The underlying protocol for transfers are safe, true, but many of the major players involved aren't.
The protocol is secure. I'm not arguing that. However, its track record in the past few years is not. Currency is built on trust.
Not sure what your point is? You are basically saying the exchanges are not secure, but you already chided that exact argument.
What do you mean by trust? I can certainly trust that any bitcoin I receive is real. I can certainly take precautions to make sure any bitcoins I possess are impossible to steal. Now, if I choose to forgo those precautions and hand possession of my bitcoins over to 3rd party, I cannot ensure that the 3rd party will not lose my bitcoins and go bankrupt. That doesn't say anything about the currency.
False. The lion's share of the currency (Freudian slip?The issue is that a lion's share of the currency is stored or goes through a few of those 3rd parties. And a number of those 3rd parties have terrible security. It's bitcoin's nature that has lead to the ecosystem it is today.
I didn't say the protocols were insecure. The point is to mock the dumb notion that these events are tossed aside with "but the math is sound!" claims. It's an insecure currency, and no amount of saying "it's the exchanges, not the protocols" is going to change that fact. If many of the biggest US banks got robbed with the same frequency, it's akin to saying "but the US Dollar is still safe because reasons!"
...
Security is hard and average programmers aren't up to the challenge, but getting the right kind of teams to do it properly is expensive and time consuming and people want their businesses up now.
...
False. The lion's share of the currency (Freudian slip?) sits in privately held wallets unaffected by the exchange shenanigans (apart from the price).
Let it! Centralized exchanges are incompatible with a decentralized currency and it would be illogical for the government to protect bitcoiners when they see bitcoin as a threat to their powerbase.And I think without some level of regulation and auditing for these new exchanges, this will just continue.
Let it! Centralized exchanges are incompatible with a decentralized currency and it would be illogical for the government to protect bitcoiners when they see bitcoin as a threat to their powerbase.
Left to their own devices, the bitcoin community will find a way around the exchange problem. After the spectacular fall of MtGox, it is going to be hard for the remaining exchanges to convince anyone that they are still viable and not just some joker with a bitcoin wallet and a bank account.
Developments such as Ripple are already pointing the way forward.
Bitcoin IS secure, that is one of it's main advantages.
And blathering about bitcoin there.Michaelsuede,the starter of this thread, in now active in the Science section of JREF promoting a "Free Energy" scheme.
I note that if you fall for woo in one area, you are very likely to fall for it in another.
It's the exact opposite of what you are saying. Anti-bitcoiners are saying, "bitcoin is unsound because exchanges". That is akin to saying that the US dollar is unsound because banks get robbed.
Accreditation by an independent agency is a definite possibility. However, it would cost money and there is a strong possibility that no matter how good the exchange, the agency might not want to stake its name on a business that deals with bitcoin.perhaps something along the lines of voluntary ISO 27000 accreditation would help build trust.
Is this the place I should be reporting you, or is this your idea of being cute?
So you're unable to identify who's dumb notion you're responding to. Got it.
I'm glad you admit you're making an association fallacy, the wise next step would be to examine why you felt necessary to make it.
This is essentially what this loss of public trust is. Some scream that bitcoin cannot be trusted "because exchanges" and people don't trust it any more, nevermind the blatantly ridiculous notion. It is irrational. That's why they call it a logical fallacy. You describing the situation doesn't make it rational.
So to summarise recent bitcoin news:
- MtGox has evaporated taking money, both real and DKs, with it.
- The Canadian "Bitcoin bank" Flexcoin has shut down after a major (alleged) theft.
- Poloniex ("a fast, secure exchange") has also been the subject of an (alleged); the exchange has reduced all its users’ balances by 12.3% and has terminated actual .
- Then there's the suspected suicide of Autumn Radtke (CEO of the Singapore based First Meta currency exchange; lots of speculation about missing "assets" but no definite info yet. And the Singapore police are investigating.
linky said:An economic bubble: A bubble is similar to a Ponzi scheme in that one participant gets paid by contributions from a subsequent participant (until inevitable collapse). A bubble involves ever-rising prices in an open market (for example stock, housing, or tulip bulbs) where prices rise because buyers bid more because prices are rising. Bubbles are often said to be based on the "greater fool" theory. As with the Ponzi scheme, the price exceeds the intrinsic value of the item, but unlike the Ponzi scheme, there is no single person misrepresenting the intrinsic value.
Hey, I just think it's funny that you say I'm using strawmen, when you used strawmen as a (factually incorrect) passive-aggressive jab at me in your previous post, and also later in your post, and later in this one. So you tell me.
You keep using that phrase. What's the association fallacy? In the quoted post, you complained about vagueness. So why don't you start here, what exactly is it? Is it like the association fallacy that, because the BC protocol is secure, the currency -as it's used- is secure? The notion I'm mocking?
And here, I thought it was due to the rampant and systematic thefts.
Who's screamin? The strawmen constituents?
Nowhere in that quote was there an association, besides the "security is only as good as the weakest link". And if that's the association fallacy, then we are done here. I don't have time to waste on randomly throwing "fallacy" at things you don't like.
So why don't you start here, what exactly is it? Is it like the association fallacy that, because the BC protocol is secure, the currency -as it's used- is secure? The notion I'm mocking?