How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
um, er, wasn't the idea of bitcoin that you could transfer money without recourse to financial institutions?

The point of bitcoin has never been exchanges, it was to transfer bitcoin from wallet to wallet. In a hypothetical utopian world where bitcoin would be the main currency and accepted worldwide, you wouldn't even need exchanges.
 
A year or two.

I've been predicting a total collapse of the dollar in or around 2012 for some time now.

Apparently I'm not the only one who sees the writing on the wall:

The Head Of The World's Biggest Hedge Fund Sees "Economic Collapse" Due To Money Printing By Early 2013


Looks as if bitcoin is not the only thing the guy who claimed that bitcoin is the most important invention in the history of man was wrong about.........


What amazes me is how many people who are pretty intelligent fall for the Libetarian/AnCap woo. And let's face it, the Libertarian/AnCap types have been bitcoin's biggest promoters.
 
Last edited:
Not a valid comparison. bank are robbed yes, but the money loss are ridiculously small compared to the amount in circulation.

On the other hand with mtGox we are speaking of 40.000 BTC lost for one incident, among 12 million (tip of iceberg IMHO).

Call me back when somebody rob enough bank that 0.3% of the whole world money disappear in one go.

It's not valid only because you choose to ignore most of my post you quoted. If it's not worth your time to read and address the entire point I made then it's not worth mine to explain in greater detail.
 
The point of bitcoin has never been exchanges, it was to transfer bitcoin from wallet to wallet. In a hypothetical utopian world where bitcoin would be the main currency and accepted worldwide, you wouldn't even need exchanges.
You may have missed the sarcasm of my previous post.

Somehow I can't help but think of MagicalTux as Bender: "I will set up my own exchange! With blackjack, and hookers! On the second thought, forget the exchange."
 
Yeah, the CoinDesk article was a bit misleading and not really a source article, they're fetching their info from other sites and linking willy-nilly. I haven't seen any mention by Kraken that Fidor was dealing their USD transactions. In fact, in one announcement, Kraken staff said they are pleased with their EUR banking partner, but the USD one is having some delays.

Can you explain the highlighted part? The Coindesk link implies that Fidor is their USD banking partner. What linking willy-nilly are you talking about? This just looks like more deflection to me.


There are so many, I won't be able to quote them all. Just some from recent pages:

This is all hysterical FUD market manipulation. Oh, that's right, you don't have a horse in this race.

Can't handle the truth apparently. The fact is that Kraken has halted USD withdrawals by cancelling them. The meaning is plain but you refuse to accept it.


How am I deflecting it? Let's be honest and concise here. In BTC context, illiquidity can be understood as in your money's gone, there's no cash nor BTC to turn into cash, what is left is illiquid assets like office rooms, supplies etc.

So now you have a special definition of liquidity just for BTC? LOLOLOL!!!!!!!!!!!

Let's try again:

2. The quality of being readily convertible into cash: an investment with high liquidity.

Kraken has no BTC to US $ liquidity. That is a simple statement of fact which you seem to be unable to accept.



But if you're in a hurry, why not withdraw in EUR?

Your bank won't take EUR wires, that's fairly obvious I would think and why people deposited in USD to begin with.

What I objected to was your claim that they halted withdrawals:

But they did just that, they cancelled all the outstanding USD withdrawal requests.

I'm not deflecting the fact that there are delays when withdrawing USD, that's what the freaking article said. How are you not getting it? And why are you insisting on using the word liquidity if you mean delays? It seems we agree on the general gist, but you want to score some semantic point.

I am insisting on using liquidity because it is the most accurate and shortest way to describe the USD issue at Kraken right now. It doesn't mean insolvent which is what you are conflating it with. I made the first post and you started whining about my use of the word liquidity right off the bat because I suspect you misunderstood it.



If you want to play the semantic game, liquidity refers to how easily an assent can be bought and sold, how easy it is to find a buyer. BTC is easily sold with high trading activity. It doesn't even make sense to say there's "no liquidity in US $" in the light of this definition.

Except that I have plainly highlighted definition #2 for you from two different sources and you seem to have problems with accepting the fact that it perfectly describes the USD liquidity problem that Kraken is having, i.e. they have no BTC to USD liquidity.
 
You may have missed the sarcasm of my previous post.

I don't think I did.

Can you explain the highlighted part? The Coindesk link implies that Fidor is their USD banking partner. What linking willy-nilly are you talking about?

Their linking implies Fidor is Kraken's banking partner for USD transaction, which AFAIK isn't true. That's the willy-nilly linking. Did you read the article it was linking to? There isn't any mention that Fidor is their US banking partner, plus what I said earlier regarding their own statement.

This just looks like more deflection to me.

You keep using that word, I do not think it means what you think it means. I've been addressing your points. You haven't explained how am I deflecting.

Can't handle the truth apparently. The fact is that Kraken has halted USD withdrawals by cancelling them. The meaning is plain but you refuse to accept it.

Well, it's the time when reading comprehension comes in handy again. Cancel a request != halt withdrawals. This is again your equivocation game. The fact is you can withdraw USD if you want to.

So now you have a special definition of liquidity just for BTC? LOLOLOL!!!!!!!!!!!

If you think investopedia is exclusive to bitcoin definitions...


Your bank won't take EUR wires, that's fairly obvious I would think and why people deposited in USD to begin with.

My bank? Fetch me a Kraken user who has his money stuck in there, I'll gladly hear what someone in the know has to say. Your speculation is speculation, and as history shows, wild and imaginative. I can't think of a reason why someone wouldn't be able to get their money out. A statement form Kraken team is at the bottom of this post regarding the very same.

But they did just that, they cancelled all the outstanding USD withdrawal requests.

They cancelled all the pending requests. Withdrawing in USD isn't halted. You can process your withdrawal request if you want to wait for several weeks.

Kraken has no BTC to US $ liquidity. That is a simple statement of fact which you seem to be unable to accept.
I am insisting on using liquidity because it is the most accurate and shortest way to describe the USD issue at Kraken right now. It doesn't mean insolvent which is what you are conflating it with. I made the first post and you started whining about my use of the word liquidity right off the bat because I suspect you misunderstood it.
Except that I have plainly highlighted definition #2 for you from two different sources and you seem to have problems with accepting the fact that it perfectly describes the USD liquidity problem that Kraken is having, i.e. they have no BTC to USD liquidity.

Sorry, I did confuse it with solvency. :blush: So I guess we agree.




In the meantime, here's what Kraken support has to say:

"We have every penny that users have deposited. The problem is that we've reached the limit of our US bank's capacity to deal with the transaction volume on our account. Banks, especially US banks, associate higher transaction volume with higher risk. They are in fact uncomfortable with clients that process higher volumes of transactions (and it also doesn't help if you're a bitcoin company).
We've offered to convert customer's USD to EUR at a 2% bonus so they can enjoy better service from our EUR banking partner and trade our more liquid EUR pairs. Those that still wish to withdraw USD can still do so, but this may involve a delay of up to 4 weeks or more. This is why we recommend that everyone choose the EUR conversion option. Most of our users with USD balances live in the EU anyway, so they can easily transact in EUR. Those with USD-only banks can still accept EUR, but will have to pay a <1% conversion fee, which the 2% bonus amply accounts for."


(my bolding)
 
In the meantime, here's what Kraken support has to say:

"We have every penny that users have deposited.


We shall see, won't we? I wouldn't count on it.

The problem is that we've reached the limit of our US bank's capacity to deal with the transaction volume on our account. Banks, especially US banks, associate higher transaction volume with higher risk. They are in fact uncomfortable with clients that process higher volumes of transactions (and it also doesn't help if you're a bitcoin company).

Nonsense.
 
Kraken support[/URL] has to say:[/B]

"We have every penny that users have deposited. The problem is that we've reached the limit of our US bank's capacity to deal with the transaction volume on our account. Banks, especially US banks, associate higher transaction volume with higher risk. They are in fact uncomfortable with clients that process higher volumes of transactions
Not buying this for a second. I have built too many online transaction processes to buy it (the krakken spin). The processors WANT volume. That's how they make their money. That's why you see small volume of transaction traders getting lumped together into a generic account. They simply don't generate enough volume on their own to warrant a separate account. This is pure spin because...

(and it also doesn't help if you're a bitcoin company).
This I buy. The first thing a processor does is carry out a risk assessment on the nature of the transactions to be processed and sets the rates accordingly. I would love to see a bitcoin risk assessment. For a processor to decline more volume would require a pretty horrendous risk assessment. Kraaken is trying to spin this as "we have more volume than they can handle" but the reality is "the risk of defaults just isn't worth accepting more volume". Were I the processor in question, I would honour any outstanding obligations and quietly withdraw.
 
Last edited:
I wonder if Kraken has a revolver (not a pistol, but a commercial line of credit), have maxed it out, and can only process USD withdrawals as cash comes in to pay down the credit line.

There is no way to tell that, but it would not surprise me. An unprecedented contract like bitcoin would likely attract even more unprecedented conditions if the legal eagles were doing their job. I would be amazed if there are not all sorts of "Get out of Jail Free" cards deployed in whatever contracts by both sides.
 
In the meantime, here's what Kraken support has to say:

"We have every penny that users have deposited. The problem is that we've reached the limit of our US bank's capacity to deal with the transaction volume on our account. Banks, especially US banks, associate higher transaction volume with higher risk. They are in fact uncomfortable with clients that process higher volumes of transactions (and it also doesn't help if you're a bitcoin company).
We've offered to convert customer's USD to EUR at a 2% bonus so they can enjoy better service from our EUR banking partner and trade our more liquid EUR pairs. Those that still wish to withdraw USD can still do so, but this may involve a delay of up to 4 weeks or more. This is why we recommend that everyone choose the EUR conversion option. Most of our users with USD balances live in the EU anyway, so they can easily transact in EUR. Those with USD-only banks can still accept EUR, but will have to pay a <1% conversion fee, which the 2% bonus amply accounts for."

I have serious doubts.
 
Not buying this for a second. I have built too many online transaction processes to buy it (the krakken spin). The processors WANT volume. That's how they make their money. That's why you see small volume of transaction traders getting lumped together into a generic account. They simply don't generate enough volume on their own to warrant a separate account. This is pure spin because...

This I buy. The first thing a processor does is carry out a risk assessment on the nature of the transactions to be processed and sets the rates accordingly. I would love to see a bitcoin risk assessment. For a processor to decline more volume would require a pretty horrendous risk assessment. Kraaken is trying to spin this as "we have more volume than they can handle" but the reality is "the risk of defaults just isn't worth accepting more volume". Were I the processor in question, I would honour any outstanding obligations and quietly withdraw.

Or at least consider charging prohibitive transaction fees.
 
We shall see, won't we? I wouldn't count on it.



Nonsense.
Not buying this for a second.
I wonder if Kraken has a revolver (not a pistol, but a commercial line of credit), have maxed it out, and can only process USD withdrawals as cash comes in to pay down the credit line.
I have serious doubts.
This is what it's all about.

"Another bitcoin exchange in trouble" sounds so much more exciting than "Bank causes delays in transactions".
 
I say again: time for the governments to step in and shut this phony "currency" down 100%. Jail all "miners", exchange owner/operators, and users.
Absolutely not. Let the bitbugs suffer for their stupidity. If they're bailed out now they'll simple whine and there'll be another bitscam along soon.

Some of the commenters who got burnt on MtGox are now talking about setting up a real exchange, with accounting, and security, and... um, er, wasn't the idea of bitcoin that you could transfer money without recourse to financial institutions?
How very typical; they want "deregulation" and "freedom" until they get hurt then they whine for government assistance.

I wonder if Kraken has a revolver (not a pistol, but a commercial line of credit), have maxed it out, and can only process USD withdrawals as cash comes in to pay down the credit line.
Very probably. A highly constrained line of credit too.

This is what it's all about.

"Another bitcoin exchange in trouble" sounds so much more exciting than "Bank causes delays in transactions".
Because the former is accurate and the latter a nonsensical analogy.
 
In the meantime, here's what Kraken support has to say:

"We have every penny that users have deposited. The problem is that we've reached the limit of our US bank's capacity to deal with the transaction volume on our account. Banks, especially US banks, associate higher transaction volume with higher risk. They are in fact uncomfortable with clients that process higher volumes of transactions (and it also doesn't help if you're a bitcoin company).
This is simultaneously both true and a bunch of horse hockey. Banks _do_ associate high transaction volume and bitcoin with risk (go figure). But "reached the limit of capacity?" WTF? How do normal businesses who handle gallons of transactions a day manage this just fine, but bitcoin exchanges can't?

We've offered to convert customer's USD to EUR at a 2% bonus so they can enjoy better service from our EUR banking partner and trade our more liquid EUR pairs. Those that still wish to withdraw USD can still do so, but this may involve a delay of up to 4 weeks or more. This is why we recommend that everyone choose the EUR conversion option. Most of our users with USD balances live in the EU anyway, so they can easily transact in EUR. Those with USD-only banks can still accept EUR, but will have to pay a <1% conversion fee, which the 2% bonus amply accounts for."

(my bolding)
More horse hockey. Kraken fails dismally at service here -- why not just admit that they don't have the USD, rather than try to pretend that it's somehow convenient for users with USD bank accounts to sort out all the BS with EUR? Current guess: They converted the vast majority of the money they took in to EUR for unknown reasons, and what they're dealing with is a US bank that doesn't want to do massive _conversion_ volume, not just _transaction_ volume.

We'll see how it shakes out. In the meantime, add Kraken to the list of "Don't know if you'll be able to get your money out" exchanges.

ABecause the former is accurate and the latter a nonsensical analogy.

It's important to not let the rubber duckie sink.
 
Last edited:
Oh and if the 740K bitcoin stolen are true then we are speaking of 6% of the whole world money stolen in one go. About 240 billion USD equivalent (world money circulation is 4 trillion about USD equivalent, so 6% of it...).

I think the total amount of money in the world is about 75 trillion and increasing according to vsauce .. 5 trillion if you only count physical cash, but why would you do that. So 6 % of that equals 4,56 trillion. In one heist..
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom