How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
It seemed ludicrous that the man credited with inventing Bitcoin - the world's most wildly successful digital currency, with transactions of nearly $500 million a day at its peak - would retreat to Los Angeles's San Bernardino foothills, hole up in the family home and leave his estimated $400 million of Bitcoin riches untouched.

I bet I know why. You don't really have $400 million if it's not really there.
 
Michaelsuede,the starter of this thread, in now active in the Science section of JREF promoting a "Free Energy" scheme.
I note that if you fall for woo in one area, you are very likely to fall for it in another.
 
From reading the article, it didn't seem to be related to the bitcoin protocols as such. It looks like the developers messed up the design and/or implementation of their exchange software, failing to prevent race conditions.

Are you referring to the twitter comment about removing commands from a global queue sequentially?

Nevermind, I went back to the article and found the link to the forum where he describes the flaw.

I was most interested in the equal 12% haircut that all account holders were required to take.
 
Last edited:
From reading the article, it didn't seem to be related to the bitcoin protocols as such. It looks like the developers messed up the design and/or implementation of their exchange software, failing to prevent race conditions.

I didn't say the protocols were insecure. The point is to mock the dumb notion that these events are tossed aside with "but the math is sound!" claims. It's an insecure currency, and no amount of saying "it's the exchanges, not the protocols" is going to change that fact. If many of the biggest US banks got robbed with the same frequency, it's akin to saying "but the US Dollar is still safe because reasons!"
 
I thought one of the most important aspects of a viable currency was some measure of stability and reliability- resulting from the support and backing of a massive, successful institution. Does Bitcoin have anything like that?
 
I didn't say the protocols were insecure. The point is to mock the dumb notion that these events are tossed aside with "but the math is sound!" claims. It's an insecure currency, and no amount of saying "it's the exchanges, not the protocols" is going to change that fact. If many of the biggest US banks got robbed with the same frequency, it's akin to saying "but the US Dollar is still safe because reasons!"
It's the exact opposite of what you are saying. Anti-bitcoiners are saying, "bitcoin is unsound because exchanges". That is akin to saying that the US dollar is unsound because banks get robbed.
 
It's the exact opposite of what you are saying. Anti-bitcoiners are saying, "bitcoin is unsound because exchanges". That is akin to saying that the US dollar is unsound because banks get robbed.

"It"??? As in what I said? I said the exact opposite of what I said?
 
Last edited:
The point is to mock the dumb notion that these events are tossed aside with "but the math is sound!" claims.

Whose dumb notion? You're arguing against straw men.
Or what exactly do you mean by tossed aside? It's the ant-bitcoiners who "toss aside" all the thefts, hacks etc with "bitcoin being bitcoin", and "fools being fools". You might want to reread the thread or at least respond to what is being said in the thread. Or at least quote the relevant bits from wherever you get these odd ideas you wish to refute.

It's an insecure currency, and no amount of saying "it's the exchanges, not the protocols" is going to change that fact.

Vague assertion is vague. By insecure currency you of course mean the exchanges and no amount of vagueness is going to hide your association fallacy. Correct me please If you meant something else.

And since when is it currency? You bitskeptics should make up your mind.

If many of the biggest US banks got robbed with the same frequency, it's akin to saying "but the US Dollar is still safe because reasons!"

Since when banks = USD? Oh I'm sorry, I guess since exchanges = BTC. But that's just odd. You do understand that banks being robbed is not the fault of dollar bills? :rolleyes:
 
Whose dumb notion? You're arguing against straw men.
straw men.
straw men
You're real funny, kid. I almost thought you were serious for a second.

You might want to reread the thread or at least respond to what is being said in the thread.
Like the part, where that post was me responding to ctamblyn, who was responding to my older post? Where I was responding to wrs?

By insecure currency you of course mean the exchanges and no amount of vagueness is going to hide your association fallacy
The currency is safe investment. The multiple massive losses so many folks have had in the recent past is a statistical fluke, got it. Also, apparently contraposition means an association fallacy. That's a new fact I learned today.

You bitskeptics should make up your mind.
Racist.

If many of the biggest US banks got robbed with the same frequency, it's akin to saying "but the US Dollar is still safe because reasons!"
Since when banks = USD? Oh I'm sorry, I guess since exchanges = BTC. But that's just odd. You do understand that banks being robbed is not the fault of dollar bills?
. . .
That loud sound you just heard was me face palming. I don't even know where to start with what's wrong here. But it all stems from one source: you don't understand that a currency is only as good as you can trust it. And security is only as good as the weakest link. The perfectestly secure transaction math does. not. change. that. The fact that a sizeable percentage of the BC currency has been gained by malicious means is testament to that.
 
You are not that stupid.

You just can't answer my post so you are playing silly word games.

Twisting somebody else's words and then claiming they are playing "word games" is rich, I'll give you that.


The analogy is straightforward, you twisted completely the opposite of what I said. I'm talking about the disregard for the massive losses in the BTC economy because they're financial institutions. Swap BTC for Dollar.
 
You're real funny, kid.

Racist.

Is this the place I should be reporting you, or is this your idea of being cute?

Like the part, where that post was me responding to ctamblyn, who was responding to my older post? Where I was responding to wrs?

So you're unable to identify who's dumb notion you're responding to. Got it.

That loud sound you just heard was me face palming. I don't even know where to start with what's wrong here. But it all stems from one source: you don't understand that a currency is only as good as you can trust it. And security is only as good as the weakest link. The perfectestly secure transaction math does. not. change. that. The fact that a sizeable percentage of the BC currency has been gained by malicious means is testament to that.

I'm glad you admit you're making an association fallacy, the wise next step would be to examine why you felt necessary to make it.
This is essentially what this loss of public trust is. Some scream that bitcoin cannot be trusted "because exchanges" and people don't trust it any more, nevermind the blatantly ridiculous notion. It is irrational. That's why they call it a logical fallacy. You describing the situation doesn't make it rational.
 
Is this the place I should be reporting you, or is this your idea of being cute?
Hey, I just think it's funny that you say I'm using strawmen, when you used strawmen as a (factually incorrect) passive-aggressive jab at me in your previous post, and also later in your post, and later in this one. So you tell me.


So you're unable to identify who's dumb notion you're responding to. Got it.
Unfair double standard strikes again. But I will later.


I'm glad you admit you're making an association fallacy, the wise next step would be to examine why you felt necessary to make it.
You keep using that phrase. What's the association fallacy? In the quoted post, you complained about vagueness. So why don't you start here, what exactly is it? Is it like the association fallacy that, because the BC protocol is secure, the currency -as it's used- is secure? The notion I'm mocking?


This is essentially what this loss of public trust is.
And here, I thought it was due to the rampant and systematic thefts. Wait, those are ignored because "because exchanges". The *EXACT* notion I'm complaining about. You wanted a real case, I found it.


Some scream that bitcoin cannot be trusted "because exchanges"
Who's screamin? The strawmen constituents? You think I'm joking, but I'm just holding you to your own demands. You don't want to play strawman, then fine, we don't play strawman. But that's a two-way street.


and people don't trust it any more, nevermind the blatantly ridiculous notion.
. . .

It is irrational. That's why they call it a logical fallacy. You describing the situation doesn't make it rational.
Nowhere in that quote was there an association, besides the "security is only as good as the weakest link". And if that's the association fallacy, then we are done here. I don't have time to waste on randomly throwing "fallacy" at things you don't like.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom