How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
So no denial of the facts about the 744,000 lost BTC.

1) There are no facts.
2) No confirmation either. If you read the chat, Mark was very disinterested in giving anything informative. The usual talking while saying nothing routine.
 
No more $ for bitcoins at kraaken. So they will only do Euro transactions from now on.

Claiming no liquidity in $ errr, if you want $ for your bitcoins, fuggedaboutit........

ETA: the bolding - they didn't claim that, that's your imagination. They claimed delays that weren't acceptable to them, so they will not be accepting any more USD.

Kraken said:
“We’re still doing dollar withdrawals and dollar trading; we just don’t want to take any more new dollars”



Isn't this the same problem MtGox had too? No $ liquidity for the ridiculous prices?

I applaud the move. MtGox seemed to have similar problems, yet they refused to take a corrective step and let the delays pile up.
 
Last edited:
Mt. Gox Faces US Subpoena and Investigation in Japan



The Wall Street Journal article is behind a paywall.

Nothing much

Bitcoin exchange Mt. Gox has received a subpoena from federal prosecutors in New York, according to a person familiar with the matter, dealing another blow to the embattled marketplace for buyers and sellers of the virtual currency.

Mt. Gox, one of the largest bitcoin exchanges, shut down on Tuesday, underscoring the risks of bitcoin, the virtual currency that has seen a meteoric rise in the past year.
 
No more $ for bitcoins at kraaken. So they will only do Euro transactions from now on.

Claiming no liquidity in $ errr, if you want $ for your bitcoins, fuggedaboutit........


Bitcoin exchange Kraken put a brief halt on US dollar withdrawals and suspended USD deposits today, offering customers a 2% bonus to convert their balances to euros (EUR).
Oops! You forgot about that bit.

Carry on with your story ......
 
ETA: the bolding - they didn't claim that, that's your imagination. They claimed delays that weren't acceptable to them, so they will not be accepting any more USD.

Really, well to me, there is no liquidity in US $ if they halt withdrawals. But maybe you missed this point. Liquidity being greater refers to being non-zero as opposed to zero.

coindesk article said:
Most Kraken customers trading in USD are not even US residents. Powell recommended those customers should switch to euros, where liquidity was greater and transaction fees were lower.
 
Last edited:
Oops! You forgot about that bit.

Carry on with your story ......

Not at all, that makes my point. They can't give you dollars so they will give you something else and pay a bonus if you will let them out of their obligation to deliver $. It's the same thing as settling a futures contract for cash over the settlement price if you will forgo delivery of the underlying.

It's obvious people are selling bitcoins and want $ so they can get out of the bitcoin game. Now these people with the $ accounts are screwed if they don't have a Euro account. So what good does a bonus do if you don't have a Euro account and cannot easily open one?
 
Last edited:
1) There are no facts.
2) No confirmation either. If you read the chat, Mark was very disinterested in giving anything informative. The usual talking while saying nothing routine.

No, he pretty clearly stated that the BTC were unavailable when asked about personal losses. This means that he cannot get his BTC either becuase Gox doesn't have them. I am sure they are trying to work out who took them but good luck with that, they lost them and cannot get them back. They have moved through many different wallets in the meantime no doubt.
 
coindesk said:
"Many USD withdrawals have been delayed beyond a limit we can accept, and it reflects poorly on our service,” a customer support representative said.
...........................
The problem was apparently caused by a recent increase in US dollar transaction volume, much of which came from outside the United States, and temporarily overwhelmed Kraken’s current US banking partner.
.................................
Kraken CEO Jesse Powell said US dollars represented only a small piece of the company’s business, and that dealing with USD and its associated headaches cost it more in customer service and agent time than it earned in revenue.


They can't give you dollars .........
Either your reading for comprehension is appalling or you are claiming without evidence that the Kraken statements are a complete lie.
 
Not at all, that makes my point. They can't give you dollars so they will give you something else and pay a bonus if you will let them out of their obligation to deliver $. It's the same thing as settling a futures contract for cash over the settlement price if you will forgo delivery of the underlying.

But I want my truckload of lean hogs, dammit!
 
I say again: time for the governments to step in and shut this phony "currency" down 100%. Jail all "miners", exchange owner/operators, and users.
 
Either your reading for comprehension is appalling or you are claiming without evidence that the Kraken statements are a complete lie.

No, I believe that Kraaken is spinning the truth which is that they can't get the $ they need and that is why they are looking for new $ partners. Fidor is their $ banking partner. Now all of a sudden when people with $ denominated bitcoin accounts want to liquidate bitcoin for $, Fidor is "overwhelmed" by the volume of transactions? Then Kraaken proposes a bonus if you will take Euro instead?

I think your reading comprehension is as expected, you are reading with your bitcoin blinders on.
 
Really, well to me, there is no liquidity in US $ if they halt withdrawals.

wut? They didn't halt withdrawals. They specifically said they didn't, I specifically quoted that part. Did you miss that?

The coinDesk article may be a bit misleading if you only read the headline. Here's their support message: http://www.reddit.com/r/Kraken/comments/1yy4uy/pending_usd_withdrawals_have_been_cancelled/

"In the meantime, USD withdrawals and trading will continue to be available, though we strongly encourage USD traders to shift to our EUR pairs. Most major banks will allow you to send EUR even if your account only holds USD.
All pending USD withdrawals not already in transit are being cancelled and the funds will be automatically credited back to your account. You will then have the following options."


The two options are either to convert your USD to EUR with 2% bonus or to make your USD withdrawal request again which "may take up to 4 weeks or more to process".

But maybe you missed this point. Liquidity being greater refers to being non-zero as opposed to zero.

umm, yea, meaning they didn't claim "no liquidity in $".
I'm confused what are you trying to say?
 
This means that he cannot get his BTC either becuase Gox doesn't have them.

Well that's your imagination again. Might be true, might not be true. Mark has neither denied nor confirmed that. But by all means, speculate.

No, I believe that Kraaken is spinning the truth which is that they can't get the $ they need and that is why they are looking for new $ partners. Fidor is their $ banking partner. Now all of a sudden when people with $ denominated bitcoin accounts want to liquidate bitcoin for $, Fidor is "overwhelmed" by the volume of transactions? Then Kraaken proposes a bonus if you will take Euro instead?

I think your reading comprehension is as expected, you are reading with your bitcoin blinders on.

:) Fidor is their European partner, it's a German bank and their banking partner for EUR not USD. But your conspiracies are entertaining :)
 
I say again: time for the governments to step in and shut this phony "currency" down 100%. Jail all "miners", exchange owner/operators, and users.

Are you operating in the same world as the rest of us? I think Bitcoin is a great way for suckers to lose money, but statements like "jail all users" are simply ignorant of the applicable laws, not to mention oblivious to the practical and societal considerations of doing such a thing.

tl;dr: That was a butt-stupid suggestion that contributed ****-all to the thread.

TeapotCavalry said:
"In the meantime, USD withdrawals and trading will continue to be available, though we strongly encourage USD traders to shift to our EUR pairs. Most major banks will allow you to send EUR even if your account only holds USD.
All pending USD withdrawals not already in transit are being cancelled and the funds will be automatically credited back to your account. You will then have the following options."


The two options are either to convert your USD to EUR with 2% bonus or to make your USD withdrawal request again which "may take up to 4 weeks or more to process".

This should be a red flag to anyone who currently has anything there. If the money's there, it's there -- it shouldn't take 4 weeks to process unless the money _isn't_ there, in which case who knows what they've been doing under the table.

A lot of you have been saying "But someone has to deposit funds to buy the BTC, so there will always be 100% of the funds available even if someone deposits BTC just to sell" -- which is great in theory, but I suspect most of these exchanges were operating under their own version of "fractional reserve" and doing it very, very wrong.
 
wut? They didn't halt withdrawals. They specifically said they didn't, I specifically quoted that part. Did you miss that?

The CoinDesk article may have been more realistic, not misleading. Those people are Bitcoin supporters, they are at least capable of writing the truth instead of quoting industry spin put out by the deceptive and dishonest exchange.

All pending USD withdrawals not already in transit are being cancelled and the funds will be automatically credited back to your account. You will then have the following options.

So anyone with a withdrawal request for dollars must now resubmit the request because it has been cancelled. Why? The request has already been made, Kraaken have admitted that cannot fulfill it right now, why the requirement to resubmit? What is the point of that or meaning? They are admitting that the current request cannot be fulfilled. Any new requests are subject to :

Please note that under this option your USD wire may take up to 4 weeks or more to process. This option will be the slowest by far, so we highly recommend the first option.

They recommend converting to EUR, what does that say? They don't have the $ and don't know how they will get them. That is illiquidity, so is 4+ week processing time. This is MtGox all over again and this Kraaken was one everybody was praising and saying how good they were while ragging on Gox about a week ago.


umm, yea, meaning they didn't claim "no liquidity in $".
I'm confused what are you trying to say?

Of course they did but with your bitcoin blinders on and you not being screwed by Kraaken, your spin is obvious.

This whole "exchange" thing is a scam that is being exposed and moreover, the "exchange" scam is the only thing that supports the silly nonsensical numbers being printed on the screens.
 
This should be a red flag to anyone who currently has anything there. If the money's there, it's there -- it shouldn't take 4 weeks to process unless the money _isn't_ there, in which case who knows what they've been doing under the table.

Well it's a yellow flag, but that might be out of our my ignorance. Can you explain to me the exact process of how the withdrawal takes place? Are there any regulatory limits, limits imposed by banks and governments, verification limits etc?

From Kraken FAQ: "*All USD deposits and withdrawals are processed manually at the present time, and this can result in long delays. Faster USD transactions are coming soon, but for the time being, please be advised that they can take a long time to process."

What does it mean they are processing it manually, and how is that consistent with their statement that they have "reached the limit of their US bank's capacity to deal with the volume on their account"

A lot of you have been saying "But someone has to deposit funds to buy the BTC, so there will always be 100% of the funds available even if someone deposits BTC just to sell" -- which is great in theory, but I suspect most of these exchanges were operating under their own version of "fractional reserve" and doing it very, very wrong.

I suspect they're doing fractional reserve too, and I trust Kraken as much as I trust any bank doing it.
 
Last edited:
but I suspect most of these exchanges were operating under their own version of "fractional reserve" and doing it very, very wrong.

Exactly, otherwise how does the price always bounce back and how did it get so ridiculously high to begin with? It's obvious that there was never enough money there, the truth was clear way back when Gox couldn't liquidate withdrawals at $200. The people with bitcoin blinders on just can't see it because they don't want to.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom