How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
The sale of those 10,000 on BitStamp yesterday morning was sure smart now in retrospect wasn't it? Plenty of people on the inside knew about this.

Yep, someone saved themselves about a million bucks selling 10K yesterday rather than today. I wonder if the bitbugs now understand why it is that we have laws and the SEC to prevent people from doing this kind of thing in the fiat-currency world.
 
Yep, someone saved themselves about a million bucks selling 10K yesterday rather than today. I wonder if the bitbugs now understand why it is that we have laws and the SEC to prevent people from doing this kind of thing in the fiat-currency world.

Prevent meaning slowing them down or putting an obstacle in the way but not stopping because this is common practice on Wall Street but with a lot of different games. There are so many ways that they have to steal money it's unbelievable.

You should go read about auction rate securities and see how many people got ripped off on that deal back when the big collapse happened. That is just one of many scams Wall Street covered up in the big bailout.
 
If they could get their cash out of the exchanges, that is...

Which exchanges are not paying out? Could we get some less vagueness?

From my admittedly cursory following of this thread, and some of the links in it, I was under the impression that there were upper limits on the amount of cash that you could get over a given time period on many of the exchanges.
If I let my mind drift back, ISTR that Bitstamp claimed to have no such limits if you had a double ultraplus super identified status or some such, but there were complaints that getting such status was virtually impossible, because whatever the people complaining gave them, trying to follow their rules, they asked for something else in addition to that. That was some time back, and maybe it was something temporary that has since been straightened out.

There are upper limits, and I see nothing suspicious about having them. It's their exchange and their call what kind of cash flow they are able or willing to handle, and they're not coy about it either. Bitcoin exchanges aren't the only ones to implement withdrawing or trading limits. And I cannot see how having withdraw limits is an indication of insolvency.

All in all, you are not forced to deposit a greater amount into your account than what your current verification level allows to withdraw.

I don't have a dog in this fight, but are all the complaints about the inliquidity of bitcoins coming from the Mt Gox situation?

Yes. If there are other major exchanges having liquidity problems, it's news to me.
 
Prevent meaning slowing them down or putting an obstacle in the way but not stopping because this is common practice on Wall Street but with a lot of different games. There are so many ways that they have to steal money it's unbelievable.

Well, yes, but something as obvious as selling $5M worth of stock the day before your company shuts down would surely commend itself to the attention of regulators. No such protection for the Mt. Gox victims, though.
 
To suggest that "pretty much everyone in this thread" thinks that MtGox=Bitcoin is pretty insulting.

I didn't say, or even imply that. I did say, and will say again, that the problems which are currently coming to a head were entirely predictable and were, in fact, predicted in this very thread.

Caveat bitcoinor.
 
I didn't say, or even imply that. I did say, and will say again, that the problems which are currently coming to a head were entirely predictable and were, in fact, predicted in this very thread.

Caveat bitcoinor.

That doesn't make sense. You were responding to a post about bitcoin crashing - not Mt Gox. Can't you tell the difference?
 
Well, yes, but something as obvious as selling $5M worth of stock the day before your company shuts down would surely commend itself to the attention of regulators. No such protection for the Mt. Gox victims, though.

Yeah but who knows the identity of that seller? It turned out to be more than just one big sale, there were another 1000 or so dumped at a couple of times later on in the day.

What clowns the whole thing is how the pumpers immediately start pushing the price back up and claiming all is well, saying it's just good that we are finally rid of Gox. Well here is the problem with getting rid of a big cancer like Gox. There is risk of both recurrence and metastasis, which I think highly likely in some of the other exchanges, this was not an isolated event IMO. Look how quickly the other exchanges have sought to distance themselves but they all shut themselves down due to the malleability issue so I am certain they lost coins too.

The other problem with removing a cancer is with the surgery itself. If the wound doesn't heal well, then the patient dies of sepsis. No, I hardly think that 750,000 BTC vanishing into thin air is small potatoes since it's about 6% of the entire BTC currency. There are thousands of people affected by this that will simply walk away from bitcoin never to return.
 
That doesn't make sense. You were responding to a post about bitcoin crashing - not Mt Gox. Can't you tell the difference?

Not much difference to tell the truth. MtGox has been a microcosm and there were plenty of people that lost a lot in MtGox. Too bad mhaze isn't around to tell us how much he lost.
 
The other problem with removing a cancer is with the surgery itself. If the wound doesn't heal well, then the patient dies of sepsis. No, I hardly think that 750,000 BTC vanishing into thin air is small potatoes since it's about 6% of the entire BTC currency. There are thousands of people affected by this that will simply walk away from bitcoin never to return.

I agree completely. A lot of BTC victims will go trade forex or lean hogs or something else.
 
Is the Bitcoin world crashing around us?

Nah, ’tis just a flesh wound.
:boxedin:
We'll probably see a steep fall in price, but I doubt it's the end of bitcoin.

Pretty much everyone in this thread, actually, with a couple of notable exceptions.

Recent posts in this thread by some posters illustrate, despite the apparent spirit and purpose of the forum, the irrationality and reactionary nature of "general population", who necessarily doesn't know the ins and outs of what bitcoin is, and can be swayed to and fro by mainstream media reports. This is the gravest danger of this MtGox crumble, the PR disaster for bitcoin - general population linking the problems of MtGox to bitcoin. This is essentially what MtGox tried to do itself by blaming bitcoin protocol, and subsequently getting harsh backlash for it from the people in the know.

It's fun to watch bitskeptics hopping on the guilt by association FUD train like clockwork, as if it's somehow of a vital importance to smear bitcoin, even without any factual basis. Nothing in bitcoin has changed to the worse (on the contrary, people are tackling the malleability weakness), yet the doomsday peddlers are louder than ever singing the same tune they did years before, only this time they have MtGox as ammuntaion. That's not a prediction, that's a conviction. The tune remains the same, but the explanation changes as circumstances change. Shoehorning is the name of the game.

jhunter1163, you supposedly don't have anything to gain or lose by what bitcoin does, yet you continually try to make it seem as if bitcoin has failed, is failing and will be failing regardless of real world events or facts, which have been discussed here thoroughly. You have even called people who invest in bitcoin fools. I find this passionate engagement with the subject and supposed neutrality curiously juxtaposed. No doubt bitcoin's future is on shaky grounds at this point and we have every reason to examine the security of exchanges and bitcoin protocol, but you're just giving out mis/disinformation about "exchanges" not paying out, implying insolvency, people desperately trying to get out and not succeeding etc. It's as if you're doing some price manipuation yourself. Planning to buy in? :D

Can't you tell the difference?

His posts seem to be intentionally vague.
 
That doesn't make sense. You were responding to a post about bitcoin crashing - not Mt Gox. Can't you tell the difference?

Not so speak for other members, but wouldn't a commodity losing more than half its value in less than three months count as a crash?
 
Not so speak for other members, but wouldn't a commodity losing more than half its value in less than three months count as a crash?

Well this one loses a quarter of it's value and regains it on a daily basis so it's a little hard to tell. The real key here is the way it's constantly pumped up in value on "exchanges" irrespective of it's real use as a currency or intrinsic value as a commodity. The fact is, bits in a computer lack value and only to the degree people believe they have value can they be exchanged for value. The belief people have in the solvency of banks is what allows money as we know it today, to function. Right now, bitcoin is demonstrating that it has very little real value aside from bogus numbers printed on screens from various "exchanges". Of course people have been foolish enough to trade bits with current value for bits with no value and those stuck with the no value bits are learning a hard lesson.
 
Last edited:
Not so speak for other members, but wouldn't a commodity losing more than half its value in less than three months count as a crash?

I doubt there are many people who don't consider this as a crash of bitcoin in value, that much is obvious from the price drop. But I, for one, read the "Bitcoin world crashing around us" implying something more integral, a demise of bitcoin as a cryprocurrency and protocol.
 
I doubt there are many people who don't consider this as a crash of bitcoin in value, that much is obvious from the price drop. But I, for one, read the "Bitcoin world crashing around us" implying something more integral, a demise of bitcoin as a cryprocurrency and protocol.

I predict the former is the beginning of the latter.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom