How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
I didn't say, or even imply that. I did say, and will say again, that the problems which are currently coming to a head were entirely predictable and were, in fact, predicted in this very thread.

Caveat bitcoinor.

Don't worry. MHaze predicted 5000$ per BTC by 2015 at least. I wish he were here to rub it in our faces.
 
Time for the regulators to step in and close the rest of those sites proffering this phony "currency".


Depends on the country:
Japan's financial regulators, by contrast, have largely given bitcoin a shrug.

"Bitcoin is not a currency; it is an alternative to currencies, like gold," said a spokesman for the Financial Services Agency. "We are only responsible for currencies and therefore bitcoin is not subject to our regulatory oversight."

Japanese Finance Ministry officials also said they are not in charge of regulating the virtual currency.

https://news.yahoo.com/bitcoin-exch...Rwc3RhaWQDBHBzdGNhdANob21lBHB0A3BtaA--;_ylv=3

........................................
ETA:
same source
Karpeles himself, while insisting on his own exchange's reliability, has made no secret that bitcoin is, as he told Reuters last April, a "high-risk investment".

"If you buy bitcoins, you should buy keeping in mind that the value could be zero the day after."

Really?!
 
Last edited:
jhunter1163, you supposedly don't have anything to gain or lose by what bitcoin does, yet you continually try to make it seem as if bitcoin has failed, is failing and will be failing regardless of real world events or facts, which have been discussed here thoroughly. You have even called people who invest in bitcoin fools. I find this passionate engagement with the subject and supposed neutrality curiously juxtaposed. No doubt bitcoin's future is on shaky grounds at this point and we have every reason to examine the security of exchanges and bitcoin protocol, but you're just giving out mis/disinformation about "exchanges" not paying out, implying insolvency, people desperately trying to get out and not succeeding etc. It's as if you're doing some price manipuation yourself. Planning to buy in? :D

I've said before that the fundamental principle of bitcoin (a secure and anonymous place to store value) is a sound one. However, with certain trivial exceptions, that is not how BTC is being used in practice. In practice, it is almost exclusively being used as a speculative investment. And, yes, anyone who would invest in something which can lose double-digit percentages literally overnight is, in my opinion, a fool.

As far as mis/disinformation about exchanges not paying out, given recent events and problems at all of the exchanges (not just Gox) with "transaction malleability", I would say that skepticism about the security of all Bitcoin exchanges is entirely warranted.

Full disclosure: I am not now, never have been, and never will be a BTC user or investor.
 
I just have to post this. It might even be worth it's own thread in conspiracy but it's so typical of the bitcoin community at large. Nothing can ever be wrong with bitcoin, it's always someone trying to torpedo prices or the concept.

Between this and the fake "crisis report" filled with grammar and spelling mistakes, I have to wonder if someone has taken over Mt. Gox by force and is now faking a full meltdown to drive Bitcoin prices down.
Could it be that everyone involved in Mt. Gox are being held hostage somewhere and someone else is making it look like they are going into full meltdown mode?

Priceless.........
 
I just have to post this. It might even be worth it's own thread in conspiracy but it's so typical of the bitcoin community at large. Nothing can ever be wrong with bitcoin, it's always someone trying to torpedo prices or the concept.



Priceless.........

Yeah, some people have a twisted sense of importance.
 
That's my theory as well.

I'm not sure you'll find anyone except a few barking loons who's not of the opinion that Gox is now several miles over the "boned" horizon and accelerating rapidly.

As you note above, the question really is: how much damage will this do to bitcoin? There are 15000 BTC worth of bit orders on Bitstamp right now between 440 and 450 -- the lowest bid amount shown, signifying that there are indeed people with more money than sense out there. Trying to predict the bottom of a crash so they can time their buying perfectly is a mug's game, especially with a commodity that's based on hope.
 
I just have to post this. It might even be worth it's own thread in conspiracy but it's so typical of the bitcoin community at large. Nothing can ever be wrong with bitcoin, it's always someone trying to torpedo prices or the concept.



Priceless.........

That SPESSMEHREN guy isn't taking this very well.
 
So was it a flaw in btc's cryptologic algorithm or was it a flaw in mtgox? CNN and NPR are both reporting it as a problem with btc itself, but many boosters seem to be saying that it's just a problem with MtGox and also that the foundation is working on a fix (which doesn't make sense since MtGox is now closed).

Either way, it rather underlines my point about the importance of institutional protections for the little guy. Hopefully these people have more money than sense and can afford to lose this money, but if I had even a fraction of that disappear, my family would go hungry.
 
Here's a conspiracy for you--what if Mt. Gox was built to fail?

I offer no evidence, so I ask for no particular credibility. I'm purely speculating.
 
So was it a flaw in btc's cryptologic algorithm or was it a flaw in mtgox? CNN and NPR are both reporting it as a problem with btc itself, but many boosters seem to be saying that it's just a problem with MtGox and also that the foundation is working on a fix (which doesn't make sense since MtGox is now closed).

By "it" what do you mean exactly? There are a number of weaknesses with bitcoin protocol that were known long before all the shady stuff started happening with mtgox. MtGox going belly up have only themselves to blame for it. Details aren't clear, but if they lost the 744,400 BTC over years due to someone exploiting the transaction malleability, it's their own fault not to make regular audits or check their balance and install some security measures. It seems they had no idea what they were doing. I can't wrap my head around how this could happen, so I'm going to take all of this with a grain of salt. We might never know the truth.

Transaction malleability is not some mystical whole that sucks bitcoins and mtGox were naive in thinking they can blame their problems on it, to an audience of techies and nerds no less.

Basically what it is, is someone changing the transaction ID by tampering with some minor non-essential parts of the transaction packet. So someone on the receiving end of the transaction can fraudulently claim they did not receive the coins and if the sender is, say, mtGox and their software relies solely on checking transaction IDs, they might believe the transaction failed, because there's no indication of a transaction with that ID in the public ledger. That does not however mean that the transaction didn't go through - it did, but with a different ID. So they'll pay twice. Multiply that with millions of transactions and users and you find yourself a few missing bitcoins.

This is a decent explanation of what is transaction malleability :
Who's at fault?
article said:
On the one hand, you can argue that malleability has been a known issue since 2011 and companies should have known to be watching for the non-malleable payment details of a transaction to show up, rather than waiting for the transaction ID to show up. If you’re not doing this, your system is buggy and it’s your own fault. Or so this argument goes.

On the other hand, watching for a transaction ID is an easy mistake to make, and it is kind of odd to call something a transaction ID when it can be changed. This is certainly a rough edge in the Bitcoin design, which could have been avoided and will likely be fixed in the future. This was an avoidable error by the Bitcoin designers. Or so this argument goes.

Both arguments have some merit. The bottom line is that these problem could have been prevented either by the Bitcoin designers or by the authors of the affected software. This is an important reminder that relying on new, complex technologies carries risks, and it pays to be extra careful to engineer the details of your technology correctly.
 
No more $ for bitcoins at kraaken. So they will only do Euro transactions from now on.

Claiming no liquidity in $ errr, if you want $ for your bitcoins, fuggedaboutit........

Many USD withdrawals have been delayed beyond a limit we can accept, and it reflects poorly on our service,” a customer support representative said.

Isn't this the same problem MtGox had too? No $ liquidity for the ridiculous prices?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom