How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
More on the Gox Leak].

Once again, it seems more certain those 750,000 coins are gone, never to return. Now of course everyone is rallying around the flag and yet, what is any different at Bitstamp or Btc-e (which is a very shady entity) or Kraken? What makes them any better at auditing or have anymore idea of how a financial business is run? Why are they not subject to the same risks and not making the same kinds of mistakes? The sure look the same on the outside................
 
Interesting article from MacLeans.

The Mt. Gox caper, in which 744,408 Bitcoins disappeared from the Tokyo-based cryptocurrency exchange, doesn’t mean Bitcoin is destined to die, but it probably will.
.....
At the current exchange rate, the lost Bitcoins—equivalent to about six per cent of all the Bitcoins in circulation—are worth US$395 million.
But let’s face it, Bitcoin isn’t an established currency like the U.S. dollar, backed by the “full faith and credit of the United States.” It’s a plaything of corporate anarchists that exists solely on the faith its users place in it that their investment/deposit isn’t going to walk out the virtual door in someone else’s pocket. The only hope I can see for Bitcoin’s survival after this is the creation of a deposit insurance system, similar to the FDIC in the U.S. or the CDIC in Canada, which protects a bank customer’s deposits up to $100,000 in the case of failure. But I have no idea who would ever bankroll such a scheme since a Bitcoin’s value could be anywhere from zero to infinity.
Duncan Stewart goes much deeper here in looking at bank thefts vs Bitcoin exchange thefts. After tallying up all the Bitcoin thefts since 2011, and drawing on FBI bank robbery stats, he concludes “the annual losses due to theft in the Bitcoin currency would have been roughly 1,000 times greater than the equivalent losses in the U.S. dollar currency ecosystem over the same time period.” An interesting read.
Link.

Also a compilation of responses to the MtGox fiasco here.

Particularly amusing is the rantings from defunct bitbugs who wish to have the administrators of MtGox murdered. A reasoned response indeed.
:rolleyes:
 
Interesting article from MacLeans.

Link.

Also a compilation of responses to the MtGox fiasco here.

Particularly amusing is the rantings from defunct bitbugs who wish to have the administrators of MtGox murdered. A reasoned response indeed.
:rolleyes:

I found this funny, for some reason:
From the 2nd link said:
@Bro_Pair If only there was an untraceable currency these nerds could use to pay the hitman. Some sort of...cryptocurrency.
 
Interesting article from MacLeans.
..............
................. The only hope I can see for Bitcoin’s survival after this is the creation of a deposit insurance system, similar to the FDIC in the U.S. or the CDIC in Canada, which protects a bank customer’s deposits up to $100,000 in the case of failure. .............
..............
Government to the rescue? Why would anybody think that propping up such a bunch of incompetents would help bitcoin in any way?

MtGox's attempt to blame "transaction malleability" for their loss bitcoin losses is really just an admission that they didn't have their eye on the ball for a long time. People who wish to hold/use bitcoins are better off without clowns like these.

http://www.coindesk.com/bitcoin-bug-guide-transaction-malleability/ gives a clear description about transaction malleability and how it can be avoided. Here are the "Jack and Jill" bits:
Let’s say that Alice runs an exchange, and Eve has bitcoins sitting in that exchange. Eve decides to withdraw her coins, and asks Alice to send the bitcoins to her address. When Alice sends them, this automatically creates a transaction, which is transmitted for mining so that it can be included in the bitcoin block chain.

But Eve pretends that Alice never sent them. She uses the transaction malleability flaw to reproduce Alice’s original transaction, tweaking the signature slightly to produce a different hash. She then retransmits that transaction, with the different ID.

There is a chance that Eve’s transaction will be confirmed on the block chain first. If that happens, the network will assume that transaction is valid, and won’t record Alice’s. Eve can then complain to Alice that she didn’t receive the coins. When Alice checks for her transaction ID in the block chain, she won’t find it, and she might try to send more bitcoins, meaning that she’ll be out of pocket.

...........................

In our exchange example above, you’d hope that Alice would have detailed enough bookkeeping records that she would still be able to reconcile the bitcoins that she had sent. If she sent Eve, say, 1 bitcoin at 12:10pm GMT on February 5th, that’s a pretty unique transaction. She could simply say “our records show that this transaction went out, at this time, with these parameters. The transaction ID must have changed, so I’m not resending those bitcoins.”

An exchange could also implement tools to automatically track inputs on transactions, which would help it spot mutations.
 
Particularly amusing is the rantings from defunct bitbugs who wish to have the administrators of MtGox murdered. A reasoned response indeed.
:rolleyes:

They were all cheerleaders until the music stopped and they didn't have a chair.

Alternately, "Only when the tide goes out do you discover who's been swimming naked." - Warren Buffett
 
The gloating sure never gets old. It's not like we have every other post filled with schadenfreude and cute metaphors.

I'm sure if we go back to last November, right about the time the bubble started, we won't find any of the pro-bitcoin posters speaking with a similar tone... while the price was on its way up.

Right?
 
If you want to invest in something that is totally free of any kind of government regulation, don't expect any of the protections that you get from governments against fraud, etc.

Bitcoin:Tulipmania for the New Millinium.
 
I'm sure if we go back to last November, right about the time the bubble started, we won't find any of the pro-bitcoin posters speaking with a similar tone... while the price was on its way up.

Right?

I don't know, I wasn't active in the thread then. Maybe they were, and while I'm thinking it's the bitskeptics who are unnecessarily hostile and dismissive and fond of spin, it's just a reaction to earlier feud or something. Is it healthy, though?
 
Government to the rescue? Why would anybody think that propping up such a bunch of incompetents would help bitcoin in any way?
<snip>
I see you ignore the vastly higher level of thefts of bitcoins in comparison to real currency.

Somehow it's hanging in around $580.

www.preev.com
Ah but can you actually convert Dunning–Krugerands at that price? And get real money dirty worthless fiat.
 
Government regulation isn't necessary for reliability. The market place can be just as good a regulator.

Mt Gox seems to be one of the more secure exchanges (nowadays) but from what EGarrett says, it is still subject to delays in processing transactions. That might make me think twice about using it.

Still, for the amount of bitcoin business that I would likely do, EBAY might suit my purposes just as well.

Archeology time :-) This post is from april 26.2013.This is not an attack on you, psionl0. This just struck me as a post that is informative of an attitude towards mtgox at the time - of what I would consider a more reasonable bitcoin proponent. And you mention egarrett bless him!

In my opinion it shows why the mtgox could be the Lehman Brothers of bitcoin. A giant institution (70 % of the money flow april 2013! )people consider secure going out with a bang.
 
Last edited:
Archeology time :-) This post is from april 26.2013.
Thanks for digging up that post eirik. It shows that at a time when nobody was suggesting that there was anything untoward about MtGox, I was already advising caution. Expecting to hand over 1,000's of bitcoins and collect 1,000,000's of dollars (in one hit) is one of those "sounds too good to be true" situations.

The market has certainly regulated MtGox out of business and the other exchanges are going to have their work cut out trying to convince the public that they are still safe. Imagine how this might have panned out if the government had decided that MtGox was "too big to fail".

I see you ignore the vastly higher level of thefts of bitcoins in comparison to real currency.
I'm not particularly interested in the losses of someone who's idea of security is the equivalent of leaving a large bag labeled "CA$H" out on the front porch of their home.
 
Last edited:
What else would you expect from a totalitarian country? Do you want the same thing to happen in the US too?

I want Bitcoin to be free to use. At the same time I want a new internationally regulated similar currency that competes with Bitcoin. A legally approved global digital currency that is more stable in terms of deflation/inflation and that is free from the pyramid scheme type nature of Bitcoin.
 

From the article:

Currencies like bitcoin are unnerving financial regulators in Asia and elsewhere because they are outside of their control. Established banks don't like them because people can send the money around the world with any fees.
<snip>
Aside from an investment and buying goods and services online, bitcoin could be used by Vietnam's diaspora to sends home remittances if the currency were to take a broader hold.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom