How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
No, I believe that Kraaken is spinning the truth which is that they can't get the $ they need and that is why they are looking for new $ partners. Fidor is their $ banking partner. Now all of a sudden when people with $ denominated bitcoin accounts want to liquidate bitcoin for $, Fidor is "overwhelmed" by the volume of transactions? Then Kraaken proposes a bonus if you will take Euro instead?

I think your reading comprehension is as expected, you are reading with your bitcoin blinders on.

Yep. "Delayed" is a code word for "we don't have the money and you're screwed (unless we find new rubes....errr...'investors' to send us cash)".
 
Last edited:
:) Fidor is their European partner, it's a German bank and their banking partner for EUR not USD. But your conspiracies are entertaining :)

Fidor was linked to as their USD banking partner in the source article. It really doesn't matter who the partner is though, does it? The problem is that they have no $ liquidity.
 
Maybe you just don't understand liquidity.


2. The ability to convert an asset to cash quickly. Also known as "marketability."

So bitcoin at Kraaken in USD is illiquid.

QED

Good for you, scored some Internet Points. So your point was that Kraken can't convert BTC to USD quickly? Duh, that's what the announcement was about, that's what they said. There are delays. Thanks for pointing out the obvious.
 
If the money's there, it's there -- it shouldn't take 4 weeks to process unless the money _isn't_ there, in which case who knows what they've been doing under the table.
Obviously, if the money is "there" then it is in a bank account. So either the bank wasn't handling USD transactions in a timely manner or Kraaken didn't have the money in the bank account.

The latter possibility could be the subject of all sorts of thrilling stories about theft and embezzlement but without a shred of evidence they are just made-up stories.

The more likely (but boring) possibility is that the bank wasn't geared up for the increased USD business (probably from disaffected MtGox customers).
 
Fidor was linked to as their USD banking partner in the source article.

Source article? Where?

It really doesn't matter who the partner is though, does it? The problem is that they have no $ liquidity.

The problem is you're overreacting to a sound business decision and imagining paranoid scenarios. I don't particularly mind, but I'm struggling to see this as being a discussion anymore when you fail at basic reading comprehension and make things up. I'd love to discuss facts, not fantasies and hyperboles.
 
Source article? Where?

The coindesk article.

coindesk said:
The problem was apparently caused by a recent increase in US dollar transaction volume, much of which came from outside the United States, and temporarily overwhelmed Kraken’s current US banking partner.

Follow the link.


The problem is you're overreacting to a sound business decision and imagining paranoid scenarios. I don't particularly mind, but I'm struggling to see this as being a discussion anymore when you fail at basic reading comprehension and make things up. I'd love to discuss facts, not fantasies and hyperboles.

What sound business decision and what paranoid scenario? You are attempting to deflect the fact that Kraken has a USD liquidity problem.

That was the word you objected to in my original post. By the definition of liquid, Kraken has a no US $ liquidity. If it takes 4 weeks or longer to get $ from them and no guarantee on what longer might mean. Then by defintion, they have no US $ liquidity. There is no paranoia or anything else involved. There is a lot of deflection by you though.

Posting the definition of liquidity from another source, just for you.

li·quid·i·ty (lĭ-kwĭd′ĭ-tē)
n.
1. The state of being liquid.
2. The quality of being readily convertible into cash: an investment with high liquidity.
3. Available cash or the capacity to obtain it on demand: a bank that is increasing its liquidity by shortening the average term of its loans.
 
In other news, banks occasionally get robbed, hackers occasionally steal credit/debit/bank account information, and financial giants manipulate all manner of markets. Some question if these are as safe and secure as believed and wonder if any storage/transfer of value is truly safe.

Not a valid comparison. bank are robbed yes, but the money loss are ridiculously small compared to the amount in circulation.

On the other hand with mtGox we are speaking of 40.000 BTC lost for one incident, among 12 million (tip of iceberg IMHO).

Call me back when somebody rob enough bank that 0.3% of the whole world money disappear in one go.
 
Idealists with minimal real world business experience, riding a revolutionary "meme" and betting on pixels on a screen, might understandably have a poor understanding of basic financial concepts such as "liquidity."

Lots of fun until it's time to pay the piper.

I wonder what effect this latest crash will have on the planned FBI auction of the Bitcoins seized in the Silk Road takedown. (Not that they particularly care how much they get for them anyway.)
 
Not a valid comparison. bank are robbed yes, but the money loss are ridiculously small compared to the amount in circulation.

On the other hand with mtGox we are speaking of 40.000 BTC lost for one incident, among 12 million (tip of iceberg IMHO).

Call me back when somebody rob enough bank that 0.3% of the whole world money disappear in one go.

Oh and if the 740K bitcoin stolen are true then we are speaking of 6% of the whole world money stolen in one go. About 240 billion USD equivalent (world money circulation is 4 trillion about USD equivalent, so 6% of it...).
 
Good for you, scored some Internet Points. So your point was that Kraken can't convert BTC to USD quickly? Duh, that's what the announcement was about, that's what they said. There are delays. Thanks for pointing out the obvious.

No , the obvious is the time asked : 4 weeks. You continue to ignore that little bit.
 
The coindesk article.
Follow the link.

Yeah, the CoinDesk article was a bit misleading and not really a source article, they're fetching their info from other sites and linking willy-nilly. I haven't seen any mention by Kraken that Fidor was dealing their USD transactions. In fact, in one announcement, Kraken staff said they are pleased with their EUR banking partner, but the USD one is having some delays.

What sound business decision

The decision to not accept any more USD because their USD banking partner is having delays - that was the whole news. Is that not a sound decision? They're concerned with quality and customer service, unlike mtGox, who gladly accepted whatever currency and let their customers wait for months.

and what paranoid scenario?

There are so many, I won't be able to quote them all. Just some from recent pages:

It's obvious that there was never enough money there
They don't have the $ and don't know how they will get them
This is MtGox all over again
This whole "exchange" thing is a scam

This is all hysterical FUD market manipulation. Oh, that's right, you don't have a horse in this race.

You are attempting to deflect the fact that Kraken has a USD liquidity problem.

How am I deflecting it? Let's be honest and concise here. In BTC context, illiquidity can be understood as in your money's gone, there's no cash nor BTC to turn into cash, what is left is illiquid assets like office rooms, supplies etc. It takes time to sell/liquidate them and you'll end up with financial loss. MtGox is assumably illiquid. What Kraken has is delays with their USD banking partner. The USD is liquid, EUR is liquid, BTC is liquid. Of course another definition is not readily or quickly convertible into cash. But to you, that's the whole point, to equivocate so that it seems worse than it actually is.

But if you're in a hurry, why not withdraw in EUR?

That was the word you objected to in my original post. By the definition of liquid, Kraken has a no US $ liquidity. If it takes 4 weeks or longer to get $ from them and no guarantee on what longer might mean. Then by defintion, they have no US $ liquidity. There is no paranoia or anything else involved. There is a lot of deflection by you though.

What I objected to was your claim that they halted withdrawals:
me said:
wut? They didn't halt withdrawals. They specifically said they didn't, I specifically quoted that part. Did you miss that?

I'm not deflecting the fact that there are delays when withdrawing USD, that's what the freaking article said. How are you not getting it? And why are you insisting on using the word liquidity if you mean delays? It seems we agree on the general gist, but you want to score some semantic point.

Posting the definition of liquidity from another source, just for you.

Posting the definition of liquidity from your own source, just for you.

Definition of 'Liquidity'

1. The degree to which an asset or security can be bought or sold in the market without affecting the asset's price. Liquidity is characterized by a high level of trading activity. Assets that can be easily bought or sold are known as liquid assets.


If you want to play the semantic game, liquidity refers to how easily an assent can be bought and sold, how easy it is to find a buyer. BTC is easily sold with high trading activity. It doesn't even make sense to say there's "no liquidity in US $" in the light of this definition.
 
No , the obvious is the time asked : 4 weeks. You continue to ignore that little bit.

You continue to ignore that I don't ignore that. What about the 4 weeks? Is that not a delay? To me, it is a delay. They said it is a delay. I said it is a delay. What's the problem?
 
Last edited:
Bitcoin exchange Kraken put a brief halt on US dollar withdrawals and suspended USD deposits today, offering customers a 2% bonus to convert their balances to euros (EUR).


If (1) they are offering immediate conversions to Euros with a 2% bonus, and if (2) that bonus covers the conversion back to US$ through a real bank (which AFAIR, the fee is around %2, I haven't checked), then isn't it basically the same as converting to US$?
 
Some of the commenters who got burnt on MtGox are now talking about setting up a real exchange, with accounting, and security, and... um, er, wasn't the idea of bitcoin that you could transfer money without recourse to financial institutions?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom